You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever
November 16 2026 7.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our greatest player ever


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Cannonball Flag High in the Ozarks. 18 Apr 18 10.32am

For commitment my vote goes to Jim Cannon. my all time number one.

 


Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you.

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 18 Apr 18 10.04pm

I love Wilf. I loved Clinton.

Wilf is the new Clinton....key man, epitomises the club and is South London with it.

God I hope he doesn't leave in the Summer.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

CockneyRebel Flag West Harrison,NY. 20 Apr 18 6.47pm

Put it all in perspective.. Today,yes, Wilf is fantastic..the best...BUT, I go back to the days of Johnny (Budgie) Byrne.. I remember him as fantastic, nobody like him etc, etc. So time is the factor, Everybody see's it differently..

Best goalkeeper ever..Vic Rouse..John Jackson, Jules, etc,etc..

 


Here since 81...(LAST CENTURY !!).. x-Dunraven School, early 1960.... Palace 'nut' since 58....

glazedallover Flag Allier 20 Apr 18 6.55pm

By some of the criteria mentioned here, Shaun Derry was a great serveant. Played out of position, involved in promotion, came back as captain during admin....

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 20 Apr 18 7.12pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

If you were a little nerdy and had the time on your hands to score someone on loyalty, match winning performance, technical skill, dribbles, other stuff, hair, tattoos and worth, then I think Wilf would fair well. Everyone has their favourite. Of the current team I love Luka who was just as responsible for today’s result if not arguably moreso.

In days gone by Lombardo was immense. Always loved Clinton!!

Lombardo's career at Palace was as short as his haircut. Technically one of the best but if you are talking greatest then he must be ingrained in the clubs history far more, so for me Jim Cannon or Geoff Thomas, both in periods of great Palace teams and both great leaders.

Edited by Booted Eagle (20 Apr 2018 7.16pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

mikebcpfc Flag Horsham 20 Apr 18 7.34pm

Our greatest player is not necessarily the best player. Lombardo world class for sure but wilf is far greater than him as a palace player in my eyes.

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 20 Apr 18 7.46pm

Been supporting since my first game in 1979 and it is really hard to compare players now. The pitches are so much better, and it is far less physical. Imagine Kenny Sansom and Vince Hilaire in todays game.

My top 5 would sadly not include Zaha just yet, although if he continues to improve then he will become a true club legend. I could say the same for Luka too.

Mine are:
1- Wright - Just a joy to watch
2- Cannon - Best captain we will ever have
3 - Sansom - Best naturally gifted player
4- Lombardo - A brief time but a massive impact. Heads and shoulders above everyone on the pitch
5 - Gilbert - A monster. Loved him.

You could also argue Hinchelwood, Martyn, Burridge, Thomas, Bright, Fan Z, Mabbutt, Hilaire, Kember. The list could go on, just depends what you are lookimg for.

We have been blessed with some fantastic players in my time, just a shame they all played at different times.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

gloryhunter Flag EDINBURGH 20 Apr 18 7.50pm

Originally posted by fozzaisere

I have just got in from a day out and watched the motd highlights.

From my standpoint will we ever see a player greater than Wilf Zaha? I am 29 been supporting palace for 19 years so missed the glory years etc but it's not just the skill, trickery etc but the passion this guy shows for the club. The way he celebrates goals - particularly brighton ones - feels me with so much happiness. Maybe i am being silly but can't see another talismanic homegrown player like him coming along for a life time. Long live king Zaha

Zaha is an excellent player but like all goal scorers he gets the headlines. My favourite has always been Kenny Sansom for the difference he made to our team and our performances.

 


gloryhunter (eagle in exile)

TheBigToePunt Flag 20 Apr 18 8.00pm

Of those I've seen (so from 1988 onwards) Wright and Zaha are out on their own. Zaha probably now the no1, but not by much.

After that take your pick from Bright, Johnson, Martyn, Thomas and Jedinak.

The next level is Southgate, Coleman, Shaw, Hughes.

Probably missed someone really important out.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (20 Apr 2018 8.01pm)


Bollocks. Did forget someone. Freedman.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (20 Apr 2018 8.15pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Apr 18 9.10pm

Remember watching Ken Sansom as a kid and he was outstanding but in terms of his contribution to Palace's history you'd argue his contribution wasn't that great. 2nd Division champion but left after one season in the first for Arsenal. Might want to consider that Vince Hilaire and Jim Cannon were greater talismen and influence in those years.

Ian Wright plucked out of non league helped propel a previously struggling Palace team to the top flight with massive goals in the play offs. Broke his leg (I think twice) in the first season we were up and the team did OK without him including getting to the cup final where he starred as a sub. 1990-91 we finished 3rd with help of his goals but he left under a bit of a cloud beginning of 1991-92 amid stories of him behaving like a tool in order to force a move. Badge kissing incident 1992-93 when we were relegated.

Wilf needs no explanation and some parallels with Wright's Palace career but IMO his individual contribution to survival years in the Championship, promotion and the most successful spell in the clubs history makes him the greatest. Also a wizard with the ball like no other and to all intents a local / academy kid.


 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 20 Apr 18 9.14pm

Was only about 10/11 when we had Lombardo but remember thinking how incredible he was even then. Him and Wilf of the players that I've seen.

Also had a massive soft spot for Matt Jansen despite the brief time he spent with us, thought he was absolutely class.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

glazedallover Flag Allier 20 Apr 18 9.20pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Was only about 10/11 when we had Lombardo but remember thinking how incredible he was even then. Him and Wilf of the players that I've seen.

Also had a massive soft spot for Matt Jansen despite the brief time he spent with us, thought he was absolutely class.

I was thinking of mentioning Matt Jansen. Could have been a real great.

Whats it like in Whitstable these days?

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 20 Apr 18 9.40pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

I was thinking of mentioning Matt Jansen. Could have been a real great.

Whats it like in Whitstable these days?


Yeah real pity that his career was derailed by injury as had such talent and, as you said, could have been great.

Whitstable is very nice these days thanks, infinitely better when drenched in sunshine of course. Can't beat a few beers on the beach by the Neptune pub!

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

glazedallover Flag Allier 20 Apr 18 9.44pm

I know the Neptune. Lived on island wall for a few years back in 2000-4. Is the Ship Centurion still going? Used to be run by a german guy Armin. Great pub. Great town.

 

mikebcpfc Flag Horsham 20 Apr 18 10.20pm

Jedinak - f me nowhere near this list

 

mikebcpfc Flag Horsham 20 Apr 18 10.20pm

Freedman and Jansen i except. Freedman more so.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 20 Apr 18 10.30pm

Accept.......

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever