You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Austerity Works


Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 17 Dec 15 7.40pm

Rental prices are crippling this, and future generations.
It used to be a way of having a home while saving a deposit for your OWN home, but now many are paying the mortgages of others luckily enough to be in a position where they can get credit.
Some are good businessmen but the majority, in my experience, are just fortunate as 'the baby boomers' left them a chunk and leaving it in the bank earns diddly, so why not become a landlord.
The point made regarding the lack of house building is a valid one but equally rents should be capped on the properties that already exist, imo. If not that, then heavily tax 3rd+ property ownership to the point that makes it a less attractive proposition for many.
But neither will ever happen (regardless of which party are in 'power' as higher house prices = higher mortgages = happy bankers.
And that's the deal.

'Feudal times' are back in vogue.

 


Time to move forward together.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Dec 15 7.41pm

Quote elgrande at 17 Dec 2015 7.08pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Dec 2015 6.57pm

Quote elgrande at 17 Dec 2015 6.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Dec 2015 6.10pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Dec 2015 4.10pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Dec 2015 3.30pm

Quote Stuk at 17 Dec 2015 3.10pm

Quote nickgusset at 17 Dec 2015 3.04pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Dec 2015 2.31pm

Quote silvertop at 17 Dec 2015 11.52am

We were unfavourably hit by the 2008 crisis because our economy is so heavily geared towards finance. We have been favourably blessed by the recovery as it was that sector that has made the biggest adjustment.

Control over public spending has improved or credit rating and is one of many factors that has led to where we are now.

However, the OP stating that the tight budget is the cause of low unemployment does not suggest a very savvy grip on the complexities of economics.

Best stick to football.

I was making the connection between welfare reforms and unemployment figures, which are, in one way or another, connected.

No one can really be against a lower welfare burden and in turn, more tax receipts going to the Exchequer ?

Lower welfare burden = 105,000 homeless children this Christmas (figure from today's Today programme.


Only via a warped interpretation of the word.

more than 103,000 children will spend Christmas in B&Bs, hostels or temporary rented homes.


Oh that's all right then.


They would be able to live in their own homes nick, but any spare housing is all rented out to EU citizens exercising their rights to live/work any where in the EU and of course asylum seekers/refugees/economic migrants from the middle east... not to mention hordes of illegal immigrants living here too.

But of course that is there right to live here in the UK and we must welcome them with open arms according to lefty/liberal supporters. To try and cope with demand we end up building houses on flood plains and then you lot blame the flood on governmental incompetence and global warming!


There are over 600,000 empty homes in the U.K. Considering we are in the top 10 richest countries in the world, having 1 homeless child is unacceptable.

Edited by nickgusset (17 Dec 2015 6.11pm)


Now you see that is more left wing bollocks,A house only has to be empty for 6 months to be classed as "long term".
And the 600.000 is very missleading as over half of that amount are re- rented,within that time scale.
I am not saying it is not a problem....it is,but not any of the ruling parties have built anywhere near enough new homes.
And as much as the multi culture loving left don't like it, mass immigration does nothing but add huge amounts to the problem.

Whilst I concede your first point about numbers (although I am taking your word for it, I think you are mistaken in blaming the homeless problem on immigration. Many many people (including those with chilldren) have been evicted from their homes because they can't afford the extortionate rent due to a reduction in welfare support.
Nothing to do with immigration.

Edited by nickgusset (17 Dec 2015 6.59pm)


But I am not blaming it entirely on immigration I said it adds to the problem....which lets be fair is prety darn obvious.
But the cap is £26.000 I believe FFS if you cannot find anywhere to rent in that area and you rely on benifits then you have to move to where it is affordable.
In London the rents are through the roof I agree,but it still matters that not enough social housing has been built in the last 20 years or more.
You have to cut the cloth accordingly.


Many people work, moving somewhere cheaper, away from your community could mean having to give the job up.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 17 Dec 15 8.04pm

Quote -TUX- at 17 Dec 2015 7.40pm

Rental prices are crippling this, and future generations.
It used to be a way of having a home while saving a deposit for your OWN home, but now many are paying the mortgages of others luckily enough to be in a position where they can get credit.
Some are good businessmen but the majority, in my experience, are just fortunate as 'the baby boomers' left them a chunk and leaving it in the bank earns diddly, so why not become a landlord.
The point made regarding the lack of house building is a valid one but equally rents should be capped on the properties that already exist, imo. If not that, then heavily tax 3rd+ property ownership to the point that makes it a less attractive proposition for many.
But neither will ever happen (regardless of which party are in 'power' as higher house prices = higher mortgages = happy bankers.
And that's the deal.

'Feudal times' are back in vogue.

TUX - as a landlord it's not in my interest to want to agree with you however I do believe you are correct.
In order to stop rents increasing there are really only two things which can be done.
1, stop the supply (i.e. dramatically reduce our net immigration figure)
2, Introduce some kind of system to cap rental prices.
I don't really see anything else working.
All the time we have an open door immigration policy rents will continue to rise.
This month I have let two properties, one to two Polish girls and one to an Italian family.
I have never bothered to work anything out but I would guess that over three quarters of properties I have let over the past 5 years have been to foreign nationals.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 17 Dec 15 8.15pm

Correct me if I'm wrong (and I'm sure all the finance ministers for Jermey Corbyn on here will do ) but if you are spending beyond your means that leads to debt, and more debt.

The only way out is to lessen your spending. Choices have to be made as to what your are going to save on.

Waitrose to Aldi, going out to staying in, Sky + HD to freeview, driving to public transport.Point is we've all had to make cuts when the times are tough, and this government I'm pleased to say, are making some good approaches to welfare regulation. You know they are on the right track when the great unwashed start marching on Number 10 amid a cloud of Lambert and Butler and weed, indignant to their very core that they may have to get a job if they wish to smoke a bar a week.

Someone somewhere is going to have to take a bite of the shyte sandwich, in fact we all are really, look at how many were made redundant in the HM Forces, Jesus the Army is that small now we could all fit in Wembley stadium, without needing the pitch !!! 25 thousand proud men and women made redundant, and yet the scroungers are moaning about a £25000 cap on handouts! excuse me but fcuk the fcuk off.

Social housing has always been an issue, always will be it's an expensive problem that has to wait in line just like the battered and nearly broken NHS.

The point has been made, and I agree entirely with it, that accepting a mass of immigrants is in no way going to help the problem, unless of course they are all gazzilionaire house builders,surgeons and nurses.

Cuts simply have to happen, it's never nice, but essential non the less.

Edited by dannyh (17 Dec 2015 8.19pm)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 17 Dec 15 8.28pm

Quote Tom-the-eagle at 17 Dec 2015 8.04pm

Quote -TUX- at 17 Dec 2015 7.40pm

Rental prices are crippling this, and future generations.
It used to be a way of having a home while saving a deposit for your OWN home, but now many are paying the mortgages of others luckily enough to be in a position where they can get credit.
Some are good businessmen but the majority, in my experience, are just fortunate as 'the baby boomers' left them a chunk and leaving it in the bank earns diddly, so why not become a landlord.
The point made regarding the lack of house building is a valid one but equally rents should be capped on the properties that already exist, imo. If not that, then heavily tax 3rd+ property ownership to the point that makes it a less attractive proposition for many.
But neither will ever happen (regardless of which party are in 'power' as higher house prices = higher mortgages = happy bankers.
And that's the deal.

'Feudal times' are back in vogue.

TUX - as a landlord it's not in my interest to want to agree with you however I do believe you are correct.
In order to stop rents increasing there are really only two things which can be done.
1, stop the supply (i.e. dramatically reduce our net immigration figure)
2, Introduce some kind of system to cap rental prices.
I don't really see anything else working.
All the time we have an open door immigration policy rents will continue to rise.
This month I have let two properties, one to two Polish girls and one to an Italian family.
I have never bothered to work anything out but I would guess that over three quarters of properties I have let over the past 5 years have been to foreign nationals.


The immigration issue is just another example of our govt (regardless of colours) not listening to the majority of the electorate.

I applaud your honesty. (thumbs up)



 


Time to move forward together.

elgrande Flag bedford 17 Dec 15 8.32pm

Quote -TUX- at 17 Dec 2015 7.40pm

Rental prices are crippling this, and future generations.
It used to be a way of having a home while saving a deposit for your OWN home, but now many are paying the mortgages of others luckily enough to be in a position where they can get credit.
Some are good businessmen but the majority, in my experience, are just fortunate as 'the baby boomers' left them a chunk and leaving it in the bank earns diddly, so why not become a landlord.
The point made regarding the lack of house building is a valid one but equally rents should be capped on the properties that already exist, imo. If not that, then heavily tax 3rd+ property ownership to the point that makes it a less attractive proposition for many.
But neither will ever happen (regardless of which party are in 'power' as higher house prices = higher mortgages = happy bankers.
And that's the deal.

'Feudal times' are back in vogue.

As someone who is more to the right of things(you would never guess" I tend to agrre with you on this Tux,to a certain extent.
maybe on the third propertie and above you pay a higher rate,or have to let said property out at an affordale rate.
But as has been said while more and more people come here they need homes,more people means more demand...therefore landlords are laughing.


Edited by elgrande (17 Dec 2015 8.33pm)

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 17 Dec 15 8.39pm

Quote dannyh at 17 Dec 2015 8.15pm

Correct me if I'm wrong (and I'm sure all the finance ministers for Jermey Corbyn on here will do ) but if you are spending beyond your means that leads to debt, and more debt.

The only way out is to lessen your spending. Choices have to be made as to what your are going to save on.

Waitrose to Aldi, going out to staying in, Sky + HD to freeview, driving to public transport.Point is we've all had to make cuts when the times are tough, and this government I'm pleased to say, are making some good approaches to welfare regulation. You know they are on the right track when the great unwashed start marching on Number 10 amid a cloud of Lambert and Butler and weed, indignant to their very core that they may have to get a job if they wish to smoke a bar a week.

Someone somewhere is going to have to take a bite of the shyte sandwich, in fact we all are really, look at how many were made redundant in the HM Forces, Jesus the Army is that small now we could all fit in Wembley stadium, without needing the pitch !!! 25 thousand proud men and women made redundant, and yet the scroungers are moaning about a £25000 cap on handouts! excuse me but fcuk the fcuk off.

Social housing has always been an issue, always will be it's an expensive problem that has to wait in line just like the battered and nearly broken NHS.

The point has been made, and I agree entirely with it, that accepting a mass of immigrants is in no way going to help the problem, unless of course they are all gazzilionaire house builders,surgeons and nurses.

Cuts simply have to happen, it's never nice, but essential non the less.

Edited by dannyh (17 Dec 2015 8.19pm)

If austerity is working, how is it that the rich are getting richer? Where have they suffered in all of this? They haven't. The gap has expanded!

You're just like my dear old mum tbh, blaming all the countries problems on those who never started the bl--dy problem in the first place but put the onus upon them!
Kinda makes voting pointless?



 


Time to move forward together.

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 17 Dec 15 8.49pm

Quote We are goin up! at 17 Dec 2015 11.09am

Quote Ketteridge at 17 Dec 2015 10.13am

Depends how you look at it, people in work is at the highest level since records began in 1971 but unemployment is only just returning to levels of 2008. GDP has grown but GDP per capita is still below 2008 levels.
The jobs that have been created have largely been unskilled. Median income has remained the same last year making people worse off in real terms and the top income decile have increased their income further in comparison.
Public sector works have had their pay frozen for the next 4 years which means any rise in inflation will result in roughly a quarter or the work force being significantly worse off.
In real terms homelessness and use of food banks has rocketed and levels of working people in poverty has hit record levels.
Oh and national debts is up.


Not really since there's been no inflation, in fact the essentials like fuel and food have fallen in price.

Food bank use has rocketed because those nasty Tories changed legislation to allow job centres to direct people to them. It's also something to be proud of that we as a country provide charity like this off our own backs, rather than expecting the state to be the source of charity instead.

