You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 5 most overrated british bands.
November 22 2026 1.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

5 most overrated british bands.


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Pussay Patrol Flag 27 Apr 15 12.35pm

Quote silvertop at 27 Apr 2015 11.42am

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


Pikester I think I love you. Unfortunately, the last time I posted on here a few years ago to like effect, I was all but threatened with death.

It's a real shame. Mick Jones cannot sing or write a decent song. If he was excised from the band or just played his instrument and shut up, the Clash could have been one of the greats.

The others to the list:

Rolling Stones [after Brian Jones]
Who [save their early mod stuff]
Queen

On Queen, I have so much to say I could fill a thread such is my hatred of them and alarm at their ever-lasting popularity. Suffice to say they are 4 extremely talented individuals who produced ground breaking material and some really good songs but somehow collectively their "music" has an effect like a cheese grater to the cochlea. It is beyond awful.

Have to agree on Queen. Apart from the 70's rock stuff they became a camp pop band. All that 80's era with Radio Gaga and I want to Break free was not the stuff of legends. They were completely forgotten about over the States

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Plane Flag Bromley 27 Apr 15 12.50pm

Quote silvertop at 27 Apr 2015 11.42am

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


Pikester I think I love you. Unfortunately, the last time I posted on here a few years ago to like effect, I was all but threatened with death.

It's a real shame. Mick Jones cannot sing or write a decent song. If he was excised from the band or just played his instrument and shut up, the Clash could have been one of the greats.

The others to the list:

Rolling Stones [after Brian Jones]
Who [save their early mod stuff]
Queen

On Queen, I have so much to say I could fill a thread such is my hatred of them and alarm at their ever-lasting popularity. Suffice to say they are 4 extremely talented individuals who produced ground breaking material and some really good songs but somehow collectively their "music" has an effect like a cheese grater to the cochlea. It is beyond awful.

I didn't rate the Clash when they were first around but got to like them later in life, musically limited but a great 'pub' band.

Gotta pull you up on the Stones though, their best work was done with Mick Taylor in the band.

Queen, bit of meh from me but their stadium rock doesn't really float my boat but their set at Live Aid was one of the best on the day.

 

Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 12.54pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 27 Apr 2015 12.35pm

Quote silvertop at 27 Apr 2015 11.42am

Quote Pikester at 25 Apr 2015 2.45pm

The Clash - I know this will anger many on here but I just never 'got' them.

Should I stay or should I go is ok - but Rock The Casbah is bloody awful.


Pikester I think I love you. Unfortunately, the last time I posted on here a few years ago to like effect, I was all but threatened with death.

It's a real shame. Mick Jones cannot sing or write a decent song. If he was excised from the band or just played his instrument and shut up, the Clash could have been one of the greats.

The others to the list:

Rolling Stones [after Brian Jones]
Who [save their early mod stuff]
Queen

On Queen, I have so much to say I could fill a thread such is my hatred of them and alarm at their ever-lasting popularity. Suffice to say they are 4 extremely talented individuals who produced ground breaking material and some really good songs but somehow collectively their "music" has an effect like a cheese grater to the cochlea. It is beyond awful.

Have to agree on Queen. Apart from the 70's rock stuff they became a camp pop band. All that 80's era with Radio Gaga and I want to Break free was not the stuff of legends. They were completely forgotten about over the States


Well that ticks all my boxes!

 




The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 15 1.08pm

Quote palace777 at 27 Apr 2015 11.52am

u2,u2,u2,u2 and u2

What about U2 ????

My hatred for Bono and his three little acolytes is off the scale

I am really pleased I am not the only Queen 'hater' either and totally agree....

4 really good musicians
Did some really truly ground-breaking music
Had possibly the greatest 'front man' of all time

But they have the effect of rubbing your cock with industrial grade wire wool on me


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 15 1.10pm

Quote silvertop at 27 Apr 2015 11.49am

Quote pefwin at 25 Apr 2015 7.48pm

1 Yes
2 Style Council
3 The Police
4 The Beatles
5 Status Quo

There are so many.

Edited by pefwin (25 Apr 2015 7.49pm)

Since when have they been rated? They started as the "poor mans Canned Heat" and progressed to stadium novelty act. We are talking bands who critics wet their knix over for no discernible reason... like the Clash

Its impossible to hate Status Quo - they don't even take themselves seriously...they are a pub band who got really lucky and they know it.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 1.15pm

Boomtown Rats anyone? Mainly because the u2 talk reminded me of massively self satisfied c*ck munchers I want to punch.

