You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg Monday.
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clattenburg Monday.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Hoof Hearted 07 May 14 11.05am

Did us a favour early on by not giving the penalty for Bolasie's challenge.... but not the reason I'm posting.

Did anyone else see his run from our box when Bolasie broke clear to set up Dwight for our 2nd goal?

Fcuk me he was motoring and p1ssed past the Liverpool players trying to get back too. He was well in our box as Dwight side-foots it home.

If any player had matched his run they might have stopped that goal.

Respect to the ref!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 May 14 11.11am

Thought he did well. Right decision re Bolassie, Johnson was already going down. If he hadn't been it would certainly have been given.

Overall tried to play advantage and keep the game flowing.

That run was funny his cheeks were blowing but as you say it was some effort.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

merganser Flag 07 May 14 11.14am


The ref had a terrific game - tight control but he also allowed the play to flow.

I don't think that YB air-kick was a penalty. The player was taking a tumble before the contact.

However, I hope YB will heed the lesson - no clumsy challenges in the penalty area please

 

Plane Flag Bromley 07 May 14 11.15am

I've watched the Motd highlights a few times and you're right about the Bolasie challenge, the comm says at the time GJ is looking for it but I think we got a bit lucky there, they say that all these things even themselves out over a season, 'they' are probably correct

And you're absolutely right about the ref, perhaps Brenda should sign him as a defender, couldn't do any worse

Clattenburg had a decent game imo.

 

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 07 May 14 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...

 

Plane Flag Bromley 07 May 14 11.19am

Quote Proper_Gander at 07 May 2014 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...


Sorry, I didn't see it

 

Hoof Hearted 07 May 14 11.21am

Quote Plane at 07 May 2014 11.19am

Quote Proper_Gander at 07 May 2014 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...


Sorry, I didn't see it


Classic Arsene Wenger line!

 

Plane Flag Bromley 07 May 14 11.25am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 07 May 2014 11.21am

Quote Plane at 07 May 2014 11.19am

Quote Proper_Gander at 07 May 2014 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...


Sorry, I didn't see it


Classic Arsene Wenger line!

Je ne comprends pas!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 May 14 11.26am

Decided it was probably a penalty after a few rewatches, but the ref doesn't have that option, and it did look like Glen Johnson was going down before contact was made (and in real time the contact looked very minimal).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Generix Flag Orpington 07 May 14 11.27am

Looked like YB only made contact with the players shorts flailing in the air, not the players actual leg.

Could have had some sympathy with the ref had he give it.

I think it was the right decision not to, both as he didn't make contact with the player (imo) and certainly not enough for him to go down and the fact he was already on his way down.

Good decision. Overall good reffing.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 May 14 11.28am

Quote Proper_Gander at 07 May 2014 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...

Its supposed to be, but then you see that all the time in the box from set pieces, by both sides. We never get them, why should they.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 07 May 14 11.31am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 May 2014 11.28am

Quote Proper_Gander at 07 May 2014 11.17am

If GJ hadn't gone down before Bolasie kicked him, it would have been a penalty imo.

Ledley (iirc?) wrestling Gerrard to the ground was a penalty though to be honest...

Its supposed to be, but then you see that all the time in the box from set pieces, by both sides. We never get them, why should they.

I'm not complaining!

Just offering my objective opinion on the matter before quickly forgetting it ever happened.

 

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 07 May 14 11.42am

Not just saying this cos of the outcome, but I've always rated Mark Clattenburg. Definitely one of the better ones. Howard Webb would have ensured we lost 10-0.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 07 May 14 11.54am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 May 2014 11.26am

Decided it was probably a penalty after a few rewatches, but the ref doesn't have that option, and it did look like Glen Johnson was going down before contact was made (and in real time the contact looked very minimal).


It wasnt a penalty because the kick didnt cause him to fall to the ground and the ball was almost in Speronis hands when it was made. It was however a big call as you see them being given all the time.

Gotta say I think Clattenberg is probably the best ref at the moment; the game he reffed in Europe the other day Benfica vs Juve he was excellent in.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 07 May 14 12.04pm

On another day we could've quite easily conceeded 3 pens (Bolasie on Johnson, Dann on Suarez and the challenge on Gerrard in our box before the counter for our 2nd goal).

If they'd been the other way around we'd be moaning and feeling a little hard done by. On the other hand, Ledley was fouled by Allen leading up to there 1st goal so maybe he was evening things up.

Edited by Stuart Shave (07 May 2014 12.05pm)

 

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 07 May 14 12.10pm

Was at the match but haven't seen it on TV since (only goals).

I felt Clattenburg had a good match. Let it flow well. I was really pleased in the way he allowed physical challenges where I think he felt a player went down to easy. I'm sure if Webb was the referee he would of blown his whistle.

Was surprised that five minutes was added for ET.

Haven't seen any interviews with the two managers. Did they have any complaints about decisions made/not made?

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 May 14 12.13pm

best thing he did was book Suarez for diving- he'd had a word with Gerrard about it earlier too.

 

SH17FIELDS Flag Swanley 07 May 14 12.16pm

With reference to our second goal, did you hear the comments of the Sky presenters in the studio that the defender should have taken one for the team and taken Bolasie out as he would not have been sent off as it was not a goal scoring opportunity as we know it, well just goes to show how wrong that phrase can be. With a break at that speed the ball ended up in their net from that move. We would have ended up with just a free kick in the centre.

 

Green Bin Flag Carshalton Beeches 07 May 14 12.22pm

Quote SH17FIELDS at 07 May 2014 12.16pm

With reference to our second goal, did you hear the comments of the Sky presenters in the studio that the defender should have taken one for the team and taken Bolasie out as he would not have been sent off as it was not a goal scoring opportunity as we know it, well just goes to show how wrong that phrase can be. With a break at that speed the ball ended up in their net from that move. We would have ended up with just a free kick in the centre.

I would have been impressed if Johnson had got anywhere near him, and he might have been sent off for dangerous play anyway

 

chateauferret Flag 07 May 14 6.50pm

I didn't see him then, all I saw was the acres of space Bolasie had to run into with the ball. Enough to park a couple of buses.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg Monday.