You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Now that's my kind of Religion
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Now that's my kind of Religion


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 1.22pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 1.15pm

As a Christian and a Bodybuilder I rather like this depiction...

*just lightening things up folks


Now I see why the Christian Right in the US are so big on Guns.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 18 Mar 15 1.30pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 1.20pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 1.06pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 11.27am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 17 Mar 2015 11.29pm

Quote dannyh at 17 Mar 2015 11.01am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 17 Mar 2015 9.39am

Quote dannyh at 17 Mar 2015 9.14am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Mar 2015 2.05pm

Quote dannyh at 16 Mar 2015 1.59pm


I like the idea of God and Jesus and all that stuff of course, who wouldn't, but my adult brain thinks,,,no actually, it knows, that the bible is full of absolute dog toffee that has been proven beyond any doubt to be bollicks. Espeically the old testament crap, Adam and Eve Noah and all that old tosh.

In fairness, even most of the writers of that era wouldn't really have expected people to take stories at face value.

Classical literature of the time (and before) very much uses the concept of fables, parables and metaphor as key elements. No one would read Ovid's Metamorphosis and think 'ah right, that's literal'. Similarly, Rabbi's don't generally refer to the Torrah (and the old testament books) as being literal events.

Although there is a lot of evidence to support the idea of a few 'great floods', the ark isn't supposed to be taken as anything more than a metaphor. The film is much better than the book.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (16 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

pah !

Christianity in it's wisdom says the world is only 6000 years old. We all know the earth is billions of years old, Thats the book of genesis kicked into touch without even breaking sweat, and thats the basis of the entire bible.

Oh yeah did I mention a talking snake ?


1) The vast majority of Christians and Jews do not see the Bible as the literal word of God. Although many think it is inspired by the Holy Spirit, it is likely to have heaps of factual imperfections because human knowledge (especially then, was limited). That is emphasised in opposition to God's infinite wisdom.

Human Knowledge was limited ? can you explain the pyramids for me again then. And if God if so wise why are thousands of children dying of hunger and starvation as we speak, doesn't seem very wise to me.

2) Much of the Bible's language is allegorical. The point of the talking snake and events in the first part of Genesis is to detail the relationship of good and ever and man's relationship to God. Whether it actually happened or not is irrelevant. The seven days thing is simple creation myth language.

It's interesting that you say whether it happened or not is irrelevant, so as a christian (clearly) you are saying the story of creation as written in the king James bible is irrelavant. It's only irrelavant because even you in your Jesus is great slanted look at life know that it is simply bollocks. The Earth has stood for billions of years it wasn't made in 7 days by the big sky fairy, and Adam and Eve were not the first humans on Earth, Try reading a factual book on Darwinism.


3) I know that the insightful wisdom you clearly possess coupled with a delightful cynicism is unique, but Christians have heard it all before. I don't know why you're so self-centred to highlight talking snakes etc., but your points are neither original nor of any interest to anyone else.

It is not isightful wisdom it is fact. Pure cold scientific FACT. My Cynicism is far from unique, before you have me burnt at the stake (another enligtened Christian pass time) why dont you google Atheist at see how many there are out there.

Christians do not care in the slightest what your position is because you do not have the faculties to present tricky problematic doctrinal and theological problems for Christianity but point out logical flaws that a moron (you maybe?) could recognise.

I could go to great length in theoligical debate with you as I was brought up a catholic and went to a catholic school, but people like you dont listen to reasoned debate, your like the women out of the film paul, who when confronted with an Alien, sank to her knees and receited Amazing grace! I would also argue that if I a "moron" can point out such open and easily discreditable bible tosh then what does it say about those that belive it (you?)


If Christians are being moronic to you then so be it but Christians don't care. Christianity is a faith-based religion and requires far more nuanced insight with regard to fallacies in order to form a more coherent theology in regard to scripture.

Oh so because you believe in some omni present Sky Fairy that makes you brighter than me, Listen mate I don't care what you believe but you have no more proof to your belief system than I could provide to show aliens exist. Different people believe differen things, I chose not to belive in wholsale religion because then I don't have to aleinate other just becuase they believe in a different type of fairy at the bottom of the garden than I do.

4) Join the national secular society. Funnily enough you might learn something.

About the NSS

We work in the UK and Europe to challenge the disproportionate influence of religion on governments and in public life. We provide a secular voice in the media, defending freedom and equality as a counterbalance to the powerful religious lobby and some of the more destructive religious impulses that can threaten human rights worldwide.

You know I just might.


Edited by dannyh (17 Mar 2015 11.03am)

Yo, Danny old buddy old pal.

I just realised who exactly you are and that we had a similar argument five years ago and that you sent me these private messages off the forum:


dannyh
'Tell you what mate you keep on being abusive, all it proves is that you catholics are all the same, how dare someone disagree with your religious views.
I'll tell you what as well hard man why don't you meet me and say that stuff to my face,
t***t'

------------

EaglesEaglesEagles
'Listen, why are you saying this to me and why not on the forum. I don't understand, apart from calling you stupid I tried to show you how you are wrong, not being abusive without anything to back me up. I apologise for doing this though, I realise I was too heated, I'm sorry. A forum is a forum for a reason and for debate, so I don't understand your concept of one. To be honest you atheists in this country are the same: how someone dare believe in Catholicism/any faith and you show so much hate. I wouldn't have replied to your specific post if it hadn't angered me so much.
Well you wouldn't say those things face to face with a catholic who is equally violent as you but much bigger and stronger than you. Or would you hard man?'

