You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last Night - Question To All
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Last Night - Question To All


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dazza Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 8.27am

As much as last night was a disgrace (I was one of the ones singing my heart out at the game) can I ask a question:

How long is it going to take AP/Owners to accept that players like Mutch, Fryers (Who was completely out of his depth not even sure he would make the Championship) Chungy ( Who had a lot of energy but no real end product) Sako are just not good enough and on last nights showing should not be anywhere near the first team squad.

Wickham also looked dis-interested and looks like he has accepted that now Benteke and Remy are here he will no longer play.

We have youngsters like Kalkai, Anderson, Williams (Who parses was only saying a few weeks back that he needs to see him more) Appiah, J Benteke, Boetang, Dreyher, surely these are the players that should be used in theses sort of games and would give us much more hunger, desire than the bunch did last night.

Anyone making excuses about last night really need to question themselves as it was a disgrace our first shot on target was on 82 minutes from Benteke who won more headers in the last 10 minutes than wickham did in 90.

What actually goes on at training as Fryers is terrible seriously bad makes me wonder what AP has been watching.

Yet again it has just proved we have no depth and could seriously be in trouble if we get some injuries and fear if we lose 2 CB cause we just have cover.

Let's hope we play like we did on Sunday against Sunderland.

Onwards and Upwards

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 Sep 16 8.42am

Do you not think they're trying to improve the squad bit by bit already?

Do you not think that the starting eleven (and fringes of it) are stronger than it was this time last year?

Jaysus some people simply have no patience at all!

-.-'

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

DivingIsNotGood Flag se25 22 Sep 16 8.50am

Fully agree with squad depth, great first 11 but shocking squad players. The biggest bugbear I got is not giving our youth a chance. Pardew is too arrogant to play them but with pressure he will, being the arrogant sh he is, he'll take full credit when they come on and have a stormer. He will say that they needed the time in lower league's to develop when we all know many young players simply sink or float. Last night was the ideal opportunity to try some of them out.

 


VOTING OUT - Brexit will allow Britain to embrace the Commonwealth and be GREAT again

Winch Eagle Flag Fleet, Hampshire 22 Sep 16 8.54am

I was one who said we had not had as great a transfer window as many had thought but I agreed with the argument Rome was not built in a day..
Most of these guys are on contracts with a decent wage attached so even if the will of the club is there if the player does not get the same wedge elsewhere he will not go.
Put into that the fact bad luck (to a degree) with both Tompkins and Pap being injured guys like Fryers need a game as with proved last. Night with Dann coming off we will need them to fill a shirt moving forward.
No excuses for last night but it was a numbers of players who are not quite good enough playing either their first game of the season or starting for the first time in a few weeks but what can he do?
With regards to the youngsters they would not realistically get in the team that beat Stoke so he has to either keep them here playing for the 23s in a non competitive league or blood them in eslsewhwere to progress them.
Frustrating I know.

 


Winch Eagle

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 22 Sep 16 8.55am

I think the rule changes re loans have been missed by many. We can no longer hold onto development/youth squad players for early cup games etc then loan them out. These guys need game time so it is in both theirs & the club's best interest to get them playing regularly which would not happen with us.

They are clearly, in the manager's opinion, not ready for the first team squad which needs a bit of EPL experience in it. Whilst we are 'thin' in many areas, you'd normally expect to only ever need to use a couple of fringe players at any one time (allowing for injuries/suspensions/respite) rather than wholesale changes like last night.

Maybe Dann shouldn't have been risked last night but the team, whatever the lineup, needs leadership on the pitch & we do lack real leaders now Jedi has gone.

It was an opportunity for many to step up and stake a claim to the first team but none seemed to feel the need.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

slubglurge Flag welling 22 Sep 16 8.55am

The truth is out of our 22 outfield players in the squad only 16 are ul to it and three of those are currently injured one long term(Pape) and another that we wont see until Dec(Remy) so we only have 13 outfield players of Prem quality. Every member of the squad should be able to make a decent contribution

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 22 Sep 16 8.57am

I guess when we have a lot of injuries we will have to integrate one or two players who reduce the overall quality of the first XI. That is juts how football.

