You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Has Hennessey lifted his game?
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Has Hennessey lifted his game?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Mstrobez Flag 13 Aug 18 3.58pm

Originally posted by Painter

Luckily your opinion doesn’t matter, all the recent managers have had him as their first choice, they can’t all be wrong. Buying Guiata was to keep Hennessey on his toes and it has worked, since he was announced as arriving at the end of Jan he has been first class.
Trying to rubbish him, isn’t clever, he is the best we have.

Luckily I’m still entitled to it.

My point is that, he being the best we have isn’t encouraging. I’m going on 5 years of him playing for us and countless mistakes and poor goalkeeping. We’ve become better defensively, the idea Hennessey has done anything other than ordinary since then is bizarre. The credit should go to Roy and the whole of the defence.

It’s not like Hennessey hasn’t had the opportunity to prove his doubters wrong in the past. Anywhere else and he would certainly not be the number 1. Whilst you say managers have picked him, he was number 2 under Pulis. Pardew tried to replace him twice. And the only reason he played under Allardyce was because Mandanda already had one foot out the door.

Nothing against the guy personally, but I’m not gonna pretend he’s all of a sudden a good goalkeeper on the back of some performances where he didn’t have a howler.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 14 Aug 18 10.08am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Luckily I’m still entitled to it.

My point is that, he being the best we have isn’t encouraging. I’m going on 5 years of him playing for us and countless mistakes and poor goalkeeping. We’ve become better defensively, the idea Hennessey has done anything other than ordinary since then is bizarre. The credit should go to Roy and the whole of the defence.

It’s not like Hennessey hasn’t had the opportunity to prove his doubters wrong in the past. Anywhere else and he would certainly not be the number 1. Whilst you say managers have picked him, he was number 2 under Pulis. Pardew tried to replace him twice. And the only reason he played under Allardyce was because Mandanda already had one foot out the door.

Nothing against the guy personally, but I’m not gonna pretend he’s all of a sudden a good goalkeeper on the back of some performances where he didn’t have a howler.

Use the same imagination you use to pretend he is not good enough for this level when he has helped us stay here for five years. We have seen many 'quality' keepers relegated Pickford , Foster , Fabianski. We are still here , can he be that bad?
The same imagination for all the countless mistakes, some I may suggest are in your opinion which you are entitled to.

Pulis bought Hennessey as he could see we needed a new keeper . Speroni then went into the form of his life for the second half of that season so Pulis kept him in , good management. Much Like Roy is doing now with our keepers.

Pardew tried to replace him twice . Neither keeper made it , is it because they were not as good as Hennessey or is Hennessey not as bad as you pretend.

Sam Allardyce would have played Mandanda if he was better than Hennessey because Sam is a football man and plays his best available when can regardless of circumstance.

Of course you have nothing against him personally , you don't know him , but you certainly seem to have something against him playing for Palace and helping us stay in the top flight.

I suspect you cannot wait for his next mistake or perceived mistake, which will be damaging for Palace instead of just enjoying the form he is in and trying to prove the doubters wrong, which is helping Palace. Might be best to wait and see whether Guaita proves himself and comes through to become a top keeper which will be great for Palace.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 14 Aug 18 10.17am

That last point nails it. Our current keeper upping his game as he has one of Europe's unsung best snapping at his heels. Good times for the club.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Has Hennessey lifted his game?