You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Hillsborough Verdict
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Hillsborough Verdict


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 26 Apr 16 10.39pm

I cant believe there are people on here still blaming the fans. What will it take?
Duckenfield; Thatcher; The Sun; The Police Federation. Lying scum the lot of them. Your in good company.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Apr 16 11.14pm

Originally posted by kevlee

I cant believe there are people on here still blaming the fans. What will it take?
Duckenfield; Thatcher; The Sun; The Police Federation. Lying scum the lot of them. Your in good company.

I don't think there are people blaming fans, just saying that events prior to this gave a picture of what can occur. This would've given the inexperienced Duckendale more reason to make knee jerk decisions. Nit the fans fault but his, and those who gave him the role.

By accounts it appears he was prepared for hooliganism before safe crowd control. The Home Office and Thatcher didn't know of his inexperience when visiting Hillsborough days after. I'm not saying the Police are not responsible because of fan reputation because they are. Well those in charge were responsible for all people on the day, young, old, fit, weak, whatever, they have a duty of care.

But saying there is no evidence that LFC were there without tickets, you cannot prove that either way but they can say this is not the reason it happened. The dozen reasons are why it happened.

Lots of clubs were trying to get in ticketless in those days. I've just read on the BBS Spurs had the same problem in the LLEnd in 1981 vs Wolves and people suffered broken arms and legs. Spurs used to try entry without tickets. They also had a crush outside the Wembley gate in 1987. Those who got in passed their unused tickets to those who didn't have tickets. Should the fans be doing this? No. Did the Sheffield Police or Wembley correct their failings with stadia and organising? No.

It was a minority doing it and if policed and organised properly would never have resulted in injury whatsoever. Reducing capacity would've been a start years before.

I do not blame LFC fans then. It could've been anyone. Us the year after if in small pens rather than big terraces like The Holte End or The Stretford End.

If there were ticketless fans then there should've been measures dealing with it. But I have trouble understanding LFC fans who climb over walls to add to full capacity now. It happened in the 3-3 game. Climbing over the WH End walls to get in their away end or anywhere. Again, nobody stewarding or policing where needed.

 


COYP

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 26 Apr 16 11.28pm

Thatcher was trying to use Hillsborough to get a national ID Card scheme. It took the Taylor Report to scupper that. She was all set to use the tragedy to advance her agenda. The local MP at that time, a Tory, was telling anyone who would listen it was down to drunken hooligans who even tried to urinate on police and ambulance workers. That lie was exposed in the 2012 Independent Inquiry.

When I came to Britain in 1989, cash turnstiles were a shock to me. We never had that at any major sporting ground in the US. The semi was "all-ticket," so that wasn't a factor. As many have posted here, including Rudi, Cucking and more, today is the day that the real reasons for the deaths of the 96 were cemented into the law. There was a failure to uphold a duty of care. The police hierarchy failed to properly plan prior to the match, failed to brief their subordinate constables adequately enough and failed to react as the situation worsened. The commander lied about an order he issued. Sheffield Wednesday failed to provide a safe facility for the match. They failed to heed warnings that the facility had serious problems that needed to be addressed. They failed to train their employees, particularly match day stewards, and failed to place them at critical safety positions. They also failed to obtain a current safety certificate, which should have disqualified them from hosting a match of the magnitude of a FA Cup semi final. That, as I see it, is the verdict of the jury.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 26 Apr 16 11.58pm

The following links are the official transcripts for today's verdicts. The actual verdict and the recording of individual cause and times of death are at this link:

[Link]

The signing of the records of inquest for each of the 96 is here. Only the seven jurors who voted for "unlawful killing" were permitted to sign.

[Link]

The next link is for the General Questionnaire for the Jury's Determination. This document contains the answers to the 14 Questions with reasons for finding. The criteria for Question 6, Unlawful Killing, are the last two pages.

[Link]

The last link is for the Individual Questionnaires For the Jury's Determination. This gives the official medical cause and time of death for each victim.

