This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 11.36am
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 11.26am
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 11.23am
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 10.40am
Quote SamCPFC17 at 28 May 2015 9.36am
I think you'll find the failures in Venezuela had a great deal more to do with government incompetence (a problem in practically all 3rd world countries) than socialist policies. Across the vast majority of the rest of Latin America, left-wing governments during the 2000s and 2010s have made many incredible achievements - Why do you think that throughout history people have tried to flee from extreme left wing states and sought refuge in democratic Capitalist states.
To claim all attempts at Socialism have failed is as ludicrous as saying that all attempts at Capitalism have failed - it's a simplistic analysis which no historian worth their salt could get away with. The major difference between the two ideology's retrospective successes is that throughout the 20th century, every single attempt at Socialist economic or social change has been challenged, and often actively stamped out by the dominant imperial power of the century, America. That's what we are seeing currently taking hold in Venezuela - covert operations by the American secret service to overthrow a nation who won't dance to their tune. I could write a long analysis of what's going on in Venezuela, but it's probably better to leave it to a Venezuelan to do so: [Link] That's not to say that Socialist states would be flourishing without American interference. Cuba is incredibly homophobic, Uruguay is a very racist country, Russia's centralised authoritarianism was brutal. But then have a look at some of the wonderful examples of Capitalism in action: American incarceration of blacks, Russian homophobia, Pinochet in Chile. lol. Can you give us a list of successful Socialist countries then?
Although given that I can tell you won't be satisfied until I provide examples of 'successful' Socialism, how about the Kurds in northern Syria fighting IS with half of their front line being female? Spanish communes are flourishing, and even in South America Socialist states have dealt comparatively well with poverty, malnutrition and disease. Now in response, can you give me a list of successful Capitalist countries?
Which is basically the definition of Socialism.
'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 28 May 2015 4.59pm
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 1.24pm
Quote dannyh at 28 May 2015 1.13pm
let me see if I've got this socialism right? Someone works like a demon all thier days and ends up with the same lot in life, as some workshy unwashed bin dipper. I think Capitalism seems a bit fairer.
Edited by serial thriller (28 May 2015 1.34pm) At some point someone called Wal-Mart worked his pips off to provide for his family and by hard work and luck he made a fortune, how the family administer that fortune is not for you to decide (or to distribute among your comrades). Much like Richard Branson, started off with one sh1t heap of a record shop, and through hard work, business savy, and persistence now has an empire, why should he just give at away to Jeremy Kyle types who make the three toes sloth look as productive as hive of bumble bee's. Last question, why is it always middleclass types who abhor the wealthy, is it because they really think they deserve to be as rich as Branson, or Lord Sainsbury, even though the only noteworthy they ever did was drive a bus for ten years ? Capitalism isn't perfect, but it sure is better than anything else out their.
I think the problem is that people tend to think in a either / or situation in regards to socialism or capitalism, and disregard the fact that what currently works for us is a balance of the two. Socialism functions better as a critical assessment of the fundamental flaws and inequalities within capitalism, and has served as the process by which systems of capital have been tempered and restrained within history. I doubt few of us would regard American Capitalism as being a particularly successful model for the provision of its general population, any more than we'd regard Soviet planned economies as serving the general population particularly well; both being extremes which serve a minority. Capitalism as we experience it, as a western liberal, European democracy, owes a lot of its survival to its capacity to absorb social movements, most notably those of the left. For the record, Richard Branson's background is quite privileged - He'd have been out of business in 1972 if his mother hadn't bailed him out. His initial brand succeed on the back of a tax fraud involving selling records branded for export, internally (a scam he'd picked up from his mail order company). Whilst he repaid the tax and fine (or rather his mother did) it allowed him to establish the brand and chain of record stores. As for Wal-Mart, well that was founded on 5k saved during the army (he was an officer stationed stateside) and 20k lent to him by his father in law. His father previously worked through the great depression repossessing farms for his brothers company. His education came via ROTC, but he only joined the military as a result of WWII, on graduation he went to work for JC Penny. Ironically the success of Wal-Mart ultimately lies with the Landlord of his first Store being greedy and forcing him to sell up, as this pushed Sam into expansion to a new store that really took off. Probably a bit more self made than Branson, but neither really are quite the myth of the self made man pulling himself up from the gutter that people like to imagine. Both deserve some admiration, they took what they had and made a lot more from it, but its not like they didn't actually get a lot of help from privillage and family that most people wouldn't have.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 29 May 2015 3.50pm
Quote ghosteagle at 29 May 2015 2.50pm
Quote dannyh at 28 May 2015 4.59pm
Quote serial thriller at 28 May 2015 1.24pm
Quote dannyh at 28 May 2015 1.13pm
let me see if I've got this socialism right? Someone works like a demon all thier days and ends up with the same lot in life, as some workshy unwashed bin dipper. I think Capitalism seems a bit fairer.
Edited by serial thriller (28 May 2015 1.34pm) At some point someone called Wal-Mart worked his pips off to provide for his family and by hard work and luck he made a fortune, how the family administer that fortune is not for you to decide (or to distribute among your comrades). Much like Richard Branson, started off with one sh1t heap of a record shop, and through hard work, business savy, and persistence now has an empire, why should he just give at away to Jeremy Kyle types who make the three toes sloth look as productive as hive of bumble bee's. Last question, why is it always middleclass types who abhor the wealthy, is it because they really think they deserve to be as rich as Branson, or Lord Sainsbury, even though the only noteworthy they ever did was drive a bus for ten years ? Capitalism isn't perfect, but it sure is better than anything else out their.
Please enlighten me with stories of socialist utopias the world over.....wait a minute, you can’t , there aren't any. There aren't really any capitalist Utopias either of course, utopias are a fictional myth, their impossible to achieve, without establishing a post-scarcity economy, they'd require a technological breakthrough that rendered resources valueless (a technology such a nanotechnology or other atomic scale manipulation). The failure of socialism has always been the idea of remaking the world and forcing the revolution, rather than seeing socialism as an end result of capitalism.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 8.25am
This is how it would be here if TUSC or similar 'progressives' were in power.
|
|
|
Quote derben at 28 May 2015 8.25am
This is how it would be here if TUSC or similar 'progressives' were in power.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.