You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > This is madness surely!
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

This is madness surely!


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Nobbybm Flag Dartford 20 Aug 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Parish is saying we need to sell to buy and hoping for 3 more players (very unlikely).

Why have we not got any money from American investors, Chinese sponsors and £100+ million TV dosh?

We have a thin squad with no PL quality goalie & one striker, and let alone needing PL quality in other positions, we have a manager whose footballing philosophy has produced one shot on target and no goals in 2 games and us plating up goals for opposing teams!

As many of you will know supporting Palace is not and has never been a choice for me, my season ticket is a given. So can someone offer me something in my despair that Parish may have just murdered our season and PL status other than blind and delusional optimism?

That's not actually what he said though is it. His words:

"In a perfect world probably three [new players], it's just whether we can stretch financially to do that, there's probably some we need to get out too."

To me that says we have 3 targets and a budget which is hopefully enough but might have to offload some to make it work, especially regarding wage bills & FFP.

It's getting pretty boring watching folk looking to make a negative about every little thing the Club, the players or the staff do (or don't do).

Edited by Nobbybm (20 Aug 2017 8.47pm)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 20 Aug 17 8.48pm

Originally posted by Pierre

Its amazing to read on here how easy it must be to run a Premiership football club judging by some of the comments!

I mean you only have to select the finest players at rock bottom prices knowing their values will only skyrocket in value. How hard can that be?

They will be playing under your special personally selected manager (nobody on your management shortlist would ever turn you down or fail to return your call surely?)
The team will only do well results are positive and will continue to be so!
Agents never stop ringing and players will always be willing to come to South London and play for Palace due to the fantastic location, opportunities and current facilities!

I for one am a realist it must be bloody hard work trying to keep a club like Palace running, healthy and also within the Premier League Short Term Cost Control Rules.

Sure there have been a couple of subsequently poor purchases that carry high wages we would rather rid of.
Also current problems like the training ground and Sainsburys not playing ball but there have also been good news recently like the new shirt and sleeve sponsorship deals which did pull in £6-7m.
However I believe SP and the board will get on with the business of football and make sure we are still in the premiership next season. Parish likes to play his cards close to his chest.
Its still a long way until next May!

'Like'

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

simlaboy Flag coulsdon 20 Aug 17 8.53pm

Definitely best chairman since Arthur , but that's not hard , two crooks and two t***s by my reckoning

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 20 Aug 17 9.19pm

Originally posted by Pierre

Its amazing to read on here how easy it must be to run a Premiership football club judging by some of the comments!

I mean you only have to select the finest players at rock bottom prices knowing their values will only skyrocket in value. How hard can that be?

They will be playing under your special personally selected manager (nobody on your management shortlist would ever turn you down or fail to return your call surely?)
The team will only do well results are positive and will continue to be so!
Agents never stop ringing and players will always be willing to come to South London and play for Palace due to the fantastic location, opportunities and current facilities!

I for one am a realist it must be bloody hard work trying to keep a club like Palace running, healthy and also within the Premier League Short Term Cost Control Rules.

Sure there have been a couple of subsequently poor purchases that carry high wages we would rather rid of.
Also current problems like the training ground and Sainsburys not playing ball but there have also been good news recently like the new shirt and sleeve sponsorship deals which did pull in £6-7m.
However I believe SP and the board will get on with the business of football and make sure we are still in the premiership next season. Parish likes to play his cards close to his chest.
Its still a long way until next May!

take that bit in bold as an example tho...the main shirt & sleeve sponsorship just about covers bentekkers wages for 1 season, thats the scary part...people see loads money from spinsorship but dont realise where it comes from.

lets get realistic in how we think

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Aug 17 9.28pm

Do love the people on here who think they can provide an exact analysis of the maths, those who want to compare our position now contextually against the history of the club or best of all the absolute f***ing muggy do gooders who think they have some moral high ground for speaking out against anyone raising a concern - my feelings for you people are visceral.

Would like to highlight that my original point if you read properly or to be fair maybe misinterpreted, was to ask if anyone had any positives for me as believe it or not I will still drink out of my selhurst mug at work, attend all home and some away games and keep the home shirt hanging from my wall at home.

I just feel as though the situation is pretty dire currently, I struggle to see where the optimism or hope can be justified (thin, non PL quality squad with a lack of transfer activity, bizarre tactics etc.) I thought maybe I hadn't taken something into consideration.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 20 Aug 17 9.45pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

That's not actually what he said though is it. His words:

"In a perfect world probably three [new players], it's just whether we can stretch financially to do that, there's probably some we need to get out too."

To me that says we have 3 targets and a budget which is hopefully enough but might have to offload some to make it work, especially regarding wage bills & FFP.

It's getting pretty boring watching folk looking to make a negative about every little thing the Club, the players or the staff do (or don't do).

Edited by Nobbybm (20 Aug 2017 8.47pm)

Good post.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 20 Aug 17 9.49pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Do love the people on here who think they can provide an exact analysis of the maths, those who want to compare our position now contextually against the history of the club or best of all the absolute f***ing muggy do gooders who think they have some moral high ground for speaking out against anyone raising a concern - my feelings for you people are visceral.

Would like to highlight that my original point if you read properly or to be fair maybe misinterpreted, was to ask if anyone had any positives for me as believe it or not I will still drink out of my selhurst mug at work, attend all home and some away games and keep the home shirt hanging from my wall at home.

I just feel as though the situation is pretty dire currently, I struggle to see where the optimism or hope can be justified (thin, non PL quality squad with a lack of transfer activity, bizarre tactics etc.) I thought maybe I hadn't taken something into consideration.[/quote]

You haven't. We've got a very sought after young manager who wants to change the DNA of the club for the better and is just finding his feet still. The transfer window doesn't shut for another ten days.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Aug 17 10.05pm

In response do Brentmaster, I did mention earlier my despair (suggesting perhaps some irrationality), but a manager trying to change the DNA of a club which barely survived due to loaning a world class CB and playing to its strengths (or 'DNA' by employing tactics almost directly against this, without that player and relying on us apparently signing a number of players in the next 10 days with no real evidence of that happening doesn't really help.

Still very concerned

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Aug 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

In response do Brentmaster, I did mention earlier my despair (suggesting perhaps some irrationality), but a manager trying to change the DNA of a club which barely survived due to loaning a world class CB and playing to its strengths (or 'DNA' by employing tactics almost directly against this, without that player and relying on us apparently signing a number of players in the next 10 days with no real evidence of that happening doesn't really help.

Still very concerned

Do you not think that the reason hes trying to change thd DNA is so that we don't just struggle to stay up each year..

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 20 Aug 17 11.16pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Do love the people on here who think they can provide an exact analysis of the maths, those who want to compare our position now contextually against the history of the club or best of all the absolute f***ing muggy do gooders who think they have some moral high ground for speaking out against anyone raising a concern - my feelings for you people are visceral.

Would like to highlight that my original point if you read properly or to be fair maybe misinterpreted, was to ask if anyone had any positives for me as believe it or not I will still drink out of my selhurst mug at work, attend all home and some away games and keep the home shirt hanging from my wall at home.

I just feel as though the situation is pretty dire currently, I struggle to see where the optimism or hope can be justified (thin, non PL quality squad with a lack of transfer activity, bizarre tactics etc.) I thought maybe I hadn't taken something into consideration.

The problem with your original point is that it both miss-quotes SP and takes it out of the context in which it was made.

I would politely suggest you actually listen to the podcast of that show for what was actually said before starting such a negative thread (especially when there are already plenty to choose from).

[Link]

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

mixed nuts Flag 20 Aug 17 11.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Do you not think that the reason hes trying to change thd DNA is so that we don't just struggle to stay up each year..

Sam left us, we didn't kick him out because Parish wanted him to stay, our new manager has been brought in to work and encourage the youngters and bring them through because he has an excellant record with them, the manager before Sam was also changing the way we play just as now but the club had to step in with sam to rescue what they perceived as relegation, nobody will ever be able to prove whether we would have gone down with the manager before Sam.
Swansea play lovely football and since they sacked Monk have struggled badly with it, the style of play with clubs such as us and Swansea means nothing more then just entertainment, players that play demand big pay and bright lights.
Frank de Boer is hopefully going to be given time to bring players through our youth and to buy bargains from the lower leagues that he can see will listen to him, this will be a tough transistion and hopefully if we find ourselves in a rotten position like the manager before Sam did we don't go knocking on Allardyce's door again.

Edited by mixed nuts (20 Aug 2017 11.47pm)

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 20 Aug 17 11.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Do you not think that the reason hes trying to change thd DNA is so that we don't just struggle to stay up each year..

Well that is kind of obvious , but if in trying he actually takes us down , well that is not progress,

It very simple and very obvious , play to the strengths of the players that we have , get the points required to stay up , then tinker , then we will have more money to get better players, then play to the players you have strengths , get enough points , stay up tinker some more more , and repeat until we have players good enough to play possession football and stay up with no worries.

Although I for one do not give a monkeys about possession football , I want to see football that wins us games.

 

mixed nuts Flag 21 Aug 17 12.10am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Well that is kind of obvious , but if in trying he actually takes us down , well that is not progress,

It very simple and very obvious , play to the strengths of the players that we have , get the points required to stay up , then tinker , then we will have more money to get better players, then play to the players you have strengths , get enough points , stay up tinker some more more , and repeat until we have players good enough to play possession football and stay up with no worries.

