You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cub leaders
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cub leaders


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 25 Feb 16 10.27am

What a sad reflection on 21st century British society this thread is. Glad I grew up in an age when parents were less risk obsessed. Was in the scouts 11-16 and loved it especially the camping. Our Scoutmaster was an ex RN petty officer and several of the younger assistants were coppers. Somehow I managed to avoid the perverts and abusers that the OP - and others here - seem to believe run the scout movement.

 

conrada20 Flag Eastbourne 25 Feb 16 11.57am

Originally posted by Casual

My little girl has just started brownies , all her mates at school have started at the same time, not a problem with it, they do loads of activities etc and as they get older they need to do hobbies away from the family ( she's 7).
My oldest boy is at a Palace football club after school , at he's school, which obviously I encourage.
My youngest boy is a f**king lunatic that runs round smashing the house up, smashed up a new tele I bought after 5 weeks.
Anyway we were round my mums the other day with one of my sisters talking about Maggie going brownies and my mum mentioned my 2 boys going Cubs , I said that there's no f**king way that my boys will ever go to Cubs, sleeping in a tent with a fully grown man, no f**king chance. They looked at me like I was a nutter.
Am I wrong in thinking that a man that wants to look after other people's kids is more likely to be a nonce?
Cub leaders want to dress up like the kids and have a sleep over, I know there's good and bad in all, but surely it would appeal to wronguns.
My mum and sister saying ' your boys will miss out because you wouldn't let them go'
Am I wrong for not wanting to put my kids on offer.
I'm interested in hearing what people think, although this is one subject that I won't be swayed on.
My oldest boy will probably want to join, so I'll have that little battle , but thankfully my youngest will more than likely burn the cub hut down rather than become one.
I can't see that my girl going on brownie camp with a load of women would be at the same risk , as the boys.
Stereotyping I know , but who would leave their boy with the local priest for choir practice nowadays ?

How ignorant are you? You very clearly have no understanding or idea what Scouting is all about.
As a fully qualified and vetted Scout leader, allow me to educate you;
1. All leaders have to return a clean enhanced DBS (criminal records investigation), this has to be renewed every three years.
2. All leaders have to complete, and pass, an intensive training course (over a two year period) to become a leader.
3. Safeguarding young people and first aid are bi-yearly exams.
4. There will always be two leaders where there are young people present.
5. Leaders do not dress up as kids, we wear a uniform, just like the armed services, police, fire brigade, nurses, doctors, football players, etc.
6. Leaders are not baby sitters, although some parents do think this, we are there to teach, instruct and expand young peoples minds.
7. There are no mixed sex tents on camp, nor are leaders permitted to share a tent with anyone under 18 years of age.
8. Leaders and young people have separate shower and toilet facilities...
The list is endless.
Why do I do it? Although it is a LOT of hard work, and takes up a LOT of your own time, it is enormously fun and rewarding. How many people have the opportunity of experiencing the thousands of diverse activities on offer in Scouting, whilst helping young people achieve far more than a school environment can ever offer.
Oh, and by the way every-time you allow your children to visit a friends house to play, or for a sleepover, go to school, football club, dance clubs and what ever-else, by your very own definition, YOU ARE putting your kids on offer.
Take a look at the Scout website, and stop judging everyone by your own deviant behavioural traits.

 


Too many years at the Palace to be surprised anymore.....

Holmesdale Steve Flag East Grinstead 25 Feb 16 12.02pm

Originally posted by Apollofuzz

What a sad sad thread. As a family we have been heavily involved in Cubs, Scouts, Rainbows & Guides. I have been a cub, Scout and assistant leader along with running a Football club for Kids (Boys and Girls) 8 – 11.
My Eldest daughter is a Guide leader, and has been a Guide, Scout & Explorer my middle daughter has been a cub, a guide and assistant Rainbow leader. I have seen some very dedicated people giving up vast amounts of their own time and Holiday for the good of Scouting. We have never had anything but positive and great experiences. The regulations regarding adults being alone with children is very strict, I wish all kids would join and get off the couch and experience the great outdoors. If you are that worried I suggest let him join and you volunteer to help, maybe then you will see the hard work and dedication these men and women put in.


Edited by Apollofuzz (25 Feb 2016 8.50am)

Edited by Apollofuzz (25 Feb 2016 8.52am)


Spot on. My eldest son was in the cubs and although I didn't become a leader, I used to help out whenever my work schedule would allow. As a helper, I had to have a full CRB check.
All activities were carefully planned so that no single adult was alone with the kids. No adults ever shared a tent with kids. I couldn't even share a tent with my own son.
These leaders give up their own time throughout the year and should be applauded for their efforts.
As in any walk of life, there will be a very small minority that give everyone a bad name but if these people weren't cub leaders they would be doing something else to access kids (football, swimming, teaching etc).

 


There's a bloke down my road who walks round in a Tesco's carrier bag. Turns out he is a brighton faggot.

mr. apollo Flag Somewhere in Switzerland 25 Feb 16 12.20pm

Originally posted by conrada20

How ignorant are you? You very clearly have no understanding or idea what Scouting is all about.
As a fully qualified and vetted Scout leader, allow me to educate you;
1. All leaders have to return a clean enhanced DBS (criminal records investigation), this has to be renewed every three years.
2. All leaders have to complete, and pass, an intensive training course (over a two year period) to become a leader.
3. Safeguarding young people and first aid are bi-yearly exams.
4. There will always be two leaders where there are young people present.
5. Leaders do not dress up as kids, we wear a uniform, just like the armed services, police, fire brigade, nurses, doctors, football players, etc.
6. Leaders are not baby sitters, although some parents do think this, we are there to teach, instruct and expand young peoples minds.
7. There are no mixed sex tents on camp, nor are leaders permitted to share a tent with anyone under 18 years of age.
8. Leaders and young people have separate shower and toilet facilities...
The list is endless.
Why do I do it? Although it is a LOT of hard work, and takes up a LOT of your own time, it is enormously fun and rewarding. How many people have the opportunity of experiencing the thousands of diverse activities on offer in Scouting, whilst helping young people achieve far more than a school environment can ever offer.
Oh, and by the way every-time you allow your children to visit a friends house to play, or for a sleepover, go to school, football club, dance clubs and what ever-else, by your very own definition, YOU ARE putting your kids on offer.
Take a look at the Scout website, and stop judging everyone by your own deviant behavioural traits.

Good reply

 



Glad

All

Over

Casual Flag Orpington 25 Feb 16 12.23pm

Originally posted by conrada20

How ignorant are you? You very clearly have no understanding or idea what Scouting is all about.
As a fully qualified and vetted Scout leader, allow me to educate you;
1. All leaders have to return a clean enhanced DBS (criminal records investigation), this has to be renewed every three years.
2. All leaders have to complete, and pass, an intensive training course (over a two year period) to become a leader.
3. Safeguarding young people and first aid are bi-yearly exams.
4. There will always be two leaders where there are young people present.
5. Leaders do not dress up as kids, we wear a uniform, just like the armed services, police, fire brigade, nurses, doctors, football players, etc.
6. Leaders are not baby sitters, although some parents do think this, we are there to teach, instruct and expand young peoples minds.
7. There are no mixed sex tents on camp, nor are leaders permitted to share a tent with anyone under 18 years of age.
8. Leaders and young people have separate shower and toilet facilities...
The list is endless.
Why do I do it? Although it is a LOT of hard work, and takes up a LOT of your own time, it is enormously fun and rewarding. How many people have the opportunity of experiencing the thousands of diverse activities on offer in Scouting, whilst helping young people achieve far more than a school environment can ever offer.
Oh, and by the way every-time you allow your children to visit a friends house to play, or for a sleepover, go to school, football club, dance clubs and what ever-else, by your very own definition, YOU ARE putting your kids on offer.
Take a look at the Scout website, and stop judging everyone by your own deviant behavioural traits.


Good post. To be fair I never said that you was all nonces, would just expect there to be a higher proportion than in everyday society. Anyway fair play to you for giving your time , for I'm assuming no pay? But i still won't be sending my boys.
Cheers.

 

mr. apollo Flag Somewhere in Switzerland 25 Feb 16 12.41pm

Originally posted by Casual


Good post. To be fair I never said that you were all nonces, would just expect there to be a higher proportion than in everyday society. Anyway fair play to you for giving your time , for I'm assuming no pay? But i still won't be sending my boys.
Cheers.

Well I would expect a LOWER proportion than normal society as normal society does not have to go through all the cross checks, I don't suppose you've asked your boys what they think?