Who gives a f*ck that a rancid Irish scarecrow didn't like Mondays? He's still dining out on that rubbish band and all those patronising songs about Africans.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 15 1.20pm

Quote Part Time James at 27 Apr 2015 1.15pm

Boomtown Rats anyone? Mainly because the u2 talk reminded me of massively self satisfied c*ck munchers I want to punch.

Who gives a f*ck that a rancid Irish scarecrow didn't like Mondays? He's still dining out on that rubbish band and all those patronising songs about Africans.

I quite like the track, but the boomtown rats are frankly s**t. Also the Stranglers, like them, lucked into one good track before disappearing into their own bum holes.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 15 1.22pm

Quote Part Time James at 27 Apr 2015 1.15pm

Boomtown Rats anyone? Mainly because the u2 talk reminded me of massively self satisfied c*ck munchers I want to punch.

Who gives a f*ck that a rancid Irish scarecrow didn't like Mondays? He's still dining out on that rubbish band and all those patronising songs about Africans.

Hell yes - f*cking abysmal...


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 15 1.24pm

Quote The Sash at 27 Apr 2015 1.10pm

Quote silvertop at 27 Apr 2015 11.49am

Quote pefwin at 25 Apr 2015 7.48pm

1 Yes
2 Style Council
3 The Police
4 The Beatles
5 Status Quo

There are so many.

Edited by pefwin (25 Apr 2015 7.49pm)

Since when have they been rated? They started as the "poor mans Canned Heat" and progressed to stadium novelty act. We are talking bands who critics wet their knix over for no discernible reason... like the Clash

Its impossible to hate Status Quo - they don't even take themselves seriously...they are a pub band who got really lucky and they know it.

The Quo are alright, the only people who really rate them are their fans. I'm related to Alan Lancaster as it goes (he's my mums cousin). They're one of the few bands I ever met who are somewhat bemused by how much their own fans rate them.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 15 1.25pm

Iron Maiden must also rate as one of the most overated bands of the UK.

They're not s**t, by any stretch, but f**k me they're loved by people in IT on 'Non-Uniform' friday

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 1.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Apr 2015 1.20pm

Quote Part Time James at 27 Apr 2015 1.15pm

Boomtown Rats anyone? Mainly because the u2 talk reminded me of massively self satisfied c*ck munchers I want to punch.

Who gives a f*ck that a rancid Irish scarecrow didn't like Mondays? He's still dining out on that rubbish band and all those patronising songs about Africans.

I quite like the track, but the boomtown rats are frankly s**t. Also the Stranglers, like them, lucked into one good track before disappearing into their own bum holes.


Yeah, actually I don't mind it that much, but I'm only happy to accept it if Geldof goes on telly one day and says "I got lucky with a track and since then I've done nothing but release a load of sh*te, milk the plight of the starving, preach to everyone else about how to live their lives and fail to keep my own family in order".

THEN and only then would I go "Ya know what? I'm forking out 79p on iTunes for that tune they once did to help that poor old chap out".

 




Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 1.32pm

I was going to say Franz Ferdinand in my list but no one has rated them for quite some time so I left it.

Saw them live at Glastonbury while I waited for Goldfrapp and the Chemical Brothers. I can only think the lead singer couldn't hear his own voice. Or his testicles had got twisted putting his trousers on.

Does Fatboy Slim count as a band? Not really but I'm putting him in too. His live show involves an old bloke who can't put his headphones on properly pressing play on a CD player. On that basis my dad's act is roughly the same. People say "yeah, well, the tunes he's released" but if you look at, for example, Right Here Right Now, there's virtually no part of that that he made himself. It's 3 or 4 samples put on top of each other. Well done you bald old Brighton supporting bell end.

Edited by Part Time James (27 Apr 2015 1.33pm)

 




radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 27 Apr 15 1.41pm

UB40 or anything to do with them
Status Quo
Mumford And Sons
Elbow
Black Sabbath

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 15 1.46pm

Quote Part Time James at 27 Apr 2015 1.32pm

I was going to say Franz Ferdinand in my list but no one has rated them for quite some time so I left it.

Saw them live at Glastonbury while I waited for Goldfrapp and the Chemical Brothers. I can only think the lead singer couldn't hear his own voice. Or his testicles had got twisted putting his trousers on.