National debt is up, you're right. Because the deficit hasn't really been dealt with, which is because we haven't really had austerity. Osborne has somehow duped the markets (and the public) into thinking we have and that he's economically responsible.


As Mr Gristle has already said be being proud of the fact that 1 million people need to use food banks in a rich western country is slightly disturbing.
The ridiculous thing is that to believe the idea that food bank have somehow linked up a demand and a supply that had previously been ignored or unnoticed you have to assume that during the Blair and Brown years the demand was high but these million people had no access to charity. They were I assume wandering around emaciated and starving looking for some free charity food. A lot has happened since 2008, and the days of Sheki Kuqi and Paddy McCarthy seem a whole different world away now but I'm sure I'd remember that.

CPI was negative for a few months and wages grew at a faster rate, meaning living standards rose during this period but it was four months over the summer this needs to be set against years in which inflation has grown at a faster rate then wages. It also ignores the fact that RPI is at 1.1%, RPI unlike CPI includes housing costs and this has disproportionate effect on people below the median income.


 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 17 Dec 15 8.51pm

Quote elgrande at 17 Dec 2015 8.32pm

Quote -TUX- at 17 Dec 2015 7.40pm

Rental prices are crippling this, and future generations.
It used to be a way of having a home while saving a deposit for your OWN home, but now many are paying the mortgages of others luckily enough to be in a position where they can get credit.
Some are good businessmen but the majority, in my experience, are just fortunate as 'the baby boomers' left them a chunk and leaving it in the bank earns diddly, so why not become a landlord.
The point made regarding the lack of house building is a valid one but equally rents should be capped on the properties that already exist, imo. If not that, then heavily tax 3rd+ property ownership to the point that makes it a less attractive proposition for many.
But neither will ever happen (regardless of which party are in 'power' as higher house prices = higher mortgages = happy bankers.
And that's the deal.

'Feudal times' are back in vogue.

As someone who is more to the right of things(you would never guess" I tend to agrre with you on this Tux,to a certain extent.
maybe on the third propertie and above you pay a higher rate,or have to let said property out at an affordale rate.
But as has been said while more and more people come here they need homes,more people means more demand...therefore landlords are laughing.


Edited by elgrande (17 Dec 2015 8.33pm)


I don't know anyone who voted for this to happen. Those that 'we must obey' voted for it.

Edit: Proof again that this is far from a 'democracy'.

Edited by -TUX- (17 Dec 2015 9.22pm)

 


Time to move forward together.

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 17 Dec 15 10.56pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 16 Dec 2015 10.19am

[Link]

Unemployment lowest for 10 years at 5.2%


I think you mean counting the unemployed is the lowest for years. Scratch the service and there are self employed people who do not get enough work and rely on tax credits. People working on zero hours contract who do not get a decent weeks work.

Its just smoke and mirrors.

 

reginald_maudling Flag 17 Dec 15 11.01pm

Quote dannyh at 17 Dec 2015 8.15pm

Correct me if I'm wrong (and I'm sure all the finance ministers for Jermey Corbyn on here will do ) but if you are spending beyond your means that leads to debt, and more debt.

The only way out is to lessen your spending. Choices have to be made as to what your are going to save on.

Waitrose to Aldi, going out to staying in, Sky + HD to freeview, driving to public transport.Point is we've all had to make cuts when the times are tough, and this government I'm pleased to say, are making some good approaches to welfare regulation. You know they are on the right track when the great unwashed start marching on Number 10 amid a cloud of Lambert and Butler and weed, indignant to their very core that they may have to get a job if they wish to smoke a bar a week.

Someone somewhere is going to have to take a bite of the shyte sandwich, in fact we all are really, look at how many were made redundant in the HM Forces, Jesus the Army is that small now we could all fit in Wembley stadium, without needing the pitch !!! 25 thousand proud men and women made redundant, and yet the scroungers are moaning about a £25000 cap on handouts! excuse me but fcuk the fcuk off.

Social housing has always been an issue, always will be it's an expensive problem that has to wait in line just like the battered and nearly broken NHS.

The point has been made, and I agree entirely with it, that accepting a mass of immigrants is in no way going to help the problem, unless of course they are all gazzilionaire house builders,surgeons and nurses.

Cuts simply have to happen, it's never nice, but essential non the less.

Edited by dannyh (17 Dec 2015 8.19pm)


hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Dec 15 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 18 Dec 15 7.01am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Dec 2015 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


No it's not it is basic keynesian economics. It makes common sense as a narrative and ideal there shuld be no debt or deficit but since we hocked the nation's finance to bail out the banks we have a national debt and the debate needs to be how to deal with it.
My household budget is fixed,income and outgoings largely set. If there is too much month at the end of the money,as Mrs Ketteridge likes to say,then we stay in. we don't have access to a money printing machine to create new money. This was the problem for Greece it couldn't print money to help pay off debt as it could effect the euro and the value of Germany exports.
Secondly interest rates are at a historic low, it is the perfect time to borrow for sensible long term benefits. to use a household example if I'm stuck working on minimum wage is it more sensible for me to stick at it or borrow a few thousand at low rates do a plumbing course and triple my income,should I borrow to replace the dodgy boiler to half my outgoings?
The analogy is the same, investing in infrastructure can reduce costs and increase tax receipts. A social housing building programme will employ skilled workers,bring in rent tax receipts and reduce housing benefit payments. Investing in solar and wind power will keep Britain on the leading edge of technology help exports, create new jobs and apprenticeship and stop us being reliant on foreign oil.
The problem is austerity is sensible at an individual level but on national level is dangerous.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

becky Flag over the moon 18 Dec 15 8.09am

Quote Ketteridge at 18 Dec 2015 7.01am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Dec 2015 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


No it's not it is basic keynesian economics. It makes common sense as a narrative and ideal there shuld be no debt or deficit but since we hocked the nation's finance to bail out the banks we have a national debt and the debate needs to be how to deal with it.
My household budget is fixed,income and outgoings largely set. If there is too much month at the end of the money,as Mrs Ketteridge likes to say,then we stay in. we don't have access to a money printing machine to create new money. This was the problem for Greece it couldn't print money to help pay off debt as it could effect the euro and the value of Germany exports.
Secondly interest rates are at a historic low, it is the perfect time to borrow for sensible long term benefits. to use a household example if I'm stuck working on minimum wage is it more sensible for me to stick at it or borrow a few thousand at low rates do a plumbing course and triple my income,should I borrow to replace the dodgy boiler to half my outgoings?
The analogy is the same, investing in infrastructure can reduce costs and increase tax receipts. A social housing building programme will employ skilled workers,bring in rent tax receipts and reduce housing benefit payments. Investing in solar and wind power will keep Britain on the leading edge of technology help exports, create new jobs and apprenticeship and stop us being reliant on foreign oil.
The problem is austerity is sensible at an individual level but on national level is dangerous.

Maybe I'm being dense but...... if the social housing is funded by either National or local government (as it must be to be true social housing), then there will be no rent tax receipts, only income to recover outlay and as for a reduction in housing benefit, I can only ask where will all these people suddenly get income of more than £26,000 p.a. to be able to pay full rent and council tax on these properties and reduce their benefit levels?

Unemployed/unemployable in social housing will cost exactly the same as unemployed/unemployable in private rentals unless unreasonably low rent is charged on the social housing, which will leave more debt from the cost of construction to be paid for.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 18 Dec 15 9.54am

Quote Ketteridge at 18 Dec 2015 7.01am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Dec 2015 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