------------

dannyh
'Yes I would You see the thing is unlike you what ever I put on a messarge board I would say to someones face I dont hide behind anything, Ask anyone who knows me on here.
As for Catholics I was brought up as one, went to an all Boys Catholic school, mass every sunday, but when I was old enough to make up my own mind I realised that if God or jesus could see how their word has been warped and twisted they would not be to chuffed.
The Catholic church is clouded in controversy always has been.
Your a blinkered fool.'


Not saying that this does anything to disprove your argument or further mine but I think you're a bit of a prick as a person and I don't think there is any point to further debate. I personally since then have changed my opinion and do not think atheists are all the same. Other people on the forum have far stronger and interesting arguments than you and you don't want to listen, just criticise after a childhood Catholic experience which seems to have scarred you.

You are dismissive to the point of abusive on points of view which contradict yours. To you they are dangerous and should be derided and destroyed if possible.
You belittle faith but personally I can't fathom how life can simply exists after having been a bunch of material and chemicals. Nor can I see how time can never have existed and that everything is infinite.
I'm not sure you can explain that by science. Maybe ask jamiemartin, he has a pretty good idea of the argument, although I can't fathom it myself. I think just in a general sense you are unintelligent and rude. I'm separating you from thousands upon thousands of atheists who are highly intelligent and create fascinating, challenging concepts.


Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (17 Mar 2015 11.32pm)


Ahhh the last defence of the beaten, name calling and an unswerving ability to simply belittle points that religious types simply dismiss because the alternative (when they stop waffling about an argument 5 years ago, dude you really kept that for five years, your weird) is to have to admit that their belief system is based on nothing more, than a book written a long long time ago, and that has very little historical fact to it.

I might bury a copy of Lord of the Rings in a cave somewhere, who knows it might be found hundreds if not thousands of years from now and start a new religion based on Frodo being the new messiah.

I love the fact you call me rude and unintelligent, your not showing yourself as much better are you ?

The fact is this you believe in an omnipresent infallible God.

My point is that there is way to much suffering across the globe for your beliefs to hold water. And your attitude to people like myself is similar to that of anyone who has stood up to the church over the years. But time moves on, (unlike you) and fortunately for me you can't burn "heretics" at the stake anymore.


Edited by dannyh (18 Mar 2015 11.41am)

1) I brought up those messages because they are the only things that have ever been sent to my inbox. So I remember them and in sending them to me you were a massive prick. I don't know why you sent me the messages, you could have just replied on the forum. Why did you?

2) Maybe I am unintelligent but I do not consider myself rude and funnily enough, I'm not so close minded to believe that everyone who believes in a religion has no valid argument in any way. I believe that atheists, agnostic and religious people (of all faiths) can be intelligent. You have presented yourself as dismissive of anything that isn't scientific atheism. I'd rather be a moron than abusive and horrible, which is what you have showed yourself to be.

3) I have had civilised and thorough debates with people who seem far more accepting and intelligent than you and are totally against my opinion both on this forum and in real life.

4) Not everything can be immediately verified by science or history. I draw your attention to the 'miracle' of the sun in 1917, witnessed by at least 30,000 people, many of whom were atheists and journalists. Things like this are part of my basis for faith, not simply a book.

5) You talk about Christians burning heretics. You're right that was dreadful but check out this (probably inaccurate) graphic. [Link]
The top 3 murderous dictators were atheists, Mao and Stalin establishing states which persecuted the religious (along with other groups of course).


Frankly mate, you are not suited to debate. I don't quite know why there is so much suffering in the world to be honest. I don't claim to know everything. I just can't accept that the universe was a big mass of elements and as part of the big bang was created having been infinite. Why did it always exist? How does life manifest itself?


Brilliant

I've described you as a massive prick because you took it upon yourself to unfairly undermine mine and others' arguments through abusive responses to what should be a civilised debate.

There is no room for a civilised debate with you because you are not willing to consider other arguments in a respectful way.

For that reason I am open and happy to call you a massive prick because of this attitude. Nonetheless, my approach in response to your comments on my beliefs has been respectful and calculated to the best of my abilities. Nonetheless I think it fair that I can express my personal thoughts on your character even if I treat your arguments in my responses with the same respect I would anyone else.

You're the one who decided to send abusive messages to my inbox. That was a private conversation completely unrelated to the context of debate. It is on these grounds and these grounds only that I called you a massive prick not because of your opinions on religion. And you are a massive prick. Good day sir.


Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (18 Mar 2015 1.31pm)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 18 Mar 15 2.11pm

Thanks for your contributions EaglesEaglesEagles and dannyh. Perhaps leave it there between you before things get too unpleasant? Cheers.