Does Fatboy Slim count as a band? Not really but I'm putting him in too. His live show involves an old bloke who can't put his headphones on properly pressing play on a CD player. On that basis my dad's act is roughly the same. People say "yeah, well, the tunes he's released" but if you look at, for example, Right Here Right Now, there's virtually no part of that that he made himself. It's 3 or 4 samples put on top of each other. Well done you bald old Brighton supporting bell end.

Edited by Part Time James (27 Apr 2015 1.33pm)

Indeed, Fat Boy Slim seems to have made a superstar status out of sampling a few tracks and quotes, and banging Johnny Balls daughter.

Infact looking at his history, largely it involves just sampling someone elses work and putting some lyrics over the top (Dub be Good to me is just 'Guns of Brixton with different words and a fit bird).

But his tracks as fatboy slim are really so similar as to be actually plaugurising his own back catalogue. And he's s**t live as a DJ.

Plus I know two people who've banged Zoe Ball, at university, and apparently its not a) that difficult b) that good. Just like his dire output as F**k Me S**T


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Apr 15 1.47pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Apr 2015 1.25pm

Iron Maiden must also rate as one of the most overated bands of the UK.

They're not s**t, by any stretch, but f**k me they're loved by people in IT on 'Non-Uniform' friday


Ah, dear old heavy metal.

Iron Maiden fall into the same category as do ACDC and [believe it or not] Saxon. Enjoyed ironically by non-rural Britain, but in parts of the Continent, the US and Japan!

A mate was at a party hosted by the girlfriend of the [then] guitarist of Saxon. In the UK, he walks about in blessed [and deserved] anonymity. In Germany, each band member are assigned a team of close protection security guards!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 27 Apr 15 2.07pm

Off the top of my head

Oasis (not to be confused with the Bootleg Beatles)
Radiohead
Sex Pistols
Fleetwood Mac
Pulp

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 2.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Apr 2015 1.46pm

Quote Part Time James at 27 Apr 2015 1.32pm

I was going to say Franz Ferdinand in my list but no one has rated them for quite some time so I left it.

Saw them live at Glastonbury while I waited for Goldfrapp and the Chemical Brothers. I can only think the lead singer couldn't hear his own voice. Or his testicles had got twisted putting his trousers on.

Does Fatboy Slim count as a band? Not really but I'm putting him in too. His live show involves an old bloke who can't put his headphones on properly pressing play on a CD player. On that basis my dad's act is roughly the same. People say "yeah, well, the tunes he's released" but if you look at, for example, Right Here Right Now, there's virtually no part of that that he made himself. It's 3 or 4 samples put on top of each other. Well done you bald old Brighton supporting bell end.

Edited by Part Time James (27 Apr 2015 1.33pm)

Indeed, Fat Boy Slim seems to have made a superstar status out of sampling a few tracks and quotes, and banging Johnny Balls daughter.

Infact looking at his history, largely it involves just sampling someone elses work and putting some lyrics over the top (Dub be Good to me is just 'Guns of Brixton with different words and a fit bird).

But his tracks as fatboy slim are really so similar as to be actually plaugurising his own back catalogue. And he's s**t live as a DJ.

Plus I know two people who've banged Zoe Ball, at university, and apparently its not a) that difficult b) that good. Just like his dire output as F**k Me S**T


And yet, I probably still would. Actually, of course I would. And I'd repeat the phrase Right Here Right Now the entire time in a monotone.

 




Part Time James Flag 27 Apr 15 2.09pm

Quote radsyrendot at 27 Apr 2015 1.41pm

UB40 or anything to do with them
Status Quo
Mumford And Sons
Elbow
Black Sabbath


As soon as I realised that within the first two lines of War Pigs they rhymed "Masses" with "Masses" I went right off Black Sabbath. It's like the Doors rhyming "Fire" with "Fire" except they aren't British so I can't slate them here.

 




nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 27 Apr 15 2.11pm

Quote radsyrendot at 27 Apr 2015 1.41pm

UB40 or anything to do with them
Status Quo
Mumford And Sons
Elbow
Black Sabbath


Agree with this, with a caveat. Signing Off by UB40 is one of the greatest albums ever. Beyond that a downward slope of s***e

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 27 Apr 15 2.19pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 27 Apr 2015 2.07pm

Off the top of my head

Oasis (not to be confused with the Bootleg Beatles)
Radiohead
Sex Pistols
Fleetwood Mac
Pulp


I think the Mac are fab

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 5 most overrated british bands.