You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Massive Squad overhaul needed
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Massive Squad overhaul needed


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 07 May 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe


Goalkeeper; Left-footed centre-half and a Number 10 to support the centre-forward.

Throw in another lower-prem standard centre half to give us injury / tiredness cover, plus a starting-quality right back. Add one more midfielder of a standard higher than the current level of Punch.

This season has shown up how terribly thin our squad actually is and how we really do need 15-18 Prem standard players rather than hoping to get by with perhaps 8 or 9 (at the start of the season).

Edited by Mr_Gristle (07 May 2017 2.58pm)

Edited by Mr_Gristle (07 May 2017 2.59pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 07 May 17 2.59pm

Must stop quoting instead of editing.


Edited by Mr_Gristle (07 May 2017 2.59pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 May 17 3.28pm

Originally posted by whitehorselane

Agree with Parrot. They have got to a better option than Remy. Got to develope our youngsters.

Cannot judge players until they've been given the opportunity

The judgement is already in. They haven't particularly shone whilst on loan. No grounds whatsoever to believe they'd perform any better in the Premiership. If either Boateng or Kaikai showed the promise to perform at the highest level, they'd have demonstrated it by now.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 May 17 3.52pm

Originally posted by Painter

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I just hope that finally the chairman will realise tht you can't do things on the cheap.

quote]

You are talking a load of crap. A good scouting network to find new players is what's needed, not just splashing out cash on overpriced players with greedy agents.
It is impossible to clear out a squad of players, they are on contracts, if nobody is going to offer to buy them, your stuck with them. This is the problem every new manager has, they inherit players they don't want. As a club we cant afford to just ignore them, we have to try and get the best out of them and get them playing.
I think far to many posters on here think the Football Manager game is reality.

I've never played football manager, but I have seen our chairman splash ridiculous money on average players this winter because we failed to spend enough in the Summer when better players are available. If we have average players to offload on contracts it's because we signed them in the first place. Our record on transfers has been mixed to say the least and a failure to spend big in the summer might yet cost us our place in the Premier League. The current ownership has had plenty of time to build a good scouting network and like all owners coming from other business, they need several years to understand how football works.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 May 17 3.59pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe


Parish will be choking on his champagne if he reads this.

This season we splashed a staggering £30m on Benteke, whose 14 goals give us a chance of staying up.

We also did £13m on an England international (Andros) and during the January window Parish spent another £30m-odd.

As a club we have thrown absolutely mental money at it.

We actually spent less than 10 million net in transfer fees in the Summer and then had to splash 40 million in panic buys in January.
Does that make sense to you?

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 May 2017 7.35pm)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 07 May 17 5.33pm

We need another forward with CB and Connor. MUST buy a number 10 and bench Punch. A player like Juan Mata would be great. Luka and Cabaye have been great but we need a back up. Macca not good enough. Wardy not good enough too. Icing on cake would be Sakho, Tomkins was starting to look the part beside him. If Pape returns he could push PVA and Schlupp at LB

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 07 May 17 8.39pm

The front 3, Luka and Yoyo, three of the back four and Henessey are all good to great - for a top first XI just Punch and Ward need to be upgraded. The problem isn't the team it's the squad - one or two injuries in key places and we really suffer - Kelly hasn't been a bad squad player, but not as good as Hangeland was - you CAN make shrewd value aquistions, but our second XI has all this Chungy, Mutchy, Sako-ey championship quality to it - it'll only take a couple of signings to get the first XI competitive, but it's the back-up players and the competition for places that probably guarantee the mid table security we've lacked in each of our four prem campaigns. The front-line part of the squad has undoubtedly progressed during our time in the prem, remember Gabbidon, Moxey, O'Keefe and KG played a lot of games in our first season back - they wouldn't get a sniff today. But we still need to add regularly in the windows - we'll have Conor and Benteke next season, so a striker isn't first priority, a young winger to keep Andros and Wilf up to their game, two proper midfielders, a right back and a centre back (hopefully but unlikely Sakho). And a keeper. That's a miniumum of five prob more like six to keep us competitive. We'd be carrying Punch and Ward next season and definitely have to move on there. Mind you I've got this strange feeling Puncheon might be Big Sam's Kevin Nolan.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 07 May 17 9.37pm

What do people think the budget is? I think we will have to receive more than we spend because we pushed the boat out in Jan. (I know some will disagree and would sincerely love to hear why). I'd happily see the back of Schlupp if we could get anywhere near the 11m or so we reportedly paid for him.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

GladAllOver27 Flag 07 May 17 9.49pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

What do people think the budget is? I think we will have to receive more than we spend because we pushed the boat out in Jan. (I know some will disagree and would sincerely love to hear why). I'd happily see the back of Schlupp if we could get anywhere near the 11m or so we reportedly paid for him.


I doubt we will have to make a profit, with the 2nd year of the television money.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 07 May 17 9.52pm

Disagree massively. The squad's pretty damn good. Can't plan for your first 3 choice CB getting injured.

We need competition for Ward. Competition for Puncheon on the AM role and we need to try our hardest to secure both Sakho and Zaha. Then with Wickham back to fitness, that'll be a decent squad.

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 07 May 17 9.55pm

It's not how much you spend. It how you spend it. Can we find better than what we currently have in our squad. My guess the budget will be about 40 to 80 million. As big Sam spoke in his presser about moving to the next level. Which Blackburn didn't match his ambitions. I can't see parish making a similar mistake to the pulis situation.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 07 May 17 10.02pm

Originally posted by sprites

Disagree massively. The squad's pretty damn good. Can't plan for your first 3 choice CB getting injured.

We need competition for Ward. Competition for Puncheon on the AM role and we need to try our hardest to secure both Sakho and Zaha. Then with Wickham back to fitness, that'll be a decent squad.

Completely agree with this. A few games ago people would have been saying we only need a couple of additions for next season but suddenly after a few bad results it seems half the squad need to go! An additional striker like Defoe, the return of a fit Papa Souare and two or three new players and we will be a comfortable middle of the table side assuming we stay up obviously.

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 07 May 17 10.07pm

Originally posted by sprites

Disagree massively. The squad's pretty damn good. Can't plan for your first 3 choice CB getting injured.

We need competition for Ward. Competition for Puncheon on the AM role and we need to try our hardest to secure both Sakho and Zaha. Then with Wickham back to fitness, that'll be a decent squad.

If the squad that good. Where's the back up for Wilf , no competition for puncheon role. We lost 20 games in 36 games. Under pulis We stayed up with about 5 games to go with a strike force of Jerome and chamakh. A midfield of kg, Stuart o'keefe and jedinak. I not claiming this players are better, but they certainly had a great mentality. We fell into the trap of buying prem mercenaries like flamini,remy and adebayor. Our scouting has to be the worst in the prem.

 

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 07 May 17 10.33pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Pretty much spot on. Kelly I might consider as a back up player (as he can play full back and centre back) but we need two central defenders, a right back, a goal keeper (Pickford from Sunderland maybe) and a defensive minded midfielder.

See, we do sometimes agree - All of those players, except maybe Kelly, I'd say are surplus to requirements over several seasons.


Don't forget Mutch.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 07 May 17 11.06pm

Originally posted by Dan89

That maybe true but he's been back for at least a month. He form has diminished

He's been back since January 31st. He should be fully fit by now.

Edited by Dan89 (07 May 2017 1.08pm)

He was suffering with back spasms and is stil clearly not over it as he isn't moving right and it has been effecting his performances , he has had more poor games in the last month than he had in the previous two years.

 

Philombardo Flag Tunbridge Wells 07 May 17 11.16pm

Originally posted by sprites

Disagree massively. The squad's pretty damn good. Can't plan for your first 3 choice CB getting injured.

We need competition for Ward. Competition for Puncheon on the AM role and we need to try our hardest to secure both Sakho and Zaha. Then with Wickham back to fitness, that'll be a decent squad.

We don't need competition for Punch and Ward, we need replacements!
Sakho would be a brilliant if unlikely acquisition and Heaton or Pickford would be an upgrade on WH.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 07 May 17 11.49pm

Everything depends on what league we are in.

Stay up we need four or five improvements, keeper , midfield , centre backs , Salhouse is not ours .

Go down we will have many involuntary losses and will need 8 or 9 to replace and compete at championship level.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 08 May 17 1.05am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

If the squad that good. Where's the back up for Wilf , no competition for puncheon role. We lost 20 games in 36 games. Under pulis We stayed up with about 5 games to go with a strike force of Jerome and chamakh. A midfield of kg, Stuart o'keefe and jedinak. I not claiming this players are better, but they certainly had a great mentality. We fell into the trap of buying prem mercenaries like flamini,remy and adebayor. Our scouting has to be the worst in the prem.

The purchase of Milovojevic alone would suggest otherwise. That was a win for our scouting department. Plus the addition of Sakho has just about saved our season. And before that, Benteke, Tomkins and Townsend have all turned out to be decent additions too. So I challenge that.

You're right about competition for Punch. If you read my comment, I mentioned that. And no, we don't have a direct replacement for Wilf. But will we ever find one? It's not necessarily about direct replacements, because if it was, they'd never play. Because a fit Wilf always will. But players can play multiple positions, which make them valuable squad members. If Wilf got injured tomorrow, Puncheon or Chungy would do a decent job, for example.

And don't be silly, Stuart O'Keefe barely started a game for us.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 08 May 17 1.09am

Originally posted by Philombardo

We don't need competition for Punch and Ward, we need replacements!
Sakho would be a brilliant if unlikely acquisition and Heaton or Pickford would be an upgrade on WH.

Yes, but only if they're better than them.

When on their game, both Punch and Ward are decent players at this level. We've all seen that. They've just got less reason to bust a gut, as they're certain starters at the minute. That's why they need competition. Hence the comment.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 08 May 17 1.26am

Even tho punch has improved under Sam he is certainly let himself down. I mean here we have a player who for the most part plays the number 10 role. He has made how many assists or scored how many goals? I know parked prob had a hand in ruining his game but come on...i think there must be a bus load of players better to be found in close season that would elevate that part of our game.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Massive Squad overhaul needed