You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ben Foster caught on the ball
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ben Foster caught on the ball


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 05 Dec 17 12.30pm

And allow them to waste and waste and waste and waste time? You must be kidding. The only reason the backpass rule came in was keeping more flow in the game and I am in no doubt that it has been one of the better changes of the last decades.


Originally posted by Pigglelet

Perhaps we haven’t noticed the change to the back pass rule that allows the keeper to pick up the ball (or push it away) when he is under pressure and so the ref can now judge when the keeper is under sufficient pressure that the back pass rule should be ignored. Which of course is a perfect opportunity for refs to make a decision that favours one team over another, which of course couldn’t happen because we know that they are all scrupulously fair.

Why don’t we just go back to the old days of simply letting the keeper always pick up the ball?


 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 05 Dec 17 12.30pm

Zaha NEVER seems to get the benefit of the doubt. Twice clearly pushed inside box at Amex, now this and there will be lot more wrong-Wilf decisions before season ends.

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 05 Dec 17 1.38pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

And allow them to waste and waste and waste and waste time? You must be kidding. The only reason the backpass rule came in was keeping more flow in the game and I am in no doubt that it has been one of the better changes of the last decades.

Yes, Johan, I know. I was actually being sarcastic. I do appreciate you wouldn't necessarily have realised that.


Edited by Pigglelet (05 Dec 2017 1.42pm)

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 05 Dec 17 11.13pm

Must be my inclination for double Dutch

Originally posted by Pigglelet

Yes, Johan, I know. I was actually being sarcastic. I do appreciate you wouldn't necessarily have realised that.


Edited by Pigglelet (05 Dec 2017 1.42pm)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 06 Dec 17 6.33am

Where’s the view from our very own referees champion on this one? Very quiet.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Dec 17 10.46am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Where’s the view from our very own referees champion on this one? Very quiet.

I did ask politely very early in this thread but got no response. There is no defence to this for the keeper, I think it is purely a case of the ref forgetting it was a backpass that started it all off. Wilf deffo asked him specifically about the handball and the ref just waved him away without explanation.

Just add it to the long list of ones we are owed this year.

 

pizzapat Flag Caterham 06 Dec 17 2.54pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Where’s the view from our very own referees champion on this one? Very quiet.

as this decision doesnt involve hie "hero" who has since proven that EVERYTHING he did was BIASED ,i dont expect an answer....

which is a shame as id love to see him defend the official on this one;obvs to busy denying Wilf a pen to have noticed the original back pass offence!!

 


2010 decided my services were no longer required after 10 years service on the WHITEHORSE LANE FAMILY STAND

#CRPS

please read [Link] to find out what #CRPS is

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 17 3.53pm

Originally posted by pizzapat

as this decision doesnt involve hie "hero" who has since proven that EVERYTHING he did was BIASED ,i dont expect an answer....

which is a shame as id love to see him defend the official on this one;obvs to busy denying Wilf a pen to have noticed the original back pass offence!!

This incident would have formed part of the post match evaluation where every decision would have been forensically scrutinised using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the Michael Oliver's performance.

At the end of the day Zaha and Foster came very close together as Zaha attempted to intercept the pass and the referee from his angle might not have had the best viewing position to judge whether Zaha had made contact with the ball or not.Happened very quickly the players came close together and the referee had to make a split-second decision.Only Michael Oliver will know and he would have had to make his opinion known as part of the assessment.

If he got it wrong he got it wrong - does he deserve to be hung,drawn and quartered ? We are all excellent referees after watching 'Slow-Mo' umpteen times.

Given you my opinion - nothing more for me to add.


Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 3.56pm)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 06 Dec 17 5.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

This incident would have formed part of the post match evaluation where every decision would have been forensically scrutinised using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the Michael Oliver's performance.

At the end of the day Zaha and Foster came very close together as Zaha attempted to intercept the pass and the referee from his angle might not have had the best viewing position to judge whether Zaha had made contact with the ball or not.Happened very quickly the players came close together and the referee had to make a split-second decision.Only Michael Oliver will know and he would have had to make his opinion known as part of the assessment.

