You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ledley & McArthur


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 4.08pm

Originally posted by silvertop

...In spades.

Which is more than I can say for Flamini. He got left for dead yesterday and could have cost us a goal [if it was anyone but Stoke]. I can't recall the last time I saw one of our players so well beaten for pace. Hopefully, this is something the coaches are working on to get him back to full match fitness.

Wasn't he just. He seemed to start sprinting and then slowed down after 2/3 paces. I couldn't believe it. We cannot have that with a normal scoreline. He'll have to be brought up to pace before he can be considered a real option or he'll be a liability.

 


COYP

Username Flag Horsham 19 Sep 16 4.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Wasn't he just. He seemed to start sprinting and then slowed down after 2/3 paces. I couldn't believe it. We cannot have that with a normal scoreline. He'll have to be brought up to pace before he can be considered a real option or he'll be a liability.

Said to my Dad at full time that Flamini badly needed those minutes.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Mr. Mainstand Flag west norwood 19 Sep 16 5.37pm

Early days of course, but it will be interesting to see who gets player of the year. I think McArthur would be a very well deserved and popular winner.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 19 Sep 16 6.55pm

Well Cabaye won't be match fit, so Ledley starts. But I still bring Cabaye on at say 66 min (earlier if we are chasing the game).

If all are healthy, I expect Cabaye and McArthur to start, with Ledley to sub on when needed.

I haven't looked at stats, but both Ledley and Cabaye are solid defensively, but I'd bet that Cabaye is miles better on interceptions. Cabaye is a better playmaker by far, and makes life difficult. No contest for me.

Now just make sure Benteke takes the penalties...

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 19 Sep 16 6.58pm

Joe Ledley is hugely underrated. I reckon our win ratio with him in the side is pretty good, better than Cabaye and McArthur perhaps. That is only a gut feeling but I am sure someone with far more time than I will prove me wrong!

 

palace-metros Flag Redhill 19 Sep 16 7.16pm

This really should be no surprise. When Jedi went off to the Asian Cup, we played Ledley & Macca and won eight of the 12 games from 10th January 2015. It's a combination that worked then and works now. Injuries and the arrival of Cabaye have largely prevented it from being tried again until recently.

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 19 Sep 16 7.18pm

Originally posted by citizensmudge

You remember the Spurs game Parrot? Cabaye replaced Ledley at half time and it changed the game massively because of Cabayes ability to get the team moving forward. Ledley and Cabaye are pretty well matched defensively but Cabaye offers a dimension offensively that Ledley just doesn't have in his locker. They will all be rotated Flamini included once hes matchfit but the big games will be JMac and Cabaye if everyones 100%.

Yep. Didn't Punch play alongside Ledley? Completely different to the point I was trying to make.

Macca and Ledley are a partnership and its working both defensively and offensively.

We need to play what works well and not tinker just because a star player returns from injury.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Removal Man Flag London 19 Sep 16 7.38pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Joe Ledley is hugely underrated. I reckon our win ratio with him in the side is pretty good, better than Cabaye and McArthur perhaps. That is only a gut feeling but I am sure someone with far more time than I will prove me wrong!

A quick count up on Soccerbase gives win percentages of Ledley 50% - 34/68 Cabaye 43% - 17/40 and McArthur 47% - 29/62.

This is the bare statistics of all games each has been involved in and includes sub appearance and all competitions.

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.39pm)

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.46pm)

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.46pm)

 

bicycle repair man 19 Sep 16 8.04pm

Ledley was excellent against Stoke ,as was Mcarthur.
I thought Ledley's days were numbered but I was wrong.Playing with players who are perhaps more gifted than him in some departments has improved his game.He is playing to his strengths ,winning the ball and supplying the playmakers.Most teams need someone like that,and I think he will get a lot of games this season.

 

teedee Flag Croydon 19 Sep 16 8.50pm

McArthur was the best player on the pitch by a mile and he is not 100% fit yet

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 20 Sep 16 2.47am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

We shouldn't forget we played similarly brilliantly with Cabaye in the team at the start of last season. However, away from home especially the McArthur/Ledley combination seems to just work.

It's not always about playing the best players, it's the best combinations. Look at the Gerrard/Lampard conundrum England had for years, two unbelievable players but they didn't work together.

The balance of the team is more important. Cabaye has lost his place as far as I'm concerned and must earn it back as McPunchley (sorry) is working a treat at the moment.

I prefer McLuncheon!

The thing to remember is not that Cabaye and McArthur worked well together, but that when they weren't in together our second option didn't offer much. We are currently playing well and the combo that got us high up the table in December is the potential fall back plan. That's a good feeling.

Last season we were worried when Bolasie was out injured. We missed Macca plain and simple. Please Pards wrap him in cotton wool.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 20 Sep 16 4.11am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

its McArthur thats the key here
Ledley is average
Flamini is better than both he and Cabaye

Edited by Croydonlad (19 Sep 2016 2.27am)

Based on what. He was average atbeat last season at Arsenal?

I think he is probably the worst of the bunch ability wise but is a wise old head and decent cover.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 20 Sep 16 8.26am

Originally posted by Removal Man

A quick count up on Soccerbase gives win percentages of Ledley 50% - 34/68 Cabaye 43% - 17/40 and McArthur 47% - 29/62.

This is the bare statistics of all games each has been involved in and includes sub appearance and all competitions.

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.39pm)

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.46pm)

Edited by Removal Man (19 Sep 2016 7.46pm)

Thanks. So my instinct was right albeit not by much. Over the course of a peen season we would take a 50% win rate.

 

glaziermart Flag 20 Sep 16 3.41pm

Never change a winning team is the old saying. It will be interesting if Cabaye gets his place back as soon as he is fit again, as it will vindicate those who think he is Pardew's favourite

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Sep 16 4.25pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

Never change a winning team is the old saying. It will be interesting if Cabaye gets his place back as soon as he is fit again, as it will vindicate those who think he is Pardew's favourite

What if he gets his place back, plays a blinder and we beat Sunderland 5 0

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 20 Sep 16 6.16pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

What if he gets his place back, plays a blinder and we beat Sunderland 5 0

If that's the case it will be "luck" that AP bought him into the side and absolutely nothing to do with Cabayes class or AP's ability as a manager.Should we only scrape a win or worse AP will be a w***er and there will be calls to sell Cabaye in January from certain sections on this forum.

Edited by citizensmudge (20 Sep 2016 6.16pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Sep 16 6.35pm

Originally posted by citizensmudge

If that's the case it will be "luck" that AP bought him into the side and absolutely nothing to do with Cabayes class or AP's ability as a manager.Should we only scrape a win or worse AP will be a w***er and there will be calls to sell Cabaye in January from certain sections on this forum.

Edited by citizensmudge (20 Sep 2016 6.16pm)

Ho ho ho. Nah. Hysterical. Pardew bought Cabaye and put him in with MacArthur to make one of our best midfield partnerships in our history. It's when that came to a halt it all went t1ts up.

And no I don't buy this intention to play MacArthur and Ledley when AP was having MacArthur, Cabaye, Jedinak, Punch sometimes in front of Ledley. But managers do find something that clicks when options are limited. Perfectly normal. Happens all the time. But you've made a big thing of it.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (20 Sep 2016 6.46pm)

 


COYP

citizensmudge Flag midlands 20 Sep 16 7.42pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Ho ho ho. Nah. Hysterical. Pardew bought Cabaye and put him in with MacArthur to make one of our best midfield partnerships in our history. It's when that came to a halt it all went t1ts up.

And no I don't buy this intention to play MacArthur and Ledley when AP was having MacArthur, Cabaye, Jedinak, Punch sometimes in front of Ledley. But managers do find something that clicks when options are limited. Perfectly normal. Happens all the time. But you've made a big thing of it.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (20 Sep 2016 6.46pm)

Listen you boring insignificant little boy, I had a similar conversation with you on another thread.You were all ballsy until I quoted actual facts about the subject and then you stopped posting and found a different thread to puke all over.What you don't realise is that while you do make some valid points occasionally the minute anyone challenges them you start posting in your default manner which is poncy,sanctimonious bellend.None of us are right all the time including you and also me but I will choose to side with those on here who manage to enjoy the result against Stoke for what it was in the grand scheme of things instead of attempting to dissect it and claim the ability to know what you simply cant. My comment above was completely tongue in cheek following on from someone elses similar post.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Sep 16 7.58pm

Originally posted by citizensmudge

Listen you boring insignificant little boy, I had a similar conversation with you on another thread.You were all ballsy until I quoted actual facts about the subject and then you stopped posting and found a different thread to puke all over.What you don't realise is that while you do make some valid points occasionally the minute anyone challenges them you start posting in your default manner which is poncy,sanctimonious bellend.None of us are right all the time including you and also me but I will choose to side with those on here who manage to enjoy the result against Stoke for what it was in the grand scheme of things instead of attempting to dissect it and claim the ability to know what you simply cant. My comment above was completely tongue in cheek following on from someone elses similar post.

Ironic coming from you of all people. You should read some of the pompous verbal sh&t you irritate people with, getting all chopsy at the same time. And you appreciating that other people are right? That's a f'ing joke, right?

I stopped posting in that thread because I can tell you're in a similar mould as Sg Bilko. Not as bad, but as stubborn and pointless continuing with. Do me a favour, get over yourself and your hubris from your armchair you think is a throne.

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 20 Sep 16 7.58pm

Bit harsh that people are judging Flamini on 10 minutes of football !!

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ledley & McArthur