[Link]

All documents, trial transcripts, witness statements and rulings by HM Coronor Lord Justice Goldring are available at:

[Link]

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

OldFella Flag London 27 Apr 16 12.48am

Originally posted by kenbarr

Thatcher was trying to use Hillsborough to get a national ID Card scheme. It took the Taylor Report to scupper that. She was all set to use the tragedy to advance her agenda. The local MP at that time, a Tory, was telling anyone who would listen it was down to drunken hooligans who even tried to urinate on police and ambulance workers. That lie was exposed in the 2012 Independent Inquiry.

When I came to Britain in 1989, cash turnstiles were a shock to me. We never had that at any major sporting ground in the US. The semi was "all-ticket," so that wasn't a factor. As many have posted here, including Rudi, Cucking and more, today is the day that the real reasons for the deaths of the 96 were cemented into the law. There was a failure to uphold a duty of care. The police hierarchy failed to properly plan prior to the match, failed to brief their subordinate constables adequately enough and failed to react as the situation worsened. The commander lied about an order he issued. Sheffield Wednesday failed to provide a safe facility for the match. They failed to heed warnings that the facility had serious problems that needed to be addressed. They failed to train their employees, particularly match day stewards, and failed to place them at critical safety positions. They also failed to obtain a current safety certificate, which should have disqualified them from hosting a match of the magnitude of a FA Cup semi final. That, as I see it, is the verdict of the jury.

You are one seriously opinionated man. Just saying...

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Apr 16 1.28am

Originally posted by OldFella

You are one seriously opinionated man. Just saying...

He's entitled to it, and I fully concur with him.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Apr 16 6.59am

Originally posted by kenbarr

[Link]

Finally, after 27 years, those responsible for the unnecessary deaths of 96 people are being called to book. By a 7-2 vote, the jury concluded that these deaths were the result of criminal negligence (unlawful killing) due to the failure of police command to adequately plan and as well as opening the exit gate which is blamed as the proximate cause of the crush. Sheffield Wednesday is being held responsible for their share in failing to insure safety. I wish the FA's decision to choose Hillsborough for that match even though they knew, or should have known, that there were crushes at several semi finals held there going back to 1981. the supporters were held blameless (Question 7). Can we now acknowledge that this was not due to drunkeness or hooliganism. This was down to incompetence rising to a criminal level by people responsible for one thing, safety. That an incompetent police commander failed to do his duty. That an English Football Club, whose chairman was quoted as saying any threat of a life threatening crush was "nonsense" put his wallet ahead of ticket buying customers. That things we take for granted at Selhurst Park, competent policing, dedicated turnstiles for terrace sections, as they were when the Holmesdale was a three section terrace, didn't exist at Hillsborough with fatal consequences.

Very well written, Kenbarr.

I'd like to hope that everyday conscientious folk will stop buying The Sun as protest for their heinous, shoddy, arrogant treatment of Liverpool fans, especially under the editorship of Kelvin Mackenzie. And The Sun's response to yesterday's legal landmark = relegated to pp 8-9.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 16 8.10am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don't think there are people blaming fans, just saying that events prior to this gave a picture of what can occur. This would've given the inexperienced Duckendale more reason to make knee jerk decisions. Nit the fans fault but his, and those who gave him the role.

By accounts it appears he was prepared for hooliganism before safe crowd control. The Home Office and Thatcher didn't know of his inexperience when visiting Hillsborough days after. I'm not saying the Police are not responsible because of fan reputation because they are. Well those in charge were responsible for all people on the day, young, old, fit, weak, whatever, they have a duty of care.

But saying there is no evidence that LFC were there without tickets, you cannot prove that either way but they can say this is not the reason it happened. The dozen reasons are why it happened.

Lots of clubs were trying to get in ticketless in those days. I've just read on the BBS Spurs had the same problem in the LLEnd in 1981 vs Wolves and people suffered broken arms and legs. Spurs used to try entry without tickets. They also had a crush outside the Wembley gate in 1987. Those who got in passed their unused tickets to those who didn't have tickets. Should the fans be doing this? No. Did the Sheffield Police or Wembley correct their failings with stadia and organising? No.

