You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We can't progress because we won't let it happen


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Aug 17 2.25pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

It gets you to safety and then you try the new system in competitive matches for the rest of the season and get ready to use that system for the following season. A good manager will also adapt their systems for an individual match, or even during a match, I didn't see much of that today when we were playing crap under the 'new' system.

Last time I looked at the table we were only 3 points off top spot... We're currently Safe!!

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Aug 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

You saw Dann and reidewald as positives. I thought they were competing to be the most s*** player on the pitch

I fully accept that Danns decision making was poor but it was good to see him physically back and sharp, decision making can be addressed. Reideweld was excellent on the ball technically and started a number of attacks, again his physicality was lacking but he's 20 and it was his 1st introduction to the Prem... So let's put things into perspective shall we. Ward on the other hand was poor positionally and technically..

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Aug 17 2.33pm

Originally posted by FinchleyEagle

For me, De Boer does not yet understand Crystal Palace and is trying to change too much too quickly, without having the players to do it, or possibly the coaching acumen.

The same thing happened to Pardew.

Pulis is a massively underrated manager and certainly here because of the acrimonious nature of his departure. That aside, at every club he's been at, he's looked at the players he has and plays to the individual and collective strength, then gradually imposes where he wants to go with new signings. It's not rocket science but is surprisingly rare.

Allardyce had a simple approach that can be implemented at pretty much any prem club. That's why he's never been relegated.

De Boer needs to learn in double-quick time what he's got (a very good squad) and how to get the best out of them and get results. Over time he can refine while hopefully still getting enough results, but not straight away.

I can only presume he hasn't done his homework on Palace, either last season or since we've been in the prem, which is such a shocking thought I hope I'm wrong. He doesn't seem to know that Townsend is one of our best players, Ward is a good player but never a wing back and we are not comfortable in possession in front of our own box - although few are in this time of chasing players down.

I hope he rectifies quickly, it's ok to make mistakes, especially at the beginning, but to not adapt would be unforgiveable.


Great well balanced post

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 13 Aug 17 2.47pm

Formations come and go, one thing will always remain, you will never be sucessful without a strong spine to the team, goalie, centre half, midfield, centre forward, get this right and then you play any formation you like, we sadly have a problem in two maybe three of those positions, Liverpool could be a disaster, if we set up the same, which i dont think we will, confidence could quickly become an issue, support for our team is vital, we went very quiet yesterday at times

 

bodge Flag 13 Aug 17 5.06pm

We need a new stand or three and a manager that gets us playing a set style that wins games. FDB could be the man i expect us to improve game on game as he adjusts the team to play his way it will be interesting to see if we go with a back four next week. The booing was a disgrace shame on the fans who did.

 

johnno42000 Flag 13 Aug 17 8.20pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Last time I looked at the table we were only 3 points off top spot... We're currently Safe!!

Actually we are 2nd to bottom but I think you know that isn't what I meant about being safe. Hit the 37-40 points and then try the new formation.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 13 Aug 17 11.56pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Spot on..its clear we still have players trying to adapt but there were positives today in RLC, Dann, Fosu Mensa and reidewald...our fans are fickle and will NEVER he happy. I'd have been more concerned if we didn't create chances but we did.. many more than they did.. the difference being we didn't convert them and their keeper made saves.. they took their chances even though to be fair we might as well have not had a keeper at all.

Deflated by that experience as I have ever been. But I agree we've got to give them a chance. I'm hoping new blood comes in. Maybe they will let us have Sakho after we play Liverpool.we must support the team, at least give them a chance to learn the system properly.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 13 Aug 17 11.57pm

Originally posted by bodge

We need a new stand or three and a manager that gets us playing a set style that wins games. FDB could be the man i expect us to improve game on game as he adjusts the team to play his way it will be interesting to see if we go with a back four next week. The booing was a disgrace shame on the fans who did.

Yes we are supporters. We must support.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

Jaha Flag 14 Aug 17 12.42am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

This style of football only works if you have top players. So yes when Barcelona, Bayern etc play it they win. But take any mid table team from any other league and put them in the premier league and they will be just as s*** as we were today.

Swansea of a few years ago managed to do it with a fair bit of success

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Aug 17 2.04am

Last season we were saved pretty much single handedly by Sakho a loan player. We now have our capacity of them and 2 teenagers were our best players on Saturday, but totally different players to Sakho. The permanent players have one new addition from last season who was definitely lacking for the second goal.
That leaves us with a squad who for nearly 2 seasons now has been seriously struggling. So why will any 'new system' alter the fundamental problem that our squad for whatever reason is struggling and Saturday was no different. Why should it have been?
The same players continue to struggle other than 2 gifted teens from Man U and Chelsea.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 14 Aug 17 2.29am

Don't let us kid ourselves, every season we (and several other teams) are surviving the rat race of PL by the skin of our teeth.
Last season could have been a disaster, but we got out of it. Now we're on it again. There's no time for experimenting in this division. Remember Hillsboro 2010? We stayed up because of our warriors that day, players who got stuck in - McCarthy, Lee and of course our talisman that season (Darren Ambrose).
With this system our defenders seem lost, not knowing when to passand when to get rid of the ball (and let those on the top fix the rest). Tackling was totally absent while the opposition got stuck in (did you sleep Jon Moss?)
Now FdB says he won't change anything come our playground in Liverpool. After a game that must have been one of the biggest managerial wake-up calls ever. Our 0-9 trashing from that FA Cup year still lives on. Without (possible) Zaha & Luka out as well, the faces of Parish/Bright will look even grimmer during that game.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Aug 17 6.39am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Last season we were saved pretty much single handedly by Sakho a loan player. We now have our capacity of them and 2 teenagers were our best players on Saturday, but totally different players to Sakho. The permanent players have one new addition from last season who was definitely lacking for the second goal.
That leaves us with a squad who for nearly 2 seasons now has been seriously struggling. So why will any 'new system' alter the fundamental problem that our squad for whatever reason is struggling and Saturday was no different. Why should it have been?
The same players continue to struggle other than 2 gifted teens from Man U and Chelsea.

This. We kid our self wr have quality players. One or two yes, the rest aren't. It wouldn't have mattered what system we played saturday, we just weren't good enough. Don't say we did well at the end of ladt season, that was almost entirely down to sakho. Without him we would have been relegated. According to frank they discussed before the Huddersfield game when they should pass it about and when to play it more direct, and the players kept making the wrong decisions.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 14 Aug 17 7.54am

Originally posted by spartakev2

This. We kid our self wr have quality players. One or two yes, the rest aren't. It wouldn't have mattered what system we played saturday, we just weren't good enough. Don't say we did well at the end of ladt season, that was almost entirely down to sakho. Without him we would have been relegated. According to frank they discussed before the Huddersfield game when they should pass it about and when to play it more direct, and the players kept making the wrong decisions.


His apparent inability to accept even partial responsibility is worryingly Pardewesque.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

timbob Flag 14 Aug 17 8.08am

No panic required
Keep the faith coyp

 

Face in Wetherspoons Flag 14 Aug 17 8.29am

He's probably s******g himself already having been totally outclassed by a newly promoted Team who were the bookies' main choice for Relegation. Maybe FdB did not fully appreciate just how tough it is in the Premier League and that there is very little time for players such as Riedeweld (who will probably develop into a fine player) to adjust to the demands. It is not a case that we are judging the Eagles on just one game as they had the two Asia Cup games and two First Team friendlies plus time on the training pitch to prepare. The Huddersfield match was the fifth occasion to play to the new system and the lads all looked totally lost not knowing what to do. We are all aware that you cannot allow a points gap to appear too early in the Season as it then becomes a real task to catch up. I wish FdB well and hope that it all turns out well but trust that he is prepared to change things if it is clear from a very early stage that there is a need to do so.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 14 Aug 17 5.42pm

I appreciate the thoroughness of your message however would like to offer you an alternative point of view. Perhaps even a bit of a qualified alternative point of view as I was a season ticket holder at the great Ajax mid nineties and a regular visitor of Ajax also under the Boer.

The main reason why the money floods in the English game is the attitude you seem to think rather derogatory about. Directness, attacking in principle, lots of things happening in the box. I think that is what brings worldwide TV money in the game. Now I will not say we were brilliant to watch under Allerdyce but in principle there is nothing wrong or not entertaining with a direct style.

You mention Guardiola and van Gaal. The first is indeed a prime example of system over everything. he now has to spent a s***load of money to try and repeat what he did at Barcelona and Bayern but any comparison with us is non existent as they are in a different league altogether. Van Gaal I would rate as tactically very very strong, he almost got us in the World cup final with a very average squad and to be honest very defensive football. Yet at Man Utd he made exactly the mistake that I am worried FdB is also making right now: putting system over squad and reality not taking into consideration what the crowd wants and be arrogant and know it all about it.

And you may think its appropriate to call a groaning crowd pathetic but sorry to say that I may well have been one of the groaners. Maybe you should allow people to have there own preference of style and not by default assume a new system will bring superior football and entertainment. I come across to England not to see a possession based style of football that leads to no treat, no action in the box and defenders playing it to each other. I have seen so much of this in the Amsterdam Arena that it may just be too much effort to travel across for. And yes, I feel strongly about it and will ask the question: do we really get more entertainment from a different style? And would we really think, at the moment we are a club that can move up the table into European positions? Tweak things yes, try things out fine, but the attitude of "a new system is there to be implied, whatever" is not something I will buy.

Also I would think it is rather odd you call the Chelsea style of football of last season s***ty, yet this is exactly the style FdB wants to introduce. What furthermore, strangely so, has gone completely under the radar is that FdB never ever played this system at Ajax. That was simply a 4 man defense, with 3 in midfield and yes, 2 wingers and central attacking player upfront. Something I would hope he would soon settle for with us.


Originally posted by Mstrobez

After an extremely poor result and performance I'm gonna put an opinion out that I know will prove unpopular but here goes.

In England, we delude ourselves senseless that we have the best league in the world. We go on about how much harder it is in england in comparison to Spain and Germany but our top teams never compete in Europe. We constantly talk down a possession based style of play, despite the fact that the best teams in the world play with this style and produce some of the most entertaining and successful teams and players in the world.

A new manager comes to the premier league, say a Pep or Van Gaal and instantly everyone calls them out to fail because "it doesn't work in the premier league". And the minute there is a bad result, the media and the fans are on progressive type managers like a pack of wolves with the "I told you so's" "you ain't in Spain/Holland/Germany/Italy anymore pal" etc etc.

No one ever stops to see the bigger picture, everyone wants instant results and success, regardless of longevity. Regardless of building anything in the long term. Regardless of whether or not overall they could build a more successful team that actually wins consistently or continentally. It's all now now now. The consequence of this is teams like Chelsea, playing a s***ty brand of football, winning the league and then the next season not even coming close to doing anything, getting knocked out by a European giant in the champions league and sacking Conte.

This is the epitome of what I saw at Selhurst today. There has been negativity around trying a new approach from the minute it was brought up. Every time we tried to play out from the back, the crowd groaned. Every time Hennessey or Dann or Riedewald didn't hoof the ball out, the crowd groaned. Ironically, when they did then hoof it out, the crowd also groaned. I think as fans we massively underestimate the amount it undermines the team and quite frankly one game in to the season, I think it was utterly pathetic.

The reason we won't progress is because of this attitude, we cannot improve without giving it a chance. Its funny how we bang on about "OH NOT A FAN OF THIS TIPPY TAPPY NONSENSE" yet completely ignore the fact that the newly promoted side who tanked us today are a team who've worked on a progressive type system for the past year. They're no hoof ball merchants, they're patient in possession, tactically sound and they play as a team.

There were many negatives in today's performance, that goes without saying. I have my own reservations about De Boer. We looked defensively all over the place and god forbid we sustain any injuries because barring Cabaye that would've been pretty much a fully fit team we put out today. But unless we try and get better, unless we adapt to the modern game, we will stagnate and it will inevitably lead to relegation because there are only so many Big Sams and Pulises knocking about and we've used up those 2 life lines already.

I predict the media will inevitably already have De Boer as a target and it would seem the fans have already passed judgement and deemed this a failed experiment. This will probably lead to a half hearted approach to our new style at the fear of being ruined by the press and booed every time we evade Hennessey hitting and hoping for the best. I've got my tin hat firmly on for this one and I will make a speedy exit before I undoubtedly get destroyed by many on here but this is my opinion about the Premier league in general. And it's one I've had for years, I don't buy the media nonsense pushed down our throat in this country about how amazingly excellent our league is.
Watch how one of the European giants play on a big champions league night, that's the best football in the world in my opinion, not this counter attacking "let's be avin ya" 80s type s*** that is common in the premier league.


Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.45pm)

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.46pm)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 14 Aug 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I appreciate the thoroughness of your message however would like to offer you an alternative point of view. Perhaps even a bit of a qualified alternative point of view as I was a season ticket holder at the great Ajax mid nineties and a regular visitor of Ajax also under the Boer.

The main reason why the money floods in the English game is the attitude you seem to think rather derogatory about. Directness, attacking in principle, lots of things happening in the box. I think that is what brings worldwide TV money in the game. Now I will not say we were brilliant to watch under Allerdyce but in principle there is nothing wrong or not entertaining with a direct style.

You mention Guardiola and van Gaal. The first is indeed a prime example of system over everything. he now has to spent a s***load of money to try and repeat what he did at Barcelona and Bayern but any comparison with us is non existent as they are in a different league altogether. Van Gaal I would rate as tactically very very strong, he almost got us in the World cup final with a very average squad and to be honest very defensive football. Yet at Man Utd he made exactly the mistake that I am worried FdB is also making right now: putting system over squad and reality not taking into consideration what the crowd wants and be arrogant and know it all about it.

And you may think its appropriate to call a groaning crowd pathetic but sorry to say that I may well have been one of the groaners. Maybe you should allow people to have there own preference of style and not by default assume a new system will bring superior football and entertainment. I come across to England not to see a possession based style of football that leads to no treat, no action in the box and defenders playing it to each other. I have seen so much of this in the Amsterdam Arena that it may just be too much effort to travel across for. And yes, I feel strongly about it and will ask the question: do we really get more entertainment from a different style? And would we really think, at the moment we are a club that can move up the table into European positions? Tweak things yes, try things out fine, but the attitude of "a new system is there to be implied, whatever" is not something I will buy.

Also I would think it is rather odd you call the Chelsea style of football of last season s***ty, yet this is exactly the style FdB wants to introduce. What furthermore, strangely so, has gone completely under the radar is that FdB never ever played this system at Ajax. That was simply a 4 man defense, with 3 in midfield and yes, 2 wingers and central attacking player upfront. Something I would hope he would soon settle for with us.

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.45pm)

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.46pm)

I was under the impression that 4-3-3 was his preferred formation. Very surprised by the change personally.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Aug 17 6.58pm

Frank also said ''Of course, results over style.''

Add that to the promise of doing it gradually. If it goes t1ts up with a massive serving of stubbornness then people will be rightfully p1ssed off.

Time will tell. Come on Frank. Come on Palace. (Praying we're okay. Could do without this so early in the season after the tension at the end of the last season)

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 14 Aug 17 10.40pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Frank also said ''Of course, results over style.''

Add that to the promise of doing it gradually. If it goes t1ts up with a massive serving of stubbornness then people will be rightfully p1ssed off.

Time will tell. Come on Frank. Come on Palace. (Praying we're okay. Could do without this so early in the season after the tension at the end of the last season)

I think what a lot of people are missing is 3-4-3 is a direct response to this. He didn't play 3 at the back at Ajax or Inter so implementing this style is in my opinion a solution for those concerned he wouldn't adapt. The idea, from what he's said is that it effectively can lead to you defending with 5 at the back when the opposition is on the front foot.

Edited by Mstrobez (14 Aug 2017 10.41pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Aug 17 10.47pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I think what a lot of people are missing is 3-4-3 is a direct response to this. He didn't play 3 at the back at Ajax or Inter so implementing this style is in my opinion a solution for those concerned he wouldn't adapt. The idea, from what he's said is that it effectively can lead to you defending with 5 at the back when the opposition is on the front foot.

Edited by Mstrobez (14 Aug 2017 10.41pm)

Trouble is the 2 wide forwards high up the pitch so you less players defending overall. 3-5-2 is an alternative. You can have Zaha in a free role, Luka shielding and 2 midfielders doing their stuff from box to box with freedom they didn't have v Huddersfield.

 


COYP

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen