You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are you Pardew in or Pardew out
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are you Pardew in or Pardew out


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Holmesdale 1989 Flag 15 Dec 16 10.52pm

The real question is Parish in and out with Pardew

 

phillanth Flag London 15 Dec 16 11.26pm

Walking away from the Liberty Stadium I was a definite out but now I am not so sure. The immediate point of getting rid of Pards is to improve results but ideally we would want someone who is also committed to the club for the longer term. I think we need to go for a definite upgrade with a record of achievement in the Prem not a panic appointment. So far no-one on here has come up with such a candidate. Sacking Pards and leaving Millen or some other caretaker in charge is the worst of both worlds. I do not think instability at the club will help us. Secondly there are only two weeks to go to the transfer window in which we desperately need to strengthen the defence at least. Sacking the manager without an immediate replacement could lead to us missing out on any targets. Despite all the frustrations with Pardew which I share, I think we are very close to being a decent team which with competent defending, game management and refereeing would be in the top half of the table. I am therefore a reluctant in. We are stuck with Pardew for now and have to just hope he can sort it out.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Dec 16 11.32pm

How many points lost through poor team selections / tactics / substitutions and an inability to close out a game do you really need to see ?

Throw in sulky looking and overweight players, frequent public criticism of individual players, crass and ridiculous media soundbytes, a thinning squad that continually pick up injuries etc. etc.

Oh sorry - and s*** results for nearly a year.

Losing the dressing room is just a cliché and the players are still trying but for sure they will be able to see what everyone else can.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Dec 16 12.20am

Originally posted by Clock87

IN - Give the geezer more time

To many times have clubs chopped and changed managers.....were not in dire straights yet.......just look at Leeds, Birm, Blackburn, Pompey & Charlton to name a few clubs as examples we dont want to follow.
Even to the extent of Hull......they've been up & down from the pl to the champ in the space we've managed to hold our own in the premier league.

This isnt a Mickey mouse league, and i know results and performances aren't all that at the minute, but people need to remember were not Barcelona......were Crystal Palace who are used to the yo yo nature of football.

Parish is trying to build a team around a man who he geniuelly believes in.....i trust him. Look at the players we've got at the club. Ok some of them are not performing all that (Townsend....cough cough) but who would of thought 2-3 years ago, even when we were in the prem we could of signed someone of Benteke's statue.

Parish knows, chopping and changing manager isnt the right thing to do, just look at utd with fergie and what they've achieved in that era.....why cant we be the same in 20 years time? Not saying pardew will be here in 20 years time, but what i am saying is that if we have a stable team, a stable manager, new infastructure & a huge catchment area theres no reason in 5 years time we are really making some noise in the league and become an even more attractive club/

People being to impatient here i think

PARDEW IN.....For now!!!

You're counting on Pardew achieving this because he's a good manager. Well he isn't so that utopia of your's needs ripping up and getting the best candidate in pretty soon. It's already later than it should be snd the longer we leave it the worse it will get.

 


COYP

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 16 Dec 16 12.23am

OUT [Link]

 


[Link]

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 16 Dec 16 12.37am

Originally posted by simonmdt

The same could be said of you, sweetie. yawn

I come on this site to hear the opinions of like minded fans. The kind of fans who support the club. Which, at the moment includes Alan Pardew.You are obviously not one of those fans.

It seems you like to hear the same thing regurgitated again and again. I find that immature, much like your response.

You are getting your wish at the moment. Relish it.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Pikester Flag Worthing 16 Dec 16 12.46am

I really wanted him to do well (Still do). We improved so much when he first came here.
He felt like such an upgrade on Pulis - the excitement was back. We were taking the game to other teams.

BUT Swansea was inept, Hull was disappointing and last night was marred by a stupid substitution.

We're not a bad side and going forward we often look brilliant but we've hit a wall and we always seem 2 minutes from disaster.

I want to hang on to him because I fear us doing a Fulham and getting in some useless manager and getting relegated.

And I don't dislike Pardew - sure he makes some odd comments - but doesn't everyone under the PL spotlight? I prefer him as a man to Mourinho, Mike Phelan, Fat Sam, Holloway, Freedman, Pulis and many other managers who've been in the PL.

But then I remind myself we need the results and he's not getting them. I imagine West Ham fans are going through the same thing - slipped close to the bottom but managed by a guy who's had them playing some great football.

I feel it's right he goes if there's a better replacement but I wouldn't be deliriously happy to see the back of him - more disappointed it didn't quite work out when it seemed so close.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 16 Dec 16 1.09am

Originally posted by Pikester

I really wanted him to do well (Still do). We improved so much when he first came here.
He felt like such an upgrade on Pulis - the excitement was back. We were taking the game to other teams.

BUT Swansea was inept, Hull was disappointing and last night was marred by a stupid substitution.

We're not a bad side and going forward we often look brilliant but we've hit a wall and we always seem 2 minutes from disaster.

I want to hang on to him because I fear us doing a Fulham and getting in some useless manager and getting relegated.

And I don't dislike Pardew - sure he makes some odd comments - but doesn't everyone under the PL spotlight? I prefer him as a man to Mourinho, Mike Phelan, Fat Sam, Holloway, Freedman, Pulis and many other managers who've been in the PL.

But then I remind myself we need the results and he's not getting them. I imagine West Ham fans are going through the same thing - slipped close to the bottom but managed by a guy who's had them playing some great football.

I feel it's right he goes if there's a better replacement but I wouldn't be deliriously happy to see the back of him - more disappointed it didn't quite work out when it seemed so close.

Spot on. It's the idiotic vitriol towards him, from some on here, I don't get.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

lancseagle Flag burnley 16 Dec 16 1.13am

Has to be out its gone on for far too long the main overriding reason some people want him to stay is who do we replace him with but looking at the results win ratio etc I think it's a non argument anybody could do a better job if not equal it its that poor.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Dec 16 4.34am

What the board have pulled off over the past five years has been truly mind blowing. Interesting that the vast majority of Palace fans are rightly behind them. This decision is well over my head and probably most other fans.
The track record of the board is unreal, and they have our future in their hands......not our hands.
So by all means moan on here about AP and some of his very odd decisions, but leave the direction to the directors. They have already proven they know best and deserve our full support.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 16 5.38am

Originally posted by Clock87

people need to remember were not Barcelona......were Crystal Palace who are used to the yo yo nature of football.

Even Steve Parish said that it's about time we stopped thinking like that

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 16 Dec 16 7.36am

The main reason I have switched to out is that he has failed to improve the team.

Near Total failure in the transfer market from performances in a red and blue shirt.

Only improvement in defence Souare unfortunately involved in car crash.
Nothing in midfield.Maybe Benteke up front.

Two improvements IMO since we beat Liverpool Away Gerard's last home game.
16 May 2015.

Lost track of the players signed.

We need a left back in January,not sure if Alan will be able to find one.

We will see.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 16 Dec 16 8.30am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

What the board have pulled off over the past five years has been truly mind blowing. Interesting that the vast majority of Palace fans are rightly behind them. This decision is well over my head and probably most other fans.
The track record of the board is unreal, and they have our future in their hands......not our hands.
So by all means moan on here about AP and some of his very odd decisions, but leave the direction to the directors. They have already proven they know best and deserve our full support.

Couldnt have put it any better. Still not worried about being relegated yet (as the board obviously arent or he would be gone. I trust SP to do the right thing at the right time.

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Dec 16 9.33am

I do think that the board have no choice now but to continue with AP with the transfer window almost upon us how can we recruit a new manager in that time and then expect him to evaluate the needs of the team and then find the players that are clearly required. If we changed at this stage of the season it would be a much bigger risk than staying with the devil we know. I have serious concerns with little or confidence we can get any points from the next three games, I hope I'm wrong as I so much want us to remain in the PL even if that means finishing 17th!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Dec 16 9.46am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

What the board have pulled off over the past five years has been truly mind blowing. Interesting that the vast majority of Palace fans are rightly behind them. This decision is well over my head and probably most other fans.
The track record of the board is unreal, and they have our future in their hands......not our hands.
So by all means moan on here about AP and some of his very odd decisions, but leave the direction to the directors. They have already proven they know best and deserve our full support.

You think 'the board' always know best with what we see on the football pitch? Really?

People I've spoken to with football knowledge and experience cannot believe the situation we are in and are sticking with. The football management on pitch side of things shows rank incompetence.

The only reasons I can think that we haven't got rid of him is that we are not quite in the inevitable position of amongst the relegation places and Parish feels some responsibility in not buying and actually scouting more players we knew we'd probably need. This was no surprise. I said the few outfield players we signed wasn't enough, the red and blue spec wearers thought it was amazing and lo and behold, it wasn't enough because in truth it was only half done and we could've done more..... and Souare being unavailable is not unusual in this industry. The p1ss poor number of defenders and full backs is.

