You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-4-3 Do we have the players
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-4-3 Do we have the players


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Jul 17 5.00pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

This for me:

Adrian
Chambers Sahko Riedewald
Van der Wiel Milevoyevic Cabaye(C)/Loftus-Cheek PVA
Zaha Benteke Townsend

SUBS: Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins/Dann, Schlupp, Puncheon/McArthur, Loftus-Cheek, Wickham/Ladapo/Anderson

My idea of a decent line-up (and I don’t care about Puncheon being made captain)

We'd win many a game with that line up.

 

OneMax Flag Maidstone 26 Jul 17 5.24pm

Why is Riedewald being put in anyone's team he is 20 he was not even a starter for Ajax last season, we have not seen him play give the lad a chance. I hope he develops into a good if not great Palace player but lets not build him up too much. If he starts the season on the bench he will be happy.

 

bodge Flag 26 Jul 17 7.19pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why would you spend a small fortune in buying up better players than we already have and then stick an old man in goal?

Buffon has done very well at JSs sort of age.

 

leejaneagles Flag 26 Jul 17 7.45pm

It's alright having these ideal line ups but when you stop and think they are definitely just fantasy.

We just might get Sakho but Chambers and Der Wiel? We aren't Man City!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 26 Jul 17 9.38pm

Benteke's mainly headed goals and Wilf's wing play with goals added to his game were the main reason we managed to stay up.

Get the idea about varying the tactics but appears Benteke hardly saw a cross in HK. Reserve judgement but getting a bit concerned by some of this bullsh1t tbh.

 

Zaha Oh Yes Flag Epsom 30 Jul 17 4.42pm

Hennessy , Speroni, ???? :- gk
????, Kelly -Rcb
dann, Tomkins - cb
Riedewald, Delaney - Lcb
PVA , schlupp :- Lwb
Townsend, ????:- rwb
Puncheon, Cabaye- cm 1
Mcarthur, Luka , loftus-cheek - cm2
zaha,Sako - lw
Lokilo, ?????- rw
Benteke, wickham, ???- St

Gk,Cb, rwb and winger/striker


 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 31 Jul 17 11.33pm

I'm not the biggest fan of it and wouldn't say it suits us too well. The way we play it, our two central midfield players end up sitting very deep and are not too willing to carry the ball forward (would expect Puncheon to do this but he doesn't), meaning that they can't really link with the front three. For me, there has seemed to be too much of a gap between them.

From what I have seen they are not always looking to receive the ball from the back three either which means that the defenders end up having to try and hoof the ball. Benteke seems very isolated. Also I personally prefer having wingers and full backs so that they can support each other up and down the flanks. However if we have a central midfielder who is willing to carry the ball forward and pass effectively (not just backwards or sideways all the time) perhaps it could work a bit better.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Aug 17 1.50am

Yeah feels like we're trying to squeeze our players into a system, instead of figuring out a system to suit our players. We've got 4/5 quality centre mids...with two spots for them in the new system. Mmmm.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Aug 17 11.44am

No Palace do not have the defenders who can control the ball and either pass it easily to an area on least contention or run forward with the ball and play defence splitting passes often enough. FeB is worriedabout his and has asked Milyovich to drop into defence, as he could do the job required. That is receive the simple pass from another defender and distribute it. Alternatively, run forward with the ball catching all those advanced opposing forwards out of position.
How FdB gets around this dilemma is anybody's guess, but he may try it initially as Huddersfield doesnt seem a stretch and against Liverpool away Palace have nothing to lose.

 

majorkaios Flag Trowbridge, Wilts 01 Aug 17 12.06pm

This year WE ONLY NEED 1 RWB AND 1 FWD/ST on loan but will be happy to wait till we can afford top quality next year.

I'm ready for the rollercoaster with Frank De Boar its gonna be a bumpy ride at first

COYP

 


School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. ))

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Aug 17 12.14pm

Originally posted by majorkaios

This year WE ONLY NEED 1 RWB AND 1 FWD/ST on loan but will be happy to wait till we can afford top quality next year.

I'm ready for the rollercoaster with Frank De Boar its gonna be a bumpy ride at first

COYP

As FdB would say..."for sure"

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 02 Aug 17 10.32am

very interesting article from Sky on 3-4-3 and how opposition teams cope against it

[Link]

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 02 Aug 17 11.03am

Originally posted by adrian b

No Palace do not have the defenders who can control the ball and either pass it easily to an area on least contention or run forward with the ball and play defence splitting passes often enough. FeB is worriedabout his and has asked Milyovich to drop into defence, as he could do the job required. That is receive the simple pass from another defender and distribute it. Alternatively, run forward with the ball catching all those advanced opposing forwards out of position.
How FdB gets around this dilemma is anybody's guess, but he may try it initially as Huddersfield doesnt seem a stretch and against Liverpool away Palace have nothing to lose.

This 100%
Slightly concerning we currently don't have the players for this. Reassuring that FdB at least seems aware of this and is trying to address it. I thought the same last year when AP started trying to change us to a possession based team... But thought he could do it with an entire defence who were completely uncomfortable with the ball at their feet.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 02 Aug 17 11.20am

Originally posted by adrian b

How FdB gets around this dilemma is anybody's guess, but he may try it initially as Huddersfield doesnt seem a stretch and against Liverpool away Palace have nothing to lose.

Except the nine points we've picked up at Anfield in the last three seasons, of course.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Hudsoneagle Flag 02 Aug 17 12.16pm

FdB made a recent comment that his true favoured formation was 4-3-3 but that he didn't think we have the players to play that formation at the present time so he was going to go with 3-4-3 which I just find baffling.

The Palace squad has been built around the 4-3-3 formation for the past few years, so I can only assume he means we don't have the right players to play his iteration of 4-3-3.

I don't think we have the players for 3-4-3, much less than we do for 4-3-3. Like I said it is all a bit confusing but at the end of the day FdB will know far more than I could ever hope to when it comes to player types and how they do or don't fit a system.

Right now I would say forget which centre backs we do or don't have. We don't have a right sided wing back at all. Joel Ward is not a wing back and neither is Townsend.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 02 Aug 17 12.34pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

FdB made a recent comment that his true favoured formation was 4-3-3 but that he didn't think we have the players to play that formation at the present time so he was going to go with 3-4-3 which I just find baffling.

The Palace squad has been built around the 4-3-3 formation for the past few years, so I can only assume he means we don't have the right players to play his iteration of 4-3-3.

I don't think we have the players for 3-4-3, much less than we do for 4-3-3. Like I said it is all a bit confusing but at the end of the day FdB will know far more than I could ever hope to when it comes to player types and how they do or don't fit a system.

Right now I would say forget which centre backs we do or don't have. We don't have a right sided wing back at all. Joel Ward is not a wing back and neither is Townsend.

Since when have we played 433?? think your confused with 451 which is very different in the way that the positions link together.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 02 Aug 17 12.45pm

Originally posted by adrian b

No Palace do not have the defenders who can control the ball and either pass it easily to an area on least contention or run forward with the ball and play defence splitting passes often enough. FeB is worriedabout his and has asked Milyovich to drop into defence, as he could do the job required. That is receive the simple pass from another defender and distribute it. Alternatively, run forward with the ball catching all those advanced opposing forwards out of position.
How FdB gets around this dilemma is anybody's guess, but he may try it initially as Huddersfield doesnt seem a stretch and against Liverpool away Palace have nothing to lose.

Agree with this. It also requires a CM who can keep possession when receiving from the defense in tight areas and turn. So far, whilst puncheon keeps possession he just passes backwards. Loftus Cheek seemed to be the player who had confidence (in the WBA game at least) to take on the on the opposition when he was closed down.

Ideally a pairing of Luka and Loftus Cheek in CM would leave me happy but as Punch is captain, I can't see it.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Aug 17 1.07pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

Since when have we played 433?? think your confused with 451 which is very different in the way that the positions link together.

after Luka arrived it was really him as the holding midfielder so a bit like 4-1-4-1 or a bit of 4-1-1-3-1 becoming 4-5-1 when sitting deep.

I'm concerned about 3-4-3 because of the personnel restrictions and the fact that Frank has never played it and only the top top rich clubs have. Valid concerns I'd say and people putting full trust in it might benefit from being a bit cautious about it. Won't be surprised if we're on the end of some coupon busters.

 


COYP

The_postman Flag Forest Row 02 Aug 17 1.08pm

I also agree with this. The way to counteract a 4-3-3 system is to press high when not in possession and move the ball into the space behind the wing backs as soon as you win possession. Dann, Tomkins and Delaney do not have the ball playing skill or the pass accuracy needed to cope with that pressure and that's why Luca has been drafted in as CB. Unfortunately whilst he has the skill he does not have the experience of playing as a CB which showed when he played in the Metz striker for the equaliser. Plus I think we need him as a defensive midfield player. I expect that the club are doing all they can to bring in a suitable CB to partner Riedewald. I also hope that we buy a proper right wing back as I am not convinced that Townsend can do the defensive part of that job.

Edited by The_postman (02 Aug 2017 1.09pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Aug 17 1.13pm

Originally posted by samprior

This 100%
Slightly concerning we currently don't have the players for this. Reassuring that FdB at least seems aware of this and is trying to address it. I thought the same last year when AP started trying to change us to a possession based team... But thought he could do it with an entire defence who were completely uncomfortable with the ball at their feet.

All part and parcel of selling yourself for a contract extension. Lesson learned, hopefully.

 


COYP

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-4-3 Do we have the players