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Mar 15 2.40pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 1.30pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 1.20pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 1.06pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 11.27am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 17 Mar 2015 11.29pm

Quote dannyh at 17 Mar 2015 11.01am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 17 Mar 2015 9.39am

Quote dannyh at 17 Mar 2015 9.14am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Mar 2015 2.05pm

Quote dannyh at 16 Mar 2015 1.59pm


I like the idea of God and Jesus and all that stuff of course, who wouldn't, but my adult brain thinks,,,no actually, it knows, that the bible is full of absolute dog toffee that has been proven beyond any doubt to be bollicks. Espeically the old testament crap, Adam and Eve Noah and all that old tosh.

In fairness, even most of the writers of that era wouldn't really have expected people to take stories at face value.

Classical literature of the time (and before) very much uses the concept of fables, parables and metaphor as key elements. No one would read Ovid's Metamorphosis and think 'ah right, that's literal'. Similarly, Rabbi's don't generally refer to the Torrah (and the old testament books) as being literal events.

Although there is a lot of evidence to support the idea of a few 'great floods', the ark isn't supposed to be taken as anything more than a metaphor. The film is much better than the book.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (16 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

pah !

Christianity in it's wisdom says the world is only 6000 years old. We all know the earth is billions of years old, Thats the book of genesis kicked into touch without even breaking sweat, and thats the basis of the entire bible.

Oh yeah did I mention a talking snake ?


1) The vast majority of Christians and Jews do not see the Bible as the literal word of God. Although many think it is inspired by the Holy Spirit, it is likely to have heaps of factual imperfections because human knowledge (especially then, was limited). That is emphasised in opposition to God's infinite wisdom.

Human Knowledge was limited ? can you explain the pyramids for me again then. And if God if so wise why are thousands of children dying of hunger and starvation as we speak, doesn't seem very wise to me.

2) Much of the Bible's language is allegorical. The point of the talking snake and events in the first part of Genesis is to detail the relationship of good and ever and man's relationship to God. Whether it actually happened or not is irrelevant. The seven days thing is simple creation myth language.

It's interesting that you say whether it happened or not is irrelevant, so as a christian (clearly) you are saying the story of creation as written in the king James bible is irrelavant. It's only irrelavant because even you in your Jesus is great slanted look at life know that it is simply bollocks. The Earth has stood for billions of years it wasn't made in 7 days by the big sky fairy, and Adam and Eve were not the first humans on Earth, Try reading a factual book on Darwinism.


3) I know that the insightful wisdom you clearly possess coupled with a delightful cynicism is unique, but Christians have heard it all before. I don't know why you're so self-centred to highlight talking snakes etc., but your points are neither original nor of any interest to anyone else.

It is not isightful wisdom it is fact. Pure cold scientific FACT. My Cynicism is far from unique, before you have me burnt at the stake (another enligtened Christian pass time) why dont you google Atheist at see how many there are out there.

Christians do not care in the slightest what your position is because you do not have the faculties to present tricky problematic doctrinal and theological problems for Christianity but point out logical flaws that a moron (you maybe?) could recognise.

I could go to great length in theoligical debate with you as I was brought up a catholic and went to a catholic school, but people like you dont listen to reasoned debate, your like the women out of the film paul, who when confronted with an Alien, sank to her knees and receited Amazing grace! I would also argue that if I a "moron" can point out such open and easily discreditable bible tosh then what does it say about those that belive it (you?)


If Christians are being moronic to you then so be it but Christians don't care. Christianity is a faith-based religion and requires far more nuanced insight with regard to fallacies in order to form a more coherent theology in regard to scripture.

Oh so because you believe in some omni present Sky Fairy that makes you brighter than me, Listen mate I don't care what you believe but you have no more proof to your belief system than I could provide to show aliens exist. Different people believe differen things, I chose not to belive in wholsale religion because then I don't have to aleinate other just becuase they believe in a different type of fairy at the bottom of the garden than I do.

4) Join the national secular society. Funnily enough you might learn something.

About the NSS

We work in the UK and Europe to challenge the disproportionate influence of religion on governments and in public life. We provide a secular voice in the media, defending freedom and equality as a counterbalance to the powerful religious lobby and some of the more destructive religious impulses that can threaten human rights worldwide.

You know I just might.


Edited by dannyh (17 Mar 2015 11.03am)

Yo, Danny old buddy old pal.

I just realised who exactly you are and that we had a similar argument five years ago and that you sent me these private messages off the forum:


dannyh
'Tell you what mate you keep on being abusive, all it proves is that you catholics are all the same, how dare someone disagree with your religious views.
I'll tell you what as well hard man why don't you meet me and say that stuff to my face,
t***t'

------------

EaglesEaglesEagles
'Listen, why are you saying this to me and why not on the forum. I don't understand, apart from calling you stupid I tried to show you how you are wrong, not being abusive without anything to back me up. I apologise for doing this though, I realise I was too heated, I'm sorry. A forum is a forum for a reason and for debate, so I don't understand your concept of one. To be honest you atheists in this country are the same: how someone dare believe in Catholicism/any faith and you show so much hate. I wouldn't have replied to your specific post if it hadn't angered me so much.
Well you wouldn't say those things face to face with a catholic who is equally violent as you but much bigger and stronger than you. Or would you hard man?'