I don't expect to see each of these players playing together in a League match. The potential is that when surrounded by better players then someone like Lee, for example, will be playing much better, as is in evidence this season. Even Yannick Bolasie seems to be playing better at Everton surrounded by better players.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 9.05am

We're stuck with these players until a few mugs turn up to buy them on equal wages.

We're not covered enough in defence now. We weren't in midfield but got Flamini in. Now he might have to be used at RB but Ledley sooner at LB if anything happens back there very soon.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 9.07am

Originally posted by pstrutt

I guess when we have a lot of injuries we will have to integrate one or two players who reduce the overall quality of the first XI. That is juts how football.

I don't expect to see each of these players playing together in a League match. The potential is that when surrounded by better players then someone like Lee, for example, will be playing much better, as is in evidence this season. Even Yannick Bolasie seems to be playing better at Everton surrounded by better players.

This is the true. Start bringing in 2 though or certainly 2 in. Triangle or line across or down the pitch though and it can be a problem and a weakness the opposition use as a strategy for attack.

 


COYP

cpj Flag Kent 22 Sep 16 9.30am

Originally posted by pstrutt

I guess when we have a lot of injuries we will have to integrate one or two players who reduce the overall quality of the first XI. That is juts how football.

I don't expect to see each of these players playing together in a League match. The potential is that when surrounded by better players then someone like Lee, for example, will be playing much better, as is in evidence this season. Even Yannick Bolasie seems to be playing better at Everton surrounded by better players.

Perhaps the management/coaching is better there too?

 

Username Flag Horsham 22 Sep 16 9.40am

Not sure what people are expecting, we clearly aren't set up to have two quality starting XIs.

Where we have depth is for players to come in and perform alongside the more establish players. As has been shown by Ledley, Kelly, Delaney and Lee so far in the league.

That's what depth means to a club like us.

To expect what is basically a reserve team to suddenly turn up and gel together and perform as well as the starting XI is a bit ridiculous. Funnily enough Mutch, Wickham and Sako don't look great playing next to each other in one game having not featured much this season. Unless disaster strikes though, we won't be throwing a line up like this together anytime soon.

Yeah, it would be great if we were playing youngsters in this game. Then once we were knocked out they could sit on the bench for the rest of the year. Personally, I much prefer the fact that they're all getting regular games every week on loan.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 Sep 16 9.53am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

This is the true. Start bringing in 2 though or certainly 2 in. Triangle or line across or down the pitch though and it can be a problem and a weakness the opposition use as a strategy for attack.

TBF that's exactly how Utd did this with their kids...brought 1 or 2 in to a very strong unit and as such they were able to be 'carried' in parts by the unit.

We now have a strong enough 11 to risk the odd 'youth' player in certain games...20min cameos for the likes of Luke Dreher wouldn't go amiss.

Having said that if the team is fighting relegation then all whimsical thinking goes out of the door and the experienced pro's being paid the big bucks to deliver should rightly be 1st names on the teamsheet.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

DannyH93 Flag London 22 Sep 16 9.55am

I have never seen a Palace player so out of this depth as Fryers was last night against an also weakened southampton side. I fear we are on a kick into nothing with him. Give him away in January or just release him.

 

Mr_Flow Flag London 22 Sep 16 9.56am

Whilst i'd like to see youth given a chance, it's much more beneficial for them at this stage of their career to be playing week in, week out. If they stayed, and we just gave them a run out in Capital One cup, they'd play around 2/3 games a season. I much prefer this approach of letting them go out on loan and gradually loan them up the leagues.

If they can do the business in the Championship, then they may have a good chance of doing it in the premiership. At the moement, the only one that seems likely to be able to make the leap, is Kaikai.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Sep 16 10.22am

Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood

The biggest bugbear I got is not giving our youth a chance. Pardew is too arrogant to play them but with pressure he will, being the arrogant sh he is, he'll take full credit when they come on and have a stormer.

