You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Donald Trump
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Donald Trump


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
leifandersonshair Flag Newport 10 Dec 15 12.17pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 11.26am


Trumps statements are as useful as saying 'some men are rapists, therefore all men should be treated as rapists'.


I don't agree Jamie.

I accept that not all Muslims want to maim or kill us, that's a given... BUT... the threat to all of us comes as a result of belief in Islam and the Khoran directing the killing of Kafirs (non believers) which certain members of the Muslim community have decided to take at face value and put it into practice.

What Rump is suggesting is very much like putting everyone on the sex offenders list that views child p***.graphy - they might go on to be paedophiles, so keep an eye on them for safety's sake.

If Muslims were to denounce the Khoran's teachings and publicly announce that it is wrong to call for the killing of non-believers then we can allow them free passage to travel where and when they want. Until then we should view them all with suspicion and be on our guard... after all we don't know the ones that might be fundamentalists as against the benign/tolerant followers of Islam.

It's just an extension of airport security... we've tightened up massively after the shoe bombers etc why not raise security another level and maybe ask more questions at boarding to prevent another bloody massacre or bombing of a plane? It might flush out those intent on destruction?

I hate all religion, but right now Islam appears to be a dangerous barbaric ideology about 500 years behind modern times in it's thinking and preaching and treatment of women.

Quite right. And anyone who has ever had or might have a mental illness too. After all, can never tell when one of them might flip their lid and attack someone.

Maybe everyone who supports a football team ought to be on a watch list too- including all of us. After all, there is trouble at football grounds occasionally, so all football fans should be regarded as enemies of the state- can't tell which ones are the peaceful majority and which the potential hooligans after all!

I don't much like religion myself, but yours is frankly one of the most extremely deluded arguments I have ever seen. Seriously. Demonising a minority always works out well, doesn't it?


 

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 12.18pm

Quote leifandersonshair at 10 Dec 2015 12.17pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 11.26am


Trumps statements are as useful as saying 'some men are rapists, therefore all men should be treated as rapists'.


I don't agree Jamie.

I accept that not all Muslims want to maim or kill us, that's a given... BUT... the threat to all of us comes as a result of belief in Islam and the Khoran directing the killing of Kafirs (non believers) which certain members of the Muslim community have decided to take at face value and put it into practice.

What Rump is suggesting is very much like putting everyone on the sex offenders list that views child p***.graphy - they might go on to be paedophiles, so keep an eye on them for safety's sake.

If Muslims were to denounce the Khoran's teachings and publicly announce that it is wrong to call for the killing of non-believers then we can allow them free passage to travel where and when they want. Until then we should view them all with suspicion and be on our guard... after all we don't know the ones that might be fundamentalists as against the benign/tolerant followers of Islam.

It's just an extension of airport security... we've tightened up massively after the shoe bombers etc why not raise security another level and maybe ask more questions at boarding to prevent another bloody massacre or bombing of a plane? It might flush out those intent on destruction?

I hate all religion, but right now Islam appears to be a dangerous barbaric ideology about 500 years behind modern times in it's thinking and preaching and treatment of women.

Quite right. And anyone who has ever had or might have a mental illness too. After all, can never tell when one of them might flip their lid and attack someone.

Maybe everyone who supports a football team ought to be on a watch list too- including all of us. After all, there is trouble at football grounds occasionally, so all football fans should be regarded as enemies of the state- can't tell which ones are the peaceful majority and which the potential hooligans after all!

I don't much like religion myself, but yours is frankly one of the most extremely deluded arguments I have ever seen. Seriously. Demonising a minority always works out well, doesn't it?



Sadly it is NOt a minority Mr Sarcasm.

And for the record.. no one is demonising Muslims... but using your analogy above letting patients with mental illness roam around London has led to many deaths where people have been pushed under a train on the Underground by those that otherwise could have been detained in a secure hospital.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (10 Dec 2015 12.35pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 12.40pm

Those people that disagree with Trump.... tell us your plans to avoid further bloodshed rather than sarky responses and abusive quips.

Seriously... I'd love to know how you're going to ensure our safety!

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 10 Dec 15 12.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.18pm

Quote leifandersonshair at 10 Dec 2015 12.17pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 11.26am


Trumps statements are as useful as saying 'some men are rapists, therefore all men should be treated as rapists'.


