This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I don't see how it can look like a penalty from any angle because the way in which Niasse collapses is not consistent with the way in which he was allegedly contacted. His words bear that out: he felt the contact on his shoulder, and threw himself on the ground (which involved his legs). Had he been shoved in the shoulder he would have fallen forwards onto his front with his legs more or less straight. We should also view the incident in the context of the rest of the game, in which Taylor did not exactly cover himself in glory. Gallagher's agenda, of course, is the same as Willo's, i.e. apologist for incompetent referees. Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 4.39pm) Gallagher like me gives me his honest opinions and being a former PL referee he speaks from authority.He doesn't always say that the referee is right.He knows only too well that referees err from time to time and cannot be 100% right all of the time.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Gallagher like me gives me his honest opinions and being a former PL referee he speaks from authority.He doesn't always say that the referee is right.He knows only too well that referees err from time to time and cannot be 100% right all of the time. Well what he's said in pretty well all those reports is that the correct decision would have been X but it's so difficult for the ref with this and that and with the benefit of replays we might have seen such-and-such and oh what a hard job he has so sometimes the decisions turn out to be bollocks, basically. He also ignores the fact that Taylor got about a thousand other things wrong in that match. Now who does that remind one of?
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Well what he's said in pretty well all those reports is that the correct decision would have been X but it's so difficult for the ref with this and that and with the benefit of replays we might have seen such-and-such and oh what a hard job he has so sometimes the decisions turn out to be bollocks, basically. Now who does that remind one of? Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 5.15pm) He has got a referees perspective having refereed at the top level in the PL for many years.He understands what it is like for a referee and can understand why decisions are made even if they might not necessarily be the right ones. I have never refereed at PL level but have spoken to some who have and perhaps this together with my own experiences explains some of the arguments I make on HOL.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
He has got a referees perspective having refereed at the top level in the PL for many years.He understands what it is like for a referee and can understand why decisions are made even if they might not necessarily be the right ones. I have never refereed at PL level but have spoken to some who have and perhaps this together with my own experiences explains some of the arguments I make on HOL. Being a weed troll explains a good many of them as well. Anyway what do you mean, "arguments"? You only have one argument, which is that referees' backsides can serve as sources of solar energy. Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 5.26pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Being a weed troll explains a good many of them as well. Anyway what do you mean, "arguments"? You only have one argument, which is that referees' backsides can serve as sources of solar energy. Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 5.26pm) Chimerical piffle and attempts at humour but alas it was hardly a mirthquake to register on the Richter scale.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
If you want to stamp out the behaviour, you have need to have an incentive to the club, team and player to avoid cheating. As it stands, if he's banned for even three games, he earned his club 2 points. Most managers would take losing a player for 3 games, in exchange for 2pts.
So the punishment has to be a points deduction. Deduct the unearned points plus one. So, Niasse's dive earned them a point they wouldn't have got, so take it away plus one. Same for if it gets you a win over a draw, take away the 2 unearned points plus one. If the differential was bigger than 1 goal - or you lose - still deduct 1 point. Of course, this all assumes that the panel will have any balls whatsoever to actually call a dive a dive, which they won't. The greater the stakes, the more they will shrink from their responsibilities.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
So the punishment has to be a points deduction. Deduct the unearned points plus one. So, Niasse's dive earned them a point they wouldn't have got, so take it away plus one. Same for if it gets you a win over a draw, take away the 2 unearned points plus one. If the differential was bigger than 1 goal - or you lose - still deduct 1 point. Of course, this all assumes that the panel will have any balls whatsoever to actually call a dive a dive, which they won't. The greater the stakes, the more they will shrink from their responsibilities. The panel don't make a collective decision. Each panel member reviews the footage independently of the other members.There has to be a unanimous decision of the 3 members for a definitive decision.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Bollocks. Martinez cleaned him out. No, sorry, just watched it back on Sky Plus. He dives and commentators say it looked a penalty but reply’s show it’s a dive. Don’t want to argue about it, just pointing out we’re all as bad as each other. The way to be sure of winning is to do so without hoping for good officials. Because you will probably be disappointed!