After all the talk of mistakes with leaving us stretched previously either 1 or both has made the same mistakes again and there really is no excuse with a net spend of £10mil. Every manager would be trying to cover Jedinak going and/or another left footed defender, not accept the situation and disappear to let the chairman make his salon appointment.

Pardew is too acquiescent and manages like the fanny he was as a player. Chairman/manager relationship is important but a nodding dog as manager and chairman who'd prefer to risk us going as close to the trap door without getting in obvious additions and happy with the acquiescent nodding dog is not a match made in heaven. This risky game I think they might be playing can one day run out their luck.

Having said that Pardew is pathetic. Other managers would've done better than this. So many points gifted away and all managers have problems and deal with them. He has 1 or 3 points in his pocket and flushes them down the toilet every week. We should not be where we are with a handful of wins in 12 months but he is so sh1t in this job we are, slowly drifting closer to the drop.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Dec 16 9.54am

Originally posted by Den1923

I do think that the board have no choice now but to continue with AP with the transfer window almost upon us how can we recruit a new manager in that time and then expect him to evaluate the needs of the team and then find the players that are clearly required. If we changed at this stage of the season it would be a much bigger risk than staying with the devil we know. I have serious concerns with little or confidence we can get any points from the next three games, I hope I'm wrong as I so much want us to remain in the PL even if that means finishing 17th!

If we you keep delaying something then a date does get gradually closer. It should've been done in the summer and a few times since.

Nobody has suddenly put us here having a handful of wins all year, with 1 win in 8, only 4 wins v poor sides on the day and losing to all the poor teams we've played recently.

They have had a choice. Parish had a choice in the summer and extended his deal for 5 years. 5 facking years. I don't know how much more bad luck, players not responding to defensive training (only to take it themselves the next week), relying on penalties or red cards it's going to take to see it's not in a good state.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 16 Dec 16 10.12am

He should have gone after the cup final really, but as he didn't, after Swansea was the last realistic opportunity to recruit and give the new man a reasonable chance in the January window. Now I think we're going to be stuck with each other for a while. So I suppose I'm a very reluctant in, but I'm extremely nervous about our future.

Edited by bexleydave (16 Dec 2016 10.13am)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 16 Dec 16 10.22am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

in. hes earnt time over the last 2 years.

he will keep us up and nobody can even name a better manager to replace him anyway

I think you mean no one can name a manager you think is better.

Also he's been here 2 years 50% of which have been toilet, not sure that earns time?

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Den1923 Flag 16 Dec 16 10.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If we you keep delaying something then a date does get gradually closer. It should've been done in the summer and a few times since.

Nobody has suddenly put us here having a handful of wins all year, with 1 win in 8, only 4 wins v poor sides on the day and losing to all the poor teams we've played recently.

They have had a choice. Parish had a choice in the summer and extended his deal for 5 years. 5 facking years. I don't know how much more bad luck, players not responding to defensive training (only to take it themselves the next week), relying on penalties or red cards it's going to take to see it's not in a good state.

I agree with everything you are saying, my concern now is it too late as the any new manager would not have the time to look at the team and identify what we need which in my humble opinion is a lot more than just a left back as some are suggesting. The problem is without doubt SP has done a great job since 2010 but now the club has reached the critical mass point where the Chairman is to close to the front line and he should step back from a hands on involvement in football matters and instead recruit a good director of Football who has the contacts to get quality players and at the same time help the manager with advice on coaching and tactics. The Director of football could also be responsible for succession planning for the future development of the club. All the stats point clearly that AP should have gone at the end of last season and I'm surprise how many people want to separate the stats from one season to the next and in any event even looking at the last 10 games we have one win which is appalling to most unless your SP?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 16 Dec 16 10.30am

Originally posted by Den1923

I agree with everything you are saying, my concern now is it too late as the any new manager would not have the time to look at the team and identify what we need which in my humble opinion is a lot more than just a left back as some are suggesting. The problem is without doubt SP has done a great job since 2010 but now the club has reached the critical mass point where the Chairman is to close to the front line and he should step back from a hands on involvement in football matters and instead recruit a good director of Football who has the contacts to get quality players and at the same time help the manager with advice on coaching and tactics. The Director of football could also be responsible for succession planning for the future development of the club. All the stats point clearly that AP should have gone at the end of last season and I'm surprise how many people want to separate the stats from one season to the next and in any event even looking at the last 10 games we have one win which is appalling to most unless your SP?


I thinks that's a fair summary, with which I agree.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are you Pardew in or Pardew out