This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Did loftus cheek even touch the ball today. I dont remember the commentators calling his name out. I could be wrong as was in the pub ( noisy and d runk) COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I'm not reading too much into this, I guess Southgate just wants to have a look at him. Seems reasonable given some of the dross England have been coming out with over recent years. I'm sure you're right, its just a friendly and he wants to have a look at some youth. Still personally i think its wrong to give caps out in such fashion. Instead of looking at players playing well - such as townsend, he's simply picking up the list of kids who are meant to be future prospects. Yet they actually done nothing yet... Townsends England future.... OVER.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I'm surprised Shelvey never got a call-up. England are not good at retaining possession and Shelvey is one who looks after the ball and sprays passes about - his distribution is excellent. No surprise really... Shelvey doesn't play for a big club. Why would he get called up. Completely agree though, England would do well taking a player like him with them next summer. Shows how much Southgate is just a nodding dog. Yes man to his FA's masters and don't disturb the apple cart which is promoting the big clubs. Sham....
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I'm surprised Shelvey never got a call-up. England are not good at retaining possession and Shelvey is one who looks after the ball and sprays passes about - his distribution is excellent.
|
|
|
According to a sky reporter, he will be starting against Germany on Friday. You really don't have to do much to get an England cap these days do you...
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
According to a sky reporter, he will be starting against Germany on Friday. You really don't have to do much to get an England cap these days do you... That does surprise me somewhat, though. It's not necessarily the case that the best players will get caps; players will be passed over because of politics, team fit, experience in a particular system, etc. Wilf probably didn't fit because he wouldn't have been comfortable with the slow, plodding, pedestrian rubbish that England prefer to play, or more charitably that they didn't want to play quick football on the break. If we were Wales or Scotland any reasonable selection would have to be based on the best players and the best team. But if you're England you can muck about more, I suppose. The French have been doing this for years: they wouldn't select Cantona, for example. Edited by chateauferret (09 Nov 2017 11.30am)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Yeah but he didn't actually do anything then either... Look this is the highest level of football you can play at, and i just can't see how he's earned that. Whats it say to Townsend whos clearly been playing better.... Basically it says you're international future is over. RLC I hope he plays well for us and imagine he'll have a great long future in front of him. But picking him for england after he's had a handful of Prem games, and hasn't performed outstanding in any of them. Na just stinks of FA shoehorning big club players in to the team. Just like they've done for the last ten years which is why we never win anything... Don't play the best players play the best NAMES... Is all the FA does. They assume these lads playing for Chelsea are the future and yet they've DONE NOTHING YET.... Complete joke... I think everyone agrees that there is big club bias when England pick teams. For the case of Townsend, he should be more annoyed that Lingard get picked over him. I disagree that RLC didn't do anything. Set up some decent chances that should have been finished and almost stuck us 1-0 up away at City. Granted, last couple of games he's been quiet, he looks lost on the right wing. But, in Southgate's defence (can't believe I'm saying this), he knows these players from U21 level and there are a lot of injuries to first team players at the moment. We are qualified, and have friendlies against two superb football teams. I think this is as good a time as any to pick these players and see what they can do. Abraham, RLC and Gomez will probably not be ready for the World Cup this year, but this could give them the confidence in their ability to help them be ready for the Euros in 2020.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ulysses
Unlikely as it was before, it would now make it nigh on impossible to sign him permanently. I'd disagree with that. It might make him realise that by playing for a club like us, the regular football means he's noticed by the England gaffer, so long as we manage to stay in the PL.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Griffish
I think everyone agrees that there is big club bias when England pick teams. For the case of Townsend, he should be more annoyed that Lingard get picked over him. Is Burnley a big club then as they had two players in the England squad last year of which one has been sold to Everton in the summer and the other is injured but they now have Jack Cork in the squad too
|
|
|
I don't think Southgate trust Shelvey's temperament. He's always prone to an outburst or a red card or getting involved in some kind of aggro. You'd also have to question if he's the type you'd want in and around the camp for four weeks particularly if he's not playing and getting bored... Originally posted by Willo
I'm surprised Shelvey never got a call-up. England are not good at retaining possession and Shelvey is one who looks after the ball and sprays passes about - his distribution is excellent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Is Burnley a big club then as they had two players in the England squad last year of which one has been sold to Everton in the summer and the other is injured but they now have Jack Cork in the squad too One of those is Tom Heaton, there are no England goalkeepers at any big clubs so he doesn't count. Jack Cork has been picked because the squad is at a bare minimum due to injuries and there is a serious lack of English centre midfielders at top clubs. Arguably, you can say Cork deserves it for this seasons performances. For Burnley, Tarkowski and Mee have been better than Keane this season, where is there call up? There are always exceptions to the bias, but there is no doubt that it is there. I remember Callum Chambers being sold to Arsenal and then straight away starting ahead of Clyne for England, despite him being behind Clyne in the pecking order at Southampton.
|
|
|
Gotta love the negative know-it-alls on this site..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Yeah but he didn't actually do anything then either... Look this is the highest level of football you can play at, and i just can't see how he's earned that. Whats it say to Townsend whos clearly been playing better.... Basically it says you're international future is over. RLC I hope he plays well for us and imagine he'll have a great long future in front of him. But picking him for england after he's had a handful of Prem games, and hasn't performed outstanding in any of them. Na just stinks of FA shoehorning big club players in to the team. Just like they've done for the last ten years which is why we never win anything... Don't play the best players play the best NAMES... Is all the FA does. They assume these lads playing for Chelsea are the future and yet they've DONE NOTHING YET.... Complete joke... He didn't do too badly tonight
|
|
|
An excellent performance in his 21st senior game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Griffish
He didn't do too badly tonight Yep i eat my hat, he certainly played real well. I'm very pleased for him. Good call by Southgate to use the chance to try players out. Still would argue whats he done to earn an england cap. But given the chance he showed everyone why the manager had faith in him. Really pleased for him.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.