You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Batshuayi for Benteke?
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Batshuayi for Benteke?


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 24 Jan 18 5.39pm

Benteke plus £10m for Batshuay and RLC.

Ohhh that would tempt us right?

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 24 Jan 18 6.15pm

I like Benteke, I tend to agree that he will come good - but I would take that deal.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 24 Jan 18 7.32pm

Originally posted by mattteo

If Benteke is better at hold-up play can only be assessed by a more qualified eye than you or I or even Ray Wilkins. It's subjective. It's not quantifiable, like how many goals they scored. Some people at Chelsea thought Batshuayi is better than Benteke 1 year ago when they decided to pay 30 million for him and not Benteke. Others at Liverpool thought Benteke is better at holding the ball and building up attacks a few years back and gambled on him.

You see something more in Benteke, I see something more in Batshuayi. It's subjective.
I can't really see much building up play at Benteke after seeing the back heel pass and build-up to the Brighton goal that Batsuayi made with Hazard and Willian. I mean, when has Benteke offered a build-up for a goal with his foot? Ever? His only good passes for team mates come from head deviations. Why would his hold-up of the ball contribution be considered so good if he never set up his team mates for dangerous situations with his feet?

And on the subject of the team letting Benteke down.....I think Zaha and Townsend are really good assisters, PVA is a great crosser. He has players to work with, better than in 7-8 other PL teams. He has let himself down

The key to that is we still struggle to play the ball up the field through midfield. We are getting better but still away off. Those flicks Chelsea were doing most of the 1st half till Brighton started to get some grip on the game. Like I said before, it's easy when you have players around you capable of that and Willian and Hazard are very very capable players. We're comparing two different players for 2 very different teams.

Regarding PVA, he's not really had much look in since Roy and he overlap has hardly been there. Whether he can cross or not is irrelevant if he hasn't played. We have pretty much relied on Zaha and Townsend to create this season and whilst Benteke should have scored more its not like he hasn't contributed.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 25 Jan 18 8.23am

Originally posted by mattteo

You see- this is what I have a problem with. Tricking football. When you take a gazzillion penalties for your team, you'll surely hit double figures. Doesn't mean you'd have hit those figures if you weren't the designed penalty taker. Let's have all strikers as penalty takers and then say that Benteke hit double figures and others didn't!

Without taking penalties, he'd have:
16 goals in the 12/13 season
7 goals in the 13/14 season
10 goals in the 14/15 season
8 goals in the 15/16 season
13 goals in the 16/17 season
1 in half the 17/18 season

Total playing time: 13.500 minutes.
1 goals every 250 minutes. Even in Liverpool it was 1 goals every 200 minutes, cause he scored 8 and played 1500 minutes.
Compare that to Batshuayi's 10 in 1000 mins just this season.

Edited by mattteo (23 Jan 2018 8.21pm)

So what? In most seasons he was playing in a side that was struggling for form, chances & goals other than the one at Liverpool where they did (& still do) create loads.

You keep posting reams of irrelevant, fallible statistics - players are actually human, the team/environment/situations/opposition they play in/against varies so extremely that it's a pointless argument.

Look at Kelechi Iheanacho - at City he had the best minutes per goal ratio in the EPL but that's all changed since his move. Is he suddenly an awful player?

Edit: Just looked at the 'gazillion' penalties he's taken. they total 17 since 2010 - scored 10, missed 7.

Edited by Nobbybm (25 Jan 2018 8.30am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Username Flag Horsham 25 Jan 18 8.33am

Originally posted by mattteo

If Benteke is better at hold-up play can only be assessed by a more qualified eye than you or I or even Ray Wilkins. It's subjective. It's not quantifiable, like how many goals they scored. Some people at Chelsea thought Batshuayi is better than Benteke 1 year ago when they decided to pay 30 million for him and not Benteke. Others at Liverpool thought Benteke is better at holding the ball and building up attacks a few years back and gambled on him.

You see something more in Benteke, I see something more in Batshuayi. It's subjective.
I can't really see much building up play at Benteke after seeing the back heel pass and build-up to the Brighton goal that Batsuayi made with Hazard and Willian. I mean, when has Benteke offered a build-up for a goal with his foot? Ever? His only good passes for team mates come from head deviations. Why would his hold-up of the ball contribution be considered so good if he never set up his team mates for dangerous situations with his feet?

And on the subject of the team letting Benteke down.....I think Zaha and Townsend are really good assisters, PVA is a great crosser. He has players to work with, better than in 7-8 other PL teams. He has let himself down


Leicester and Burnley. He also played in Wilf for the second penalty against Bournemouth.

PVA getting back into the side should help him, but he has been missing for most of the year so far. Townsend has been way below his form from last year for most of this season.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

taylors lovechild Flag 25 Jan 18 9.33am

A key tactic this season has been for Wilf to drive into the box and then cut it back. We do not seem to put many aerial crosses into the box like we did last season, which I don't think is helping the big man. When he goes through one on one you can sense his lack of confidence, which I really hope he can overcome. I actually think some healthy competition for his place might focus and improve his performances.

 

Username Flag Horsham 25 Jan 18 10.44am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

A key tactic this season has been for Wilf to drive into the box and then cut it back. We do not seem to put many aerial crosses into the box like we did last season, which I don't think is helping the big man. When he goes through one on one you can sense his lack of confidence, which I really hope he can overcome. I actually think some healthy competition for his place might focus and improve his performances.

I think that's where Townsend's drop in form is more notable.

Completely agree with this. It's a mix of a lack of confidence and the team not playing to his strengths in the same way they did last year.

Some competition and the chance to have a break from starting would probably do him the world of good.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Jan 18 12.09pm

Eder is being pursued to bring out the best in Benteke. He is potentially the missing piece of our attack puzzle. Fingers crossed.

Batshuayi - if he can't succeed at Chelsea where he is stuffed with supply, what chance success at a club where he will be feeding off scraps?

Those who genuinely think he is a step up from Benteke are misguided.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 25 Jan 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Eder is being pursued to bring out the best in Benteke. He is potentially the missing piece of our attack puzzle. Fingers crossed.

Batshuayi - if he can't succeed at Chelsea where he is stuffed with supply, what chance success at a club where he will be feeding off scraps?

Those who genuinely think he is a step up from Benteke are misguided.

So lets say we had Batshuayi in our side instead of Benteke and he had been the one who had all the goal opportunities that Benteke has had this season. Would you be more or less confident in them being scored?

The thing is we HAVE created chances. Benteke has fluffed 99% of them.

Edited by MonsterMunch (25 Jan 2018 12.51pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Jan 18 4.36pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

So lets say we had Batshuayi in our side instead of Benteke and he had been the one who had all the goal opportunities that Benteke has had this season. Would you be more or less confident in them being scored?

The thing is we HAVE created chances. Benteke has fluffed 99% of them.

Edited by MonsterMunch (25 Jan 2018 12.51pm)

Batshuayi would not have been in the right positon to fluff the chances. That's the difference. Benteke can come good; Batshuayi can't.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 25 Jan 18 5.27pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Batshuayi would not have been in the right positon to fluff the chances. That's the difference. Benteke can come good; Batshuayi can't.

What makes you think that Benteke can come good?....is it the same 'hope' that Rogers and Klopp and Pardew had because if it is we could be a few more years down the line in seeing the return of his Aston Villa form which Liverpool based their buying decision on and us. Love it to happen but he is showing only a trickle of what is required and that starts with sleeves rolled up and hard work. It would not surprise me at all if he was sold in this window but of course that is dependant upon incoming strikers.

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Jan 18 5.32pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

What makes you think that Benteke can come good?....is it the same 'hope' that Rogers and Klopp and Pardew had because if it is we could be a few more years down the line in seeing the return of his Aston Villa form which Liverpool based their buying decision on and us. Love it to happen but he is showing only a trickle of what is required and that starts with sleeves rolled up and hard work. It would not surprise me at all if he was sold in this window but of course that is dependant upon incoming strikers.

Perhaps with competition for his place he might show some of the form of old !

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 25 Jan 18 5.45pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Batshuayi would not have been in the right positon to fluff the chances. That's the difference. Benteke can come good; Batshuayi can't.

How on earth can you know Batshuayi can’t come good? Could simply be Wrong place wrong time for him. I mean I couldnt care less as he’s not a Palace Player but an odd statement. Also would say both players movement and positional sense is pretty similar.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Jan 18 5.51pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

How on earth can you know Batshuayi can’t come good? Could simply be Wrong place wrong time for him. I mean I couldnt care less as he’s not a Palace Player but an odd statement. Also would say both players movement and positional sense is pretty similar.

Unlike Benteke, Batshuayi is not a conventional target man - he favours the ball into feet or into the channels.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 25 Jan 18 6.07pm

If he is crap at Chelsea he is hardly going to be a success here. People have short memories about Christian. He is out of form, but we have a striker that’s hit 17 goals a season while in the PL, AJ was the last person to do that.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (25 Jan 2018 6.08pm)

 

mattteo Flag 25 Jan 18 6.21pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

If he is crap at Chelsea he is hardly going to be a success here. People have short memories about Christian. He is out of form, but we have a striker that’s hit 17 goals a season while in the PL, AJ was the last person to do that.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (25 Jan 2018 6.08pm)


This is such a stupid statement that you should just shut up about football. Forever

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 25 Jan 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by mattteo


This is such a stupid statement that you should just shut up about football. Forever

That’s incredibly rich seeing as some of the absolute sh*t you come out with from your time playing football manager.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Jan 18 6.41pm

B

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

How on earth can you know Batshuayi can’t come good? Could simply be Wrong place wrong time for him. I mean I couldnt care less as he’s not a Palace Player but an odd statement. Also would say both players movement and positional sense is pretty similar.

Rot. Have you seen his performances for Chelsea? Benteke is a target man low on confidence. I genuinely think eder is the answer to unlock his potential

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 Jan 18 6.42pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

That’s incredibly rich seeing as some of the absolute sh*t you come out with from your time playing football manager.

Totally agree Coulsdon, this poster is seriously getting on my t*** with his nonsense stats. What makes it worse he thinks he knows better than those that go to the games week in week out.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 25 Jan 18 7.04pm

Originally posted by silvertop

B

Rot. Have you seen his performances for Chelsea? Benteke is a target man low on confidence. I genuinely think eder is the answer to unlock his potential

When I say both have similar positional sense and movement I mean as in they are both poor. I would say Batshauyi is the more natural goal scorer, if there is such a thing. Both low on confidence but obviously decent players. Both probably don’t want to be here/there.

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Batshuayi for Benteke?