 



Glad

All

Over

gambler Flag Kent 25 Feb 16 12.42pm

Originally posted by conrada20

How ignorant are you? You very clearly have no understanding or idea what Scouting is all about.
As a fully qualified and vetted Scout leader, allow me to educate you;
1. All leaders have to return a clean enhanced DBS (criminal records investigation), this has to be renewed every three years.
2. All leaders have to complete, and pass, an intensive training course (over a two year period) to become a leader.
3. Safeguarding young people and first aid are bi-yearly exams.
4. There will always be two leaders where there are young people present.
5. Leaders do not dress up as kids, we wear a uniform, just like the armed services, police, fire brigade, nurses, doctors, football players, etc.
6. Leaders are not baby sitters, although some parents do think this, we are there to teach, instruct and expand young peoples minds.
7. There are no mixed sex tents on camp, nor are leaders permitted to share a tent with anyone under 18 years of age.
8. Leaders and young people have separate shower and toilet facilities...
The list is endless.
Why do I do it? Although it is a LOT of hard work, and takes up a LOT of your own time, it is enormously fun and rewarding. How many people have the opportunity of experiencing the thousands of diverse activities on offer in Scouting, whilst helping young people achieve far more than a school environment can ever offer.
Oh, and by the way every-time you allow your children to visit a friends house to play, or for a sleepover, go to school, football club, dance clubs and what ever-else, by your very own definition, YOU ARE putting your kids on offer.
Take a look at the Scout website, and stop judging everyone by your own deviant behavioural traits.

"Deviant" is one of my favourite words.

 

Apollofuzz Flag On the edge of reason 25 Feb 16 1.19pm

Originally posted by Casual

My little girl has just started brownies , all her mates at school have started at the same time, not a problem with it, they do loads of activities etc and as they get older they need to do hobbies away from the family ( she's 7).
My oldest boy is at a Palace football club after school , at he's school, which obviously I encourage.
My youngest boy is a f**king lunatic that runs round smashing the house up, smashed up a new tele I bought after 5 weeks.
Anyway we were round my mums the other day with one of my sisters talking about Maggie going brownies and my mum mentioned my 2 boys going Cubs , I said that there's no f**king way that my boys will ever go to Cubs, sleeping in a tent with a fully grown man, no f**king chance. They looked at me like I was a nutter.
Am I wrong in thinking that a man that wants to look after other people's kids is more likely to be a nonce?
Cub leaders want to dress up like the kids and have a sleep over, I know there's good and bad in all, but surely it would appeal to wronguns.
My mum and sister saying ' your boys will miss out because you wouldn't let them go'
Am I wrong for not wanting to put my kids on offer.
I'm interested in hearing what people think, although this is one subject that I won't be swayed on.
My oldest boy will probably want to join, so I'll have that little battle , but thankfully my youngest will more than likely burn the cub hut down rather than become one.
I can't see that my girl going on brownie camp with a load of women would be at the same risk , as the boys.
Stereotyping I know , but who would leave their boy with the local priest for choir practice nowadays ?

Maybe a structured and organised association like the Beavers (Scouts) is what your youngest son needs, a chance to get out and let off steam, work with others, within the rules of Scouting, You don’t have to let him go away on camps if that makes you feel uncomfortable. Do you know if your local Beaver Leader is a man? more than likely it’s a woman. Beavers is normally only 1.5hrs in a hall or outside, Go along and see what happens, become a parent helper.
I wonder how you feel about your children going away on residential trips with the school which I believe is part of the curriculum?

 


I ride a GS scooter with my hair cut neat
I wear my war time coat in the wind and sleet.

Part Time James Flag 25 Feb 16 1.35pm

I work with kids at the local junior parkrun, part of the wider parkrun scheme that started off as an outlet for adults. I do it as a volunteer and give up a lot of my time, but at the same time I do understand why these days eyebrows are raised. I have found since I started doing it that I don't feel any particular attachment to the kids and I distance myself from my involvement with the kids quite a bit (the others in my team are much more natural with the youngsters so I leave them to it). I get more involved in the admin side of things. You are right, it'd be a bit weird if I had maternal instincts. I look forward to being a dad myself one day though.

I'm the only member of the core team that doesn't have kids myself (we have an even split of men and women), plus I have a big beard which makes me look like a dirty weirdo. I imagine at some point at least one of the parents has thought "who is that f**king nonce hanging about"?!! There is a bit of a difference though. The majority of the kids that take part have their parents constantly in attendance, unlike with cubs/scouts etc.