It was a minority doing it and if policed and organised properly would never have resulted in injury whatsoever. Reducing capacity would've been a start years before.

I do not blame LFC fans then. It could've been anyone. Us the year after if in small pens rather than big terraces like The Holte End or The Stretford End.

If there were ticketless fans then there should've been measures dealing with it. But I have trouble understanding LFC fans who climb over walls to add to full capacity now. It happened in the 3-3 game. Climbing over the WH End walls to get in their away end or anywhere. Again, nobody stewarding or policing where needed.

We had a similar experience at WHL in the cup which for anyone who was there was not a good experience - pens full to absolute bursting point before the police finally saw something wasn't right and opened up another to relieve the crushing - for anyone attending games in the 80's, Hillsborough has a feel of 'there but for the grace of god' about it.

As for Hillsbrough - its just a litany of mistakes and errors which when added together caused the death of 96 people - I know from a Forest fan who was there that day that mobs of Liverpool fans without tickets tried to get in to the Forest end at one point so it did happen (and as you say continues to do so) and probably gives a pointer to the police actions on the day in terms of attitude and crowd control.

To suggest that there wasn't a wide spread attempt for ticketless fans to get in stretches incredulity. It happened and most big games in the 80's for mostclubs and certainly was something Liverpool fans excelled in, both following their club and at England away games which I personally witnessed

All said and done it is simply another factor that lead to the deaths of 96 people but alongside Duckenfield, Thatcher, McKenzie et al there should be some people alive today who attended that game who need to have a look at themselves as well for the possibly small part they played in adding to the days event.

Edited by The Sash (27 Apr 2016 8.14am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 16 8.20am

Originally posted by kevlee

I cant believe there are people on here still blaming the fans. What will it take?
Duckenfield; Thatcher; The Sun; The Police Federation. Lying scum the lot of them. Your in good company.

I think over the years anyone who's dare to suggest that some LFC fans may have had a part to play in this, however small, are seen as siding with the obvious mis-handling, error strewn policing, the odious s*** McKenzie or Thatchers use of this politically and somehow insinuating that 96 people contributed to their own deaths - far from it.


To suggest though that this was apparently the only 'ticketed' game where Liverpool didn't have a significant number of fans turn up without tickets and try to gain entry in some way shape or form is incredible in the extreme.

It was a widespread facet of 80's football and certainly something that Liverpool, amongst others, had form in. I know that Liverpool fans tried to gain entry to the Forest end that day from a Forest fan who was there.

Now what that had as a contributory factor is impossible to gauge - did it lead to police making incorrect decisions to open gates just to deal with the larger than expected numbers all trying to get in ? Did it colour the attitude to policing on that day so its was far more focused around 'hooliganism' than safety, (which was pretty much the default police position across every force in the country anyway) ?

All said and done it really doesn't matter, its a minor piece of this.

What matters is that 96 people died from a catalogue of events, decisions and issues which started when a ground that should never have hosted the game was selected - it shows the level football fans were treated and how they where thought of that it didn't even have a safety certificate

There are people who should be brought to account for themselves either legally or simply through media scrutiny - don't hold your breath though - they wont be.


Edited by The Sash (27 Apr 2016 9.10am)

Edited by The Sash (27 Apr 2016 9.13am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 27 Apr 16 9.12am

What i didn't realise until yesterday is that the inquest knew how many fans were on the terraces via clicked turnstiles just before the gates were opened. There was room for 10,000 and just 5,800 were on it - i.e had tickets - so another 4,000 at least were outside just before kick off for an all-ticket affair in that tight bottleneck.

That totally dissolves any culpability at all on ticketless fans in my book. And there would have been hundreds of them there.

Here's what Duckenfield has had to say most recently:

[Link]

"I think it's fair to say that it is arguably one of the biggest regrets of my life"

'One' of the biggest regrets? What else have you fvcked up to that level then?

The 'man' is a fvcking disgrace and I hope he is haunted by this until his dying day.

