This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote -TUX- at 02 Oct 2015 7.09pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 02 Oct 2015 9.11am
...and in the hands of teenagers, whose judgment in emotional situations is legendary. There's not really much to debate. The answer is probably enforced birth control for all members of the NRA family. Then they can get rid of guns in a generation or so.
Harder than you think, given the webbing and additional digits.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 02 Oct 2015 5.00pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 02 Oct 2015 4.37pm
Quote Stuk at 02 Oct 2015 4.32pm
Of course you can. Or would you prefer we had a military without weapons at all? Being consistently naive about what having Trident achieves, or prevents, isn't a good show of intellect. No to the first question. That is because an armed military serves many purposes other than deterrence, where some form of weaponry may be required. Trident, however, serves no purpose whatsoever other than deterrence (and enriching the pockets of defense contractors.) Since neither of those ends is, to me, worthwhile, I find it easy to justify being against it without feeling naive. There is nothing naive about arguing the position that violence is not a functional response to violence.
It's not a response to violence, it's a deterrent. Anyway comparing private and largely unregulated gun ownership to military, and heavily regulated, weapons is irrelevant. How many nukes have been fired by accident or used by rogue groups? Would that be none? Unlike the weekly problems of private ownership. These days its very hard to maintain and active a nuclear weapon (unlike those of the past), except it seems on TV where. In truth, the military are very very careful and have a lot of contingencies and redundancies in place to make it as close to an impossibility as possible to 'fire a nuclear missile'. The US and Russia managed to lose several nuclear weapons over the years. That's about as close as its come (and those lost were mostly between the 60s-80s; the lack of maintenance means their warheads almost certainly wouldn't fire now).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote The Sash at 05 Oct 2015 12.48pm
John Oliver had a very pithy sound bite regards gun control which I kinda liked. To paraphrase 'One failed shoe bomber tries to board a plane and everyone now has to take their shoes off at the airport before boarding, 31 school shootings in that time and absolutely no change in gun law'..... So very true. If someone from IS shot and killed 8 or 9 American kids the same people who oppose gun control would be demanding a war. When an American kid does it, they don't even demand better mental health services.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
An 11 year old boy has shot and killed an 8 year old girl in Tennessee.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote nairb75 at 05 Oct 2015 4.14pm
here's the argument: what does right to bear arms mean? many here believe there are no limits to the definition of "arms." so can i have a tank? a nuke? walk around with a bazooka? why not? so if there then IS a limit, that is the discussion that must take place. assault weapons? this country is nuts in regards to guns. we have a sitting senator make a video where he cooks bacon on the tip of his automatic gun. these people are crazy. it won't change. we had sandy hook where a bunch of kindergarteners were killed. were they to defend themselves with guns? in essence, the right's argument is that we should live in an uncivilized society where you are on your own at all times. "well granny, if you would've been packing heat, that b****** wouldn't have stole your pocket book. too effing bad." Thing is, owning a gun, actually increases your chances of being a victim of a firearm related homicide, rather than reduces it. Very dramatically when you consider half of US gun deaths are suicides.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote nairb75 at 06 Oct 2015 2.35pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Oct 2015 2.20pm
Quote nairb75 at 05 Oct 2015 4.14pm
here's the argument: what does right to bear arms mean? many here believe there are no limits to the definition of "arms." so can i have a tank? a nuke? walk around with a bazooka? why not? so if there then IS a limit, that is the discussion that must take place. assault weapons? this country is nuts in regards to guns. we have a sitting senator make a video where he cooks bacon on the tip of his automatic gun. these people are crazy. it won't change. we had sandy hook where a bunch of kindergarteners were killed. were they to defend themselves with guns? in essence, the right's argument is that we should live in an uncivilized society where you are on your own at all times. "well granny, if you would've been packing heat, that b****** wouldn't have stole your pocket book. too effing bad." Thing is, owning a gun, actually increases your chances of being a victim of a firearm related homicide, rather than reduces it. Very dramatically when you consider half of US gun deaths are suicides.
