This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote kersal at 06 Mar 2015 8.48pm
Unfortunately the Muslim world experienced a rapid deceleration of progress and complacency during the Ottoman era where militaristic expansion ensured and became wrongly associated with the continuation of the glory of a religion. After the fall of the Empire, it created a void of power and later came anger, jealousy and a lack of competitiveness against Western countries. But, this is not to say that Islam is not a religion of peace. In the emergence of Islam and later during the rise of the Ottoman Empire (700s-1600s), Muslim philosophers and scientists (such as Ibn-i Arabi, Ibn-i Sina, Omar Khayyam) were way ahead of their (Christian) peers, highly innovative, including an extremely peaceful variant in the form of Sufis, whose works were very well-received and endorsed for centuries. It is also during this period that Christianity and its associated kingdoms were in a crisis that would last hundreds of years and reach a point of desperation in the form of the Crusades; which were hundreds of years of violation of sovereignty of the Muslim nations. The historical rivalry across the religions originate as early as this period and school teachings in Muslim countries are still full of the glorious defenses that Islam, the Seljuks and the Abbasids built against the Christian "barbarians" as to their interpretation. The reason why I went deep into history was only to make the point that violence is not embedded in any religion's teaching inherently but that it depended on many other things and its openness to interpretation was manipulated by the powerful. Just as Christianity was perceived as a menace to the Muslim world in its heydays centuries ago, today the Muslim radicals are causing problems in the Christian world. Only this should be enough to show that religions are not to blame, but it is their interpreters that are to blame. Also, any generalization of the Muslim community as extremists or even an utterance of a made up 25% is a very ignorant claim to make and very misleading. I saw in an earlier post the number, 400 million Muslim extremists - pure nonsense. Anybody who talks in such broad statements should most certainly avoid any further discussions on the particular sects of Islam or minorities of the Middle East, as they would be clueless about their origins, their historical sources of peace and rivalry, and more importantly how they stand vis-a-vis one another in today's balance of affairs. Wikipedia will not be enough to teach this and neither will superficial Western interpretations of the crisis in the Middle East - you really need something scientific, anthropological and historically detailed. I come from the region, went to quite a few of the countries and still do business with clients in the region on a regular basis. I've seen very harsh interpretations of Islam, which I disliked and I've seen moderate and mild interpretations where similarities with the Western world were vast. The everyday lives of the citizens of the Arab countries are not shaped by the lenses of Al Qaida or IS - and this includes the Saudi Arabians, where interpretation of the religion is tough if you're not from there. But, I assure you that (outside the very obvious places of conflict) there is no place in the Arab world that you as a Westerner would go and be penalized for that, if you respect the local rules as they can be sensitive. Saudi Arabia is difficult but not more than that. Qatar and the UAE, same. Turkey and North African countries, the same. Lebanon and Jordan, the same. I hope you will patiently continue to do what's harder and avoid the easy way out, which is sweeping generalizations. It is such blanketing and patronizing statements that cause further polarization. Many Muslims don't feel comfortable in their own skins in the Western world as their category of identity is continuously being diminished in value by violent idiots that they cannot control the actions of thousands of miles away. I know it's hard, but you should try to empathize with the innocent as much as you highlight the obviously guilty.
However since you wrote..(quote).. "Anybody who talks in such broad statements should most certainly avoid any further discussions on the particular sects of Islam or minorities of the Middle East, as they would be clueless about their origins, their historical sources of peace and rivalry, and more importantly how they stand vis-a-vis one another in today's balance of affairs." I must ask, do you consider yourself to not be clueless in these matters? The reason I ask is because of the part I have highlighted. Did not the "hundreds of years of violation of sovereignty of the Muslim Nations" ie. The Crusades take place on lands which were formerly "christian", and conquered by islamic force in the 100 years or so from c.620AD? If you yourself are not clueless, I can`t think why you would not have mentioned it. Not to do so is equally as disingenuous as not contiuing to.."patiently continue to do what's harder and avoid the easy way out, which is sweeping generalizations". The christian crusaders were no worse, nor better, than the 7th century muslims. Discussions like this one only serve to reinforce my personal belief: the world would be a much better more understanding and peaceful place if there was no religion.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Quote sitdownstandup at 06 Mar 2015 10.41pm
How about asking the same question of christianity - is it a religion of peace? There are christian pacifists - Leo Tolstoy being the most famous and , of course there are (many more) Christians who have fought in and initiated wars - George Bush being the most recent alongside Tony Blair. The KKK were also a christian organisation. Of course both sides would denounce one another as being wrong in their beliefs although both following the same religion. So whose belief is right? No sitdown, I don`t believe it is.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 06 Mar 2015 6.23pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Mar 2015 9.25am
Quote reborn at 06 Mar 2015 9.21am
ISIS actually hate everyone. They would if they could kill 100% of Christians and ever Muslim that doesn't adhere to their insane interpretation of Islam. IS aren't muslims, they're sectarian nationalists who use Islam as a means to an end. The Koran is pretty clear that killing innocents is unacceptable, especially when their muslims. The whole Apostasy thing is a convenience (and IS is the apostacsy). IS is about power, control and domination. It has nothing to do with Islam.
