You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 13 fatal stabbings in London in 2018
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

13 fatal stabbings in London in 2018


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Stuk Flag Top half 21 Feb 18 3.32pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Narrow those stats down to Croydon or Lewisham and you watch them fall sharply. Only Monday saw a clip of a fight in a Kebab shop in Surrey Street with one of the guys wielding a foot long knife ...as school kids were walking past!!

4 in one day yesterday in Camden, 2 of which were fatal and one of those two fatalities had a brother killed in September.

 


Optimistic as ever

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 21 Feb 18 3.35pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Prison is not a deterrent nor is it a means of rehabilitation. The root issue is high levels of inequality, lack of social investment (education) and community investment and severe cuts to policing.

To say that the root of the problem is inequality is simply not true.

I grew up in a council flat on a Saf London estate to a single mum however I never carried a knife. Did lots of other stuff but never carried a knife. Through sheer bloody hard work and a will to better myself I now own a property development company and have kids at private schools.

Knives are predominately (not exclusively though) a problem in the black population.

You cannot say this is due to inequality as plenty of other races have also settled here over the years who would have faced the same challenges and yet who have not attopted the knife culture.

I would say that the reverse is probably true in your statement. It's more likely it's the knives/drugs/crime etc which is often keeping the black population at the bottom.
Many years ago the Jews arrived here and faced predudice, however they worked hard and moved up the ladder. Same with the Indians, Italians and Chinese etc. However for many the black population still occupy the bottom of society, living in the worst parts of the city and doing the worst jobs etc.
It's an absolute shame however for things to change then they also have to change.
I have no axe to grind. Just saying it how I see it.

Edited by Tom-the-eagle (21 Feb 2018 3.37pm)

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Feb 18 12.09am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

What does this actually mean?

Really ! I mean really, you have to ask.
Ok then just last night after two I say two fatal stabbings within a mile of each other, the police had to request permission for a
section 60 stop and search directive. From midnight to 7am. WHY
Because certain people kept moaning and complaining about being stopped and searched and now that is put in place. The police actually have to ask their boss to be able to search someone.
Bloody ludicrous.
That's what my pc brigade line is in my post.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Feb 18 8.15am

Originally posted by cryrst

Really ! I mean really, you have to ask.
Ok then just last night after two I say two fatal stabbings within a mile of each other, the police had to request permission for a
section 60 stop and search directive. From midnight to 7am. WHY
Because certain people kept moaning and complaining about being stopped and searched and now that is put in place. The police actually have to ask their boss to be able to search someone.
Bloody ludicrous.
That's what my pc brigade line is in my post.

So you were talking about stop and search, not 'when someone gets arrested for carrying' as you said in your earliest post - so yes, I really had to ask.

On the stop and search; whilst it was clearly flawed in it's enforcement, it's a necessary inconvenience as far as I'm concerned - I was subjected to it a few times as a teenager, and whilst I understand the frustrations it can cause, ultimately, if it means less people are carrying knives and less people are getting stabbed, it's a frustration worth suffering IMO.

Interestingly, there is a musician from Norbury called 'Dave' who took to Twitter on this point; basically summarised that as a young black guy in south London he had stopped and searched countless times, but if it meant less young black kids dying, he was more than happy to put up with it.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 22 Feb 18 9.23am

its all gang related. let them crack on.

 


@sxp55555

Matov Flag 22 Feb 18 9.52am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


Interestingly, there is a musician from Norbury called 'Dave' who took to Twitter on this point; basically summarised that as a young black guy in south London he had stopped and searched countless times, but if it meant less young black kids dying, he was more than happy to put up with it.


Problem is that the Daves of this world have no political power. And in London, we have a Mayor who effectively championed himself as the man who would make the big nasty Met cut right back on stop and search.

That is the difference between the knife problems in Glasgow and London. Essentially it is young men from the self-same socioeconomic backgrounds sticking knives into each other for ludicrous reasons. But in Glasgow because the young men are poor and white, there is absolutely no political capital to be gained from either side. Hence why it can be resolved.

But in London, because it is predominantly poor and black, then there are a massive amount of political capital involved.

And what is happening is absolutely pure and destructive racism in its most deadly form. If it were white boys killing each other at the rates we are seeing now, then drastic action would be taken. But because it is black boys, then people would rather them die than run the risk of seeing their own careers go down.

We live in a world in which the accusation 'racist' gets bandied about for the most ludicrous reasons and yet here we have a situation in which the only explanation for the lack of action is down to skin colour.

White boys lives in Glasgow are deemed for more important than those of black boys in London.

