You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Milo,Cabaye, McArthur
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Milo,Cabaye, McArthur


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
MR200% Flag 14 Oct 17 9.15pm

That's the midfield after today,Sorry Punch and thank you for the last few years but I'm afraid you are a squad player at best now

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 14 Oct 17 9.17pm

What about RLC. He is up there with Zaha for me. I'd have him ahead of MacArthur I think. It's tough though.

 

oldstand Flag Christchurch 14 Oct 17 9.18pm

Is dodgy ground on here putting cabs and mcarthur together in there but they delivered against CL quality. I say, we’ll in

 

se25 rudy Flag se25 14 Oct 17 9.22pm

Luka, RLC & Cabaye sounds like an excellent, balanced midfield to me

Edited by se25 rudy (14 Oct 2017 9.22pm)

 

MR200% Flag 14 Oct 17 9.23pm

Fair comment on RLC just wanted to make the point that Puncheon is not first team anymore

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 14 Oct 17 9.25pm

We might not have any forwards right now but we have six great midfielders...

Zaha, RLC, Cabaye, Luka, Jimmy, Andros

Wealth of talent, they'll give anyone a game.

COYP

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Oct 17 9.35pm

Originally posted by se25 rudy

Luka, RLC & Cabaye sounds like an excellent, balanced midfield to me

Edited by se25 rudy (14 Oct 2017 9.22pm)

It will be this within 2 weeks. Maybe Roy will keep healthy competition for places by making cheek earn his place but he will be back in and probably for jimmy. I don't see anyone close to him as an attacking central midfielder. He gets into scoring positions (man c away), is strong, wins fouls (2nd half v Huddersfield), carries the ball well (every game), plays one-twos with the striker (Southampton), has a good engine and precision passing (to puncheon at anfield).

The other benefit in making him earn his place is someone else may get injured and we may need to shuffle around. That way Jimmy is still sharp. After all, we probably have 15 prem players so it's a delicate process rather than just simple swaps.

Playing against a back 4 is going to be more difficult though which is why I think we need more and someone capable of occupying 2 CBs. Can Jimmy? No. Can one of wilf or Townsend running from wide into the central position? That's 3 players you're running across. Cheek has that class we're going to need their very soon.

 


COYP

oldstand Flag Christchurch 14 Oct 17 9.37pm

Originally posted by MR200%

Fair comment on RLC just wanted to make the point that Puncheon is not first team anymore

Yes you did, and you are correct. Sadly

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Oct 17 12.35pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It will be this within 2 weeks. Maybe Roy will keep healthy competition for places by making cheek earn his place but he will be back in and probably for jimmy. I don't see anyone close to him as an attacking central midfielder. He gets into scoring positions (man c away), is strong, wins fouls (2nd half v Huddersfield), carries the ball well (every game), plays one-twos with the striker (Southampton), has a good engine and precision passing (to puncheon at anfield).

The other benefit in making him earn his place is someone else may get injured and we may need to shuffle around. That way Jimmy is still sharp. After all, we probably have 15 prem players so it's a delicate process rather than just simple swaps.

Playing against a back 4 is going to be more difficult though which is why I think we need more and someone capable of occupying 2 CBs. Can Jimmy? No. Can one of wilf or Townsend running from wide into the central position? That's 3 players you're running across. Cheek has that class we're going to need their very soon.

This. You cant really change the team for Newcastle but I think this will end up happening sooner rather than later. RLC by far best player this season pre Chelsea. Looking forward to see the all playing together!

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 17 Oct 17 12.40pm

Someone needs to be dropped when Big Ben is back too.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

chateauferret Flag 17 Oct 17 12.44pm

Originally posted by topcat

Someone needs to be dropped when Big Ben is back too.

Yes. Big Ben by the looks of it.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Aray Flag South London 17 Oct 17 12.52pm

Well, well overdue. But Punch was never a central midfielder - play him on the the left where his one-footedness doesn't hold him back as much. Or if needed play him as a No. 10 - that worked for a while. But we have several players better in the centre of the park.

As for Benteke...Lets see how long our current set up works for before we write him off. He will have to be a lot hungrier to get back in the side if we can repeat Saturday's performance.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 17 Oct 17 12.54pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Yes. Big Ben by the looks of it.

haha true, but he'll be back in there, purely cos a club our size cant put a player on £110,000 a week on the bench.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 Oct 17 1.03pm

Originally posted by matthau

haha true, but he'll be back in there, purely cos a club our size cant put a player on £110,000 a week on the bench.

Why not? We should be playing our in form players not necessarily our most expensive. If he isn't giving us what we need, play men who are.

 


============
The Ferret
============

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Oct 17 1.06pm

Once Roy has the team playing as an effective unit again , and the have been improving since he started, we will see the best of Benteke.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Oct 17 1.16pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Once Roy has the team playing as an effective unit again , and the have been improving since he started, we will see the best of Benteke.

Yes quite agree. He has looked off form, looked lazy even and should also have put some of those chances away however we havent played to his strengths yet this season in fairness to him. He'll come good with the rest of the team back in form. He needs service. Not really the type of player to create on his own.

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 17 Oct 17 1.23pm

Originally posted by oldstand

Is dodgy ground on here putting cabs and mcarthur together in there but they delivered against CL quality. I say, we’ll in

Without a shadow should be the same as Saturday but with RLC in for Jeffrey. Great setup and the best ive seen for a long time

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 17 Oct 17 5.10pm

Of course, none of us know how long Bentekkers has been carrying his injury, prior to it actually needing his absence... as we all know, he's looked off the pace for weeks before going awol and the club aren't going to,admit he's carrying an injury, are they.

 

christopher1 Flag london 17 Oct 17 5.27pm

Hi.
RLC is an excellent footballer.
However - Jimmy Mac's sublime disguised pass which completely filed Alonso and led to our first goal of the Season and set us on our way, came from someone who cannot be left out of the starting 11.
Roy has to find a place for RLC with Jimmy Mac.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 Oct 17 7.17pm

Originally posted by christopher1

Hi.
RLC is an excellent footballer.
However - Jimmy Mac's sublime disguised pass which completely filed Alonso and led to our first goal of the Season and set us on our way, came from someone who cannot be left out of the starting 11.
Roy has to find a place for RLC with Jimmy Mac.

Perhaps drop Schlupp back to LB and drop van Aanholt. Hard to see who could be dropped from Saturday's performance - nice position to be in!

Speroni
Ward Dann Sakho Schlupp
Cabaye Milivojevic McArthur
Zaha Loftus-Cheek Townsend

Lots of scope for the kind of swapping round and changing places to confuse defenders there. And we would have Fosu-Mensah, Puncheon, Tomkins, Bakary Sakho and Souare or van Aanholt for the bench. Not too bad.

Edited by chateauferret (17 Oct 2017 7.19pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Milo,Cabaye, McArthur