You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We're Just Not Very Good
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We're Just Not Very Good


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 13 Dec 17 9.17am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The difference is our team is set up to let the player with the ball do it on his own too much with little or no support and their's and other teams are set up to always have an option available.

When we haven't got the result we need we start going for it after 80 mins.

Id Iike to see just a bit of full back overlapping of these predictable inside out wide midfielders. This is a big reason why Andros can't build on anything and Cheek is easily kept quiet. And all whilst there's Benteke stood in the box. Crosses 25 yards from the by line are pointless and predictable again.

We're predictable and quite easy to defend for 80 mins. Quite a fair thing to say and we won't keep winning CRUCIAL games in a few minutes.

Hit the nail on the head Rudi.

Inverted wingers only works if the full backs overlap and provide width.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Dec 17 9.26am

Originally posted by Tez

Hit the nail on the head Rudi.

Inverted wingers only works if the full backs overlap and provide width.

Who's old enough to remember the inside right and inside left positions, because that is really how we are playing at the moment and by definition, there is no width because that used to be supplied by the wingers under the old 2,3,5 system.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 13 Dec 17 11.29am

The lack of width was indeed very very obvious yesterday. Townsend is very poor at using space and just goes on dribbles with no chance and as he is lacking a good shot it comes to nothing time after time. For all the criticism of Sako, he actually put a decent cross in within minutes of coming on. Was also disappointed with FTM and his lack of drive forward, not to mention Schlupp on the left who brings absolutely nothing going forward. It's Wilf, Wilf and more Wilf where our attacking treat has to come from.

In the end of the day we are out of the bottom three but we certainly did not look good.

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Who's old enough to remember the inside right and inside left positions, because that is really how we are playing at the moment and by definition, there is no width because that used to be supplied by the wingers under the old 2,3,5 system.


 

cpj Flag Kent 13 Dec 17 11.32am

A few thoughts...
As others have said, Zaha should be on the wing where he can cause damage (as in the last 5 mins last night). Sako would be a better option alongside Benteke if Roy insists on a 442. Loftus-Cheek should be in the centre as he showed for England not wasted out wide where he is anonymous. The problem then is who does he play instead of - we're already not playing Jimmy Mac in the middle who is our best box-to-box midfielder. Schlupp in not a left-back - not sure what he really is as he seems unwilling to attack defenders when he does get forward. PVA makes too many errors there and there's talk about Souare being loaned out in January. Perhaps we could try Riedewald at left-back - he has played there for Ajax?

Also, when we get free-kicks in the middle of the pitch, we just take them quickly with a short pass and then usually lose it again. What happened to lumping the ball into the box? Surely more chance of scoring with Benteke, Dann, Tomkins?

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 11.39am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Who's old enough to remember the inside right and inside left positions, because that is really how we are playing at the moment and by definition, there is no width because that used to be supplied by the wingers under the old 2,3,5 system.

Yes I used to play centre-forward in it forty years ago

But we had lots of little fast wily guys at the front, not a stationary lampost that the wingers had to bounce the ball off into the goal.

Full-backs were always clumsy agricultural oaves with turning circles like elephants and we tore them to bits.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Dec 17 11.45am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Yes I used to play centre-forward in it forty years ago

But we had lots of little fast wily guys at the front, not a stationary lampost that the wingers had to bounce the ball off into the goal.

Full-backs were always clumsy agricultural oaves with turning circles like elephants and we tore them to bits.

Haha, sort of tells you what sort of players we should be signing then. Liverpool and Man City aren't doing too bad with that "little fast" approach.

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 12.02pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Haha, sort of tells you what sort of players we should be signing then. Liverpool and Man City aren't doing too bad with that "little fast" approach.

The wingers would whack the ball towards goal at 100 mph and the one of the following happened.

1. Goal.
2. Ball hits something then we pick it up. Goal.
3. Defender hoofs ball 100000 miles up in the air and we go and get it.
4. Ball hits defender and goes out. Corner.
5. Defender tries to hoof it and falls on his arse. We pick ball up. Goal.
6. Defender or keeper ctashes into us and knocks us over. Penalty.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Dec 17 12.14pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

The wingers would whack the ball towards goal at 100 mph and the one of the following happened.

1. Goal.
2. Ball hits something then we pick it up. Goal.
3. Defender hoofs ball 100000 miles up in the air and we go and get it.
4. Ball hits defender and goes out. Corner.
5. Defender tries to hoof it and falls on his arse. We pick ball up. Goal.
6. Defender or keeper ctashes into us and knocks us over. Penalty.

I think Silva and Mane would tell you its a little more complicated in the modern game :-)

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 13 Dec 17 12.16pm

The OP is extremely negative at a time we were playing poorly and losing 1-0 at home, did that possibly influence the post?

As has been said, our defence looks really poor. Fosu-Mensah particularly looked all over the place at times and the rest could be ok if they were the only one of them playing in a really good defence and they raised their game, but altogether it's too porous.

However, going forward we are a threat and there are way worse teams than us. Barring bad injuries to key players there's simply no way we'll go down - Hodgson's too experienced and manages the media and presumably the players well. 6 unbeaten, played Burnley and Spurs off the park away and unluckily got beaten - that shows pedigree.

It could go either way of course, but a couple of astute signings in Jan, a fair wind and we'll end up mid-table I assure you.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 17 12.40pm

Originally posted by FinchleyEagle

The OP is extremely negative at a time we were playing poorly and losing 1-0 at home, did that possibly influence the post?

As has been said, our defence looks really poor. Fosu-Mensah particularly looked all over the place at times and the rest could be ok if they were the only one of them playing in a really good defence and they raised their game, but altogether it's too porous.

However, going forward we are a threat and there are way worse teams than us. Barring bad injuries to key players there's simply no way we'll go down - Hodgson's too experienced and manages the media and presumably the players well. 6 unbeaten, played Burnley and Spurs off the park away and unluckily got beaten - that shows pedigree.

It could go either way of course, but a couple of astute signings in Jan, a fair wind and we'll end up mid-table I assure you.

It's the fair wind that's the problem. Most of the wind lately seems to have come directly from a pig's arse.

Edited by chateauferret (13 Dec 2017 12.40pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 13 Dec 17 1.06pm

Could be worth a try. He had a piss poor game in midfield at Bristol City but who didn't? Not sure he has he featured since.


Originally posted by cpj

A few thoughts...
As others have said, Zaha should be on the wing where he can cause damage (as in the last 5 mins last night). Sako would be a better option alongside Benteke if Roy insists on a 442. Loftus-Cheek should be in the centre as he showed for England not wasted out wide where he is anonymous. The problem then is who does he play instead of - we're already not playing Jimmy Mac in the middle who is our best box-to-box midfielder. Schlupp in not a left-back - not sure what he really is as he seems unwilling to attack defenders when he does get forward. PVA makes too many errors there and there's talk about Souare being loaned out in January. Perhaps we could try Riedewald at left-back - he has played there for Ajax?

Also, when we get free-kicks in the middle of the pitch, we just take them quickly with a short pass and then usually lose it again. What happened to lumping the ball into the box? Surely more chance of scoring with Benteke, Dann, Tomkins?


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 1.06pm

I was thinking about how many points we've lost out on due to luck, not finishing chances, bounce of the ball, individual fvck ups, call it what you will and a post on the BBS shows it towers over the 4 points v Stoke and Watford. Roy therefore deserves these points looking at his tenure to date. But it's noticeable we aren't playing well for most of the game and that has to improve asap to earn and cement some solid points again rather than late scrambles, even though they prove the morale and grit needed for this is there. The way the oppo always look like scoring 2 with us not creating solid chances is a concern.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 1.07pm

How do you always manage to post above previous posts?

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Could be worth a try. He had a piss poor game in midfield at Bristol City but who didn't? Not sure he has he featured since.


 


COYP

matthau Flag South Croydon 13 Dec 17 1.13pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

How do you always manage to post above previous posts?


blame it on the 'shrooms

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by matthau

blame it on the 'shrooms

Indy band?

 


COYP

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 13 Dec 17 1.15pm

My cursor comes up at the top left, so I very thoughtfully start typing straight away then end with a couple of enters

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

How do you always manage to post above previous posts?


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 1.39pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

My cursor comes up at the top left, so I very thoughtfully start typing straight away then end with a couple of enters

Your cursor is offside.

 


COYP

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 13 Dec 17 3.39pm

FWIW I do think we get 'bullied' at times by the more physical teams, e.g. Bournemouth, Watford etc. Sometimes I wish we could dole out some physical chastisement without giving fouls away, but occasionally some of our players are muscled off the ball by the bigger physical specimens that some of the clubs around us seem to have that we don't (Luka and Mamadou are possible exceptions).

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 13 Dec 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

FWIW I do think we get 'bullied' at times by the more physical teams, e.g. Bournemouth, Watford etc. Sometimes I wish we could dole out some physical chastisement without giving fouls away, but occasionally some of our players are muscled off the ball by the bigger physical specimens that some of the clubs around us seem to have that we don't (Luka and Mamadou are possible exceptions).

Agree with this 100%. Watford were much more physical than us and got 2 nd ball quicker. I was surprised but thankfull that we won.

COYP

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Dec 17 8.06pm

Most noticeable last night was how we were bullied in midfield but the idea that Roy's playing with the wrong formation etc is crap.

Him and Ray Lew have forgotten more about football than anyone on these boards knows, know the strengths and weaknesses of the squad and came in when we'd given the rest a four game start and pre-season.

Sure they're still learning one or two things about the character of squad but we won last night because he changed things and came up with plan b as the game evolved.

Fantastic moment for McArthur. What a player he's turned out to be. Never sulks, 100% honesty with quality and composure thrown in.


Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (13 Dec 2017 8.10pm)

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We're Just Not Very Good