You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Great Academy or a neglected one


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
BarEagle Flag Monmouth 30 Jun 17 9.54am

Williams is not good enough. The end.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 30 Jun 17 10.04am

Genuine question. Is an Academy with the cost and hassle worth it? Only Southampton appear to use it correctly, the rest just play at it. Why not except that you cannot take the risk of playing younger players and buy players from the lower leagues? I would love our academy to produce even one player a year but it all seems miles away. I get the impression no one is really close to the first team, perhaps the odd game in the League Cup but are we kidding ourselves that things are going to change?

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 30 Jun 17 1.35pm

Refers to OP.

Good friend of mine was in the Palace academy some years ago. Same time as Zaha and co. He said Garry Issot is a prick he can't stand the dude.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 30 Jun 17 1.41pm

Originally posted by CJr94

Refers to OP.

Good friend of mine was in the Palace academy some years ago. Same time as Zaha and co. He said Garry Issot is a prick he can't stand the dude.

What the coaching like strict or relaxed. I personally think he's been there too long and it's time for a total restructure.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 30 Jun 17 6.53pm

Really can't see an academy product in the side next season. Apart from Wilf of course. Even if we don't produce for ourselves and make the odd million to a championship club.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Username Flag Horsham 30 Jun 17 7.36pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

That's a view shared by lots of people and I see your point.

In my view they don't have to come into the 1st XI and set the world on fire, some just need to be good enough to come in as cover for injuries and put in a half decent performance every now and then.

That way we can concentrate on buying one or two real quality players who can improve the starting team without needing to divert funds signing squad players.

A bit of first team exposure would probably boost the value of the youngsters too, so if they don't make it we can still get some cash when they move on....which again can then be spent on paying for quality players to take the club forward.

Problem is, there's little to suggest they can do that? If you wanted someone to come in to be a squad player, you'd at least want them to be a notable performer in the Champ. None of our loanees have managed that so far.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Flash Flag Lampeter 04 Jul 17 9.07am

Originally posted by Dan89

Steve parish was waxing lirecal about the academy. While I understand that it's far difficult to play younger players in the prem. Even the likes of Zaha and Williams came through under Simon Jordan tenure as chairman. The reality is our academy is not good enough, because if your good enough, your old enough. I'd love to be proved wrong but can you really see the likes of Williams getting in the side. When there's about 4 players ahead of him already and will be more if new recruits join. The perfect example last season, we have a left back problem with soaure accident. Why didn't we try an academy left back, couldn't of done worse than what ward, Kelly did in that position.

From what I've seen of Nya Kirby playing for England, he's good enough & confident enough. This season he'll turn 18. The question is how confident is the manager? I really hope FdB gives this lad a chance to show what he can do. He could be a star playmaker for us.

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 04 Jul 17 9.23am

I'd play the youth in every cup game because it's VERY unlikely we're ever going to win it anyway and would keep our first team squad fresher for the league. I'd also play the majority of them in the league as soon as we're safe from relegation.

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

HeathMan Flag Purley 04 Jul 17 10.32am

None of Kai Kai, Williams or Boateng are good enough. All it takes is too look at how average they have been on loan to league 1 sides and you can see why they've never got their chance in the PL. You have to be good enough to earn it.

I believe that Championship and League One are more physical than the PL. A Palace player loaned to one of those clubs is not available to play for Palace and can be a target for physical challenges - making him look ordinary.

I agree with Leecpfc with the qualification that our young players need to be available for cup and league matches.

 

Username Flag Horsham 04 Jul 17 11.21am

Originally posted by Leecpfc

I'd play the youth in every cup game because it's VERY unlikely we're ever going to win it anyway and would keep our first team squad fresher for the league. I'd also play the majority of them in the league as soon as we're safe from relegation.

We're never going to win the league, so why give up on winning cups?

Very unlikely? We were pretty close 14 months ago.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 04 Jul 17 12.00pm

Originally posted by Username

We're never going to win the league, so why give up on winning cups?

Very unlikely? We were pretty close 14 months ago.

Agreed, Franks brief is to get to 40 points ASAP,and try to Win one or both Cups.
Selecting strong teams along the way.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Pierre Flag Purley 04 Jul 17 12.28pm

I think that FdB will have his hands full for the foreseeable future just getting to grips with the senior squad.
Deciding who to recommend for transfers in and out to eventually line up his his squad of 25 for the coming season.

As for Palace's Academy I believe its a romantic notion that FdB will be able to devote any time towards this in the near future.

Its a long held dream that Palace want to attract and sign better talent to the academy but Nya Kirby seems to be the only recent proof of this.

I do hope its an area that Palace can really develop, find the new premises that they need for it grow to a Category 1 Academy and really compete with the established clubs to produce top home grown talent!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 04 Jul 17 3.34pm

It is possible that with the appointment of FDB it could be an attraction for young talent to join given his track record elsewhere. In any event it will take time, which is generally a luxury not afforded to anyone in this day and age.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Jul 17 3.55pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

It is possible that with the appointment of FDB it could be an attraction for young talent to join given his track record elsewhere. In any event it will take time, which is generally a luxury not afforded to anyone in this day and age.

I'm not so sure. Have we sacked anyone apart from those that looked to be leading us into relegation?

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 04 Jul 17 8.54pm

To me there are those from the development squad who've had their chances and those that haven't. Time to move the former on and give the latter an opportunity to shine. Kirby & Flanaghan could be ready to step up to the plate and make names for themselves, save us millions and/or potentially make us millions
Coming back to the original question - the academy could be a goldmine if managed well ... and FdB probably has more experience of this than ANYBODY ELSE.
Superb appointment.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 05 Jul 17 9.44am

Originally posted by Dan89

There's a lot of talk that , FDB appointment is great news for the academy products. However are the likes of Kai Kai good enough or is that there not being given an opportunity. While previous managers have joined the club, with survival as their only mission. These players have hardly flourished in the U23 game or when out on loan in the football league. Im all for giving youth a chance but they have to be good enough. Didn't the academy get graded as category B. How can we improve this. Is Gary Issot the problem.

What's your thoughts on the academy and why has it been 7 to 8 years. Since Zaha burst onto he scene.

Edited by Dan89 (27 Jun 2017 11.26am)

Not done well when out on loan? I've seen Joniesta at Ipswich, a boy at Shrewsbury, another with Hartlepool. They are heroes there. They, like Kai May not be good enough for the EPL, that's all

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Jul 17 10.13am

Originally posted by adrian b

Not done well when out on loan? I've seen Joniesta at Ipswich, a boy at Shrewsbury, another with Hartlepool. They are heroes there. They, like Kai May not be good enough for the EPL, that's all

They must have made a real impression if you can't remember who they were. Ladapo was at Shrewsbury and Jake Gray was at Hartlepool who liked him so much we off-loaded him on a free to Luton, who've moved him on to Yeovil. Williams only managed eight appearances for Ipswich last season before suffering the inevitable injury. If you're right, the Tractor Boys have some rather odd "heroes".

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Dan89 Flag Se25 09 Jul 17 8.26am

He's already mentioned about Luke dreher, hasn't enough muscle to be a premier player yet. Q.Should we loan our academy product abroad, in holland or Germany for a better footballing education?

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 09 Jul 17 9.21am

We came bottom of the U23 table in the lowest division, and we came 3rd in the equivalent U18 division.

I understand that the best of the U23 bunch will be loaned out, but I imagine it's the same for other clubs in the division. If we had such great kids, they wouldn't have come bottom.

Historical we've produced good teams - won the FA Youth Cup twice and getting to the final another two times. Unfortunately, the fact is, our academy has been neglected for years, which is a massive shame given the catchment and relatively less competition we've got.

 


[Link]

GladAllOver27 Flag 13 Jul 17 4.22pm

Concern that frank said he wants to see what's in his own kitchen, his arrival hasn't suddenly turned our academy product into prem players.

[Link]

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one