Although I for one do not give a monkeys about possession football , I want to see football that wins us games.

Possession football just means being in control, meaning we used to wait for mistakes in order to attack, but to cut down on the mistakes we make while attempting to play possession football now means we need to buy ready made and expensive players like Sakho to achieve it, Pardew had this problem and he ran out of time very sadly, it is going to be interesting to see how Frank copes going one step better.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Aug 17 12.12am

Originally posted by mixed nuts

Possession football just means being in control, meaning we used to wait for mistakes in order to attack, but to cut down on the mistakes we make while attempting to play possession football now means we need to buy ready made and expensive players like Sakho to achieve it, Pardew had this problem and he ran out of time very sadly, it is going to be interesting to see how Frank copes going one step better.

Possession football means nothing if you do not do anything with the ball.
For example two games no goals.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 21 Aug 17 12.24am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Possession football means nothing if you do not do anything with the ball.
For example two games no goals.

We played Liverpool the same way we played them last season.
5 at the back.
Minimum possession.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Aug 17 12.30am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

We played Liverpool the same way we played them last season.
5 at the back.
Minimum possession.

A 'Back three' invariably becomes a 'Back five' when the opposition are on top and dominating possession.
I didn't expect much else at Anfield.

Edited by Willo (21 Aug 2017 12.30am)

 

mixed nuts Flag 21 Aug 17 12.53am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Possession football means nothing if you do not do anything with the ball.
For example two games no goals.

We didn't attempt Possession football with Liverpool and we did enough anyway with the ball against them to get a result and even more so against Huddersfield, making mistakes with possession football in that first game could only be reasonably successful with a few mistakes here and there, we made tons of them and then we failed miserably with our own great opportunities in front of their goal, against Liverpool we reduced our mistakes sufficiently enough to just miss out on a draw.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 21 Aug 17 1.06am

When people talk about 'possession football' they are confusing two ideas - we may not play tika taka but we should be able to keep hold of the ball when we need to either defensively or offensively - it's a sign of the team's quality, and it's not about individual players but how they interact with each other. To cheer up the OP just has to look at the squad - I was alarmed with some of FDB's decisions v Hudds and like the majority pleasantly surprised with the defensive solidity and return to our comfort zone v Liverpool, but a half decent manager should be able to get a tune from our front three with Kai Kai as back up, Luka, Yoyo, Jimmy Mac and RLC - 3 from 4 in the middle, and Fosu Mensah, Dann, Tomkins PVA and Schlupp to choose from at the back - with Ward, Souare and Riedewald as back up - more firepower up front (winger or striker)and a RWB (and a keeper) and we'll have all the squad depth we need, esp when Wickham;s fit again. Hopefully we can shift the deadwood (Punch, Ward, Lee, Mutch, Sako). Far too much pessimism - some of it well-founded but it's very early days and the window will be open plenty long enough.

 

mixed nuts Flag 21 Aug 17 1.37am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

When people talk about 'possession football' they are confusing two ideas - we may not play tika taka but we should be able to keep hold of the ball when we need to either defensively or offensively - it's a sign of the team's quality, and it's not about individual players but how they interact with each other. To cheer up the OP just has to look at the squad - I was alarmed with some of FDB's decisions v Hudds and like the majority pleasantly surprised with the defensive solidity and return to our comfort zone v Liverpool, but a half decent manager should be able to get a tune from our front three with Kai Kai as back up, Luka, Yoyo, Jimmy Mac and RLC - 3 from 4 in the middle, and Fosu Mensah, Dann, Tomkins PVA and Schlupp to choose from at the back - with Ward, Souare and Riedewald as back up - more firepower up front (winger or striker)and a RWB (and a keeper) and we'll have all the squad depth we need, esp when Wickham;s fit again. Hopefully we can shift the deadwood (Punch, Ward, Lee, Mutch, Sako). Far too much pessimism - some of it well-founded but it's very early days and the window will be open plenty long enough.

Puncheon and Ward we cannot lose.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 21 Aug 17 7.58am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Well that is kind of obvious , but if in trying he actually takes us down , well that is not progress,

It very simple and very obvious , play to the strengths of the players that we have , get the points required to stay up , then tinker , then we will have more money to get better players, then play to the players you have strengths , get enough points , stay up tinker some more more , and repeat until we have players good enough to play possession football and stay up with no worries.

Although I for one do not give a monkeys about possession football , I want to see football that wins us games.


Yeah, I'd agree with that. I don't find so- called "possession football" any more attractive than any other sort of football and, to be honest, I find it generally to be a bit tedious.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > This is madness surely!