I don't agree Jamie.

I accept that not all Muslims want to maim or kill us, that's a given... BUT... the threat to all of us comes as a result of belief in Islam and the Khoran directing the killing of Kafirs (non believers) which certain members of the Muslim community have decided to take at face value and put it into practice.

What Rump is suggesting is very much like putting everyone on the sex offenders list that views child p***.graphy - they might go on to be paedophiles, so keep an eye on them for safety's sake.

If Muslims were to denounce the Khoran's teachings and publicly announce that it is wrong to call for the killing of non-believers then we can allow them free passage to travel where and when they want. Until then we should view them all with suspicion and be on our guard... after all we don't know the ones that might be fundamentalists as against the benign/tolerant followers of Islam.

It's just an extension of airport security... we've tightened up massively after the shoe bombers etc why not raise security another level and maybe ask more questions at boarding to prevent another bloody massacre or bombing of a plane? It might flush out those intent on destruction?

I hate all religion, but right now Islam appears to be a dangerous barbaric ideology about 500 years behind modern times in it's thinking and preaching and treatment of women.

Quite right. And anyone who has ever had or might have a mental illness too. After all, can never tell when one of them might flip their lid and attack someone.

Maybe everyone who supports a football team ought to be on a watch list too- including all of us. After all, there is trouble at football grounds occasionally, so all football fans should be regarded as enemies of the state- can't tell which ones are the peaceful majority and which the potential hooligans after all!

I don't much like religion myself, but yours is frankly one of the most extremely deluded arguments I have ever seen. Seriously. Demonising a minority always works out well, doesn't it?



Sadly it is NOt a minority Mr Sarcasm.

And for the record.. no one is demonising Muslims... but using your analogy above letting patients with mental illness roam around London has led to many deaths where people have been pushed under a train on the Underground by those that otherwise could have been detained in a secure hospital.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (10 Dec 2015 12.35pm)

Percentage of the UK population that are Muslim according to 2011 UK Census- 4.8%. Seems like a minority to me. Or do you mean that the number of violent/radical vs tolerant/non violent Muslims is not a minority?

Happy to open up a new topic on mental health and the system if you'd like (I suspect we both agree that there are issues with it). My own fault for bringing it up, I suppose!

Your post suggests that all Muslims should be viewed with suspicion, and that we should be on our guard- does that not strike you as demonizing a whole group?

 

paperhat Flag croydon 10 Dec 15 12.45pm

Hoof, do you KNOW the Koran? the passages that refer to killing non believers are utterly minimal, probably equalled by 'our' very own Bible.

just because some loon has chosen to take that passage and brainwash easilly led fools into thinking its a message from god doesnt A) make the koran and bad thing or B) make all muslims 'a risk'

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 12.49pm

Quote leifandersonshair at 10 Dec 2015 12.42pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.18pm

Quote leifandersonshair at 10 Dec 2015 12.17pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 11.26am


Trumps statements are as useful as saying 'some men are rapists, therefore all men should be treated as rapists'.


I don't agree Jamie.

I accept that not all Muslims want to maim or kill us, that's a given... BUT... the threat to all of us comes as a result of belief in Islam and the Khoran directing the killing of Kafirs (non believers) which certain members of the Muslim community have decided to take at face value and put it into practice.

What Rump is suggesting is very much like putting everyone on the sex offenders list that views child p***.graphy - they might go on to be paedophiles, so keep an eye on them for safety's sake.

If Muslims were to denounce the Khoran's teachings and publicly announce that it is wrong to call for the killing of non-believers then we can allow them free passage to travel where and when they want. Until then we should view them all with suspicion and be on our guard... after all we don't know the ones that might be fundamentalists as against the benign/tolerant followers of Islam.

It's just an extension of airport security... we've tightened up massively after the shoe bombers etc why not raise security another level and maybe ask more questions at boarding to prevent another bloody massacre or bombing of a plane? It might flush out those intent on destruction?

I hate all religion, but right now Islam appears to be a dangerous barbaric ideology about 500 years behind modern times in it's thinking and preaching and treatment of women.

Quite right. And anyone who has ever had or might have a mental illness too. After all, can never tell when one of them might flip their lid and attack someone.

Maybe everyone who supports a football team ought to be on a watch list too- including all of us. After all, there is trouble at football grounds occasionally, so all football fans should be regarded as enemies of the state- can't tell which ones are the peaceful majority and which the potential hooligans after all!

I don't much like religion myself, but yours is frankly one of the most extremely deluded arguments I have ever seen. Seriously. Demonising a minority always works out well, doesn't it?



Sadly it is NOt a minority Mr Sarcasm.

And for the record.. no one is demonising Muslims... but using your analogy above letting patients with mental illness roam around London has led to many deaths where people have been pushed under a train on the Underground by those that otherwise could have been detained in a secure hospital.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (10 Dec 2015 12.35pm)

Percentage of the UK population that are Muslim according to 2011 UK Census- 4.8%. Seems like a minority to me. Or do you mean that the number of violent/radical vs tolerant/non violent Muslims is not a minority?

Happy to open up a new topic on mental health and the system if you'd like (I suspect we both agree that there are issues with it). My own fault for bringing it up, I suppose!

Your post suggests that all Muslims should be viewed with suspicion, and that we should be on our guard- does that not strike you as demonizing a whole group?


I was talking globally as was Trump, so Muslims are not a minority group in that sense... haven't looked it up but both Islam and Christianity probably are the two largest groups.

Viewing anyone with suspicion is not demonisation.

If you know a terrorist is more likely to come from a particular group you are on your guard when dealing with people from that group.

You like analogies... my dog doesn't like other dogs so when I'm out walking him I shorten his lead when another dog approaches, so I can control his actions. Basic commonsense?

 

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 12.56pm

Quote paperhat at 10 Dec 2015 12.45pm

Hoof, do you KNOW the Koran? the passages that refer to killing non believers are utterly minimal, probably equalled by 'our' very own Bible.

just because some loon has chosen to take that passage and brainwash easilly led fools into thinking its a message from god doesnt A) make the koran and bad thing or B) make all muslims 'a risk'


Maybe it doesn't worry you, but it alarms me even if just one "easily led fool" believes it to be true.

As I said earlier I hate and despise all religion, so quoting the Bible is no defence or excuse either - they all try to brainwash their followers.

As I also said earlier Islam is about 500 years behind the rest of society with it's ideology and treatment of women, gay people and non believers.

Tolerance is unknown to them.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Dec 15 12.57pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.40pm

Those people that disagree with Trump.... tell us your plans to avoid further bloodshed rather than sarky responses and abusive quips.

Seriously... I'd love to know how you're going to ensure our safety!

Anyone who claims they can assure safety is lying. Its impossible to achieve and its an absurd form of rhetoric to assume that 'demonising all Muslims' will in anyway serve to make a country safer. How do you actually prove someone is a Muslim, and say not a Christian?

The 9/11 Attackers specifically went out drinking and hung out in strip clubs to deflect attention. Its important to remember that martyrdom ensures entry into paradise, irrespective of your sins. I don't think it would be a stretch to say terrorists would be honest about their religion when conducting 'martyrdom operations'.

All it would mean is a increasing lack of Muslim intelligence operatives on the ground for say the CIA and reduced language experts for the NSA to exploit, essentially reducing the capacity for Intelligence agencies - Which would reduce the safety of the US.

Its vital for counter-terrorism to be able to utilise and protect assets of value. Alienating as many Muslims as possible to target militant groups and their allies is absurdly short sighted.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 12.58pm

Time for lunch....

Don't forget to post up your bright ideas to solve this problem rather than getting on Trump's case or mine.

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 10 Dec 15 1.08pm

There are plenty of passages in the Quran that condone violence against believers and non believer's alike. All this talk of Islam being a religion of peace is of course bollocks & for people to insist otherwise are trying to cover some pretty sizeable cracks, it also doesnt help anyone.

What is wrong with calling a spade a spade? Islam is a violent & aggressive religion, the text is there in the book.

There isnt some kind of Quran 2 for ISIS, Boko Haram etc they read the same Quran as everyone else, they read the damn thing day & night over & over again & I would absolutely guarantee they know the text alot better than anyone claiming you aint no muslim bruv.

Hundreds of thousands if not millions of muslims (many being highly educated doctors, engineers, mechanics etc) support the creation of the caliphate, that makes them just as complicit as those who commit the murders.

