You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....
November 16 2026 10.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by mattteo


He is quality, but not THAT MUCH quality. He could develop into a good wingback, but they paid for him the same fee they paid for Townsend. And Schlupp could never do what Townsend does. He was pretty much brought to replace Townsend

When you see Schlupp doing this, let me know.

[Link]

Or this:

[Link]

Ummmm....pretty sure there are a few from distance in there? Just saying.

[Link]

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 23 Jan 17 1.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo


He is quality, but not THAT MUCH quality. He could develop into a good wingback, but they paid for him the same fee they paid for Townsend. And Schlupp could never do what Townsend does. He was pretty much brought to replace Townsend

When you see Schlupp doing this, let me know.

[Link]

Or this:

[Link]

There are endless vids of Schlupp's goals/assists etc too, so what.

The reason we only paid £12m for Townsend was because that was the release clause in his contract - seemed odd at the time that nobody else was interested (but maybe we now know why?).

From what I saw on Saturday Schlupp has more than enough both from a defensive and work rate perspective to offset what he might not (as yet) have offensively compared with Townsend.

Some of his best performances were in Leicester's relegation battle so he's likely to be more of what we need right now than a highly talented sulk.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 23 Jan 17 1.17pm

Totally disagree with this negative thread. I thought we looked much better on Saturday and if it weren't for the Schlupp fiasco I reckon we would've got a point.
What bothered me though was when we turned the ball over in our own half, whether it was the keeper collecting the ball, a goal kick or a free kick, that we never broke at any pace letting Everton get well organised in defence, especially in the secomd half. Or am I just not as good a football tactician as everybody else on here?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 23 Jan 17 1.21pm

3-5-2 is definitely out dated.

Chelsea were killing the league until they switched formation, look at them now. Losers

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 23 Jan 17 1.27pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

3-5-2 is definitely out dated.

Chelsea were killing the league until they switched formation, look at them now. Losers

Exactly. Yesterday was a lesson in how to make that formation work to give your players a rest.. Folk have praised Hull but I don't think Chelski got out of 2nd gear that often. It simply allowed them to sit there & let Hull run around with the ball, mostly in their own half or the middle of the pitch, then break forward when the opportunity arose.

We don't need a rest as such but if we can contain sides like that then it'd be a big step in the right direction.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 1.32pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

3-5-2 is definitely out dated.

Chelsea were killing the league until they switched formation, look at them now. Losers

Look at Sunderland and Hull now. They're in relegation zone. These are the only 3 teams who have constantly played the 3 central defenders system this year. One is first, the other 2 are in the relegation zone.
What does that say?

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 1.38pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Look at Sunderland and Hull now. They're in relegation zone. These are the only 3 teams who have constantly played the 3 central defenders system this year. One is first, the other 2 are in the relegation zone.
What does that say?

That the one at the top has far superior players to the 2 in the relegation zone?

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 1.39pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Touchy!

I think it's funny how thin skinned you are when challenged or teased. You claimed you knew for a fact that over 200 players were unhappy and were available for under 10m. Repeatedly you were asked, by me and others, how you knew for a fact that they were unhappy and available, we got a bunch of abuse in return. So go on, explain how you knew that for a fact. You can't can you: hence the abuse.

Given that your claim was patently false, I was wondering if your new claim was true, or like the previous one: made up. If you try to swerve the issue by saying you listed players, or I didn't list players--to cloud the issue--all that shows, is you are full of it.


You're making things up and silly accusations. Quote to where I said that or be proven a liar.

What are you expecting of me (or anyone who suggests players), to go door to door and talk to them personally to listen to why they're unhappy?
I provided a list of players who should be unhappy because they're not getting playing time. It's up to the club to check how unhappy they are and if they can be persuaded to join.

Really, I literally give you an entire list which YOU could not pull off in a week, let alone understand, and you still clinge onto little, puerile things like "how do you know they're unhappy?".
Jeez, some people will never be sattisfied.....

 

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 1.45pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Ummmm....pretty sure there are a few from distance in there? Just saying.

[Link]


I haven't seen 1 assist of the quality Townsend provided for Cabaye against Watford.

And Townsend's goal was against Italy, not against Championship sides.

We're simply comparing a speedy DEFENDER with a quite technically gifted AND fast MIDFIELDER.
Schlupp will not be able to do more than Townsend.

If he was brought to replace him (and it sure looks that way now that another left back is set to come in), then it's a mistake

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I haven't seen 1 assist of the quality Townsend provided for Cabaye against Watford.

And Townsend's goal was against Italy, not against Championship sides.

We're simply comparing a speedy DEFENDER with a quite technically gifted AND fast MIDFIELDER.
Schlupp will not be able to do more than Townsend.

If he was brought to replace him (and it sure looks that way now that another left back is set to come in), then it's a mistake

Alright, f*** it, I'll drop to your level...I'm still waiting for Townsend to do this.
[Link]
When he does let me know....BTW, this was our CB before we reached the heights of the Premier league this time round, he was SLOW and NOT TECHNICALLY gifted.

Also, you're slating Schlupp against championship teams and raving about Townsend playing 1 pass against Watford? Plus a goal in a FRIENDLY?

Edited by Icepick Tony (23 Jan 2017 2.00pm)

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 23 Jan 17 2.05pm

Originally posted by mattteo


You're making things up and silly accusations. Quote to where I said that or be proven a liar.

What are you expecting of me (or anyone who suggests players), to go door to door and talk to them personally to listen to why they're unhappy?
I provided a list of players who should be unhappy because they're not getting playing time. It's up to the club to check how unhappy they are and if they can be persuaded to join.

Really, I literally give you an entire list which YOU could not pull off in a week, let alone understand, and you still clinge onto little, puerile things like "how do you know they're unhappy?".
Jeez, some people will never be sattisfied.....

Not making anything up as we've quoted it several times before. But you already know that. I see you've now changed it to "should be unhappy." Well done!

Furthermore, you might want to look up the word puerile so that you can use it correctly. It's not puerile to point out when someone is full of it.


 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 2.16pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Not making anything up as we've quoted it several times before. But you already know that.


No, you really haven't. You just said that I claimed so. Quote or be proven a liar.

I haven't changed or edited anything.

 

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 2.21pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Alright, f*** it, I'll drop to your level...I'm still waiting for Townsend to do this.
[Link]


Drop to my level??? Who's making the offenses here?

What does that have to do with Townsend or Schlupp?
The comparison was between them. Neither of them have dedicated their lives to Crystal Palace, they're new players in the team.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 23 Jan 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Look at Sunderland and Hull now. They're in relegation zone. These are the only 3 teams who have constantly played the 3 central defenders system this year. One is first, the other 2 are in the relegation zone.
What does that say?

I don't think for one moment that the plan is to constantly play 3-5-2 more an option when required.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 2.39pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Drop to my level??? Who's making the offenses here?

What does that have to do with Townsend or Schlupp?
The comparison was between them. Neither of them have dedicated their lives to Crystal Palace, they're new players in the team.

What does Schlupp have to do with Townsend? He's not been brought in to replace him, they play in different positions, on different sides of the pitch.
The reason we're after another LB is we didn't have a recognised one until we got Schlupp and if he gets injured we don't have one again, we need options as we don't have any on that side.
For all your praise of Townsend, he's really done nothing here since joining considering his pricetag and so called pedigree which in turn has found him warming the bench.

Your arrogant 'I know more than anyone' style of posting grinds peoples gears, hence the reason you have numerous posters pulling apart your posts.
Either way, Schlupp played well in a 5-3-2 formation which also made us more solid than we have been for a long time.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 23 Jan 17 2.57pm

Originally posted by mattteo


No, you really haven't. You just said that I claimed so. Quote or be proven a liar.

I haven't changed or edited anything.

Here we go again (and not just a couple of times either):

Matteo: "Even I know all the players in the Premier League and the Championship and what foot they kick the ball with."

Sure you do.

Matteo: "I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter."

There is more.

Matteo: "But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN"

This is getting better.

Matteo: "All of the above either don't play as starters anymore or play as starters in teams that have problems and are willing to sell for a fee less that what they would deserve."

They're only alternative facts, right?

Matteo: "It's a list of unhappy players, who COULD be tempted into coming and from clubs who might actually sell them cheapER than the modern, average prices in England."

So, you lied about the first claim (since amended in a more recent post, but it's still a lie), and were wrong on the second and others. e.g. You had Depay as a player who would cost less that 10m, then later said 10-15m before he was later sold for 16m+.

So, you are clearly making stuff up as you go along. But you abuse people and call them liars if they ask you to prove your claims. Pathetic!


Edited by NickinOX (23 Jan 2017 5.31pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 23 Jan 17 3.03pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

Thought we looked good at 3-5-2. Was only when Remy went off knackered we had to go back to the usual s*** scared suicidal deep defending and looked s***e again.

Totally agree. No idea if it will work against every team but it seemed to work against Everton.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

mattteo Flag 23 Jan 17 5.06pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Here we go again (and not just a couple of times either):

Matteo: "Even I know all the players in the Premier League and the Championship and what foot they kick the ball with."

Sure you do.

Matteo: "I do actually. I can name you over 100 players that would cost less than 10 million and would improve the Crystal Palace side this winter."

There is more.

Matteo: "But the truth is that there are close to 200 players that could improve a Premier League squad AT THIS MOMENT and they are A BARGAIN"

This is getting better.

Matteo: "All of the above either don't play as starters anymore or play as starters in teams that have problems and are willing to sell for a fee less that what they would deserve."

They're only alternative facts, right?

Matteo: "It's a list of unhappy players, who COULD be tempted into coming and from clubs who might actually sell them cheapER than the modern, average prices in England."

So, you lied about the first claim (since amended in a more recent post, but it's still a lie), and were wrong on the second and others. e.g. You had Depay as a player who would cost less that 10m, then later said 10-15m before he was later sold for 16m+.

So, you are clearly making stuff up as you go along. But you abuse people and call them liars if they ask you to prove your claims. Pathetic!


Aaaaaand.....you listed nowhere what you claimed on the previous page.

I had Depay on a list with 150 other players. Him and maybe 3-4 more cost more than 10 million, as I had actually specified there. The point was that he was going to be sold for a fee less than what he's worth. I actually said that he would cost more than 10, but you decided to just copy and paste only what you liked.

I still don't understand your puerile question of "how do you know they're unhappy?"
You should just avoid my posts altogether, they're clearly not for your level.

 

You What Flag se25 23 Jan 17 5.27pm

Originally posted by MR200%

Best display by Palace I've seen from ages Heart and soul ,Players looked very comfortable with the setup Remy and Benteke will score goals for us in that set up

This

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 23 Jan 17 5.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Aaaaaand.....you listed nowhere what you claimed on the previous page.

I had Depay on a list with 150 other players. Him and maybe 3-4 more cost more than 10 million, as I had actually specified there. The point was that he was going to be sold for a fee less than what he's worth. I actually said that he would cost more than 10, but you decided to just copy and paste only what you liked.

I still don't understand your puerile question of "how do you know they're unhappy?"
You should just avoid my posts altogether, they're clearly not for your level.

I put it in bold so that even you can find it. You were asked how you knew this. You responded with abuse.

You clearly cannot read, or are being deliberately obtuse. I suspect the latter.


Edited by NickinOX (23 Jan 2017 5.35pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....