This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo
I think all this pre and post match analysis from different ex players specially on Sky Rednapp, Souness on sky’s Super Sunday and We saw on Monday how Sala went down like a ton of brick with hardly any contact from Sakho. Referees have to be consistent and they are when it come to the top six clubs.
South London & Proud |
|
|
Originally posted by Jamesrichards8
That zaha booking was shocking. If that’s how soft the premier league has become im done with it. Too much money in the game and the refs are far too worried about protecting ‘assets’. And yet capoue gets away with murder. The decisions of referees are inconsistent but the standard of refereeing is consistently crap. No wonder we had no refs in the World Cup. Mark Clattenburg was chosen but he forfeited his place when he departed for Saudi Arabia. Mark was included in the list who were selected for preparation for the World Cup, and all those referees underwent a training programme. At the time Clattenburg left for Saudi Arabia, there were actually no competitions left to train the referees, so there was no opportunity to replace him with another English referee. So it was all about circumstances and timing rather than about the standard of our referees.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Mark Clattenburg was chosen but he forfeited his place when he departed for Saudi Arabia. Mark was included in the list who were selected for preparation for the World Cup, and all those referees underwent a training programme. At the time Clattenburg left for Saudi Arabia, there were actually no competitions left to train the referees, so there was no opportunity to replace him with another English referee. So it was all about circumstances and timing rather than about the standard of our referees. Even you must admit, Willo, that the standard of refereeing in the World Cup was far, far higher than the incompetence, guesswork, politicking and sheer unbridled bias that we see week in week out in the Premier League.
============ |
|
|
Well VAR worked fairly well for one which was a difference .
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
With the greatest of respect, I have made by views on the standard of refereeing in England patently clear and I have nothing to add.I'm not going to get drawn into any further debate on this matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I do agree with you. The only thing I can think about Capoue's challenge is that from the ref's angle he may have not seen the raking of the calf, only a trip. Where is VAR when you need it, thought Graham Souness was brilliant, he looked visibly upset at the assault. Wilf's booking was caused by the reaction of the Watford players (why did Palace players not react in the same way). Jaanmats challenge on PVA warranted a booking and his attempt to get Wilf sent off was disgraceful (thought the ref handled that well). Watford really are a scummy club, read their forum about Capoues tackle on Wilf. Shows how bad the tackle was when Graeme Souness is upset by it as he had some shockers back in the day. There’s some on YouTube that are unbelievable. Agree with everything you said, the ref was appalling. The Salah decision last week was at least debatable but this was the most blatant red card you’ll see. It was as bad as Mane not getting a second yellow last year. I do feel sorry for refs as the game is so quick and players have really gotten good at cheating. But that was an easy and obvious decision. Terrible refereeing. Watford are a dirty and classless team. Shame because they looked
|
|
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
ref was a major see you next tues. i never want to see that tw...t wearing a referees shirt again. Made Clattenburg look fair and competent.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With the greatest of respect, I have made by views on the standard of refereeing in England patently clear and I have nothing to add.I'm not going to get drawn into any further debate on this matter. Because even you cant defend Sundays referee???
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Because even you cant defend Sundays referee??? What part of "I have nothing to add. I'm not going to get drawn into any further debate on this matter" is it that you have difficulty in understanding
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
What part of "I have nothing to add. I'm not going to get drawn into any further debate on this matter" is it that you have difficulty in understanding just stated a fact, ??? were in error
|
|
|
Originally posted by Superhorns3
As a general point when decisions have been made we've heard pundits saying the ref ruined the game by as you say giving one early on but clearly in this case we should have gone down to 10. Maybe another example of why refs should come out and explain the decisions made ?
had the ref not given him a yellow then we would be seeing him get few games ban. The biggest issue is the rules the game has changed and its either a contact sport or not because just look at the chelsea penalty yesterday that was a very good tackle yet because theirs contact after he has first touched the ball it's deemed a foul what is that about this sort of thing has destroyed football same with how you flick a player he does down holding his head.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
had the ref not given him a yellow then we would be seeing him get few games ban. The biggest issue is the rules the game has changed and its either a contact sport or not because just look at the chelsea penalty yesterday that was a very good tackle yet because theirs contact after he has first touched the ball it's deemed a foul what is that about this sort of thing has destroyed football same with how you flick a player he does down holding his head. Schar definitely makes contact with the ball but he wraps his legs around Alonso in a scissor action.In pre-season meetings with the players and clubs, they were informed that just because a player makes contact with the ball, it doesn't mean that no foul can be awarded against the player making the tackle. But I suspect we will all see many instances of players in similar circumstances bellowing out "Ref - I got the ball" !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Schar definitely makes contact with the ball but he wraps his legs around Alonso in a scissor action.In pre-season meetings with the players and clubs, they were informed that just because a player makes contact with the ball, it doesn't mean that no foul can be awarded against the player making the tackle. But I suspect we will all see many instances of players in similar circumstances bellowing out "Ref - I got the ball" ! Surely ut should bd if he gets the ball first but then follows through dangerously it should be a foul (like vardys sending off). Schars follow through was hardly dangerous and IMO shouldn't havd been a penalty. It's basically banning the sliding tackle, because it's almost impossible to slide in, win the ball, and not touch the player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Surely ut should bd if he gets the ball first but then follows through dangerously it should be a foul (like vardys sending off). Schars follow through was hardly dangerous and IMO shouldn't havd been a penalty. It's basically banning the sliding tackle, because it's almost impossible to slide in, win the ball, and not touch the player. It was a penalty based on the current dictum that if a player wins the ball yet wraps his legs around the opponent in a scissor action and brings him down this is adjudged to be a foul.Bit different in the old days !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It was a penalty based on the current dictum that if a player wins the ball yet wraps his legs around the opponent in a scissor action and brings him down this is adjudged to be a foul.Bit different in the old days ! Can you show me where it says that on the fa rules, because try as I might I can't see anything saying that. Or are the refs just making up their own rules now.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.