I do actually have some sympathy for Trump, there was no outrage when Iranians were banned in the US & its not really any different to Eastern euro countries saying they will only take Christian refugees.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 10 Dec 15 1.11pm

I'm sure most christians don't actually act out the below orders, but we'd best ban them from the UK. Just in case.


Deuteronomy 17
If there be found among you, within any of thy gates which the LORD thy God giveth thee, man or woman, that hath wrought wickedness in the sight of the LORD thy God, in transgressing his covenant; 17:3 And hath gone and served other gods, and worshipped them, either the sun, or moon, or any of the host of heaven, which I have not commanded; 17:4 And it be told thee, and thou hast heard of it, and enquired diligently, and, behold, it be true, and the thing certain, that such abomination is wrought in Israel; 17:5 Then shalt thou bring forth that man or that woman, which have committed that wicked thing, unto thy gates, even that man or that woman, and shalt stone them with stones, till they die.

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Dec 15 1.15pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 11.26am


Trumps statements are as useful as saying 'some men are rapists, therefore all men should be treated as rapists'.


I don't agree Jamie.

I accept that not all Muslims want to maim or kill us, that's a given... BUT... the threat to all of us comes as a result of belief in Islam and the Khoran directing the killing of Kafirs (non believers) which certain members of the Muslim community have decided to take at face value and put it into practice.

What Trump is suggesting is very much like putting everyone on the sex offenders list that views child p*rnography - they might go on to be paedophiles, so keep an eye on them for safety's sake.

If Muslims were to denounce the Khoran's teachings and publicly announce that it is wrong to call for the killing of non-believers then we can allow them free passage to travel where and when they want. Until then we should view them all with suspicion and be on our guard... after all we don't know the ones that might be fundamentalists as against the benign/tolerant followers of Islam.

It's just an extension of airport security... we've tightened up massively after the shoe bombers etc why not raise security another level and maybe ask more questions at boarding to prevent another bloody massacre or bombing of a plane? It might flush out those intent on destruction?

I hate all religion, but right now Islam appears to be a dangerous barbaric ideology about 500 years behind modern times in it's thinking and preaching and treatment of women.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (10 Dec 2015 12.16pm)

Problem is it depends what you mean by Islam. Realistically, your talking about a specific subset of Sunni Islam and some Shia Islam. Effectively the problem is geo-political and largely fundermentalist related.

I think a certain degree of pragmatism is required, same and even some degree of profiling could be justified, but it would be erroneous to assume that all Islam is the same, or even remotely similar (there is a reason why a lot of UK Muslims moved to the UK, for many it was to avoid fundamentalist and oppressive regimes).

For the most part, successful counter-terrorism is driven by intelligence, rather than security measures. 'Upping Security' at airports rarely prevents bombings, infiltration and survelliance of suspects does a far better job - and that would require not trying to alienate a) the Muslim community in the UK and more importantly intelligence obtained abroad in Muslim countries.

Its important as well to remember that the mainstay of those fighting against groups like IS, are also Muslims (in Syria and Iraq), along with those being killed.

The problem is we're seeing a problem by the stereotype of die hard fanatics hell bent on the destruction of the west. They aren't, not really, the focus of Al-Qaeda was always Saudi Arabia, the US became a target because of its support of Saudi Arabia and political ties, not because they 'hate our freedom'.

The question of IS is a problem, but responses need to be proportional to the threat, and not actually retard our capacity to reduce the threat or more dangerously feed into fueling that threat.

Internment and Bloody Sunday did more for the Provisional IRA than the Provo's could ever have hoped for, because it alienated the Catholic community and republicans, and that anger increasingly found an outlet only available through the Provosional IRA.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Dec 15 1.17pm

The worrying thing for Americans really should be that Trump is directly targeting the American Constitution which allows for Freedom of Religion. In order to implement most of what he spouts, it would essentially require the suspension of the US constitution.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Dec 15 1.27pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 10 Dec 2015 1.08pm

There are plenty of passages in the Quran that condone violence against believers and non believer's alike. All this talk of Islam being a religion of peace is of course bollocks & for people to insist otherwise are trying to cover some pretty sizeable cracks, it also doesnt help anyone.

What is wrong with calling a spade a spade? Islam is a violent & aggressive religion, the text is there in the book.

