You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf potential ban?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf potential ban?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Jacey Flag 01 Jan 18 12.21pm

Originally posted by Jon1ukg

[Link]

Cleared for Southampton &#128513;

Edited by Jon1ukg (01 Jan 2018 12.12pm)

Thanks, very good news indeed!!

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 01 Jan 18 12.36pm

It is not maths is it? There is bound to be debate.

As for Wilf, there is no denying he gets fouled a lot and does not always get what he should but on the other hand does go down easy sometimes as well.

I do not think that was a pen. All the going down in the box for penalties spoils the game but that is my view.
I get wound up when people say: he is entitled to go down as there is contact.
Football is a contact sport and contact is not synonym for fouling. We now have the ludicrous situation that with set pieces everything is allowed, shirt holding, pushing, shoving, blocking, arms flying, leaning. However as soon as there is any attempt in open play players go down and want to win penalties. I would actually like to see the rules changed, but that is an while away I am afraid.

Originally posted by Willo

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Potential Wilf ban?' by Midlands Eagle

What's all this "Soft Penalty ? ". Next we will hear about "Hard penalty".

You hear so many hackneyed phrases about penalties - "Harsh" "I've seen them given" "Outside the box it's a foul" "He was looking for it" etc etc.


 

boo909 Flag Figeac 01 Jan 18 12.44pm

He does go down far too easy and he's always moaning at the refs, it's only a matter of time until he does get a ban for diving, hopefully it won't happen in a crucial point in our season (can't remember the last time we haven't been at a crucial point in our season though).

*Usual disclaimer: I love Wilf and think he's a fantastic player but someone needs to get him to sort this aspect of his character out.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 01 Jan 18 12.59pm

I agree with the above poster. He can go down a bit easily, which in the 90th minute v Man City I totally get - but there will now be refs more reluctant to give us what we are due.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 01 Jan 18 1.02pm

Debatable penalty, but not a dive. Thought it was a penalty from where I was standing. The thing that irks me most, is that if it was Sterling, would these pundits being saying this?

Also, the 'horror tackle' on KDB couldn't have been that bad, as he's 75% on FPL for a 'knock'. Couldn't have been that bad then, could it?

"Dirty dirty" Palace: 14 fouls
"Not-at-all-dirty" City: 11 fouls

 


[Link]

johnno42000 Flag 01 Jan 18 1.10pm

You had a forward marking a forward. Sterling had lost him, didn't get goal side and pushed him. Zaha went down. It was a foul, in the box and was a penalty.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 01 Jan 18 1.10pm

Are you serious? seeing what you see is not allowed when not "supportive"? There is some place for objectivity wouldn't you think?

Originally posted by MKCPFC

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Potential Wilf ban?' by Midlands Eagle

Just get behind your team and their players,

 

cpj Flag Kent 01 Jan 18 1.26pm

Originally posted by adrian b

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Potential Wilf ban?' by Midlands Eagle


Its such a shame Wilf does this. He doesn't need to

He does go down easily - but he does that all over the pitch. His upper body strength seems poor.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Jan 18 1.32pm

Originally posted by cpj

He does go down easily - but he does that all over the pitch. His upper body strength seems poor.

When I played my biggest asset was speed and I can assure you that when you are running at top speed it doesn't need much contact to send you flying, a gentle sideways nudge, a slight tap on the ankle is all it takes.

Edited by PZ Eagle (01 Jan 2018 1.32pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 01 Jan 18 2.04pm

Originally posted by Baldfella

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Potential Wilf ban?' by Midlands Eagle

How long does it normally take “the panel” to make their decision? With games coming thick and fast and Ashley Young banned within less than 24 hours I presume we’ll know tomorrow. My main concern that any ban will rule him out of The Weed game!

The panel can look at Puncheon ... he's too slow these days. I can't see any issue at all with the Wilf penalty (although I wish someone would tell him not to openly celebrate getting a penalty) and I can't see Wilf playing in our U23s facing Brighton next week.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

essetwentyone Flag london 01 Jan 18 2.10pm

Statistics show Wilf to be one of the most fouled players in the Prem and that doesn’t include the countless fouls we all see but are not penalised by refs. Is it any surprise that he anticipates these fouls and goes down to ensure they are penalised ? The opposition know that they can’t leave him alone because then he would destroy them so they lean on him and he goes down - and that is a foul and a pen in the area.
Basically he’s just too good for them and long may it last !!
The views of has beens like Poll and Sutton are totally irrelevant

 

merganser Flag 01 Jan 18 2.23pm

I agree with Henry of Peckham.

Wilf always looks far too exultant when he “wins” a penalty.

It would be better if his expression was more neutral - or even disgruntled at having been fouled.

Incidentally, isn’t it time for him to step up to the plate - and take a penalty himself?

Who’s turn is it next ?

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 01 Jan 18 3.21pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

He won't.

Great picture. This should be used as evidence. Clearly shows Sterling holding him back by the hand, which whether you like it or not is not allowed. Penalty no doubt. Just because Wilf falls over through loss of balance is irrelevant. Definate offence by Sterling who should of been booked for the foul.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 01 Jan 18 3.36pm

Zaha cleared.
Very good decision.
Where does that leave the sensationalist Sutton. He should get fined and banned for his filthy propaganda. Just shows what a fool he is.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 01 Jan 18 3.58pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Are you serious? seeing what you see is not allowed when not "supportive"? There is some place for objectivity wouldn't you think?

Yes at 3 hours after midnight here in Spain on New Years with much drink and a Passion for Palace I was deadly serious.
Now sober but still with a Passion for Palace I am still serious.

Reasons or objectivity ?

1. How many decisions have I seen go against Palace that have been blatantly wrong ? Far more than I have seen go for us . So when we get anything go for us I am not going to question it or our players attitude in gaining that advantage.

2. Wilf's attitude towards our club and our team is 100% Palace, he puts it out there week in week out , getting getting kicked and fouled and nothing given many times so when he seems to help sway decisions in his favour sometimes I am not going to criticise him for it. If he stops doing this , which many other players in other teams do , the refs will not suddenly decide to give us the other decisions they are not giving us now and the others players in other team will still carry on doing what they do.
So I will get 100% Wilf and not question his attitude as he gives us his all and does not deserve to be questioned by his own fans, the other teams fans do that plenty enough.

3. Was it definitely not penalty ? I don't think anyone can be conclusive on that , Sterling all over him and panicking .I think there is more of an argument for a penalty hence I will take what we are given thank you and give the benefit of the doubt to our player .

That's about as objective as I can get and obviously my Palace pride and passion may just get in the way a little bit.


 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 01 Jan 18 4.34pm

Appreciate your reasoning MK and to a certain extent I am with you.

I don't see thinking we get a decision in our favor unfairly, as not supportive. And I am no stranger to a certain amount of hypocrisy either,as I would have celebrated a winner from the spot with a dance around the lounge table. For obvious reasons I can only make a limited amount of games a season but in the ground I don't think anyone could accuse me of not being supportive.

However, I strongly feel about the whole game and the deliberate going for penalties and fouls in the box, overdoing contact, trailing your own leg or blatant diving. This was an example in my book of: not a dive, nor a penalty. Sterling was stupid to put his hand on Wilf, Wilf "made the most of it". I am not slagging him for that but as a whole, I do not like it in the game and feel it should not matter whether that is our own player or not.

Enjoy the red and blue glasses , don't think we have different wants in how things pan out.

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Yes at 3 hours after midnight here in Spain on New Years with much drink and a Passion for Palace I was deadly serious.
Now sober but still with a Passion for Palace I am still serious.

Reasons or objectivity ?

1. How many decisions have I seen go against Palace that have been blatantly wrong ? Far more than I have seen go for us . So when we get anything go for us I am not going to question it or our players attitude in gaining that advantage.

2. Wilf's attitude towards our club and our team is 100% Palace, he puts it out there week in week out , getting getting kicked and fouled and nothing given many times so when he seems to help sway decisions in his favour sometimes I am not going to criticise him for it. If he stops doing this , which many other players in other teams do , the refs will not suddenly decide to give us the other decisions they are not giving us now and the others players in other team will still carry on doing what they do.
So I will get 100% Wilf and not question his attitude as he gives us his all and does not deserve to be questioned by his own fans, the other teams fans do that plenty enough.

3. Was it definitely not penalty ? I don't think anyone can be conclusive on that , Sterling all over him and panicking .I think there is more of an argument for a penalty hence I will take what we are given thank you and give the benefit of the doubt to our player .

That's about as objective as I can get and obviously my Palace pride and passion may just get in the way a little bit.



 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 01 Jan 18 4.36pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Yes at 3 hours after midnight here in Spain on New Years with much drink and a Passion for Palace I was deadly serious.
Now sober but still with a Passion for Palace I am still serious.

Reasons or objectivity ?

1. How many decisions have I seen go against Palace that have been blatantly wrong ? Far more than I have seen go for us . So when we get anything go for us I am not going to question it or our players attitude in gaining that advantage.

2. Wilf's attitude towards our club and our team is 100% Palace, he puts it out there week in week out , getting getting kicked and fouled and nothing given many times so when he seems to help sway decisions in his favour sometimes I am not going to criticise him for it. If he stops doing this , which many other players in other teams do , the refs will not suddenly decide to give us the other decisions they are not giving us now and the others players in other team will still carry on doing what they do.
So I will get 100% Wilf and not question his attitude as he gives us his all and does not deserve to be questioned by his own fans, the other teams fans do that plenty enough.

3. Was it definitely not penalty ? I don't think anyone can be conclusive on that , Sterling all over him and panicking .I think there is more of an argument for a penalty hence I will take what we are given thank you and give the benefit of the doubt to our player .

That's about as objective as I can get and obviously my Palace pride and passion may just get in the way a little bit.


I have warned you before about supporting our players when they are being criticised by others MK. By the way you write much more eloquently when you are pissed !

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 01 Jan 18 4.42pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I have warned you before about supporting our players when they are being criticised by others MK. By the way you write much more eloquently when you are pissed !

WTF does that mean , are you having a pop ?
Hic !

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 01 Jan 18 4.49pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

WTF does that mean , are you having a pop ?
Hic !

Possibly . Well ok yes!

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 01 Jan 18 4.55pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Appreciate your reasoning MK and to a certain extent I am with you.

I don't see thinking we get a decision in our favor unfairly, as not supportive. And I am no stranger to a certain amount of hypocrisy either,as I would have celebrated a winner from the spot with a dance around the lounge table. For obvious reasons I can only make a limited amount of games a season but in the ground I don't think anyone could accuse me of not being supportive.

However, I strongly feel about the whole game and the deliberate going for penalties and fouls in the box, overdoing contact, trailing your own leg or blatant diving. This was an example in my book of: not a dive, nor a penalty. Sterling was stupid to put his hand on Wilf, Wilf "made the most of it". I am not slagging him for that but as a whole, I do not like it in the game and feel it should not matter whether that is our own player or not.

Enjoy the red and blue glasses , don't think we have different wants in how things pan out.


 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf potential ban?