You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Military Coup Attempt in Turkey
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Military Coup Attempt in Turkey


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 16 Jul 16 5.15pm

Originally posted by danincyp

Don't get too misty eyed about the turks , they invaded Cyprus with the Russians egging them on. they are strategically placed for Putin in what is a NATO battlefront.

With the Colonels in Athens egging on the Greek Cypriots to implement Enosis (Greek and Cypriot 'unification'.

The Turks may have over-reacted but had cause to do so.

 

danincyp Flag Old Bexley 16 Jul 16 5.21pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

With the Colonels in Athens egging on the Greek Cypriots to implement Enosis (Greek and Cypriot 'unification'.

The Turks may have over-reacted but had cause to do so.

I agree to a certain extent but it's beside the point, incidentally we and the yanks didn't help that particular situation.
The turks are a volatile lot and don't really have sympathy for the West . I couldn't predict which way they'd jump.
They certainly shouldnt be embraced in Europe.

Edited by danincyp (16 Jul 2016 5.21pm)

 


"I never did give anyone hell. I just told the truth and they thought it was hell."

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 16 Jul 16 5.29pm

Originally posted by danincyp

I agree to a certain extent but it's beside the point, incidentally we and the yanks didn't help that particular situation.
The turks are a volatile lot and don't really have sympathy for the West . I couldn't predict which way they'd jump.
They certainly shouldnt be embraced in Europe.

Edited by danincyp (16 Jul 2016 5.21pm)

As I implied there are serious question marks over Erdogan and where he wants to take Turkey, but for our safety best keep them in the Western orbit.

Anyway, Turkey have no particular love for Russia, historically or now. And they're probably only welcome in TRNC because of all the 'dirty money' they fritter away in the casinos.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 16 Jul 16 9.47pm

Originally posted by truleigh

Anyone supporting the coup calling themselves democrates would really be hypocrites.

This exactly.

People talk democracy all the time on this site and then support a military coup that is totally unsupported by Govenment, opposition and the people alike. That's why the coup failed, absolutely no support for it.

Believing in democracy but only if the view one supports prevails, is not democracy.

Many dead, more than a thousand civilians injured, thousands of arrests. It's always easy for people in other countries to talk about a coup elsewhere when they sit here watching X Factor and all it has done is strengthen Erdogan. He can now say that he is the one that stood up for democracy, even while closing down opposition disent.

If the Turks want Imans, hippies, neo cons, socialists or telly tubbies to run their country and they vote for it, then good luck to them. They have the same right to determine their own future, through the ballot, as we do here.

It's served us well in terms of stability, even though I don't always agree with our politicians. I still enjoy the benefits of a generally peaceful society and I respect the vote, even if I choose not to exercise that right, all the time..

I would rather see a Democratic theocracy, than a military dictatorship, if that's what the people want and vote for it.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 16 Jul 16 9.55pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

This exactly.

People talk democracy all the time on this site and then support a military coup that is totally unsupported by Govenment, opposition and the people alike. That's why the coup failed, absolutely no support for it.

Believing in democracy but only if the view one supports prevails, is not democracy.

Many dead, more than a thousand civilians injured, thousands of arrests. It's always easy for people in other countries to talk about a coup elsewhere when they sit here watching X Factor and all it has done is strengthen Erdogan. He can now say that he is the one that stood up for democracy, even while closing down opposition disent.

If the Turks want Imans, hippies, neo cons, socialists or telly tubbies to run their country and they vote for it, then good luck to them. They have the same right to determine their own future, through the ballot, as we do here.

It's served us well in terms of stability, even though I don't always agree with our politicians. I still enjoy the benefits of a generally peaceful society and I respect the vote, even if I choose not to exercise that right, all the time..

I would rather see a Democratic theocracy, than a military dictatorship, if that's what the people want and vote for it.

...unless, of course, it is the military who are taking a stand in support of secular democracy and standing up to someone in power whose agenda is very much to undermine it for their own ends.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Jul 16 9.57pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

This exactly.

People talk democracy all the time on this site and then support a military coup that is totally unsupported by Govenment, opposition and the people alike. That's why the coup failed, absolutely no support for it.

Believing in democracy but only if the view one supports prevails, is not democracy.

Many dead, more than a thousand civilians injured, thousands of arrests. It's always easy for people in other countries to talk about a coup elsewhere when they sit here watching X Factor and all it has done is strengthen Erdogan. He can now say that he is the one that stood up for democracy, even while closing down opposition disent.

If the Turks want Imans, hippies, neo cons, socialists or telly tubbies to run their country and they vote for it, then good luck to them. They have the same right to determine their own future, through the ballot, as we do here.

It's served us well in terms of stability, even though I don't always agree with our politicians. I still enjoy the benefits of a generally peaceful society and I respect the vote, even if I choose not to exercise that right, all the time..

I would rather see a Democratic theocracy, than a military dictatorship, if that's what the people want and vote for it.

If the choice was a coup or civil war - would you still say good luck?

 

turkish eagle Flag 16 Jul 16 10.12pm

Confused about last night? In one sentence here it is...

'soldiers attempting to overthrow a democratically elected government that is undemocratic in its abuse of power in order to restore democracy.'

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 16 Jul 16 10.24pm

Originally posted by turkish eagle

Confused about last night? In one sentence here it is...

'soldiers attempting to overthrow a democratically elected government that is undemocratic in its abuse of power in order to restore democracy.'

Very good

Have to remember though, in regard to respecting democracy, that the National Socialists swept into power fairly in 1933 in Germany with enough of a free vote too.

Second referendum please.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


turkish eagle Flag 16 Jul 16 10.32pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Very good

Have to remember though, in regard to respecting democracy, that the National Socialists swept into power fairly in 1933 in Germany with enough of a free vote too.

Second referendum please.

They weren't as popular as the ruling party which got close to half the vote last year. And yes they abuse their power to consolidate their own by taking over newspapers. jailing journalists and creating a climate of fear and intimidation of the opposition.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Jul 16 10.32pm

Originally posted by turkish eagle

Confused about last night? In one sentence here it is...

'soldiers attempting to overthrow a democratically elected government that is undemocratic in its abuse of power in order to restore democracy.'

And removing 2700 judges is democratic?

 

turkish eagle Flag 16 Jul 16 10.35pm

Originally posted by chris123

And removing 2700 judges is democratic?

No, its the continued abuse of that power they legitimately obtained through the ballot box by telling lies and creating a climate of fear and using the army to harass the voters in areas that they were unpopular in, on the grounds of the need for security.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 16 Jul 16 11.06pm

Originally posted by chris123

If the choice was a coup or civil war - would you still say good luck?

But that's not the choice is it.

What civil war are you talking about, Turkey was not heading for civil war.

All the opposition parties and even The self exiled cleric, Fethullah Gulen came out condeming the coup attempt, that was not the reason for the coup.

The reason was that some elements of the military, still want the society to be totally secular, harking back a 100 years ago to the ideals of a much loved dictator. That despite the fact that the people voted for change.

They have had opportunity to change the current govenment, they voted on a new constitution, They have elected their first President and had general elections. That's a mandate in my book.

They got the mood of the country very wrong and will now pay the price. They have damaged their own cause by trying to use violence because that is what they have always done when they didn't like what was going on.

Turkey has moved on since then after nearly 40 years of Democracy. No one in the country wanted to see Turkey slide back to the old ways of military dictatorship and in this modern age, Military coups are not the way to bring about positive change.

In addition, I will always say "good luck" to any attempt to establish a democratic ideal.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Mr Palaceman Flag 16 Jul 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

...unless, of course, it is the military who are taking a stand in support of secular democracy and standing up to someone in power whose agenda is very much to undermine it for their own ends.

If the people do not vote for a totally secular country, then it is not democracy to try and impose one because some elements of the military think it is better.

Also, if all in the military supported the coup, it is hard to see how the current govenment would have suceeded in suppressing it, other than by calling on the country to stand up for their right to vote for the type of govenment they want, even if they don't actually support the govenment.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

blackpalacefan Flag 17 Jul 16 3.51am

Lots thrown about conerning how the country is a 'democracy'. Yes one where the government runs the TV stations and freedom of speech and information is heavily restricted. When people make decisions based on a 'lack of' information, they often do not even fully know what they are supporting. Fear plays a part too. Those trying to stage this coup were brave. I am willing to acknowledge that and I wish they had succeeded.

Edited by blackpalacefan (17 Jul 2016 4.12am)

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 17 Jul 16 9.37am

Originally posted by blackpalacefan

Lots thrown about conerning how the country is a 'democracy'. Yes one where the government runs the TV stations and freedom of speech and information is heavily restricted. When people make decisions based on a 'lack of' information, they often do not even fully know what they are supporting. Fear plays a part too. Those trying to stage this coup were brave. I am willing to acknowledge that and I wish they had succeeded.

Edited by blackpalacefan (17 Jul 2016 4.12am)

I find myself in total agreement with your view.

Edited by Mr_Gristle (17 Jul 2016 9.37am)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

turkish eagle Flag 17 Jul 16 12.54pm

Too little is known about who was behind this attempted coup. I wouldn't jump to conclusions and assume that it was to 'restore' democracy just yet, let's see who main players are, it's quite possible that if it succeeded it could have been a tilt towards an official dictatorship rather than one that would lead towards a better more democratic society.

 

blackpalacefan Flag 17 Jul 16 1.25pm

Originally posted by turkish eagle

Too little is known about who was behind this attempted coup. I wouldn't jump to conclusions and assume that it was to 'restore' democracy just yet, let's see who main players are, it's quite possible that if it succeeded it could have been a tilt towards an official dictatorship rather than one that would lead towards a better more democratic society.

I think there are false flag elements to it too possibly. These massive changes to the military and the judiciary would've been impossible otherwise. All you'd need to do was to encourage a weak coup and then it's a done deal. Soldiers typically follow orders. From the footage and reports it's clear that lots of these young conscripts didn't even know that they were part of a coup.

It wouldn't be the first time Erdogan has attempted to create a piece of theatre in order to manipulate the population. This video he tried to ban from 2014 was very damning [Link]

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Jul 16 2.20pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Not to mention that France and Austria have already stated that they would put it to referendum, which would almost definitely result in a veto.


Indeed the front of the queue would have been Cyprus, Greece and Germany

 

blackpalacefan Flag 17 Jul 16 6.11pm

'France’s foreign minister has said Turkey may no longer be a viable partner in the fight against Isis in Syria, while Syrian state media has claimed the failed coup in the country was fabricated by President Erdogan to tarnish the military's reputation.' [Link]

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jul 16 10.00am

Originally posted by blackpalacefan

Lots thrown about conerning how the country is a 'democracy'. Yes one where the government runs the TV stations and freedom of speech and information is heavily restricted. When people make decisions based on a 'lack of' information, they often do not even fully know what they are supporting. Fear plays a part too. Those trying to stage this coup were brave. I am willing to acknowledge that and I wish they had succeeded.

Edited by blackpalacefan (17 Jul 2016 4.12am)

Turkey was headed down the same democratic road as Russia. The problem of democracy is that it requires that the state and majority are controlled by the rule of law, and rights, otherwise it simply becomes a tyranny of the majority - and that requires a clear separation of state and religion.

As for the coup, I'm not entirely sold on the idea it was in the right, but then the Turkish governments of recent years have been undermining the secularity of the state and the concept of democracy.

Clearly, a large section of the military were involved and considered that the regime, and its policies, were sufficiently damaging to need to act, and co-ordinated a fairly large scale conspiracy to implement a coup aimed at toppling the regime.

Now whether the military were right is contentious, shades of grey is the morality of coups, revolutions and the like, but its certainly not the case that these actions are always wrong because they 'aren't democratic'.

For democracy to be democracy, it has to be more than just most popular opinion rules.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Military Coup Attempt in Turkey