Now I am hardly going to win any awards for my progressive and tolerant views but I know what right and wrong is and this situation in London is now beyond a joke.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Feb 18 10.09am

Originally posted by Matov


Problem is that the Daves of this world have no political power. And in London, we have a Mayor who effectively championed himself as the man who would make the big nasty Met cut right back on stop and search.

That is the difference between the knife problems in Glasgow and London. Essentially it is young men from the self-same socioeconomic backgrounds sticking knives into each other for ludicrous reasons. But in Glasgow because the young men are poor and white, there is absolutely no political capital to be gained from either side. Hence why it can be resolved.

But in London, because it is predominantly poor and black, then there are a massive amount of political capital involved.

And what is happening is absolutely pure and destructive racism in its most deadly form. If it were white boys killing each other at the rates we are seeing now, then drastic action would be taken. But because it is black boys, then people would rather them die than run the risk of seeing their own careers go down.

We live in a world in which the accusation 'racist' gets bandied about for the most ludicrous reasons and yet here we have a situation in which the only explanation for the lack of action is down to skin colour.

White boys lives in Glasgow are deemed for more important than those of black boys in London.

Now I am hardly going to win any awards for my progressive and tolerant views but I know what right and wrong is and this situation in London is now beyond a joke.

They may not have political power, but don't underestimate the influence of positive role models - this is a cultural problem as much as a political one, so to have popular figures from within the culture speak out about it will make a huge difference.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Feb 18 11.25am

Originally posted by Matov


Problem is that the Daves of this world have no political power. And in London, we have a Mayor who effectively championed himself as the man who would make the big nasty Met cut right back on stop and search.

That is the difference between the knife problems in Glasgow and London. Essentially it is young men from the self-same socioeconomic backgrounds sticking knives into each other for ludicrous reasons. But in Glasgow because the young men are poor and white, there is absolutely no political capital to be gained from either side. Hence why it can be resolved.

But in London, because it is predominantly poor and black, then there are a massive amount of political capital involved.

And what is happening is absolutely pure and destructive racism in its most deadly form. If it were white boys killing each other at the rates we are seeing now, then drastic action would be taken. But because it is black boys, then people would rather them die than run the risk of seeing their own careers go down.

We live in a world in which the accusation 'racist' gets bandied about for the most ludicrous reasons and yet here we have a situation in which the only explanation for the lack of action is down to skin colour.

White boys lives in Glasgow are deemed for more important than those of black boys in London.

Now I am hardly going to win any awards for my progressive and tolerant views but I know what right and wrong is and this situation in London is now beyond a joke.


It's a sad irony that fear of being branded racist is stopping the police potentially save black lives.
It is the fault of authority for pandering to emotion and political correctness over reason because of the death of Stephen Lawerence and the campaign that started as a result. One Black man killed by Whites. How many Black people have died at the hands of other Black people since then?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Feb 18 1.02pm

Originally posted by sxp55

its all gang related. let them crack on.

I wonder how much is actually because drug business is under threat. This has been the case in the US with the crack business hierarchy but here?

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Feb 18 1.34pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So you were talking about stop and search, not 'when someone gets arrested for carrying' as you said in your earliest post - so yes, I really had to ask.

On the stop and search; whilst it was clearly flawed in it's enforcement, it's a necessary inconvenience as far as I'm concerned - I was subjected to it a few times as a teenager, and whilst I understand the frustrations it can cause, ultimately, if it means less people are carrying knives and less people are getting stabbed, it's a frustration worth suffering IMO.

Interestingly, there is a musician from Norbury called 'Dave' who took to Twitter on this point; basically summarised that as a young black guy in south London he had stopped and searched countless times, but if it meant less young black kids dying, he was more than happy to put up with it.

Yes that's what I wrote but alongside being found with a knife, from a search, was I thought a mandatory five years. Muted when this stab culture started to get out of control. Which it is now.So it does go hand in hand. So being found with one should be an arrest.

 

Matov Flag 22 Feb 18 2.15pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


It's a sad irony that fear of being branded racist is stopping the police potentially save black lives.
It is the fault of authority for pandering to emotion and political correctness over reason because of the death of Stephen Lawerence and the campaign that started as a result. One Black man killed by Whites. How many Black people have died at the hands of other Black people since then?

The problem is that, as a whole, the British left has always primarily defined itself by what it is against, as opposed to what it is for.

You can go back to Orwell who, in a British political world that was for all intents and purposes 100% white,argued that many Lefties did not actually like the poor nor really care about their fate but rather were driven more by a loathing of those richer than them.