Edited by Kermit8 (27 Apr 2016 9.13am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 27 Apr 16 9.17am

Originally posted by Kermit8

What i didn't realise until yesterday is that the inquest knew how many fans were on the terraces via clicked turnstiles just before the gates were opened. There was room for 10,000 and just 5,800 were on it - i.e had tickets - so another 4,000 at least were outside just before kick off for an all-ticket affair in that tight bottleneck.

That totally dissolves any culpability at all on ticketless fans in my book. And there would have been hundreds of them there.

Here's what Duckenfield has had to say most recently:

[Link]

"I think it's fair to say that it is arguably one of the biggest regrets of my life"

'One' of the biggest regrets? What else have you fvcked up to that level then?

The 'man' is a fvcking disgrace and I hope he is haunted by this until his dying day.

Edited by Kermit8 (27 Apr 2016 9.13am)

One ???? Christ - what else has he done - smash prostitutes with hammers ? Rape puppies in front of nursery school children ?

To be fair slightly to Duckenfield, I can sympathise that he is in a position that day where he has to make hard decisions in dynamic circumstances and under pressure and even as an experienced senior Policeman, he is human and humans f*** up - the issue I personally have with him is his obvious feeding of disinformation and downright lies in the aftermath....


Edited by The Sash (27 Apr 2016 9.20am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 27 Apr 16 9.24am

Originally posted by The Sash

One ???? Christ - what else has he done - smash prostitutes with hammers ? Rape puppies in front of nursery school children ?

To be fair slightly to Duckenfield, I can sympathise that he is in a position that day where he has to make hard decisions in dynamic circumstances and under pressure and even as an experienced senior Policeman, he is human and humans f*** up - the issue I personally have with him is his obvious feeding of disinformation and downright lies in the aftermath....

My sentiments exactly. Whatever went wrong on the day, people made judgement calls to the best of their ability. The fact that they were found wanting is one thing (and raises questions about the who is responsible, the individual or the organisations)but to lie like they have since is unforgivable.


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (27 Apr 2016 9.25am)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 9.59am

Originally posted by The Sash

One ???? Christ - what else has he done - smash prostitutes with hammers ? Rape puppies in front of nursery school children ?

To be fair slightly to Duckenfield, I can sympathise that he is in a position that day where he has to make hard decisions in dynamic circumstances and under pressure and even as an experienced senior Policeman, he is human and humans f*** up - the issue I personally have with him is his obvious feeding of disinformation and downright lies in the aftermath....

Agree.

 


COYP

hibbystu Flag tadworth 27 Apr 16 10.05am

I am so glad that it has been proved in a court of law, that no one was pissed and everyone had a valid ticket

 


I support Scotland, Hibs and the Palace, no glory hunters here!!!!!!

PLEASE SIR, CAN I HAVE A PIE!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 10.05am

Originally posted by The Sash

I think over the years anyone who's dare to suggest that some LFC fans may have had a part to play in this, however small, are seen as siding with the obvious mis-handling, error strewn policing, the odious s*** McKenzie or Thatchers use of this politically and somehow insinuating that 96 people contributed to their own deaths - far from it.


To suggest though that this was apparently the only 'ticketed' game where Liverpool didn't have a significant number of fans turn up without tickets and try to gain entry in some way shape or form is incredible in the extreme.

It was a widespread facet of 80's football and certainly something that Liverpool, amongst others, had form in. I know that Liverpool fans tried to gain entry to the Forest end that day from a Forest fan who was there.

Now what that had as a contributory factor is impossible to gauge - did it lead to police making incorrect decisions to open gates just to deal with the larger than expected numbers all trying to get in ? Did it colour the attitude to policing on that day so its was far more focused around 'hooliganism' than safety, (which was pretty much the default police position across every force in the country anyway) ?

All said and done it really doesn't matter, its a minor piece of this.

What matters is that 96 people died from a catalogue of events, decisions and issues which started when a ground that should never have hosted the game was selected - it shows the level football fans were treated and how they where thought of that it didn't even have a safety certificate

There are people who should be brought to account for themselves either legally or simply through media scrutiny - don't hold your breath though - they wont be.

