You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Pete53 Flag Hassocks 13 May 18 12.01am

Originally posted by gbox82

I'd say Roy, given the start we had, and given how low confidence must've been when he took over.

However, I'd say that if we are comparing rescue jobs and how far they took us as a club...then I'd say Pardews first year trumps the whole lot.

(Tin hat donned!)

I'm not sure if Pardew's was the most impressive rescue job, but totally unfair of the OP to leave him out of the reckoning.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 13 May 18 12.54am

All three managers (Pulis, Allardyce and Hodgson) have made terrific contributions to keep us in the PL. They earned their places in our history but in terms of personality it has to be Roy ... cos he has one!

Not forgetting Pards took us to our first FA Cup Final in 26 years but I am sure he would have got us relegated too.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 13 May 18 4.08am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Pulis had the worst squad to work with,However he had luck whilst Roy might have had the far better squad but was afflicted by a horrendous injury list and a run of very bad luck. So really hard to call but I'rd probably have to give it to Pulis just because he achieved so much with so little, If asking for best football, then Hodgson's team by a country mile.
The team are probably playing the best football we've seen since the 1972 team occasionally managed.

Team of the 80ies (Sansom, Hilaire, Murphy, Cannon & Co) with Terry V as manager were not bad either.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 13 May 18 4.36am

For me, Roy.

Not only did he keep us up when everyone had us as down, but he managed us with a dire injury list, an off form striker, an inherited squad, AND he also bought back confidence, belief and love for the club and team to a squad that was all over the shop, AND he also got us playing some of the best football i have ever seen at Palace.
AND.... he also didn't change anything drastic and doesn't look to altering our DNA - AND i think the chairman has learnt something from him to.

 


This was once a quality forum....

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 13 May 18 7.16am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Looking at the posts on this thread.......

We have been well served by each of them really.

The job for Eagles is to stop getting in such a mess in the first place.

Hopefully RH has seen that, he needs a lot of help to persuade the owners IMO.


That's what I think too, but if Roy is still here next season then he goes to the top of the list. Pardew did well when he first arrived, and he got us to a cup final, but he lost the plot along the way.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 13 May 18 7.57am

I think there was a greater manager than that lot...not because he was a better manager,
he came in,
we were skint,
players not getting paid,
just went into administration,
deducted 10 points ,
lost our main players who we couldn't let get injured so we could sell them,
we were going down to league 1,
nobody else would touch us.

Paul Hart

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 13 May 18 8.51am

Originally posted by aquickgame2

I think there was a greater manager than that lot...not because he was a better manager,
he came in,
we were skint,
players not getting paid,
just went into administration,
deducted 10 points ,
lost our main players who we couldn't let get injured so we could sell them,
we were going down to league 1,
nobody else would touch us.

Paul Hart

Yes, the forgotten man ... wasn't he appointed by the administrator?

Also, there was the guy who helped Dougie ... but I can't remember his name either

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 13 May 18 9.04am

Originally posted by aquickgame2

Paul Hart


Indeed and, yes he was appointed caretaker by the administrator, the day after Warnock and his crew went to QPR. Perhaps we should consult Brendan Guilfoyle on future managerial appointments?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 13 May 18 9.32am

Great thread here, split between Pulis and Roy with Sam in the middle. Without Pulis we may not of had Sam and without him Roy. Happily have any of them at the helm as they have all pulled us out of the mire at different times.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 13 May 18 9.43am

I think all 3 did brilliantly, so I cannot separate them. All 3 turned things around when we were floundering at the foot of the table.

It would be nice to have a season where we are not in a relegation scrap, but I guess we should be thankful that we have survived for yet another season in the top flight.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 13 May 18 10.08am

yes all 3 have done the job asked,Pulis had a tougher time, team only had 1 win in the first 11 games 12 if you count cup game only four goals scored 23 against so Pulis for me just,

but Roy has done well, because after the all the injurys we still had some good players on the pitch so he could still get them playing the way he wants which helped, and other teams around us didnt look that far from us.

Sam was lucky in my eyes we almost went, only a poor Hull team kept us safe but he did buy well at the time

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 13 May 18 10.22am

All of these (and yes Padrew too) fire fought brilliantly. The trick is to sustain form into additional seasons and motivate a team to muddle along with no real worry of relegation.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 13 May 18 10.27am

Pardew had better than all, fact. Pulis and allardyce never looked interested in sticking around but both done decent jobs with our team and hodgson I really belive next season we've got a great shout of getting Europe.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 13 May 18 10.30am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Yes, the forgotten man ... wasn't he appointed by the administrator?

Also, there was the guy who helped Dougie ... but I can't remember his name either

Lennie Lawrence?

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 13 May 18 10.42am

Some posters are perceiving this thread to be who is the most popular manager out of the 3 which is incorrect.

Yes Pulis is a dodgy lying c*** which was proved in court which has tarnised his tenure here but you can't doubt what he acheived here was nothing short of a miracle.

He had by far the worse squad to work with & many of the players were Championship standard & we looked dead & buried by November but we finished 11th!

All 3 have done fantastic jobs here but as 1 poster here said if it wasn't for Pulis then the other 2 wouldn't have had the opportunity to save us because we wouldn't be in the Prem!

 

Shufflin Flag Wellington 13 May 18 10.52am

Id say RH. If he keeps this form up who knows? Might even dona Burnley.

 

Shufflin Flag Wellington 13 May 18 10.54am

Originally posted by Shufflin

Id say RH. If he keeps this form up who knows? Might even do a Burnley ala Dyche and wrangle our way into Europe?

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 13 May 18 11.01am

Pulls for me too. We were as good as dead and buried in Oct before he took over and transformed the team.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 13 May 18 11.07am

Originally posted by Dixie Eagle

Pulls for me too. We were as good as dead and buried in Oct before he took over and transformed the team.

He did, but then look at Sam and Roy again. When Roy took over we didn’t even have a goal to our name let alone a point!

 

shortbutt Flag Solihull 13 May 18 11.12am

Originally posted by Welsh Eagle

Some posters are perceiving this thread to be who is the most popular manager out of the 3 which is incorrect.

Yes Pulis is a dodgy lying c*** which was proved in court which has tarnised his tenure here but you can't doubt what he acheived here was nothing short of a miracle.

He had by far the worse squad to work with & many of the players were Championship standard & we looked dead & buried by November but we finished 11th!

All 3 have done fantastic jobs here but as 1 poster here said if it wasn't for Pulis then the other 2 wouldn't have had the opportunity to save us because we wouldn't be in the Prem!

Agree with this - on this measure has to be Pulis.

However, in terms of likability/personal attributes, in my mind Roy would be streets ahead. It’s been great to have a gent in charge - and one of our own. I’m anticipating a more stable or even progressive 2018/19 season, but can’t help but feel some unexpected calamity will strike - requiring yet another Houdini feat.


Edited by shortbutt (13 May 2018 11.14am)

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?