What a daft comment. There could be a variety of reasons why Pardew doesn't play the youngsters very often but I very much doubt that arrogance is one of them.

Surely arrogance is believing that you know better than the club's manager

 

dazza Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 11.02am

I totally get what people are saying and I understand that the club are trying to improve the squad etc.

But lets be fair all we have done is the following:

Mccarthy - Relaced with Mandanda

Mariappa, Hangeland - Replaced with Tomkins so one down already in defence

Jedinak, Bolasie - Replaced with Flamini & Townsend

Gayle, Adebyor, Chamakh - Replaced with Benteke & Remy so 1 down here

So basically yes we have improved in terms of quality but in regards to the depth we have actually decreased this by 2 players.

AP himself said that this season we need to improve the depth so that when we get injuries it does not effect us like last season well this clearly has not been done just look at the defence currently.

I understand about loaning young players out but come on seriously am I the only one who thinks integrating Kalikai & Boetang into the senior squad would be worse than persavering with the likes of Sako, Chungy or Mutch.

I am not moaning about the club just making some suggestions and trying to undersatnd why certain players continue to stay around the first team squad when they have shown they are not good enough and instead we could be bedding in a couple of younger players.


Edited by dazza (22 Sep 2016 11.14am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 11.07am

dazza, edit that 2nd to last paragraph. I know what you mean but it doesn't read correctly.

On the subject of youngsters I don't fully agree but I do on being 2 men down.

 


COYP

Beastie Flag 22 Sep 16 11.20am

Palace’s fringe players not being as good as Southampton’s fringe players is ‘a disgrace’

 

Griffish Flag Croydon 22 Sep 16 11.39am

In response to the OPs message I think the board do realise that some of these players aren't good enough but they possibly can't find clubs who are willing to buy these players, which stops us from buying better players because of our wage bill.

Once Fryers and Campbell run their contracts down at the end of this season well have a extra £2.3m to spend (I believe they're on £10k and £35k respectively a week). Sako, at the time, was a very good free transfer but he has been shocking since returning from his injury last season but who is going to buy an out of form 55k a week player? That's nearly £6m in wages over two season, imagine the financial benefits if we could get him off the books. Maybe Sako will come good? I doubt it but it's a possibility if he keeps fit.

As for the players out on loan, Boateng, Anderson, Croll and Ladapo all need regular 1st team matches. Kaikai, who IMO is our only youth player that might break into the first team, is back in January so a loan to the Championship will do him a world of good and may even force himself into our plans this season (injuries usually are terrible for us around that time).

When Pardew said this would be a transitional year I thought he was talking s*** and making early excuses if we had a poor season. Maybe that was his way of saying the squad isn't good enough but it's going to take at least another season to improve it.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Sep 16 11.47am

Originally posted by dazza

I totally get what people are saying and I understand that the club are trying to improve the squad etc.

But lets be fair all we have done is the following:

Mccarthy - Relaced with Mandanda

Mariappa, Hangeland - Replaced with Tomkins so one down already in defence

Jedinak, Bolasie - Replaced with Flamini & Townsend

Gayle, Adebyor, Chamakh - Replaced with Benteke & Remy so 1 down here

So basically yes we have improved in terms of quality but in regards to the depth we have actually decreased this by 2 players.

AP himself said that this season we need to improve the depth so that when we get injuries it does not effect us like last season well this clearly has not been done just look at the defence currently.

I understand about loaning young players out but come on seriously am I the only one who thinks integrating Kalikai & Boetang into the senior squad would be worse than persavering with the likes of Sako, Chungy or Mutch.

I am not moaning about the club just making some suggestions and trying to undersatnd why certain players continue to stay around the first team squad when they have shown they are not good enough and instead we could be bedding in a couple of younger players.


Edited by dazza (22 Sep 2016 11.14am)

Similar views to mine dazza.

Surely it's better to try and develop KaiKai and Boateng and give us fans something to look forward rather than subjecting us to watching players struggle to make the grade?

Money is not an issue surely?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last Night - Question To All