Now here's Wright, his first chance to see what he can do, and he's through, it's Wright, ohhhh what an impact by the substitute. And it's Ian Wright who's sent the Palace fans into ecstasy! |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
So the punishment has to be a points deduction. Deduct the unearned points plus one. So, Niasse's dive earned them a point they wouldn't have got, so take it away plus one. Same for if it gets you a win over a draw, take away the 2 unearned points plus one. If the differential was bigger than 1 goal - or you lose - still deduct 1 point. Of course, this all assumes that the panel will have any balls whatsoever to actually call a dive a dive, which they won't. The greater the stakes, the more they will shrink from their responsibilities. Shouldn’t just be a case of deducting points from the cheat’s side, they should also be given back to the cheated’s side. Won’t happen though. It would also be nice to be able to have a panel assessing a refs overall performance (not just one mistake) with the option of a red card and subbing them at half time if they’re underperforming. Pigs will fly and hell will freeze over before that though!
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by gerry theagle
The refing in the Premiership is appalling, watched the match tonight Murray was taken out by Shawcross definite pen, Lee Mason another incompetent ref is not even up with play awards a free kick to Stoke as Murray who is flat on the ground has handled the ball. Murray himself did enough to get red carded in one go in that match. See the Everton match ref thread for a summary of ref cockups in the weekend's ten Premier League matches, three of which were refereed correctly, and in which two out of eight major calls were given correctly. Some people seem to think that's good enough. YMMV.
============ |
|
|
Although I agree the referee was awful and let everton get away with murder, frpm where I was sitting in upper holmesdale it looked like a penalty.
|
|
|
Quote
If you want to stamp out the behaviour, you have need to have an incentive to the club, team and player to avoid cheating. As it stands, if he's banned for even three games, he earned his club 2 points. Most managers would take losing a player for 3 games, in exchange for 2pts. Originally posted by Ray in Houston
It has to be a punishment to the club; one that matters. A fine for the club or player is irrelevant, because they're all stonkingly rich and any fine is comparative loose change. Still, managers will stress the need to earn a penalty by whatever means possible because winning points is all that matters. So the punishment has to be a points deduction. Deduct the unearned points plus one. So, Niasse's dive earned them a point they wouldn't have got, so take it away plus one. Same for if it gets you a win over a draw, take away the 2 unearned points plus one. If the differential was bigger than 1 goal - or you lose - still deduct 1 point. Of course, this all assumes that the panel will have any balls whatsoever to actually call a dive a dive, which they won't. The greater the stakes, the more they will shrink from their responsibilities. Unfortuntely, there is such an ambiguity over diving and intent and someone genuinely jumping out of the way to avoid injury (which should still be a foul against the tackler, even if there wasn't contact IMHO) that retrospective punishment such as this will fail it's purpose. It may work as a deterrent, but what is worse? not punishing a dive sufficiently or punishing a club with a points deduction when the player did not dive ? Having said that, when someone comes out after the game and Admits to conning the ref (with or without Video refs) then they should be strung up and fired our of the nearest skyscraper.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
When do we find out if Niasse is being referred to the diving panel and what conclusions they have come to
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
When do we find out if Niasse is being referred to the diving panel and what conclusions they have come to Niasse's antics have already been referred to the diving panel and apparently they will rule within 24 hours. Of course he's already given an interview in which he suggested that a) he did it and b) why the f*** shouldn't he, so hopefully they will make an example of the disgusting cheat. Don't hold your breath though. I don't know if Palace are still interested in the "player" or if he's still interested in us, but if the latter were the case a nice presser to the effect that he and his agent are both now as welcome at Selhurst Park as an epidemic of Gandhi's Revenge in a submarine with blocked toilets would be quite amusing.
============ |
|
|
Yes! Justice. Niasse has been charged
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
When do we find out if Niasse is being referred to the diving panel and what conclusions they have come to Been charged Act of simulation.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.