How they interpret/hide behind thier religion is open for conjecture, the fact that it is directly linked to thier chosen brand of sky fairy is not. Ok, take it literally - it has something to do with Islam, in that they're comprised of muslims and have an Islamist ideology - but they're not coherent adherents to Islam as a whole - its about their political ambitions and power, not the good of Muslims and Islam. Taking it as being representative of Islam and Muslims is ultimately misleading.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote sitdownstandup at 06 Mar 2015 10.41pm
How about asking the same question of christianity - is it a religion of peace? There are christian pacifists - Leo Tolstoy being the most famous and , of course there are (many more) Christians who have fought in and initiated wars - George Bush being the most recent alongside Tony Blair. The KKK were also a christian organisation. Of course both sides would denounce one another as being wrong in their beliefs although both following the same religion. So whose belief is right? Again though, these are largely incidents of political power that utilise a Christian message to co-opt support and appeal. The KKK isn't technically Christian, its protestant, as it persecuted Catholics as well as blacks, jews etc. But it serves as an useful parallel, in that it was entirely an organisation with religious practices and disciplines, that was entirely geared towards economical and political manipulation and power, rather than that of faith. Effectively the Christian terrorists of their time.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote kersal at 06 Mar 2015 11.05pm
To say that Christian crusades from Europe took place to take back what was rightfully theirs is diverting the attention away. I would have agreed more with that statement if Crusades were limited to the Byzantine armies, who controlled Jerusalem previously. Secondly, my point about cluelessness was on claiming 400 million radicals and potentially extending it to today's dynamics around Muslim sects and Middle Eastern minorities. If we were sitting across one another, I would have loved to tell you all I know about this topic, but it is way too complex. My goal in my post was not to teach what's happening in detail but to prevent things that are not really happening from being said. It was just a "whoa guys, hold on, there is a lot more to it than you think" sort of a heads-up. Quoting me in the sarcastic ways that you did does not really corner me. You are extremely selective in your response and not constructively so, either. kersal, I didn`t say the christian crusades took place to take back what was "rightfully" theirs. I merely put it forward to highlight the fact that they were no worse than the muslim invasions of the 7th century. A fact you conveniently omitted. Secondly I agree that labelling 25% of all muslims as radical is madness. I`d be both surprised and disappointed if it was 2.5%. Further,please do not think I percieve muslims as lesser than anyone else. I think religion in general is one of the biggest tragedies to blight mankind.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Quote kersal at 06 Mar 2015 11.44pm
Quote lankygit at 06 Mar 2015 11.21pm
Quote kersal at 06 Mar 2015 11.05pm
To say that Christian crusades from Europe took place to take back what was rightfully theirs is diverting the attention away. I would have agreed more with that statement if Crusades were limited to the Byzantine armies, who controlled Jerusalem previously. Secondly, my point about cluelessness was on claiming 400 million radicals and potentially extending it to today's dynamics around Muslim sects and Middle Eastern minorities. If we were sitting across one another, I would have loved to tell you all I know about this topic, but it is way too complex. My goal in my post was not to teach what's happening in detail but to prevent things that are not really happening from being said. It was just a "whoa guys, hold on, there is a lot more to it than you think" sort of a heads-up. Quoting me in the sarcastic ways that you did does not really corner me. You are extremely selective in your response and not constructively so, either. kersal, I didn`t say the christian crusades took place to take back what was "rightfully" theirs. I merely put it forward to highlight the fact that they were no worse than the muslim invasions of the 7th century. A fact you conveniently omitted. Secondly I agree that labelling 25% of all muslims as radical is madness. I`d be both surprised and disappointed if it was 2.5%. Further,please do not think I percieve muslims as lesser than anyone else. I think religion in general is one of the biggest tragedies to blight mankind in general. Thanks, I understand. Please know that I wasn't trying to be selectively protagonistic at all to any side. Or omitting facts conveniently. I have no pro-Muslim or pro-Christian objectives. I do not believe in God and I am not a part of a community that is associated with believing or not believing in God. I agree with your last sentence. Anything that's open to interpretations will always be manipulated by the more powerful to mobilize the less powerful.
Sorry if I came across as sarcastic there as well, I didn`t mean to.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
| Hoof Hearted 07 Mar 15 9.15am | |
|---|---|
|
Any of you seen these on people's front doors? Is it a muslim thing?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Vaibow at 07 Mar 2015 10.11pm
Quote johnfirewall at 07 Mar 2015 10.04pm
Regardless of the general stance, there's one group of maniacs with 50,000 Twitter accounts and another entire group of maniacs backing them. All with the same vile aims which amount to indiscriminate murder. The IRA may have had some numbers but had a more specific target. While these groups have a common cause there needs to be greater opposition from those with the same beliefs. I just don't get the lack of respect they show to non believers. If i wanted everyone to follow a religion, i wouldn't threaten them into doing it, that's for sure. That's because they're cruel and callous, not spiritual. Their interest is in obtaining control and power over others, not spiritual enlightenment and fulfillment. The religion is just the 'justification and rallying point'. The reality is that they've more in common with a death cult, than Islam.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.