We are all fully DBS checked, as are cubs and scouts leaders, but I do agree with the criticism of the DBS I have heard before along the lines of "that only captures anything you have previously been caught for, not intent". I bet Adam Johnson could've passed a DBS a couple of years ago. Probably Jimmy Savile a couple of years before his death.

So as someone that volunteers with a kids' event, I take no offence by comments that it looks a bit creepy. I personally know I'm not into that kind of stuff, it makes me f**king sick, and there will be a lot of people the same as me that volunteer to do stuff just because they want to give a bit back to the community. But we do live in a society where I can totally understand the concern of parents.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 16 1.41pm

Originally posted by Casual

Good post. To be fair I never said that you was all nonces, would just expect there to be a higher proportion than in everyday society. Anyway fair play to you for giving your time , for I'm assuming no pay? But i still won't be sending my boys.
Cheers.

I doubt it, its just more likely that they'd be 'caught'. Statistically speaking, the greatest threat to children is from relatives such as an uncle, close friend of the family, father or grandfather.

That's not to say it doesn't happen, it always will be a case that some people in positions of trust will abuse that trust. However most organisations that work with children directly, like Cubs, have a number of practices and procedures in place that reduce risk such as never allowing individuals to be alone with children etc (and usually reliant on having multiple positions of authority working together along with parental involvement).

Probably the best bet if you're worried about the risks, is to get involved with the cubs directly and see whether there is any real risk.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 25 Feb 16 1.48pm

I was seriously put in place by a bloke I work with who is a scout leader. I asked him if there was a "Don't tell your parents" badge the kids could earn. He didn't think that was funny at all. Actually, it isn't. That post earlier, I think by conrada20 was a very good one and I realise now it was an ignorant thing of me to say, even just to get a wind up from my mate!

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 16 1.48pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I work with kids at the local junior parkrun, part of the wider parkrun scheme that started off as an outlet for adults. I do it as a volunteer and give up a lot of my time, but at the same time I do understand why these days eyebrows are raised. I have found since I started doing it that I don't feel any particular attachment to the kids and I distance myself from my involvement with the kids quite a bit (the others in my team are much more natural with the youngsters so I leave them to it). I get more involved in the admin side of things. You are right, it'd be a bit weird if I had maternal instincts. I look forward to being a dad myself one day though.

I'm the only member of the core team that doesn't have kids myself (we have an even split of men and women), plus I have a big beard which makes me look like a dirty weirdo. I imagine at some point at least one of the parents has thought "who is that f**king nonce hanging about"?!! There is a bit of a difference though. The majority of the kids that take part have their parents constantly in attendance, unlike with cubs/scouts etc.

We are all fully DBS checked, as are cubs and scouts leaders, but I do agree with the criticism of the DBS I have heard before along the lines of "that only captures anything you have previously been caught for, not intent". I bet Adam Johnson could've passed a DBS a couple of years ago. Probably Jimmy Savile a couple of years before his death.

So as someone that volunteers with a kids' event, I take no offence by comments that it looks a bit creepy. I personally know I'm not into that kind of stuff, it makes me f**king sick, and there will be a lot of people the same as me that volunteer to do stuff just because they want to give a bit back to the community. But we do live in a society where I can totally understand the concern of parents.

Problem with any background checks is that its hard to prove someone is a risk, unless they've actually been done for something, and if you start to go down the 'have they ever been questioned' it becomes unfair.

People generally are as honest as their options, when the consequence of honesty is being penalised and the capacity to fairly refuse clearance is limited (i.e. you have priors and even then most of the people who fail background checks to work with children are just people who have convictions for unrelated offences).

After all, a known and convicted sex offender isn't going to pursue a job once they realise they'll have to pass a criminal record or background check.

Most people who don't have a criminal record can pass any kind of security or background check - short of something like Direct Vetting.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 25 Feb 16 1.52pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Problem with any background checks is that its hard to prove someone is a risk, unless they've actually been done for something, and if you start to go down the 'have they ever been questioned' it becomes unfair.

People generally are as honest as their options, when the consequence of honesty is being penalised and the capacity to fairly refuse clearance is limited (i.e. you have priors and even then most of the people who fail background checks to work with children are just people who have convictions for unrelated offences).

After all, a known and convicted sex offender isn't going to pursue a job once they realise they'll have to pass a criminal record or background check.

Most people who don't have a criminal record can pass any kind of security or background check - short of something like Direct Vetting.

