This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
I can assure you this is NOT the case.Just giving my honest opinion. At the end of the day when Mark's performance is analysed as part of a 'Forensic' analysis, which is normal, they might decide that a card should have been awarded, all I am doing is giving my opinion based on what I have seen. Well here is the truth.....the goalkeeper was committed so made a decision.to pre b ent a goal and accept the consequences. He made the right call based on Benteke's pathetic attempt at the penalty. However, he knew he was going to make the foul.....i.e. A booking at least. Why you can't just admit that is proof that you are just trying to provoke people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cannoneagle
Well here is the truth.....the goalkeeper was committed so made a decision.to pre b ent a goal and accept the consequences. He made the right call based on Benteke's pathetic attempt at the penalty. However, he knew he was going to make the foul.....i.e. A booking at least. Why you can't just admit that is proof that you are just trying to provoke people. I could argue they are provoking me ! At the end of the day I respect the opinion of others but I disagree with them.All I am doing is giving you my opinion that's all.I am certainly not taking an alternative position as an act of provocation or to stimulate any sort of debate.I hope you can accept this. Anyway I am going out shortly so HOL will be a "Willo Free" zone for a while !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Nobody would have been screaming "outrage" if Clattenburg had given Gomes a red card.... clumsy or not intentional... he caught Benteke around knee height and it deserved a red. To see that Clattenburg hadn't even given him a yellow was infuriating yet again especially when later on he gave Delaney a yellow for his penalty infringement. This so called impartial arbiter of the laws of our game needs investigating as to why CPFC always end up on the wrong end of injustice every match he officiates in involving our club. "bad luck" is supposed to even itself out, but when Clattenburg is involved we constantly suffer from his incompetence or deliberate application not in our favour. Without even giving it much thought I can cite yesterday, last year's FA Cup final and WBA away 2 seasons ago where we were the victims of major refereeing injustice by clattenburg's application of the laws. In the WBA game he allowed Dawson a free rein to inflict GBH on Speroni with his elbow FFS. PS - this is a statement of my thoughts and not an invitation to Trollo or anybody else to bore me to death with how great "Mark" is and how he is much maligned by Palace fans. Edited by Hoof Hearted (27 Dec 2016 11.07am) I'm actually beginning to believe in conspiracy theories about c***enburg now. How is he allowed to rewrite the law book, especially against us.
That's Life |
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by fish mitten
For me a red card. Yes he's going away from goal, but it's the nature of the challenge. No attempt to get the ball. He just kicks Benteke and if that was a outfield player doing that it would be a red. I think Gomes was going for the ball to boot it into the stands, he had no intention of kicking Benteke and Clatterburg in my opinion got that right, penalty was enough of a penalty for Gomes.
|
|
| OhthisbloodyPC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
I think Gomes was going for the ball to boot it into the stands, he had no intention of kicking Benteke and Clatterburg in my opinion got that right, penalty was enough of a penalty for Gomes.
Don't ever pull a stunt like that in my court room again
|
|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
I think Gomes was going for the ball to boot it into the stands, he had no intention of kicking Benteke and Clatterburg in my opinion got that right, penalty was enough of a penalty for Gomes. It doesn't matter what his intention was, it is what he did. Lots of fouls, often the worst are not intentional, doesn't make it any less dangerous or a foul.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
I think Gomes was going for the ball to boot it into the stands, he had no intention of kicking Benteke and Clatterburg in my opinion got that right, penalty was enough of a penalty for Gomes. Look at it in slow motion, you may well then change your mind. He knew exactly what he was doing and thank God that Benteke wasnt seriously injured. If you still think he got it right clumsy or not, why no card especially when Delaney got one got one for just a pull for which, a penalty was given. Just not consistent from a supposed top ref!
Bring back Brolin |
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by gerry theagle
Thank goodness Willo has gone out,bores me to tears,probably does it deliberately, amazing he has never been carded....one for being a p*at.and two being the only Holer to defend Clattenbergs decisions. Willo is very entertaining actually.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by General
I'm very confused. I think that if gk doesn't take out the CF, the CF will carry on running to the ball that he gently touched past the gk previously, then tap the ball along the floor towards the goal that he's attacking and then just f u x i n g simply score!!!!??? Am I being over damn stupid here!!?? I don't recall the ball being over the line when benteke got butchered.. Very obviously Clatterburg thought Gomes genuinely went for the ball hence his decision and I feel that he did as well, it was a 50/50 moment and Benteke won it by half a centimetre and the penalty should have been well enough of an award for his troubles.
|
|
|
He may be entertaining but always hums the same tune,to me that's a bit boring.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cannoneagle
Well here is the truth.....the goalkeeper was committed so made a decision.to pre b ent a goal and accept the consequences. He made the right call based on Benteke's pathetic attempt at the penalty. However, he knew he was going to make the foul.....i.e. A booking at least. Why you can't just admit that is proof that you are just trying to provoke people. ..everyone against Willo are having an absolute laugh, it's like putting him on a rack and stretching him until he confesses, why should he admit something against his beliefs just to shut you lot up and anyway it is great entertainment and Willo stand up for yourself because on this occasion you are absolutely right, Clatterburg got every single decision correct in this match and only people who have an agenda cannot see this and I never normally stand up for this ref, he was very fair and honest during this game.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by gerry theagle
He may be entertaining but always hums the same tune,to me that's a bit boring. ..so, the only way he doesn't sound boring is to admit he was wrong and that all you lot are actually correct, I see. Clatterburg is only a puppet, he has to be investigated after every single game where the brass in charge of him access his actions and behaviour during the games, he wouldn't be the most sort after ref if he was actually as awful as all you lot make him out to be and if his superiors got any wind of any favouritism towards any team during a game he would be out as quick as a flash and refereeing in the Champ, it is not to his benefit to muck up decisions and allow any teams any favours, because he knows he will be demoted by his superiors...all you Willo haters need to get a grip. But please don't stop, it is great entertainment.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by peterg
I think Cluntenf*ck is the worst ref in the world, but I don't agree that Gomes tried to maim Benteke. He took a swing at the ball just before Benteke touched it on and kicked Benteke instead. However he could easily have got a yellow on the grounds of dangerous play. If he was going for the ball and was just beaten to it he cannot be accused of dangerous play.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.