You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your Deals up (Do you keep or Release )
November 16 2026 9.55am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your Deals up (Do you keep or Release )


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
coulsdoneagle Flag London 26 Mar 17 11.35pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

You are ridiculous. Completely ignoring what people are saying. No one is suggesting Speroni is the first name on the sheet. People are saying he is a cheap Palace legend with a great work ethic who is capable and happy as a number three, much like Steve Harper has been. There will be few no. 3s with as much experience or ability. For the amount it costs and the benefits he brings to the squad it makes no sense to replace him as a 3rd choice. Same with Damo as 4th Choice CB. Why gut the dressing room, these are huge characters and managing a squad is more than just about getting the best 11 a club can afford.

You didn't say a goalkeeper like Hart or Begovic either, you said you wanted 'Begovic or Hart as number 1'[/quote
. I just stating my feeling on the original post. You claim they are huge leaders but that was not showing leadership under pardew. No I'm not a pardew fan. Don't worry, we stick with Delaney and speroni and turn down the likes of Gibson and begovic in the summer . Let's also stop at route through for the youth with Delaney as 4th choice centre half. He's 35 , I'm grateful what they both done for the club. Now the time to move on. The squad is old anyways dann (30), cabaye (31), puncheon (30) . There's another experience in the squad already.

When have I ever said that we don't sign Gibson or Begovic? It's not going to be a choice between Begovic and Speroni, or Damo and Gibson. We need a new CB to cover for Sakho when he leaves, and we need a reserve CB who won't play but is good enough for cover should we get 2 injuries. Begovic or Hart or whatever other name you want to pull out of thin air are the types of players who will want to play first team games or will leave, they are also unlike Jules, on enormous wages. Young keepers need to play to get better so having a young keeper as 3rd choice is pointless. Same goes with a reserve CB. As squad players, the benefits (financial, team spirit and proven at this level) to keeping them around outweigh the cons.

You don't seem to comprehend, no one is suggesting they are first teamers but they are good enough to make the 25, and probably happy to play a cover role. I think it's the first team and bench that needs an upgrade. Players like Hennessy and Ward are not good enough and Ledley, Sako, Campbell and Lee etc are also not good enough and they all probably want to play at this stage on their career and they are on quite large wages as we signed them in the PL. They are the problems in the squad.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Mar 17 9.07am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

When have I ever said that we don't sign Gibson or Begovic? It's not going to be a choice between Begovic and Speroni, or Damo and Gibson. We need a new CB to cover for Sakho when he leaves, and we need a reserve CB who won't play but is good enough for cover should we get 2 injuries. Begovic or Hart or whatever other name you want to pull out of thin air are the types of players who will want to play first team games or will leave, they are also unlike Jules, on enormous wages. Young keepers need to play to get better so having a young keeper as 3rd choice is pointless. Same goes with a reserve CB. As squad players, the benefits (financial, team spirit and proven at this level) to keeping them around outweigh the cons.

You don't seem to comprehend, no one is suggesting they are first teamers but they are good enough to make the 25, and probably happy to play a cover role. I think it's the first team and bench that needs an upgrade. Players like Hennessy and Ward are not good enough and Ledley, Sako, Campbell and Lee etc are also not good enough and they all probably want to play at this stage on their career and they are on quite large wages as we signed them in the PL. They are the problems in the squad.

. It's time we starting a pathway for our young players a route in the first team(if good enough). For me this is the weakest squad, we had since promotion. In terms of strength in depth. Players like Ledley,Kelly,Campbell,lee,mutch and even Delaney are championship players. What's the point in keeping players that nowhere good enough for the first team like Delaney if we're in the prem. The average age of the squad is 28.4 years old. Which will increase keeping the likes of Delaney and speroni.

talksport.com/football/every-premier-league-squads-average-age-ranked-oldest-youngest-170322232395?p=4

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 27 Mar 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Dan89

. It's time we starting a pathway for our young players a route in the first team(if good enough). For me this is the weakest squad, we had since promotion. In terms of strength in depth. Players like Ledley,Kelly,Campbell,lee,mutch and even Delaney are championship players. What's the point in keeping players that nowhere good enough for the first team like Delaney if we're in the prem. The average age of the squad is 28.4 years old. Which will increase keeping the likes of Delaney and speroni.

talksport.com/football/every-premier-league-squads-average-age-ranked-oldest-youngest-170322232395?p=4

This squad is by far the strongest since promotion , that comment is laughable , unless of course you think , players like okeefe are better than McCarthur , ramage Better than dann , price better than speroni , kebe better than Sako , Ledley can't currently make the squad and he's better than kg who was first choice , Delaney is now 4th choice centre back and he was first team , infact until we signed dann he was our best cb.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Mar 17 12.55pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

This squad is by far the strongest since promotion , that comment is laughable , unless of course you think , players like okeefe are better than McCarthur , ramage Better than dann , price better than speroni , kebe better than Sako , Ledley can't currently make the squad and he's better than kg who was first choice , Delaney is now 4th choice centre back and he was first team , infact until we signed dann he was our best cb.