I agree with the ticketless issue. It may or may not have contributed to what happened but if it did it was certainly not the only reason and they should be able to deal with it as it was happening every season for 2,3,4 semis and replays and cup finals and replays for that matter. Reduce capacity, don't open the gates, have enough turnstyles open, have stewards directing people. If there is a crush outside there is at least space at the back, although difficult to instruct. In a pen there is nowhere. Of course it shouldn't get to a crush anyway. Delay KO, stagger people somehow before that tight area.

I think this did add to how the Police image of every football fan spread...

'Did it (ticketless fans) colour the attitude to policing on that day so its was far more focused around 'hooliganism' than safety, (which was pretty much the default police position across every force in the country anyway)'

 


COYP

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 27 Apr 16 10.09am

Times were different. The police were Thatcher's blue-eyed boot boys and they thought they could get away with murder back then. Or in this case manslaughter. The Tories would never ever go against the police or their right-wing media buddies but the problems of corruption started well before Maggie turned up tbf. Surrey Police and the Guildford Four back in the mid-seventies a case in point.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Kermit8 Flag Hevon 27 Apr 16 10.16am

Originally posted by The Sash

One ???? Christ - what else has he done - smash prostitutes with hammers ? Rape puppies in front of nursery school children ?

To be fair slightly to Duckenfield, I can sympathise that he is in a position that day where he has to make hard decisions in dynamic circumstances and under pressure and even as an experienced senior Policeman, he is human and humans f*** up - the issue I personally have with him is his obvious feeding of disinformation and downright lies in the aftermath....


Edited by The Sash (27 Apr 2016 9.20am)

What still is astounding even taking into account the human error element is how close the police viewing box with Duckenfield in it was to the Leppings Lane end. Even Stevie Wonder could have seen that the end pens were just over half full whilst the middle ones were rammed at around 2.45.

Ralph Wiggum could have done a better job.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Apr 16 10.17am

Originally posted by The Sash

We had a similar experience at WHL in the cup which for anyone who was there was not a good experience - pens full to absolute bursting point before the police finally saw something wasn't right and opened up another to relieve the crushing - for anyone attending games in the 80's, Hillsborough has a feel of 'there but for the grace of god' about it.


The season before 1989 and in the league game between Spurs v Liverpool, Liverpool didn't have access to the pen next to Spurs in The Shelf. When it was opened due to overcrowding no doubt it was apparently seen as a 'come on then', which again makes these kinds of decisions difficult, but would be easier if there were enough stewards or Police they had in those days there in the gaps between pens before. No violence happened. LFC fans must've had a lot of experience with big games and tight terraces. Not a lot most of them coud do about it.

With regards to us, it could have happened to us or anyone with only ticket holding fans if in the wrong place and a catalogue of errors happened in quick succession. What if we playing our semi with terraces and small pens rather than the large open Holte End? vs Oldham at SWFC or if we had a semi at Spurs like Wimbledon did? It could've happened with just turning up within minutes of KO due to legal drinking and holding legit tickets to the match.

 


COYP

hibbystu Flag tadworth 27 Apr 16 10.19am

I am so glad that it has been proved in a court of law, that no one was pissed and everyone had a valid ticket

 


I support Scotland, Hibs and the Palace, no glory hunters here!!!!!!

PLEASE SIR, CAN I HAVE A PIE!!

Hoof Hearted 27 Apr 16 10.25am

Originally posted by hibbystu

I am so glad that it has been proved in a court of law, that no one was pissed and everyone had a valid ticket

But they do say the law is an ass Stu!

Sadly, because of the previous cover ups by police, government etc and putting ALL the blame on the fans, no one is even allowed to suggest that even one person from Liverpool had a schooner of sherry that day and wasn't holding a valid ticket.

Even the choice of a predominately female jury that would concur with this ridiculous notion was arranged.

Anyhow..... all our lives are a lot safer today as a result of the lessons learned from that awful tragedy.

I think there should be prosecutions for those people that arranged the cover up and the lies, but as for prosecuting Duckenfield? He already looks a broken man to me.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Hillsborough Verdict