If he got it wrong he got it wrong - does he deserve to be hung,drawn and quartered ? We are all excellent referees after watching 'Slow-Mo' umpteen times.

Given you my opinion - nothing more for me to add.


Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 3.56pm)

I think we must move beyond the ‘we’re all excellent referees with slo no.’ At some stage there must be proper accountability. These people get a decent salary and, in my view, cannot keep hiding behind that tired old hogwash. If they cannot adequately referee then they must retrain or consider an alternative profession. They are meant to be the best, after all.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 17 5.59pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

I think we must move beyond the ‘we’re all excellent referees with slo no.’ At some stage there must be proper accountability. These people get a decent salary and, in my view, cannot keep hiding behind that tired old hogwash. If they cannot adequately referee then they must retrain or consider an alternative profession. They are meant to be the best, after all.

Referees get 98% of decisions spot-on and they have to make a large number in the course of a match.

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 06 Dec 17 6.02pm

at the end of the day we should go to video refs, then it would stop all this (possibly) it works most of the time in the egg chasing game and cricket..have a video ref look then decide

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

jeeagles Flag 06 Dec 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

Referees get 98% of decisions spot-on and they have to make a large number in the course of a match.

Willo makes up 42% of facts, but ardently believes that referees are always right, believes a conversion involves repeating the same view over and over again, and looks up 0% of his player knowledge on google/wiki.

In his defence, I am happy to accept this as an honest mistake. From the few indirect free kicks I've seen from back passes I can't remember any going in. It's not really in the spirit of the rule either. We didn't do enough to win last Saturday.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 17 6.19pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Willo makes up 42% of facts, but ardently believes that referees are always right, believes a conversion involves repeating the same view over and over again, and looks up 0% of his player knowledge on google/wiki.

In his defence, I am happy to accept this as an honest mistake. From the few indirect free kicks I've seen from back passes I can't remember any going in. It's not really in the spirit of the rule either. We didn't do enough to win last Saturday.

I am not knowingly a stranger to the truth and make up statistics as part of any agenda I might have - I certainly don't have a difficult relationship with the facts.

In actual fact it is your good self who has gross inaccuracies in your assertion that I believe referees are always right.I have repeatedly stated that referees DO err from time to time and it would be ridiculous to say otherwise.

Finally, I don't rely on Wiki/Google for player information as a matter of course.Somehow I manage to retain a knowledge of players and as one chap said to me a while ago in front of my wife "You are a walking encyclopedia on football" after I engaged in conversation with him in a bar, well away from any PC.Now that I am 65, whether I retain the knowledge is a matter for conjecture.

Of course I have to research certain topics for information but to assert that I rush off to Wiki/Google each and every time to present details on HOL is wholly inaccurate.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.26pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 06 Dec 17 6.27pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Willo makes up 42% of facts, but ardently believes that referees are always right, believes a conversion involves repeating the same view over and over again, and looks up 0% of his player knowledge on google/wiki.

In his defence, I am happy to accept this as an honest mistake. From the few indirect free kicks I've seen from back passes I can't remember any going in. It's not really in the spirit of the rule either. We didn't do enough to win last Saturday.

He doesn't believe that they're always right. He just believes that it's OK for them to be s***.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 17 6.29pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

He doesn't believe that they're always right. He just believes that it's OK for them to be s***.

I really don't believe they can be categorized as such so I dismiss your allegation out of hand.

Yes there will be moments when they will frustrate us and moments when their judgement can be called into question but they are only human and have to make split-second decisions with the naked eye in fast moving situations.

And let's not forget that these referees are under enormous pressure with their every decision disected with 'Slow-Mo' etc etc.This is often forgotten.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.35pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 06 Dec 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am not knowingly a stranger to the truth and make up statistics as part of any agenda I might have - I certainly don't have a difficult relationship with the facts.

In actual fact it is your good self who has gross inaccuracies in your assertion that I believe referees are always right.I have repeatedly stated that referees DO err from time to time and it would be ridiculous to say otherwise.

Finally, I don't rely on Wiki/Google for player information as a matter of course.Somehow I manage to retain a knowledge of players and as one chap said to me a while ago in front of my wife "You are a walking encyclopedia on football" after I engaged in conversation with him in a bar, well away from any PC.Now that I am 65, whether I retain the knowledge is a matter for conjecture.

Of course I have to research certain topics for information but to assert that I rush off to Wiki/Google each and every time to present details on HOL is wholly inaccurate.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.26pm)


OK I'll accept your plea that you do say referees are not always correct BUT why wont you admit that in this case Oliver made an error which COULD have affected the result of this match? As is the case with your adopted son Clattenberg who has admitted that he cheated in the chelsea spurs match by not applying the laws of the game, in not sending off 2 possibly 3 spurs players!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 17 6.37pm

Originally posted by the silurian


OK I'll accept your plea that you do say referees are not always correct BUT why wont you admit that in this case Oliver made an error which COULD have affected the result of this match? As is the case with your adopted son Clattenberg who has admitted that he cheated in the chelsea spurs match by not applying the laws of the game, in not sending off 2 possibly 3 spurs players!

I have already stated that I will NOT be lured into any debate about Clattenburg's performances because as sure as night follows day it will disintegrate into vitriol and vituperation and yet another WILLO thread will demean HOL.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.39pm)

 

pizzapat Flag Caterham 06 Dec 17 6.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

This incident would have formed part of the post match evaluation where every decision would have been forensically scrutinised using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the Michael Oliver's performance.

At the end of the day Zaha and Foster came very close together as Zaha attempted to intercept the pass and the referee from his angle might not have had the best viewing position to judge whether Zaha had made contact with the ball or not.Happened very quickly the players came close together and the referee had to make a split-second decision.Only Michael Oliver will know and he would have had to make his opinion known as part of the assessment.

If he got it wrong he got it wrong - does he deserve to be hung,drawn and quartered ? We are all excellent referees after watching 'Slow-Mo' umpteen times.

Given you my opinion - nothing more for me to add.


Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 3.56pm)


are you saying that the official in question wasnt sure if the original pass wasnt a back pass? i was at the hawthrons at the opposite end of the ground and could see from my position that it was a back pass;after trying to dribble the ball around Wilf ( he knew it was a back pass or he wouldnt have needed to do that?) he then touched the ball with his hand to get the ball away from wilf; by the letter of the back pass law is he allowed to touch the ball with his hand in the way he did?
if he cant then an IDFK is given and takes away the need to award a penalty?

 


2010 decided my services were no longer required after 10 years service on the WHITEHORSE LANE FAMILY STAND

#CRPS

please read [Link] to find out what #CRPS is

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 06 Dec 17 6.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have already stated that I will NOT be lured into any debate about Clattenburg's performances because as sure as night follows day it will disintegrate into vitriol and vituperation and yet another WILLO thread will demean HOL.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.39pm)


I didnt ask you about clattenberk, i specifically asked about oliver!!! I mentioned clattenberk just to point out that you always defend him, even when he has admitted CHEATING!!

Yet another Willo swerve!!!

PS big words like vitriol and vituperation dont impress anyone!

Edited by the silurian (06 Dec 2017 6.44pm)

 

pizzapat Flag Caterham 06 Dec 17 6.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

I really don't believe they can be categorized as such so I dismiss your allegation out of hand.

Yes there will be moments when they will frustrate us and moments when their judgement can be called into question but they are only human and have to make split-second decisions with the naked eye in fast moving situations.

And let's not forget that these referees are under enormous pressure with their every decision disected with 'Slow-Mo' etc etc.This is often forgotten.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2017 6.35pm)

if the official at the hawthrons on saturday couldnt tell it was a back pass that led to the penalty appeal surely he shouldnt be officiating;you didnt need slowmo replays for that the fact it was a back pass was also why foster tried to dribble around wilf[ he knew he couldnt pick up the ball?

 


2010 decided my services were no longer required after 10 years service on the WHITEHORSE LANE FAMILY STAND

#CRPS

please read [Link] to find out what #CRPS is

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ben Foster caught on the ball