. I didn't state that kebe,o'keefe or price are better.
Yeah it strong now. It was verified by big Sam in Jan.You can't tell that the squad was strong at the start of the season. When we were relying on Ledley and Sako filling voids left by jedinak and bolaisie. Swapping Dwight Gayle for an injury prone remy or a unaffective Campbell. Only one recognised left back.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Mar 17 12.57pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

This squad is by far the strongest since promotion , that comment is laughable , unless of course you think , players like okeefe are better than McCarthur , ramage Better than dann , price better than speroni , kebe better than Sako , Ledley can't currently make the squad and he's better than kg who was first choice , Delaney is now 4th choice centre back and he was first team , infact until we signed dann he was our best cb.

The line ups from Boxing Day 2016
[Link]

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 27 Mar 17 1.50pm

Originally posted by Dan89


. I didn't state that kebe,o'keefe or price are better.
Yeah it strong now. It was verified by big Sam in Jan.You can't tell that the squad was strong at the start of the season. When we were relying on Ledley and Sako filling voids left by jedinak and bolaisie. Swapping Dwight Gayle for an injury prone remy or a unaffective Campbell. Only one recognised left back.

you stated this is the weakest squad in terms of depth since promotion , it isn't , it's the strongest. It may not have been in some areas in the summer , but that has been addressed.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 27 Mar 17 2.00pm

Originally posted by Dan89


. I didn't state that kebe,o'keefe or price are better.
Yeah it strong now. It was verified by big Sam in Jan.You can't tell that the squad was strong at the start of the season. When we were relying on Ledley and Sako filling voids left by jedinak and bolaisie. Swapping Dwight Gayle for an injury prone remy or a unaffective Campbell. Only one recognised left back.

About 3 posts earlier you stated

So according to you we offer speroni a new deal because of saves he made in 2015. That's was 2 half years ago. Football not a charity case it's a business. Speroni 37 and he had one very good season in the prem. The rest of his best years were in the championship. If you was in charge we'd still have ramage,Murray and jedinak. Get in the real world. You stand still in football. You go backwards.


So Jedinak was a void that needed to be filled (which he was) but at the same time was crap.

I'd suggest you understand sod all of the dynamics of human nature as well and as to how groups of people interact with one another. The best players are not always the best leaders and Jedinak wasn't the most technically gifted footballer at the club but he was a personality and a leader and wasn't adequately replaced in that respect either.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Mar 17 2.43pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

About 3 posts earlier you stated

So according to you we offer speroni a new deal because of saves he made in 2015. That's was 2 half years ago. Football not a charity case it's a business. Speroni 37 and he had one very good season in the prem. The rest of his best years were in the championship. If you was in charge we'd still have ramage,Murray and jedinak. Get in the real world. You stand still in football. You go backwards.


So Jedinak was a void that needed to be filled (which he was) but at the same time was crap.

I'd suggest you understand sod all of the dynamics of human nature as well and as to how groups of people interact with one another. The best players are not always the best leaders and Jedinak wasn't the most technically gifted footballer at the club but he was a personality and a leader and wasn't adequately replaced in that respect either.

I didn't once called jedinak crap. Jedinak the best leader we've had in my lifetime of supporting Palace. He was not adequately replaced in the summer window with his leadership and his position. Now we have luka. So let's move on.

Edited by Dan89 (27 Mar 2017 2.44pm)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Mar 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

you stated this is the weakest squad in terms of depth since promotion , it isn't , it's the strongest. It may not have been in some areas in the summer , but that has been addressed.

You take every word literally. When I made the comment about a weak squad. I was comparing it to not replacing jedinak or bolaise properly. Let's move on now Sam has rectify the squad and we steer us to safety.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 28 Mar 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

A lot of players deal are up at the end of the season. Provided we a prem side. Who should we keep or release.

Players contracts up:
Hennessy
Speroni
Fryers
Kelly
Flamini
Delaney
Appiah
Ledley
Campbell

Personally the only one I would keep is one of the gk as a 3rd choice maybe speroni. If we're to move to the next level. It's time to improve the squad.

