You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best team since early 90s?
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best team since early 90s?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 06 Aug 18 12.19am

Maybe I'm kidding myself, but I really like the look of the current team in pre-season.

If we keep Wilf, which I believe we will for this season, and if the players stay fit could we surprise everyone with a top six finish?

1990/91 was arguably our most successful season ever, coming third in the old first division and winning the Zenith Data Systems cup. So how does our current squad compare with those days?

Keeper

Clearly the big Cornishman was streets ahead of what we have now.

Defence

The Ninja and Andy Thorn were bed rock solid as are Mama and Tompkins. Humphrey and Shaw were also dependable full backs altho' Van Aanholt is probably a class above any of them

Midfield

Geoff had a great engine, Andy Gray was fiercely competitive, Gareth started out as a right-sided defensive midfielder I think, but we used to largely play long balls into the channels over the top of the mudfielders.

Today we mostly play through the middle and Luka, Meyer, Kouyate/Jimmy Mc and Townsend could be a very creative bunch indeed

Forwards

Wright, Bright and Salako/McGoldrick
could tear any defence apart on their day.

Wilf will surely become Palace's greatest ever player with 20-30 goals this season. While to have the options of Benteke, Sorloth and Wickham as no. 9s if they can stay fit is not at all bad even if they rotate.

Money is too great an influence on the modern game to get us thinking about finishing third as in 90/91, but I think finishing 6-8th would be comparable.

Of course, I could just be deluded and we might end up in another relegation scrap, but living in Southampton, I know their fans are clearly not happy about the team's form or lack of summer business.

So maybe, just maybe, 'Parish's project' will take us to another record season in the Prem with a new stand to look forward to.

After 51 years of supporting Palace through thick and thin, is there a chance that under 'Croydon Boy Roy' we will have our best season yet?

I would love it if we did, but that didn't do Kevin Keegan any good! COYP

 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

Littlebogreek Flag 06 Aug 18 12.46am

Originally posted by jackosperoni

Maybe I'm kidding myself, but I really like the look of the current team in pre-season.

If we keep Wilf, which I believe we will for this season, and if the players stay fit could we surprise everyone with a top six finish?

1990/91 was arguably our most successful season ever, coming third in the old first division and winning the Zenith Data Systems cup. So how does our current squad compare with those days?

Keeper

Clearly the big Cornishman was streets ahead of what we have now.

Defence

The Ninja and Andy Thorn were bed rock solid as are Mama and Tompkins. Humphrey and Shaw were also dependable full backs altho' Van Aanholt is probably a class above any of them

Midfield

Geoff had a great engine, Andy Gray was fiercely competitive, Gareth started out as a right-sided defensive midfielder I think, but we used to largely play long balls into the channels over the top of the mudfielders.

Today we mostly play through the middle and Luka, Meyer, Kouyate/Jimmy Mc and Townsend could be a very creative bunch indeed

Forwards

Wright, Bright and Salako/McGoldrick
could tear any defence apart on their day.

Wilf will surely become Palace's greatest ever player with 20-30 goals this season. While to have the options of Benteke, Sorloth and Wickham as no. 9s if they can stay fit is not at all bad even if they rotate.

Money is too great an influence on the modern game to get us thinking about finishing third as in 90/91, but I think finishing 6-8th would be comparable.

Of course, I could just be deluded and we might end up in another relegation scrap, but living in Southampton, I know their fans are clearly not happy about the team's form or lack of summer business.

So maybe, just maybe, 'Parish's project' will take us to another record season in the Prem with a new stand to look forward to.

After 51 years of supporting Palace through thick and thin, is there a chance that under 'Croydon Boy Roy' we will have our best season yet?