No it's not it is basic keynesian economics. It makes common sense as a narrative and ideal there shuld be no debt or deficit but since we hocked the nation's finance to bail out the banks we have a national debt and the debate needs to be how to deal with it.
My household budget is fixed,income and outgoings largely set. If there is too much month at the end of the money,as Mrs Ketteridge likes to say,then we stay in. we don't have access to a money printing machine to create new money. This was the problem for Greece it couldn't print money to help pay off debt as it could effect the euro and the value of Germany exports.
Secondly interest rates are at a historic low, it is the perfect time to borrow for sensible long term benefits. to use a household example if I'm stuck working on minimum wage is it more sensible for me to stick at it or borrow a few thousand at low rates do a plumbing course and triple my income,should I borrow to replace the dodgy boiler to half my outgoings?
The analogy is the same, investing in infrastructure can reduce costs and increase tax receipts. A social housing building programme will employ skilled workers,bring in rent tax receipts and reduce housing benefit payments. Investing in solar and wind power will keep Britain on the leading edge of technology help exports, create new jobs and apprenticeship and stop us being reliant on foreign oil.
The problem is austerity is sensible at an individual level but on national level is dangerous.


The argument breaks down at the point that debt reaches such a level that the international markets lose confidence that you have the means of paying it back.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 18 Dec 15 10.26am

I've never had it so good!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Dec 15 11.52am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Dec 2015 11.54am

Quote silvertop at 17 Dec 2015 11.52am

We were unfavourably hit by the 2008 crisis because our economy is so heavily geared towards finance. We have been favourably blessed by the recovery as it was that sector that has made the biggest adjustment.

Control over public spending has improved or credit rating and is one of many factors that has led to where we are now.

However, the OP stating that the tight budget is the cause of low unemployment does not suggest a very savvy grip on the complexities of economics.

Best stick to football.


He's probably still more of an economics guru than Brown or Balls though.... LOL


Now I am no Labour voter, but arch Tories like you conveniently forget that Labour ran up a huge budget and did a whole lot of other things that were not good. However, did they not also oversee an unprecedented period of prosperity? When Blaire was PM I saw a talk by the former head of economics at one of the big banks and he was completely smitten by Brown as Chancellor. Doing a fine job, apparently.

Economics, politics - it's no easy science it is until you introduce dogma. Go on, you're dying to mention the gold sale...

 

Hoof Hearted 18 Dec 15 12.41pm

Quote silvertop at 18 Dec 2015 11.52am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Dec 2015 11.54am

Quote silvertop at 17 Dec 2015 11.52am

We were unfavourably hit by the 2008 crisis because our economy is so heavily geared towards finance. We have been favourably blessed by the recovery as it was that sector that has made the biggest adjustment.

Control over public spending has improved or credit rating and is one of many factors that has led to where we are now.

However, the OP stating that the tight budget is the cause of low unemployment does not suggest a very savvy grip on the complexities of economics.

Best stick to football.


He's probably still more of an economics guru than Brown or Balls though.... LOL


Now I am no Labour voter, but arch Tories like you conveniently forget that Labour ran up a huge budget and did a whole lot of other things that were not good. However, did they not also oversee an unprecedented period of prosperity? When Blaire was PM I saw a talk by the former head of economics at one of the big banks and he was completely smitten by Brown as Chancellor. Doing a fine job, apparently.

Economics, politics - it's no easy science it is until you introduce dogma. Go on, you're dying to mention the gold sale...


No I prefer Brown's claim to have put and end to boom and bust.......... he certainly put an end to boom!

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 18 Dec 15 3.38pm

Quote Catfish at 18 Dec 2015 9.54am

Quote Ketteridge at 18 Dec 2015 7.01am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Dec 2015 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


No it's not it is basic keynesian economics. It makes common sense as a narrative and ideal there shuld be no debt or deficit but since we hocked the nation's finance to bail out the banks we have a national debt and the debate needs to be how to deal with it.
My household budget is fixed,income and outgoings largely set. If there is too much month at the end of the money,as Mrs Ketteridge likes to say,then we stay in. we don't have access to a money printing machine to create new money. This was the problem for Greece it couldn't print money to help pay off debt as it could effect the euro and the value of Germany exports.
Secondly interest rates are at a historic low, it is the perfect time to borrow for sensible long term benefits. to use a household example if I'm stuck working on minimum wage is it more sensible for me to stick at it or borrow a few thousand at low rates do a plumbing course and triple my income,should I borrow to replace the dodgy boiler to half my outgoings?
The analogy is the same, investing in infrastructure can reduce costs and increase tax receipts. A social housing building programme will employ skilled workers,bring in rent tax receipts and reduce housing benefit payments. Investing in solar and wind power will keep Britain on the leading edge of technology help exports, create new jobs and apprenticeship and stop us being reliant on foreign oil.
The problem is austerity is sensible at an individual level but on national level is dangerous.


The argument breaks down at the point that debt reaches such a level that the international markets lose confidence that you have the means of paying it back.

well yeah but only to the same extent that austerity relies on you ability to keep your income up and continue to repay the debt. Britain lost the triple A rating in 2013 when gdp start to stall because of austerity not in 2008 when debt was taken out to re-start the economy.
I'm not talking about an irresponsible splurge and towing Britain to the Caribbean for some winter sun but sensible investment in infrastructure.
To go back to the earlier analogy who would you lend money to the person in insecure job on minimum wage who lives or the person who wants to borrow money to do the plumbing course and triple wage. Assuming both are responsible of course

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 18 Dec 15 3.55pm

Quote becky at 18 Dec 2015 8.09am

Quote Ketteridge at 18 Dec 2015 7.01am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Dec 2015 1.57am

Quote reginald_maudling at 17 Dec 2015 11.01pm

hand bag economics

the national budget is not the same as a household budget

Mmmmm...In some ways it is, in some ways it isn't. It's still a budget. Interest on our debt is rising as it would be for anyone in debt who isn't on top of their payments and we have to pay as much on interest repayments as we do on the defence budget.

Sure capital can be raised but completely divorcing it from common sense with statements like yours is apart of the problem.


No it's not it is basic keynesian economics. It makes common sense as a narrative and ideal there shuld be no debt or deficit but since we hocked the nation's finance to bail out the banks we have a national debt and the debate needs to be how to deal with it.
My household budget is fixed,income and outgoings largely set. If there is too much month at the end of the money,as Mrs Ketteridge likes to say,then we stay in. we don't have access to a money printing machine to create new money. This was the problem for Greece it couldn't print money to help pay off debt as it could effect the euro and the value of Germany exports.
Secondly interest rates are at a historic low, it is the perfect time to borrow for sensible long term benefits. to use a household example if I'm stuck working on minimum wage is it more sensible for me to stick at it or borrow a few thousand at low rates do a plumbing course and triple my income,should I borrow to replace the dodgy boiler to half my outgoings?
The analogy is the same, investing in infrastructure can reduce costs and increase tax receipts. A social housing building programme will employ skilled workers,bring in rent tax receipts and reduce housing benefit payments. Investing in solar and wind power will keep Britain on the leading edge of technology help exports, create new jobs and apprenticeship and stop us being reliant on foreign oil.
The problem is austerity is sensible at an individual level but on national level is dangerous.

Maybe I'm being dense but...... if the social housing is funded by either National or local government (as it must be to be true social housing), then there will be no rent tax receipts, only income to recover outlay and as for a reduction in housing benefit, I can only ask where will all these people suddenly get income of more than £26,000 p.a. to be able to pay full rent and council tax on these properties and reduce their benefit levels?

Unemployed/unemployable in social housing will cost exactly the same as unemployed/unemployable in private rentals unless unreasonably low rent is charged on the social housing, which will leave more debt from the cost of construction to be paid for.


You are not being dense,I was trying to be too smart writing on the train at 6:40 before my first coffee kicked in.I forgot the comma should read rent,tax receipts.
The tax receipts coming from income tax and corporation tax of those building the houses.
The reduction in housing benefit comes from firstly not having to charge a market rate but as you say a rate that covers cost.
Secondly we pay out roughly £30billion a year in housing benefits much of this to private landlords. any sensible landlord would reinvest this into property. this increases demand and inflates the housing market further meaning more people have to rent for longer pushing up prices further. which of course means more spent on housing benefit and more profit for landlords.
Social housing doesn't need and shouldn't be just for unemployed or unemployable but for a range of people.
Sorry if there are any typos still on my phone

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works