You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Please stop selecting:
November 16 2026 10.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Please stop selecting:


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Mad4palace Flag 14 Jan 17 9.46pm

Ledley and Hennessey

Other players are underachieving but we know they can step up, on the other hand Joe Ledley does a nothing job in defensive midfield and Hennessey is an absolute liability. Flamini is far superior in Ledley's position and Speroni showed against Bolton that he still has more shot-stopping ability than Hennessey. Speroni would have definitely claimed one of those loose balls for West Ham's 1st and 3rd goals and would have stood a better chance for Carrolls judging by Hennessey's laughable attempt at a save.

When the options are there why these players are still being selected boggles the mind.

 

Reknaw Flag 14 Jan 17 9.52pm

Please also stop bringing on:

Lee.

Worst player i have ever seen wear the shirt.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 14 Jan 17 9.53pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

Please also stop bringing on:

Lee.

Worst player i have ever seen wear the shirt.

How old are you then, about 2?

 


Most certainly not European.

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 17 10.05pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

Please also stop bringing on:

Lee.

Worst player i have ever seen wear the shirt.

Are you on glue?

This afternoon alone the following were all worse than Lee.

Hennessey
Ward
Dann, arguably
Tomkins
Ledley
Puncheon
Townsend
Benteke (by miles)

Lee, Campbell and Fryers may not be the most talented players in the squad but at least they put in a shift. Zaha generally works his arse off.

Benteke today might have been arrested for loitering he did so little.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Reknaw Flag 14 Jan 17 10.11pm

Originally posted by moylerg

How old are you then, about 2?


Nope. Old enough to know he's the worst player i've ever witnessed play for the club.

(Okay may be a slight exaggeration but it grinds my gears watching him play)

 

Reknaw Flag 14 Jan 17 10.13pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Are you on glue?

This afternoon alone the following were all worse than Lee.

Hennessey
Ward
Dann, arguably
Tomkins
Ledley
Puncheon
Townsend
Benteke (by miles)

Lee, Campbell and Fryers may not be the most talented players in the squad but at least they put in a shift. Zaha generally works his arse off.

Benteke today might have been arrested for loitering he did so little.

Okay. He's the least talented player at the club imo. So what if he puts in effort, if he's not good enough he shouldn't be playing. Liability. Loses the ball every time he gets it. Falls over. Kicks the ball out of play when barely under pressure because he has no idea what to do with it. The list goes on. He would do okay at a League 1 club. Period.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 14 Jan 17 10.13pm

Originally posted by Reknaw


Nope. Old enough to know he's the worst player i've ever witnessed play for the club.

(Okay may be a slight exaggeration but it grinds my gears watching him play)

Slight exaggeration, come on. Over the years, really? Not premier league quality by a country mile, I'll give you that.

 


Most certainly not European.

Mad4palace Flag 14 Jan 17 10.17pm

This is my assessment of our squad at the moment:

Category A - Quality and doing well in the shirt:

Zaha (Away for AFCON)
McArthur

Category B - Quality to good players but not performing:

Puncheon
Dann
Ward
Cabaye
Benteke
Townsend
Tomkins
Delaney

Category C - Need more game time, shown promise when used:

Flamini
Remy
Sako (AFCON)
Speroni
Lee

Category D - Not good enough and getting too much game time ahead of superior players:

Ledley
Hennessey
Kelly (though he's only been used because we had to)


Category E - Untested:

Schlupp

Edited by Mad4palace (14 Jan 2017 10.18pm)

 

Reknaw Flag 14 Jan 17 10.25pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

This is my assessment of our squad at the moment:

Category A - Quality and doing well in the shirt:

Zaha (Away for AFCON)
McArthur

Category B - Quality to good players but not performing:

Puncheon
Dann
Ward
Cabaye
Benteke
Townsend
Tomkins
Delaney

Category C - Need more game time, shown promise when used:

Flamini
Remy
Sako (AFCON)
Speroni
Lee

Category D - Not good enough and getting too much game time ahead of superior players:

Ledley
Hennessey
Kelly (though he's only been used because we had to)


Category E - Untested:

Schlupp

Edited by Mad4palace (14 Jan 2017 10.18pm)

Spot on, to be fair. Though, you need one more category; 'Not good enough and should be sold immediately'. This category would include Lee, Mutch, potentially Fryers.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 17 10.30pm

Category F - long term injured and replacements required for rest of season

Souare
Wickham
Mandanda (may return soon but other issues may supervene)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Gribbo Flag Bromley 14 Jan 17 10.33pm

Mutch did not make the list? should he not have a special category of his very own, for those who wake up every morning and pinch themselves to check that the whole Premiership footballer thing is real.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 17 10.33pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

Spot on, to be fair. Though, you need one more category; 'Not good enough and should be sold immediately'. This category would include Lee, Mutch, potentially Fryers.