Good interesting post. Clearly it depends on what division we are playing in, but let's assume we are still in the Prem, I would keep Speroni, Hennessey, Delaney and Ledley from that lot as no more that squad cover.

Edited by Bexley Eagle (28 Mar 2017 2.49pm)

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 03 Apr 17 9.25am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

A lot of players deal are up at the end of the season. Provided we a prem side. Who should we keep or release.

Players contracts up:
Hennessy
Speroni
Fryers
Kelly
Flamini
Delaney
Appiah
Ledley
Campbell

Personally the only one I would keep is one of the gk as a 3rd choice maybe speroni. If we're to move to the next level. It's time to improve the squad.

Keep Kelly, Hennessy and speroni as squad players

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

mattteo Flag 03 Apr 17 3.43pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

You are ridiculous. Completely ignoring what people are saying. No one is suggesting Speroni is the first name on the sheet. People are saying he is a cheap Palace legend with a great work ethic who is capable and happy as a number three, much like Steve Harper has been. There will be few no. 3s with as much experience or ability. For the amount it costs and the benefits he brings to the squad it makes no sense to replace him as a 3rd choice. Same with Damo as 4th Choice CB. Why gut the dressing room, these are huge characters and managing a squad is more than just about getting the best 11 a club can afford.

You didn't say a goalkeeper like Hart or Begovic either, you said you wanted 'Begovic or Hart as number 1'

There's no rational point to having an old third choice goalkeeper other than for nostalgia.
3rd keeper should be 18-19 year old. He'll hardly play (maybe once a season, maybe not at all). No point in having Speroni. When will youngsters develop?

 

Mstrobez Flag 03 Apr 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by mattteo

There's no rational point to having an old third choice goalkeeper other than for nostalgia.
3rd keeper should be 18-19 year old. He'll hardly play (maybe once a season, maybe not at all). No point in having Speroni. When will youngsters develop?

Surprised you didn't list 324 available ones with in depth scouting reports.

Edited by Mstrobez (03 Apr 2017 5.49pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

bashy2 Flag London 03 Apr 17 6.27pm

I would keep ledley kelly speroni get rid of the rest we need to get the dead wood of the payroll the money we save by getting rid of the rest we could get sakho the 1st thing I would buy in the summer is sakho and by another forward and a new GK that would be us done for the summer than I would move mountains to buy sakho his been brilliant since he joined

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 03 Apr 17 6.51pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Julian Speroni ?

Great knowledge well done.


Agreed.

The save against Ashley Barnes during the play-off against the south coast lot was probably the greatest in the club's history.

Or was that Perry Suckling's from Simon Garner against Blackburn Rovers in the 1989 play-off 2nd leg?

Anyway, it's up there.

 

mattteo Flag 04 Apr 17 6.10am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Surprised you didn't list 324 available ones with in depth scouting reports.

Edited by Mstrobez (03 Apr 2017 5.49pm)


You know, when an incompetent attempts a joke it doesn't really go well for him

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 04 Apr 17 10.04am

End of contract and end of apprenticeship are times for change. The squad needs to be able to put out a team forty (38 PL - 1 League Cup - 1 FA Cup) or more times in a season.

We now have a number of first on the team-sheet players who were not in anyone's thoughts a few seasons ago.

Some of the remainder of the squad have done their bit for Palace; some may never perform as wanted; and we have ten injured players and almost ten on loan.

I am eagerly awaiting Sam as manager next season when he has taken the opportunity presented by contracts ending to give us a squad with a more top six finish feel.

I am sure that he has noticed how many teams are naming around four under 22 players on match-days.

COYP.

 

Mstrobez Flag 04 Apr 17 10.43am

Originally posted by mattteo


You know, when an incompetent attempts a joke it doesn't really go well for him

Yeah cos this whole Holmesdale/Scouting expert experience is going superbly well for you isn't it

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

GladAllOver27 Flag 12 Apr 17 8.16am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

A lot of players deal are up at the end of the season. Provided we a prem side. Who should we keep or release.

Players contracts up:
Hennessy
Speroni
Fryers
Kelly
Flamini
Delaney
Appiah
Ledley
Campbell

Personally the only one I would keep is one of the gk as a 3rd choice maybe speroni. If we're to move to the next level. It's time to improve the squad.

After getting their confidence back. I would keep Hennessy ,speroni and Martin Kelly

 

miss smith Flag london 12 Apr 17 8.34am

do we keep jordan mutch when his contract runs out in 2019

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your Deals up (Do you keep or Release )