I would love it if we did, but that didn't do Kevin Keegan any good! COYP


Very nice post mate and potentially I agree with you but bottom line, proof is in the pudding. I actually think a 7th place finish in this league would be a greater achievement than third back in the day so let’s keep our fingers crossed. If zaha stays and stays fit then who knows what we could do this season with this squad. The big difference between now and back then is squad depth, take one of any 4 or 5 (mile, Sakho or Tomkins, wilf spring straight to mind, hopefully Meyer is hes the play we hope he is) players out our line up and it’ll have a big impact, let’s all say our prayers for a then staying fit! Think after being written off by most, benteke will have a big part to play this year.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 06 Aug 18 12.50am

That was a nice post. I agree. I think that 7th should be the height of our aspirations. Although I don’t disagree that this might also be a team of underachievers a la the team of the 80s.

 

pssguy Flag 06 Aug 18 1.11am

Wouldn't have thought our squad depth was all that back then. Likes of Pardew and Phil Barber were still around, weren't they? Puncheon, Riedewald or Williams might be our 25th player this season - with the other two missing out

If Zaha gets 25-30 goals he will be our first player sold to Real Madrid or Barcelona

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Aug 18 6.01am

Originally posted by pssguy

Wouldn't have thought our squad depth was all that back then. Likes of Pardew and Phil Barber were still around, weren't they? Puncheon, Riedewald or Williams might be our 25th player this season - with the other two missing out

If Zaha gets 25-30 goals he will be our first player sold to Real Madrid or Barcelona

I think your right about Zaha, but Real Madrid, Barcelona would be a bit less painful than Spurs Chelsea etc.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 06 Aug 18 6.31am

Like the post although I think expecting 20+ goals from Wilf is a big ask. I think 12+ from him and 12+ from Benteke is more realistic and desirable.

I actually think the team we have now is better thn the one in the 90's if it went head to head, although of course that was different times, game has moved on a lot since then. Out of the team of the 90's if I ould transplant 3 into our current team it would be Nige, Thomas and Wrighty.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Aug 18 6.53am

must admit this team is looking good on paper,If Meyer is not a problem child,then selhurst will be rocking with or without HF,
just a little unknown fact or maybe not, when there is a 9 in the year we have a season to remember-1969,1979,1989,1991 and stretching it abit 2016,2+0+1+6=9 fa cup final, so never know what 2019 brings

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 06 Aug 18 7.08am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

must admit this team is looking good on paper,If Meyer is not a problem child,then selhurst will be rocking with or without HF,
just a little unknown fact or maybe not, when there is a 9 in the year we have a season to remember-1969,1979,1989,1991 and stretching it abit 2016,2+0+1+6=9 fa cup final, so never know what 2019 brings

Don't want to shoot you down but you do realize that there is 9 in the year every year from 1900 to 1999?

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Aug 18 7.36am

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Don't want to shoot you down but you do realize that there is 9 in the year every year from 1900 to 1999?

of course i do, but dont want to remember the bad ones positive thinking and all that,but 69,79,89 was big big seasons and the way it was achieved,and during the 90s we had alot of good cup runs

 

Chubskip Flag 06 Aug 18 7.39am

I still think this current squad is weaker than the team in the 90"s. IMO I think we need a keeper and another CB of quality. Now our new keeper may prove me wrong but we still give goals away because we seem to switch off. The Ninja and Thorny were always at it at the back we need to keep clean sheets then top 7 could be achieved this season.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Aug 18 8.13am

Such difficult eras to compare. How would Wilf have coped with defenders just coming through the back of him, often two footed? Which of those players would have had the technique and stamina to play today at the highest level?

Wilf, Wright, Martyn, Sakho all have to start (although I'm not sure Martyn could pass). After that, it all gets very hazy for me.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

The Dolphin Flag 06 Aug 18 8.14am

I didn't want to start a new thread so will post here.
I think that our squad with the new additions will do very well this season - injuries and suspensions allowing.
with roy in charge and a full squad we would never have been in the trouble we were last season - injuries decimated us.
Whether this is as good as the 90's or the best since - maybe - but I agree with another poster about the Goalkeeper - we need better to be stronger - there will always be defensive doubts with Wayne regardless of his improvement last season and we know nothing abut the new one really - not yet anyway.
If we keep Wilf then I expect a very good year and it is then that we can compare.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Aug 18 8.46am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Such difficult eras to compare. How would Wilf have coped with defenders just coming through the back of him, often two footed? Which of those players would have had the technique and stamina to play today at the highest level?

Wilf, Wright, Martyn, Sakho all have to start (although I'm not sure Martyn could pass). After that, it all gets very hazy for me.

he was a winger before becoming a keeper,and why are people forgetting about sally, better than townsend on the wing and in goal Young would be a bigger presence than sakho,
but your right about players today could they ride tackles no, Mr thomas wasnt bad at crunching tackles,for me im old school this is meant to be a mans game sadly to many players roll around with the slightest touch.
But i believe that this squad this season does look exciting even with the 3 dodgy strikers


 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Aug 18 8.50am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I didn't want to start a new thread so will post here.
I think that our squad with the new additions will do very well this season - injuries and suspensions allowing.
with roy in charge and a full squad we would never have been in the trouble we were last season - injuries decimated us.
Whether this is as good as the 90's or the best since - maybe - but I agree with another poster about the Goalkeeper - we need better to be stronger - there will always be defensive doubts with Wayne regardless of his improvement last season and we know nothing abut the new one really - not yet anyway.
If we keep Wilf then I expect a very good year and it is then that we can compare.

Only saw the highlights of the friendly, but Guaita spilled the ball from a shot that he maybe should have held for their goal. He did however make a couple of excellent saves. If he is as good as the reports about him I think we are in safe hands this season (pun intended).

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 06 Aug 18 9.12am

I think we have to distinguish between "best" and most "successful".

I think standards have gone up across the board in football since the early 90s, and the Palace team that finished 3rd in the old first division would never achieve that feat now (if they could all be transported back to the age they were then).

I believe our current side is generally a stronger team, but, it is unlikely it will be more successful than the 1990-1991 side - unless we can finish runners-up in the Premier!

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 06 Aug 18 9.45am

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Don't want to shoot you down but you do realize that there is 9 in the year every year from 1900 to 1999?

Exactly what I was thinking. Using his logic he should have won the treble in 1999 ...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Aug 18 10.02am

Originally posted by Pete53

I think we have to distinguish between "best" and most "successful".

I think standards have gone up across the board in football since the early 90s, and the Palace team that finished 3rd in the old first division would never achieve that feat now (if they could all be transported back to the age they were then).

I believe our current side is generally a stronger team, but, it is unlikely it will be more successful than the 1990-1991 side - unless we can finish runners-up in the Premier!


Back then top clubs weren’t spending £80 million or the equivalent on the near world’s best so 3rd then might be 6th or 5th now because really you should finish above one of the big 6 for it to be more impressive.

 


COYP

YT Flag Oxford 06 Aug 18 10.04am

The measure of a team is how it performs rather than who is in it. I thought our 1973/74 team would be fantastic, but it was relegated from the old Division 2.

I’ll therefore reserve judgement until the current team has played a few meaningful games, but its potential is exciting.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Aug 18 10.06am

If all key players stay fit, I'll be confident of a top half finish. If Benteke hits 15+ goals (not that I would bet on this happening), we could maybe hit 7th. Hard to see us finishing above Arsenal, Chelsea, United, City, Spurs, Liverpool.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Aug 18 10.06am

Originally posted by KAOS

Exactly what I was thinking. Using his logic he should have won the treble in 1999 ...

whats logic got todo with it 29/39 3rd div south R/U
69,79,89 promoted so has i said good things happen when its got a 9 in the year,we got promoted 2012/13 season see adds up to 9 again,see whats logic got todo with it ,sorry im spending to much time doing nothing

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best team since early 90s?