There isnt some kind of Quran 2 for ISIS, Boko Haram etc they read the same Quran as everyone else, they read the damn thing day & night over & over again & I would absolutely guarantee they know the text alot better than anyone claiming you aint no muslim bruv.

Hundreds of thousands if not millions of muslims (many being highly educated doctors, engineers, mechanics etc) support the creation of the caliphate, that makes them just as complicit as those who commit the murders.

I do actually have some sympathy for Trump, there was no outrage when Iranians were banned in the US & its not really any different to Eastern euro countries saying they will only take Christian refugees.

Its the problem of religion and fundamentalism especially, because it promotes the rejection of context, a phase becomes truth and the only truth, by its existence, and the extrapolation of that truth is placed in the authority of individuals, who's agendas are not spiritual.

Its like Christian Fundamentalists attacking abortion clinics, there isn't really any way you could read the bible and think, you know what, that's would Jesus wants. They just pick and emphasis what fits their agenda, and ignore the rest.

Groups like IS and Boko Harem are just the extreme manifestation of this kind of political machination of Religion (similar to that of Iran).

Like anything, religion can be a tool for peace or violence, dependent on the person 'reading the book'. The reality of such groups is that their intentions aren't really driven by religion or spirituality, but are about power, status and control.

The IS Caliphate is not about Islam, its about creating a 'country over which IS has dominance' same ultimately as that of the Iranian Revolution - Neither fosters the theological spiritual development of individual muslims, but the control of those people for the benefit of a few.

Which certainly isn't what Mohammed was preaching.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 10 Dec 15 1.57pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 12.40pm

Those people that disagree with Trump.... tell us your plans to avoid further bloodshed rather than sarky responses and abusive quips.

Seriously... I'd love to know how you're going to ensure our safety!


I'll have a go.

Stop using IS as a convenient enemy to have and stop using their "terror threat" as a great excuse for domestic repression, surveillance, control and of course military spending. Stop arming them and their proxies, stop doing everything in the state's power to give into whatever the Arabian and Gulf elites want.

Go after their "state", wipe them from the map with a proper conventional war. It really would be quite a straightforward task - mass leaflet drops warning civvies to get the hell out in plenty of time is also easy to do.

I work in Central London, which of course is a prize target for reprisals. A short term risk of increased attacks versus a much reduced threat over the long term sounds good to me.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 10 Dec 15 2.07pm

Number of Americans killed by Islamist terrorists since 2001: 3,380

Number of Americans killed by legal guns since 2001: 406,496

Source: [Link]

So why is Chump's focus on banning Muslims and not banning legally held guns I wonder, bearing in mind which is the greater threat to American lives?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Dec 15 4.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 10 Dec 2015 1.08pm

There are plenty of passages in the Quran that condone violence against believers and non believer's alike. All this talk of Islam being a religion of peace is of course bollocks & for people to insist otherwise are trying to cover some pretty sizeable cracks, it also doesnt help anyone.

What is wrong with calling a spade a spade? Islam is a violent & aggressive religion, the text is there in the book.

There isnt some kind of Quran 2 for ISIS, Boko Haram etc they read the same Quran as everyone else, they read the damn thing day & night over & over again & I would absolutely guarantee they know the text alot better than anyone claiming you aint no muslim bruv.

Hundreds of thousands if not millions of muslims (many being highly educated doctors, engineers, mechanics etc) support the creation of the caliphate, that makes them just as complicit as those who commit the murders.

I do actually have some sympathy for Trump, there was no outrage when Iranians were banned in the US & its not really any different to Eastern euro countries saying they will only take Christian refugees.

I don't necessarily think the idea of a caliphate is necessarily wrong, it doesn't automatically follow that a caliphate is the same as supporting IS view of the caliphate. Of course I think its a load of old bollocks, but I'm neither a resident of the middle east nor a Muslim.

My concern would be with seeing ISIS as a caliphate or anykind of legitimate regime.

I'm a Marxist, pretty much, and on some level believe in the ideals of Marxism, but not at the price and cost incurred by Lennin, Mao or Pol Pot.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 10 Dec 15 6.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 9.55am

Quote -TUX- at 09 Dec 2015 8.15pm

Trump saying what many feel but can't quite muster up the balls to say it i guess?
Many here can't decide which side of the 'PC fence' they want to sit on.

That's the real issue.

I don't think political correctness is the problem, I'd say that many of Trumps statements are unconstitutional and would never survive legal challenge at even the most basic level, without re-writing the US constitution.



The ridiculous 'uproar' from certain quarters tells me that this is a PC issue to many. Far too bloody many imo.
As for the rest, agreed.

 


Time to move forward together.

NickRobinson Flag 10 Dec 15 7.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 4.19pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 10 Dec 2015 1.08pm

There are plenty of passages in the Quran that condone violence against believers and non believer's alike. All this talk of Islam being a religion of peace is of course bollocks & for people to insist otherwise are trying to cover some pretty sizeable cracks, it also doesnt help anyone.

What is wrong with calling a spade a spade? Islam is a violent & aggressive religion, the text is there in the book.

There isnt some kind of Quran 2 for ISIS, Boko Haram etc they read the same Quran as everyone else, they read the damn thing day & night over & over again & I would absolutely guarantee they know the text alot better than anyone claiming you aint no muslim bruv.

Hundreds of thousands if not millions of muslims (many being highly educated doctors, engineers, mechanics etc) support the creation of the caliphate, that makes them just as complicit as those who commit the murders.

I do actually have some sympathy for Trump, there was no outrage when Iranians were banned in the US & its not really any different to Eastern euro countries saying they will only take Christian refugees.

I don't necessarily think the idea of a caliphate is necessarily wrong, it doesn't automatically follow that a caliphate is the same as supporting IS view of the caliphate. Of course I think its a load of old bollocks, but I'm neither a resident of the middle east nor a Muslim.

My concern would be with seeing ISIS as a caliphate or anykind of legitimate regime.

I'm a Marxist, pretty much, and on some level believe in the ideals of Marxism, but not at the price and cost incurred by Lennin, Mao or Pol Pot.


So you reject one load of old bollocks yet embrace another. The likes of Lenin, Mao and Pol Pot are inevitable products of Marxism.

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 11 Dec 15 12.16am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Dec 2015 1.27pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 10 Dec 2015 1.08pm

There are plenty of passages in the Quran that condone violence against believers and non believer's alike. All this talk of Islam being a religion of peace is of course bollocks & for people to insist otherwise are trying to cover some pretty sizeable cracks, it also doesnt help anyone.

What is wrong with calling a spade a spade? Islam is a violent & aggressive religion, the text is there in the book.

There isnt some kind of Quran 2 for ISIS, Boko Haram etc they read the same Quran as everyone else, they read the damn thing day & night over & over again & I would absolutely guarantee they know the text alot better than anyone claiming you aint no muslim bruv.

Hundreds of thousands if not millions of muslims (many being highly educated doctors, engineers, mechanics etc) support the creation of the caliphate, that makes them just as complicit as those who commit the murders.

I do actually have some sympathy for Trump, there was no outrage when Iranians were banned in the US & its not really any different to Eastern euro countries saying they will only take Christian refugees.

Its the problem of religion and fundamentalism especially, because it promotes the rejection of context, a phase becomes truth and the only truth, by its existence, and the extrapolation of that truth is placed in the authority of individuals, who's agendas are not spiritual.

Its like Christian Fundamentalists attacking abortion clinics, there isn't really any way you could read the bible and think, you know what, that's would Jesus wants. They just pick and emphasis what fits their agenda, and ignore the rest.

Groups like IS and Boko Harem are just the extreme manifestation of this kind of political machination of Religion (similar to that of Iran).

Like anything, religion can be a tool for peace or violence, dependent on the person 'reading the book'. The reality of such groups is that their intentions aren't really driven by religion or spirituality, but are about power, status and control.

The IS Caliphate is not about Islam, its about creating a 'country over which IS has dominance' same ultimately as that of the Iranian Revolution - Neither fosters the theological spiritual development of individual muslims, but the control of those people for the benefit of a few.

Which certainly isn't what Mohammed was preaching.


You give the Quran far too much credibility, the Quran IS the final word from God, that in itself is extremely threatening, we haven't even opened the book yet & this particular work of fiction is throwing context out the window.

I happen to disagree with your comments about the caliphate not being about Islam, it's at the very core of Islam & it's why thousands flood to Syria/Iraq to fight & why millions around the world cheer it on.


Edited by Ouzo Dan (11 Dec 2015 12.17am)

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Donald Trump