------------

dannyh
'Yes I would You see the thing is unlike you what ever I put on a messarge board I would say to someones face I dont hide behind anything, Ask anyone who knows me on here.
As for Catholics I was brought up as one, went to an all Boys Catholic school, mass every sunday, but when I was old enough to make up my own mind I realised that if God or jesus could see how their word has been warped and twisted they would not be to chuffed.
The Catholic church is clouded in controversy always has been.
Your a blinkered fool.'


Not saying that this does anything to disprove your argument or further mine but I think you're a bit of a prick as a person and I don't think there is any point to further debate. I personally since then have changed my opinion and do not think atheists are all the same. Other people on the forum have far stronger and interesting arguments than you and you don't want to listen, just criticise after a childhood Catholic experience which seems to have scarred you.

You are dismissive to the point of abusive on points of view which contradict yours. To you they are dangerous and should be derided and destroyed if possible.
You belittle faith but personally I can't fathom how life can simply exists after having been a bunch of material and chemicals. Nor can I see how time can never have existed and that everything is infinite.
I'm not sure you can explain that by science. Maybe ask jamiemartin, he has a pretty good idea of the argument, although I can't fathom it myself. I think just in a general sense you are unintelligent and rude. I'm separating you from thousands upon thousands of atheists who are highly intelligent and create fascinating, challenging concepts.


Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (17 Mar 2015 11.32pm)


Ahhh the last defence of the beaten, name calling and an unswerving ability to simply belittle points that religious types simply dismiss because the alternative (when they stop waffling about an argument 5 years ago, dude you really kept that for five years, your weird) is to have to admit that their belief system is based on nothing more, than a book written a long long time ago, and that has very little historical fact to it.

I might bury a copy of Lord of the Rings in a cave somewhere, who knows it might be found hundreds if not thousands of years from now and start a new religion based on Frodo being the new messiah.

I love the fact you call me rude and unintelligent, your not showing yourself as much better are you ?

The fact is this you believe in an omnipresent infallible God.

My point is that there is way to much suffering across the globe for your beliefs to hold water. And your attitude to people like myself is similar to that of anyone who has stood up to the church over the years. But time moves on, (unlike you) and fortunately for me you can't burn "heretics" at the stake anymore.


Edited by dannyh (18 Mar 2015 11.41am)

1) I brought up those messages because they are the only things that have ever been sent to my inbox. So I remember them and in sending them to me you were a massive prick. I don't know why you sent me the messages, you could have just replied on the forum. Why did you?

2) Maybe I am unintelligent but I do not consider myself rude and funnily enough, I'm not so close minded to believe that everyone who believes in a religion has no valid argument in any way. I believe that atheists, agnostic and religious people (of all faiths) can be intelligent. You have presented yourself as dismissive of anything that isn't scientific atheism. I'd rather be a moron than abusive and horrible, which is what you have showed yourself to be.

3) I have had civilised and thorough debates with people who seem far more accepting and intelligent than you and are totally against my opinion both on this forum and in real life.

4) Not everything can be immediately verified by science or history. I draw your attention to the 'miracle' of the sun in 1917, witnessed by at least 30,000 people, many of whom were atheists and journalists. Things like this are part of my basis for faith, not simply a book.

5) You talk about Christians burning heretics. You're right that was dreadful but check out this (probably inaccurate) graphic. [Link]
The top 3 murderous dictators were atheists, Mao and Stalin establishing states which persecuted the religious (along with other groups of course).


Frankly mate, you are not suited to debate. I don't quite know why there is so much suffering in the world to be honest. I don't claim to know everything. I just can't accept that the universe was a big mass of elements and as part of the big bang was created having been infinite. Why did it always exist? How does life manifest itself?


Brilliant

I've described you as a massive prick because you took it upon yourself to unfairly undermine mine and others' arguments through abusive responses to what should be a civilised debate.

There is no room for a civilised debate with you because you are not willing to consider other arguments in a respectful way.

For that reason I am open and happy to call you a massive prick because of this attitude. Nonetheless, my approach in response to your comments on my beliefs has been respectful and calculated to the best of my abilities. Nonetheless I think it fair that I can express my personal thoughts on your character even if I treat your arguments in my responses with the same respect I would anyone else.

You're the one who decided to send abusive messages to my inbox. That was a private conversation completely unrelated to the context of debate. It is on these grounds and these grounds only that I called you a massive prick not because of your opinions on religion. And you are a massive prick. Good day sir.


Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (18 Mar 2015 1.31pm)


Hahahahahaha brilliant. Just proving my point really.

Thanks.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Hoof Hearted 18 Mar 15 3.46pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 1.15pm

As a Christian and a Bodybuilder I rather like this depiction...

*just lightening things up folks


As an atheist and a dog lover I rather like this depiction...

*just lightening things up folks

The Lord Has Risen.jpg Attachment: The Lord Has Risen.jpg (20.95Kb)

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 18 Mar 15 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.

 

reborn 18 Mar 15 6.13pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.

This is what happens when any subject which solicits strong opinions comes up LOL

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Mar 15 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Jamesrichards8 Flag 18 Mar 15 6.28pm

I had a mate who was very religious, but in a good way, never forcing his beliefs on others and a very kind person. I respected him a lot for that. Then one day he told me that he believed that dinosaurs were fabricated and didn't actually exist, and that the world started only a few thousand years ago. When I asked him what the skeletons in museums were he said they were fabricated by humans. Though I still speak to him, I could never really take anything he said at face value any longer. Also he's a man united fan.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

reborn 18 Mar 15 7.26pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

That's not true Dan, if you are confrontational and rude to others on a message forum on any subject you can guarantee that you will be met with the same in spades. I quite like you, always have, you will note no bile from me for instance.

However, you are using a straw-man argument in this post, bile is ever present on a message forum, try looking around. LOL

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 18 Mar 15 8.52pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 7.26pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

That's not true Dan, if you are confrontational and rude to others on a message forum on any subject you can guarantee that you will be met with the same in spades. I quite like you, always have, you will note no bile from me for instance.

However, you are using a straw-man argument in this post, bile is ever present on a message forum, try looking around. LOL

He is actually correct in a sense. He proposes that atheism twinned with science is the only logical and appropriate position to take and that all faith based or spiritual belief is false.

Therefore, if a person tries to present a different argument and suggest any sort of supernatural force or God their action is pointless and without grounding to him. He has established what the correct thing to believe in and for this reason anything which cannot be proved purely on a basis of logic or science cannot be argued for. So if a Christian or a member of another faith try to contradict his points they have no case and engage in spouting religious bile.

I don't appreciate being called dangerous and I dont think I seethe (think that's what he meant). However, he thinks I'm blind and if faith is to be categorised universally as obsolete then he is correct.
This post is not in any way rude, attempting to be confrontational nor presenting a point of view. What I have tried to do is explain the dannyh's opinion. He doesn't care what people believe, everyone's entitled to believe anything. But there is not a single religious or faith based belief worth debating and any response to his scientific and logic based argument has absolutely no value.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.00pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 8.52pm

He is actually correct in a sense. He proposes that atheism twinned with science is the only logical and appropriate position to take and that all faith based or spiritual belief is false.

By definition, yes it would be, the logical, rational choice, by definition of rational and logical would be science.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 19 Mar 15 1.48pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 8.52pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 7.26pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

That's not true Dan, if you are confrontational and rude to others on a message forum on any subject you can guarantee that you will be met with the same in spades. I quite like you, always have, you will note no bile from me for instance.

However, you are using a straw-man argument in this post, bile is ever present on a message forum, try looking around. LOL

He is actually correct in a sense. He proposes that atheism twinned with science is the only logical and appropriate position to take and that all faith based or spiritual belief is false.

Therefore, if a person tries to present a different argument and suggest any sort of supernatural force or God their action is pointless and without grounding to him. He has established what the correct thing to believe in and for this reason anything which cannot be proved purely on a basis of logic or science cannot be argued for. So if a Christian or a member of another faith try to contradict his points they have no case and engage in spouting religious bile.

I don't appreciate being called dangerous and I dont think I seethe (think that's what he meant). However, he thinks I'm blind and if faith is to be categorised universally as obsolete then he is correct.
This post is not in any way rude, attempting to be confrontational nor presenting a point of view. What I have tried to do is explain the dannyh's opinion. He doesn't care what people believe, everyone's entitled to believe anything. But there is not a single religious or faith based belief worth debating and any response to his scientific and logic based argument has absolutely no value.


Draws deep breath .......

Right you've nearly got it, however just because I deal in absolutes on a message board doesn’t mean I haven’t sat and pondered the likely hood of Jesus Moses and all.

As I said earlier I was brought up a Catholic, and didn’t have any bad experiances (as you put it) at all. I grew up in a very stable Anglo/Irish family, but I do have an enquiring mind and as I got older, things in the bible had clear similarities to Fables read out in class, be good, don’t be bad, morality etc etc . So I spent quite a long time at odds with my faith, researching from all aspects of the argument, for and against faith based devotion.

Now I could drone on and on with my meandering thoughts and counter thoughts on the subject of religion, but I would be in to the hundreds of pages before I got to my obvious conclusion that as far as factual text goes, the bible has very little basis in fact if any, and even less credence in truth. Allow me try and let you see a tiny bit of why I have the opinion I do.

There are countless religious texts that mirror stories told in the bible that pre date Jesus by thousands of years, for example the Egyptian GodHorus 3100BC was one of the many Egyptian Gods. He had 12 disciples. He was born of a virgin in a cave. His birth was announced by a star, and was attended by three wise men. He was baptized at age thirty by Anup the Baptizer. Horus performed miracles, including rising at least one person from the dead and walking on water. He was crucified, buried in a tomb, and resurrected, just like Jesus.

Then we have Mithra2000BC Yet another example of virginal birth, Mithra was born to the virgin Anahita on December 25th. He was swaddled and placed in a manger, where he was tended to by shepherds. Like Jesus and Horus, he had 12 companions (which can be interpreted as disciples). He also performed miracles, identified with both the lion and the lamb, sacrificed his life to save the world, was dead for three days before being resurrected, and was known as the messiah, the savior, and “the Way, the Truth and the Light.” His religion also had a Eucharistic-style “Lord’s supper.”

I could go on, even Buddha has some comparisons, eg walking on water, healing the sick, he even did the old feed 500 trick from one basket of cakes ..seem familiar ?

The point is Jesus is just another example of early mans need to believe, instead of understand, and as science improves more and more people should (bit of an assumption I will admit) decide that the bible and religion as whole has one massive floor....It's all bollocks.

Now I could also perceive from my meandering research over the years, that because all these stories share similar traits there must be some truth to it ? All these different civilisations recounting almost identical stories but thousands of years apart ? it does pose an interesting question in reference to the existence of a God like figure who came to Earth many thousands of years ago. Who the fcuk knows ? I know I don't.

Look at it this way if we were in court and I was prosecuting the bible and you defending it, I would win with any jury that had half a brain and wasn't completely Tonto.(again assumption on my part but you get the point I hope).

Hopefully you now see my stance, It is not totally and utterly dismissive more my own opinion based on my own research and thoughts.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 19 Mar 15 2.00pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 1.07pm

But until I change my mind on that, I will continue to focus on his message of Love, Compassion and Forgiveness.

Sounds ok even to sceptic right?

But why do these things have to be linked to any religion? Surely these are just the basics of humanity.

So that's now a Politics and Religion thread I've posted on - sounds like one of the really good Sunday lunches we used to have at home where I could use either subject to create an argument.

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

reborn 19 Mar 15 2.42pm

Quote Charlie Croker at 19 Mar 2015 2.00pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 1.07pm

But until I change my mind on that, I will continue to focus on his message of Love, Compassion and Forgiveness.

Sounds ok even to sceptic right?

But why do these things have to be linked to any religion? Surely these are just the basics of humanity.

So that's now a Politics and Religion thread I've posted on - sounds like one of the really good Sunday lunches we used to have at home where I could use either subject to create an argument.


Of course they don't, but too rarely are they found in humanity.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 19 Mar 15 2.55pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 18 Mar 2015 6.28pm

I had a mate who was very religious, but in a good way, never forcing his beliefs on others and a very kind person. I respected him a lot for that. Then one day he told me that he believed that dinosaurs were fabricated and didn't actually exist, and that the world started only a few thousand years ago. When I asked him what the skeletons in museums were he said they were fabricated by humans. Though I still speak to him, I could never really take anything he said at face value any longer. Also he's a man united fan.

You should have just opened with the last statement. It would have put the plonker-like beliefs in context from the outset.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 19 Mar 15 4.08pm

Quote dannyh at 19 Mar 2015 1.48pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 8.52pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 7.26pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

That's not true Dan, if you are confrontational and rude to others on a message forum on any subject you can guarantee that you will be met with the same in spades. I quite like you, always have, you will note no bile from me for instance.

However, you are using a straw-man argument in this post, bile is ever present on a message forum, try looking around. LOL

He is actually correct in a sense. He proposes that atheism twinned with science is the only logical and appropriate position to take and that all faith based or spiritual belief is false.

Therefore, if a person tries to present a different argument and suggest any sort of supernatural force or God their action is pointless and without grounding to him. He has established what the correct thing to believe in and for this reason anything which cannot be proved purely on a basis of logic or science cannot be argued for. So if a Christian or a member of another faith try to contradict his points they have no case and engage in spouting religious bile.

I don't appreciate being called dangerous and I dont think I seethe (think that's what he meant). However, he thinks I'm blind and if faith is to be categorised universally as obsolete then he is correct.
This post is not in any way rude, attempting to be confrontational nor presenting a point of view. What I have tried to do is explain the dannyh's opinion. He doesn't care what people believe, everyone's entitled to believe anything. But there is not a single religious or faith based belief worth debating and any response to his scientific and logic based argument has absolutely no value.


Draws deep breath .......

Right you've nearly got it, however just because I deal in absolutes on a message board doesn’t mean I haven’t sat and pondered the likely hood of Jesus Moses and all.

As I said earlier I was brought up a Catholic, and didn’t have any bad experiances (as you put it) at all. I grew up in a very stable Anglo/Irish family, but I do have an enquiring mind and as I got older, things in the bible had clear similarities to Fables read out in class, be good, don’t be bad, morality etc etc . So I spent quite a long time at odds with my faith, researching from all aspects of the argument, for and against faith based devotion.

Now I could drone on and on with my meandering thoughts and counter thoughts on the subject of religion, but I would be in to the hundreds of pages before I got to my obvious conclusion that as far as factual text goes, the bible has very little basis in fact if any, and even less credence in truth. Allow me try and let you see a tiny bit of why I have the opinion I do.

There are countless religious texts that mirror stories told in the bible that pre date Jesus by thousands of years, for example the Egyptian GodHorus 3100BC was one of the many Egyptian Gods. He had 12 disciples. He was born of a virgin in a cave. His birth was announced by a star, and was attended by three wise men. He was baptized at age thirty by Anup the Baptizer. Horus performed miracles, including rising at least one person from the dead and walking on water. He was crucified, buried in a tomb, and resurrected, just like Jesus.

Then we have Mithra2000BC Yet another example of virginal birth, Mithra was born to the virgin Anahita on December 25th. He was swaddled and placed in a manger, where he was tended to by shepherds. Like Jesus and Horus, he had 12 companions (which can be interpreted as disciples). He also performed miracles, identified with both the lion and the lamb, sacrificed his life to save the world, was dead for three days before being resurrected, and was known as the messiah, the savior, and “the Way, the Truth and the Light.” His religion also had a Eucharistic-style “Lord’s supper.”

I could go on, even Buddha has some comparisons, eg walking on water, healing the sick, he even did the old feed 500 trick from one basket of cakes ..seem familiar ?

The point is Jesus is just another example of early mans need to believe, instead of understand, and as science improves more and more people should (bit of an assumption I will admit) decide that the bible and religion as whole has one massive floor....It's all bollocks.

Now I could also perceive from my meandering research over the years, that because all these stories share similar traits there must be some truth to it ? All these different civilisations recounting almost identical stories but thousands of years apart ? it does pose an interesting question in reference to the existence of a God like figure who came to Earth many thousands of years ago. Who the fcuk knows ? I know I don't.

Look at it this way if we were in court and I was prosecuting the bible and you defending it, I would win with any jury that had half a brain and wasn't completely Tonto.(again assumption on my part but you get the point I hope).

Hopefully you now see my stance, It is not totally and utterly dismissive more my own opinion based on my own research and thoughts.

I respect that you not only have experience with being a religious believer but have also considered and investigated the idea of myth making across the centuries and have come to the conclusion that the deification of Jesus is similarly a myth due to many similarities in other myths such as that of Horus.

I don't think you just dismiss things out of hand because you don't like them. I respect the fact that you have made conclusions through research that God cannot exist and Jesus and other religious figures are deified through methods shared with myths. I see that as a fair approach to take and have never denied that you take this. You've actually wasted a bit of your own time writing it down, I've heard these points before and can understand why people see them and find the story of Jesus as the Son of God hard to believe.

My problem is not only with the fact that you are rude and dismissive of all religious beliefs without considering the wider points. In your previous post you made reference to the fact that people are continuing to understand the world more through improvements in science. This is a point I agree on. However, I have personal problems with existence that I don't feel science can explain. They are (as I've already actually said):


1) How could the universe have infinitely existed in the form of a mass of elements and then been created chemically through a big bang of its own accord.

2) I don't necessarily dismiss the big bang, just the fact that there definitely wasn't a creative force (a God) behind it.

3) I don't understand how chemicals can combine and form molecules which develop into organs and bodies which have LIFE. How does life come from lifeless matter? How are humans conscious and no other animal comes close to us?


Please, ignore the fact that I am a Christian. Don't answer with talk about religious books or a religious figure as the only answer to these problems. They aren't. I'm not suggesting these are the solution to you. There could be a deist creator of sorts, just ignore the religious element. The point is that I am not assured of the universe's creation just happening out of chance. I am not an existentialist.
Now do you see my point?

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (19 Mar 2015 4.10pm)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 19 Mar 15 6.15pm

Best part of this whole thread is that people have realised Dannyh is a big prick,actually he has a little prick....God tried to make it bigger,just wouldn't happen.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 19 Mar 15 6.35pm

Quote aquickgame2 at 19 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Best part of this whole thread is that people have realised Dannyh is a big prick,actually he has a little prick....God tried to make it bigger,just wouldn't happen.


hahahah f*** off Abdul

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 19 Mar 15 7.04pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 19 Mar 2015 4.08pm

Quote dannyh at 19 Mar 2015 1.48pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 18 Mar 2015 8.52pm

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 7.26pm

Quote dannyh at 18 Mar 2015 6.15pm

Quote Crystal_Clear at 18 Mar 2015 5.26pm

See, this is what happens when established religion comes up.

That's why I started this thread, we'd all be better off sitting back and admiring sexy nuns, as in the video link.

Failing that, I think Peter Griffin was onto something when he started the Church of the Fonz.


That was kind of my point, I don't really give a sh1t what people believe in, but if you dare poke holes in their particular brand of sky fairy, the "Christian" attitude soon evaporates and your left with a sething pile of religious bile.

It doesnt matter if you muslim or christian or Jew, people who blindly believe all their religious texts are dangerous people to have around.

That's not true Dan, if you are confrontational and rude to others on a message forum on any subject you can guarantee that you will be met with the same in spades. I quite like you, always have, you will note no bile from me for instance.

However, you are using a straw-man argument in this post, bile is ever present on a message forum, try looking around. LOL

He is actually correct in a sense. He proposes that atheism twinned with science is the only logical and appropriate position to take and that all faith based or spiritual belief is false.

Therefore, if a person tries to present a different argument and suggest any sort of supernatural force or God their action is pointless and without grounding to him. He has established what the correct thing to believe in and for this reason anything which cannot be proved purely on a basis of logic or science cannot be argued for. So if a Christian or a member of another faith try to contradict his points they have no case and engage in spouting religious bile.

I don't appreciate being called dangerous and I dont think I seethe (think that's what he meant). However, he thinks I'm blind and if faith is to be categorised universally as obsolete then he is correct.
This post is not in any way rude, attempting to be confrontational nor presenting a point of view. What I have tried to do is explain the dannyh's opinion. He doesn't care what people believe, everyone's entitled to believe anything. But there is not a single religious or faith based belief worth debating and any response to his scientific and logic based argument has absolutely no value.


Draws deep breath .......

Right you've nearly got it, however just because I deal in absolutes on a message board doesn’t mean I haven’t sat and pondered the likely hood of Jesus Moses and all.

As I said earlier I was brought up a Catholic, and didn’t have any bad experiances (as you put it) at all. I grew up in a very stable Anglo/Irish family, but I do have an enquiring mind and as I got older, things in the bible had clear similarities to Fables read out in class, be good, don’t be bad, morality etc etc . So I spent quite a long time at odds with my faith, researching from all aspects of the argument, for and against faith based devotion.

Now I could drone on and on with my meandering thoughts and counter thoughts on the subject of religion, but I would be in to the hundreds of pages before I got to my obvious conclusion that as far as factual text goes, the bible has very little basis in fact if any, and even less credence in truth. Allow me try and let you see a tiny bit of why I have the opinion I do.

There are countless religious texts that mirror stories told in the bible that pre date Jesus by thousands of years, for example the Egyptian GodHorus 3100BC was one of the many Egyptian Gods. He had 12 disciples. He was born of a virgin in a cave. His birth was announced by a star, and was attended by three wise men. He was baptized at age thirty by Anup the Baptizer. Horus performed miracles, including rising at least one person from the dead and walking on water. He was crucified, buried in a tomb, and resurrected, just like Jesus.

Then we have Mithra2000BC Yet another example of virginal birth, Mithra was born to the virgin Anahita on December 25th. He was swaddled and placed in a manger, where he was tended to by shepherds. Like Jesus and Horus, he had 12 companions (which can be interpreted as disciples). He also performed miracles, identified with both the lion and the lamb, sacrificed his life to save the world, was dead for three days before being resurrected, and was known as the messiah, the savior, and “the Way, the Truth and the Light.” His religion also had a Eucharistic-style “Lord’s supper.”

I could go on, even Buddha has some comparisons, eg walking on water, healing the sick, he even did the old feed 500 trick from one basket of cakes ..seem familiar ?

The point is Jesus is just another example of early mans need to believe, instead of understand, and as science improves more and more people should (bit of an assumption I will admit) decide that the bible and religion as whole has one massive floor....It's all bollocks.

Now I could also perceive from my meandering research over the years, that because all these stories share similar traits there must be some truth to it ? All these different civilisations recounting almost identical stories but thousands of years apart ? it does pose an interesting question in reference to the existence of a God like figure who came to Earth many thousands of years ago. Who the fcuk knows ? I know I don't.

Look at it this way if we were in court and I was prosecuting the bible and you defending it, I would win with any jury that had half a brain and wasn't completely Tonto.(again assumption on my part but you get the point I hope).

Hopefully you now see my stance, It is not totally and utterly dismissive more my own opinion based on my own research and thoughts.

I respect that you not only have experience with being a religious believer but have also considered and investigated the idea of myth making across the centuries and have come to the conclusion that the deification of Jesus is similarly a myth due to many similarities in other myths such as that of Horus.

I don't think you just dismiss things out of hand because you don't like them. I respect the fact that you have made conclusions through research that God cannot exist and Jesus and other religious figures are deified through methods shared with myths. I see that as a fair approach to take and have never denied that you take this. You've actually wasted a bit of your own time writing it down, I've heard these points before and can understand why people see them and find the story of Jesus as the Son of God hard to believe.

My problem is not only with the fact that you are rude and dismissive of all religious beliefs without considering the wider points. In your previous post you made reference to the fact that people are continuing to understand the world more through improvements in science. This is a point I agree on. However, I have personal problems with existence that I don't feel science can explain. They are (as I've already actually said):


1) How could the universe have infinitely existed in the form of a mass of elements and then been created chemically through a big bang of its own accord.

2) I don't necessarily dismiss the big bang, just the fact that there definitely wasn't a creative force (a God) behind it.

3) I don't understand how chemicals can combine and form molecules which develop into organs and bodies which have LIFE. How does life come from lifeless matter? How are humans conscious and no other animal comes close to us?


Please, ignore the fact that I am a Christian. Don't answer with talk about religious books or a religious figure as the only answer to these problems. They aren't. I'm not suggesting these are the solution to you. There could be a deist creator of sorts, just ignore the religious element. The point is that I am not assured of the universe's creation just happening out of chance. I am not an existentialist.
Now do you see my point?

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (19 Mar 2015 4.10pm)

Well essentailly we agree then (sort of) I also believe that the something, not chance, is responsible for all life who or what that is, is if you like, the struggle of man to understand things beyond his comprehension , that in turn gives rise to all the incredulous crap that you read in religious texts.

My opinion is that, as we start to unravel the mysteries of the universe through science we will, in time, come to understand how it all started. we have barely scratched the surface, but we are on the right track, things like the Hadron collider and the infamous Higgs Boson particle are (although relatively un scrutinised) a step in that direction albeit a small one.

I guess having thought long and hard about my viewpoint, it is thus:

Rather than pin my hopes onto an "easy fix" or solution to the big question, I would rather wait it out and see what science comes up with, we can split atoms, graft skin cells, stem cell research is in its infancey but the prospects are really without limits.

I don't think (apart from being a massive prick) that my view is that different to yours.

I have just decided that the bible is to blunt a tool to answer the big question with.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Now that's my kind of Religion