Throw in the complexities, and nuances, of the identity politics of today and you get the insanity of the current situation in which poor white young male lives are deemed to be of so little political interest that the authorities can get one with what is required to stop them killing each other where as these black kids are effectively being almost given a freedom to stick knives in each other because wealthy/powerful left wingers would rather not confront what is required to stop it.

All I do know for certain is that the utter and catastrophic consequences for parents when they lose a child in such a pointless crime must be equally horrendous no matter your skin colour or culture. With the added injustice that the UK has a blue-print to prevent it. The Glasgow experience has been incredible in terms of its success.

And whilst I accept that you cannot apply it to the current problem in London on a word for word basis, I also refuse to believe that it does not contain the basics that would bring a halt to this current murderous wave.

The only question is why it is not being done? And all I can put that down to is that reality that for many in the British political spectrum, Black Lives simply do not matter enough.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Feb 18 3.21pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So you were talking about stop and search, not 'when someone gets arrested for carrying' as you said in your earliest post - so yes, I really had to ask.

On the stop and search; whilst it was clearly flawed in it's enforcement, it's a necessary inconvenience as far as I'm concerned - I was subjected to it a few times as a teenager, and whilst I understand the frustrations it can cause, ultimately, if it means less people are carrying knives and less people are getting stabbed, it's a frustration worth suffering IMO.

Interestingly, there is a musician from Norbury called 'Dave' who took to Twitter on this point; basically summarised that as a young black guy in south London he had stopped and searched countless times, but if it meant less young black kids dying, he was more than happy to put up with it.

That was the one I was trying to recall earlier in the thread.

 


Optimistic as ever

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 22 Feb 18 6.15pm

A few years ago one of the councillors in Lewisham - Dwayne Brooks (remember him?) - wanted to introduce a free service so local youths would get text alerts telling them which areas the police would be operating stop and search each day

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Feb 18 6.59pm

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

A few years ago one of the councillors in Lewisham - Dwayne Brooks (remember him?) - wanted to introduce a free service so local youths would get text alerts telling them which areas the police would be operating stop and search each day

well fair enough. But to save money could we only include those youths with criminal convictions or at risk of getting criminal convictions.
cos there is no point in bothering the mannerly nice kids.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Feb 18 8.18am

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

A few years ago one of the councillors in Lewisham - Dwayne Brooks (remember him?) - wanted to introduce a free service so local youths would get text alerts telling them which areas the police would be operating stop and search each day

Dwayne is running for Mayor of Lewisham. Saw a video he made "Lewisham has problems I can fix them". He didn't explain what problems and how he could fix them. I believe he is running as an independent so no chance as Lewisham is solid Labour.

We have to re-introduce stop and search. Critics point out that many people who are stopped are not carrying but it is a deterrent. If teenagers start to complain to each other that they are being harnessed by the police they are less likely to carry a knife. If they don't feel they will be randomly stopped, well we can all see the results.

 


One more point

npn Flag Crowborough 23 Feb 18 10.46am

Stop and search is, I'm sure, a minor inconvenience, but how long does it really take? And does it have to be a horrible experience?

It's like traffic stops (which I have more personal experience of) - if you're polite and respectful to the officer(s) involved they will (or should) be polite and respectful back. It can be just a couple of minutes, and a pleasant chat while the necessary is done, and everyone goes about their day. Of course, if the officers are disrespectful and aggressive, then I totally understand the issue, and it's not on.

Being searched on the way into football is no big deal is it?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Feb 18 10.52am

Originally posted by npn

Stop and search is, I'm sure, a minor inconvenience, but how long does it really take? And does it have to be a horrible experience?

I'm sure that the mothers, fathers, brothers and sisters who have all lost loved ones would think it a worthwhile inconvenience

 

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Feb 18 2.37pm


I don't know for certain, but I reckon there would be a lot less animosity about stop and search if weed was decriminalised.

 


Optimistic as ever

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Feb 18 3.08pm

Originally posted by Stuk


I don't know for certain, but I reckon there would be a lot less animosity about stop and search if weed was decriminalised.

Yes. From those being stopped. Problem is the psychosis linked to skunk use, especially in young people.

Who knows on those protesting on their behalf.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 Feb 18 10.45am

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

A few years ago one of the councillors in Lewisham - Dwayne Brooks (remember him?) - wanted to introduce a free service so local youths would get text alerts telling them which areas the police would be operating stop and search each day

Yes I recall was he with SL on the night he was stabbed.
Got a load of compo as well if it was him due to the police not being on the ball and of course apparently 'institutionally racist'
Opinions are free before I get pilloried.
That night things happened which I never read or heard in the press.but heard from a very very reliable source. Not all what you see and in this case don't read is the truth.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 13 fatal stabbings in London in 2018