This is true. I think though, as has been said by others on this post, I think you did as well, I'd have more faith in the practices put in place by big organisations like the scouts and junior parkrun than the DBS itself.

The rules we have to abide by are very well set out and there is no way in hell anyone would get away with anything untoward at any of our events, even if the parents didn't attend.

I'm also a qualified running coach and actually even the rules around working with adults are pretty strict too.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 16 1.56pm

Originally posted by rikz

Yes just as I thought, you won't answer.

Okay, you live in Rotherham, you have a 13 year old daughter, 2 after school clubs, one run by 3 middle eastern Muslim males the other ran by 3 British women. What club would you choose ?

Edited by rikz (24 Feb 2016 11.38pm)

It depends is your daughter homeless or in care? If so, then they're at risk from both groups, if not the risks are slightly higher in the group ran by men, than women, because of their gender.

The reality of such targeted abuse is that they target vulnerable children, typically 'troublesome' kids, those in care and those with problems they can exploit.

Particularly involving abuse with multiple Muslim men, the focus is very much around targeting vulnerable kids that people like social services and the police won't be interested in. Its like people who rape prostitutes, they do so because they know the police won't give a s**t, the CPS don't care.

The offenders tend to be responsible for the act, the status of the victim tends to be the determining factor in whether anyone will do anything about it.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 16 2.00pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I was seriously put in place by a bloke I work with who is a scout leader. I asked him if there was a "Don't tell your parents" badge the kids could earn. He didn't think that was funny at all. Actually, it isn't. That post earlier, I think by conrada20 was a very good one and I realise now it was an ignorant thing of me to say, even just to get a wind up from my mate!

Nah, its pretty funny.

Of course putting your kids into cubs is a lower risk of abuse than letting other friends or family look after them. This is where abuse occurs.

Everyone I've known who was sexually molested as a child (which is only five people), was either by a relative (two by uncles, one by their father, one by their grandfather and the other by their father best friend).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 25 Feb 16 2.03pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Nah, its pretty funny.

Of course putting your kids into cubs is a lower risk of abuse than letting other friends or family look after them. This is where abuse occurs.

Everyone I've known who was sexually molested as a child (which is only five people), was either by a relative (two by uncles, one by their father, one by their grandfather and the other by their father best friend).

"Only five" sounds quite high, but then I don't know how big your social circle is. I don't know anyone it has happened to.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 16 2.15pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

"Only five" sounds quite high, but then I don't know how big your social circle is. I don't know anyone it has happened to.

That's over 44 years. I'm one of those people that unfortunately people tend to confide in. One was a girlfriend of a friend, one was a girl I was at school with, two were people I managed in a shop and the other was a daughter of my mums friend - My mum told be about it).

Thinking about it, I can think of two more. I'm like the noncewhisperer

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 25 Feb 16 2.16pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

That's over 44 years. I'm one of those people that unfortunately people tend to confide in. One was a girlfriend of a friend, one was a girl I was at school with, two were people I managed in a shop and the other was a daughter of my mums friend - My mum told be about it).

Thinking about it, I can think of two more. I'm like the noncewhisperer

Harsh. Horrible for the victims but not very nice for you to have to hear about either.

 




LABoxers Flag Wallington 25 Feb 16 3.27pm

Sorry are there no males leaders at Brownies then?

 

rikz Flag Croydon 25 Feb 16 3.57pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It depends is your daughter homeless or in care? If so, then they're at risk from both groups, if not the risks are slightly higher in the group ran by men, than women, because of their gender.

The reality of such targeted abuse is that they target vulnerable children, typically 'troublesome' kids, those in care and those with problems they can exploit.

Particularly involving abuse with multiple Muslim men, the focus is very much around targeting vulnerable kids that people like social services and the police won't be interested in. Its like people who rape prostitutes, they do so because they know the police won't give a s**t, the CPS don't care.

The offenders tend to be responsible for the act, the status of the victim tends to be the determining factor in whether anyone will do anything about it.

Seriously, come on, paedophilia is a much higher problem within the male population, I would say it's almost none existent within the female population. Female paedophiles/child killers are so rare that they go down in history among the most infamous criminals.

And without excusing what they do they are usually working alongside a male that they are fixated, obsessed, Controlled or even abused by.
Genuine question has there ever been a woman who has been convicted of paedophilia who worked entirely alone or a female only pedophile ring ?

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cub leaders