In fairness to Americans, I would like to point out that if I was American, I'd have s**t loads of guns, but I don't think that's a ringing endorsement of the law either. Its mad that you can have an assault rifle, but go to prison for having LSD
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 02 Oct 2015 5.18pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 02 Oct 2015 5.10pm
Quote Stuk at 02 Oct 2015 5.00pm
It's not a response to violence, it's a deterrent. Anyway comparing private and largely unregulated gun ownership to military, and heavily regulated, weapons is irrelevant. How many nukes have been fired by accident or used by rogue groups? Would that be none? Unlike the weekly problems of private ownership. Trident is a response to violence, assuming we would only use it as a retaliatory measure. Deterrence is not using it at all. If we used it first, it would be violence that invited violence. Smart, that. In none of the three cases is it justified (in my opinion.) Yes, I agree that comparing military and private gun ownership is irrelevant. However, you drew the parallel, not me. I was merely responding to your post. We aren't using it at all, so it's a deterrent as I said. The threat of us using it in response is enough to make it that. I certainly did not make the comparison. You did 3 post ago. If there's been no rogue or accidental nukings, there's no irony in people on here, who back us having Trident, showing dismay at private gun ownership in the USA. Guns aren't a deterrent, clearly as displayed by the huge gun ownership in the US and the massive level of gun deaths. Trident worked in the cold war because it guaranteed Mutually Assured Destruction. Where as owning a gun in a situation where the other guy has a gun, only slightly improves your chances, because a) its unlikely you'll have your gun b) gun only works as a deterrent if the other guy knows you have it c) if you do have it, and the other guy knows you have it, he's still more likely to have the advantage. Where as having a nuclear weapons platform, that even if your enemy launches a strike that turns the whole of the UK into a smoking radioactive graveyard, devoid of life, is a deterrent - And Trident in a cold war scenario was a very effective deterrent (it was useless as an offensive platform mind).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Great Northern Loony at 06 Oct 2015 4.11pm
Quote oldcodger at 06 Oct 2015 3.27pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Oct 2015 3.19pm
Quote nairb75 at 06 Oct 2015 2.35pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Oct 2015 2.20pm
Quote nairb75 at 05 Oct 2015 4.14pm
here's the argument: what does right to bear arms mean? many here believe there are no limits to the definition of "arms." so can i have a tank? a nuke? walk around with a bazooka? why not? so if there then IS a limit, that is the discussion that must take place. assault weapons? this country is nuts in regards to guns. we have a sitting senator make a video where he cooks bacon on the tip of his automatic gun. these people are crazy. it won't change. we had sandy hook where a bunch of kindergarteners were killed. were they to defend themselves with guns? in essence, the right's argument is that we should live in an uncivilized society where you are on your own at all times. "well granny, if you would've been packing heat, that b****** wouldn't have stole your pocket book. too effing bad." Thing is, owning a gun, actually increases your chances of being a victim of a firearm related homicide, rather than reduces it. Very dramatically when you consider half of US gun deaths are suicides.
In fairness to Americans, I would like to point out that if I was American, I'd have s**t loads of guns, but I don't think that's a ringing endorsement of the law either.
Unfortunately, there is no clause nor amendment in the US Constitution that prevents the government from regulating what Americans can put in their bodies, so there you go. In fact, there used to be an amendment (the 18th one) that did specifically the OPPOSITE: it tried to tell Americans that they weren't allowed to put booze in their bodies. For some reason, that one didn't work out. The troublesome 2nd Amendment to the US Constitution currently prevents much being done about the firearms epidemic, at least as how it's being read by the courts these days. It used to be interpreted more sensibly a generation or so ago, but the US Supreme Court has gone a lot more reactionary (and outright pro-gun) since then. And, to be frank, there are a lot of Americans -- not necessarily most, but a lot -- who's opinion on gun ownership has completely fossilized to 19th century standards. I know this for a fact, because I see these people ranting on my Facebook feed practically every day. Good luck trying to deal with that lot reasonably. I just read a comment from one of them linking to a paper asserting that the '97 handgun ban was instrumental in turning the UK into the police state hellhole that you're all living under today. How about the right to the pursuit of happiness, and freedom of expression. One of those isn't an amendment.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.