I think Mutch was so poor we forgot he existed. Certainly against notloB we might as well have had ten men.

Fryers - can't make my mind up. Has shown promise and attitude but plays in a position where we have little available. Unlike the others not Pardewed so probably useful as a squad player for that reason. Kelly's now so ruined he looks like he needs a complete change.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 14 Jan 17 10.37pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

This is my assessment of our squad at the moment:

Category A - Quality and doing well in the shirt:

Zaha (Away for AFCON)
McArthur

Category B - Quality to good players but not performing:

Puncheon
Dann
Ward
Cabaye
Benteke
Townsend
Tomkins
Delaney

Category C - Need more game time, shown promise when used:

Flamini
Remy
Sako (AFCON)
Speroni
Lee

Category D - Not good enough and getting too much game time ahead of superior players:

Ledley
Hennessey
Kelly (though he's only been used because we had to)


Category E - Untested:

Schlupp

Edited by Mad4palace (14 Jan 2017 10.18pm)


Somehow have you decided who goes in Group B and who goes in Group D?

I would suggest at least half of B should or could be in D.


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Mad4palace Flag 14 Jan 17 10.38pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Mutch did not make the list? should he not have a special category of his very own, for those who wake up every morning and pinch themselves to check that the whole Premiership footballer thing is real.

I honestly forgot about Mutch, Fryers even came to my head before Mutch.

 

Mad4palace Flag 14 Jan 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


Somehow have you decided who goes in Group B and who goes in Group D?

I would suggest at least half of B should or could be in D.


They are all players of an OK quality at least in the Premier League, Ward, Tomkins, Delaney have proved in the past to be passable PL players. Ledley, Hennessey, Mutch for my mind are mid championship players, if that.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 17 10.41pm

What about Campbell? Another one where I can't tell what the potential is, but puts in a shift. Benteke was worse than him today.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 14 Jan 17 10.56pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

They are all players of an OK quality at least in the Premier League, Ward, Tomkins, Delaney have proved in the past to be passable PL players. Ledley, Hennessey, Mutch for my mind are mid championship players, if that.

Damo should be back up at best. He brings heart but we should have a better number one centre back than him. Ward? Was full of potential but even last season when chipping in with goals wasn't convincing.

Punch has been good for us and at times our best player. I'm starting to wonder if that's the problem though, the bar is too low

We have had a dead cat bounce since Allardyce came in. In my opinion we look worse. He needs time but Hull did ok didn't they.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

sprites Flag Auckland 14 Jan 17 11.14pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

Okay. He's the least talented player at the club imo. So what if he puts in effort, if he's not good enough he shouldn't be playing. Liability. Loses the ball every time he gets it. Falls over. Kicks the ball out of play when barely under pressure because he has no idea what to do with it. The list goes on. He would do okay at a League 1 club. Period.

All entitled to our opinions. But I reckon yours is wrong. He's not the worst by far. He's got great vision, good dribbling ability and generally works his socks off. I'd be starting him. Was our best player for the first 3 games or so of the season...then as soon as Punch is fit again, he's out.

Underrated.

Just my opinoin, of course

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 14 Jan 17 11.19pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Damo should be back up at best. He brings heart but we should have a better number one centre back than him. Ward? Was full of potential but even last season when chipping in with goals wasn't convincing.

Punch has been good for us and at times our best player. I'm starting to wonder if that's the problem though, the bar is too low

We have had a dead cat bounce since Allardyce came in. In my opinion we look worse. He needs time but Hull did ok didn't they.

So, while the majority of HoL are killing AP for "decimating" and "gutting" our squad of leaders, you think we should out some more of the 'old school'?

Good thinking 'In Drag With Red On'.

ps I may have got that translation wrong....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

superpalace12 Flag Athens 15 Jan 17 8.10am

We should immediately sell the following deadweights:

Kelly (just not up to the task - average championship player)
Cabaye (ive never understood what the hype is all about)
Ward (would be sad to see him go but has been underperforming for too long now)
Townsend (one trick pony)
Mutch (championship player at best)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Please stop selecting: