You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Punch better than Wilf


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 02 May 14 8.33pm

Quote Mstrobez at 02 May 2014 7.09pm

The fact this is even up for discussion after some of the stuff Wilf did last season (play offs NOT included) really does show the amount people know about football on here.

And that's from someone who liked Punch from the START. Wilf went down hill as soon as Ollie came in whether people agree or disagree and he has been managed poorly since too. There's a huge reason why Sir Alex bought him for 15mil! He was unbelievable under Dougie last season and season before!

Some people just don't get football! Comparison between Punch and Wilf? Give me a f***ing break


We all eventually went down hill when Ollie came in!.

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 02 May 14 8.58pm

Quote Leecpfc at 01 May 2014 11.10pm

I disagree. Strongly.


seconded

 

Mstrobez Flag 02 May 14 9.04pm

Quote Ian J at 02 May 2014 7.30pm

Quote Mstrobez at 02 May 2014 7.09pm

The fact this is even up for discussion after some of the stuff Wilf did last season (play offs NOT included) really does show the amount people know about football on here.

And that's from someone who liked Punch from the START. Wilf went down hill as soon as Ollie came in whether people agree or disagree and he has been managed poorly since too. There's a huge reason why Sir Alex bought him for 15mil! He was unbelievable under Dougie last season and season before!

Some people just don't get football! Comparison between Punch and Wilf? Give me a f***ing break

Do you have your own dedicated turnstile at Selhurst as I'm sure that you couldn't manage to squeeze your huge ego through the turnstiles that us ordinary mortals use

Difference between knowledge of football and ego. This thread is ridiculous

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 02 May 14 10.23pm

...sadly Wilf, has had his punch taken away.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

AussiePalace Flag Melbourne, Australia 02 May 14 10.31pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.


No, all of which Wilf hasn't done YET.

 


Executive Junior Assistant's Vice President's P.A - CPFC Melbourne Supporters Club

[Link]

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 02 May 14 10.37pm

Quote AussiePalace at 02 May 2014 10.31pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.


No, all of which Wilf hasn't done YET.


Yeah! Right on! Let's dump Punch for Wilf. He might be better!

Idiotic reply.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 May 14 11.18pm

Why would anyone want to compare these two players?
What's to be gained. So Puncheons better. So Zaha's better. So who cares? Move on.

 

AussiePalace Flag Melbourne, Australia 02 May 14 11.47pm

Quote Tim Gypsy Hill '64 at 02 May 2014 10.37pm

Quote AussiePalace at 02 May 2014 10.31pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.


No, all of which Wilf hasn't done YET.


Yeah! Right on! Let's dump Punch for Wilf. He might be better!

Idiotic reply.


Calm down Turbo.

I'm implying the Wilf backers should relax, stop comparing him to Punch, and wait to assess him when he's at the same age.

 


Executive Junior Assistant's Vice President's P.A - CPFC Melbourne Supporters Club

[Link]

wainesworld Flag west wickham 03 May 14 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)

 

wainesworld Flag west wickham 03 May 14 6.25pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.

Because hes not playing regularly.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 03 May 14 7.43pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)


Marouanne Fellani was bought for 20 Million and was s*** do you know more then David Moyes. Fact is Wilf will end up like another Scott Sinclair if he was a true professional he would play well because he loves football. I don't buy all this he needs love bollocks he has been given plenty of time to impress at Cardiff and has been s*** most games. But hey ho its not because Wilf is not a premier league player but because he came from our academy and nothing is his fault. Punch has scored 7 goals as an out and out winger and scored a few for Southampton last season and his goals have kept both sides up. But Wilfs better because he got a 15 million transfer and run Barnsley Ragged.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 03 May 14 7.45pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.25pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.24pm

Quote xGeorgex at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

Puncheon's skills:
.Scoring Goals
.Composure on the ball

Zaha's skills:
.Pace
.Skills
.Agility
.Tracking back
.Runs
.Dribbling
.Creating somthing out of nothing

For me it is Zaha.

All of which he cant do in the premier league.

Because hes not playing regularly.


Because a relegated Premier League side don't think he is good enough.

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 03 May 14 9.27pm

I think many have a rose tinted view of Wilf. He's a great lad and a legend but he's only a quality Championship player not a quality Premiership player. He's proved this himself in his time at Cardiff. Yes he was their best player on the pitch but only because the rest of them were so sh!te. Cardiff are now a Championship team and Wilf will serve them well there when Man Ure release him form his contract.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

wainesworld Flag west wickham 04 May 14 8.51am

Quote EastEndPalace at 03 May 2014 7.43pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)


Marouanne Fellani was bought for 20 Million and was s*** do you know more then David Moyes. Fact is Wilf will end up like another Scott Sinclair if he was a true professional he would play well because he loves football. I don't buy all this he needs love bollocks he has been given plenty of time to impress at Cardiff and has been s*** most games. But hey ho its not because Wilf is not a premier league player but because he came from our academy and nothing is his fault. Punch has scored 7 goals as an out and out winger and scored a few for Southampton last season and his goals have kept both sides up. But Wilfs better because he got a 15 million transfer and run Barnsley Ragged.

Your argument is flawed why bring other players into the discussion? I never said he needs love. You trivialise or ignore what Zaha did for us last season. One way to compared players is to see what their value is in the transfer market. If both came up for sale now I think the asking price would be very similar, and that's after a poor season for Wilf, and as you say Punch has been tearing premiership teams apart. Man you are deluded.

Edited by wainesworld (04 May 2014 8.52am)

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 04 May 14 9.31am

Quote wainesworld at 04 May 2014 8.51am

Quote EastEndPalace at 03 May 2014 7.43pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)


Marouanne Fellani was bought for 20 Million and was s*** do you know more then David Moyes. Fact is Wilf will end up like another Scott Sinclair if he was a true professional he would play well because he loves football. I don't buy all this he needs love bollocks he has been given plenty of time to impress at Cardiff and has been s*** most games. But hey ho its not because Wilf is not a premier league player but because he came from our academy and nothing is his fault. Punch has scored 7 goals as an out and out winger and scored a few for Southampton last season and his goals have kept both sides up. But Wilfs better because he got a 15 million transfer and run Barnsley Ragged.

Your argument is flawed why bring other players into the discussion? I never said he needs love. You trivialise or ignore what Zaha did for us last season. One way to compared players is to see what their value is in the transfer market. If both came up for sale now I think the asking price would be very similar, and that's after a poor season for Wilf, and as you say Punch has been tearing premiership teams apart. Man you are deluded.

Edited by wainesworld (04 May 2014 8.52am)

No, it'd be similar because Zaha is 21 and Puncheon is 27. United would argue that he's worth more than he is out on a pitch today because he COULD become a very good premier league winger. That's the thing though, every argument about Zaha on this debate is hypothetical. Puncheon on the other hand, has done it.

I don't really care who people deem to be better. Fact is, by the time Zaha hits his peak at 24/25, Punch will be 30/31 and beginning his descent so they'll never both be at their peak at the same time.

If people want to do it by stats, Zaha got 8 goals and 10 assists in 49 games in the Championship last season, and has 0 goals and 1 assist from 14 in the Premiership. In the Prem this season, Punch has 7 goals and 2 assists from 32 games and last season got 6 goals in 25 games in the Prem.

Forgetting who is better/may be better/may play for England and all the guesswork, hypothetical stuff, based on those numbers I'd want one over the other right now.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

dannyboy1978 Flag 04 May 14 9.34am

Ide love to see zaha bolasie and puncheon in the middle !! Dream team.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 04 May 14 10.15am

Quote EastEndPalace at 03 May 2014 7.43pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)


Marouanne Fellani was bought for 20 Million and was s*** do you know more then David Moyes. Fact is Wilf will end up like another Scott Sinclair if he was a true professional he would play well because he loves football. I don't buy all this he needs love bollocks he has been given plenty of time to impress at Cardiff and has been s*** most games. But hey ho its not because Wilf is not a premier league player but because he came from our academy and nothing is his fault. Punch has scored 7 goals as an out and out winger and scored a few for Southampton last season and his goals have kept both sides up. But Wilfs better because he got a 15 million transfer and run Barnsley Ragged.


Have you watched all the Cardiff games start to finish when he's been playing?

You're just a troll, why don't you fvck off to the Wet spam site.

Edited by Plane (04 May 2014 10.16am)

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 04 May 14 12.48pm

Quote Plane at 04 May 2014 10.15am

Quote EastEndPalace at 03 May 2014 7.43pm

Quote wainesworld at 03 May 2014 6.24pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 02 May 2014 7.02pm

Quote wainesworld at 02 May 2014 6.22pm

I don't think you can compare them at the moment. What you could compare is how good was/is each player whilst they played, or are playing for Palace.

If this is compared Wilf is miles better, some say he went missing at times but where was Jason for the majority of this season it's really only the last 12 games he's done very well.

Wilf plus Murray equalled promotion. If he was not with us last season we would not be in the prem. IMO

Edited by wainesworld (02 May 2014 6.23pm)


Wilf at Palace=Championship ripping teams up like Barnsley and Bristol City.

Puncheon at Palace=Premier League ripping teams up like Everton and Chelsea.


Really Punch ripping teams up !!!!!!! I don't think so he scored couple of goals blimey that's all. How much was Punch bought for ? How much was Wilf sold for. And that's from people in the game that know a lot more about it all than u and me.

Edited by wainesworld (03 May 2014 6.26pm)


Marouanne Fellani was bought for 20 Million and was s*** do you know more then David Moyes. Fact is Wilf will end up like another Scott Sinclair if he was a true professional he would play well because he loves football. I don't buy all this he needs love bollocks he has been given plenty of time to impress at Cardiff and has been s*** most games. But hey ho its not because Wilf is not a premier league player but because he came from our academy and nothing is his fault. Punch has scored 7 goals as an out and out winger and scored a few for Southampton last season and his goals have kept both sides up. But Wilfs better because he got a 15 million transfer and run Barnsley Ragged.


Have you watched all the Cardiff games start to finish when he's been playing?

You're just a troll, why don't you fvck off to the Wet spam site.

Edited by Plane (04 May 2014 10.16am)


I am from London Borough of Southwark just live in East London now. How am I a f***ing troll. Just because I don't share your view and think Puncheons a better player stop being a keyboard hard nut because your starting to piss me off now so just ignore my posts please or better yet just f*** off in general. Puncheon has done it in the prem Wilf has not that's all you need to know. He wont come back anyway. He will be like Scott Sinclair Mark 2 if he does not sort his attitude out.

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 04 May 14 12.52pm

What attitude! He is a good professional!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 May 14 12.53pm

Fairly delusional, Zaha is by far the better option. One season of not playing more than substitute for massively underperforming teams doesn't make Puncheon better.

Puncheon is good, no mistaking, but he has a terrible history of inconsistency, underperformance and not turning up for games. He's been excellent for us under Pulis, and I think Pulis has brought the best out of him, like Warnock did with Ambrose.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf