You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Sep 18 11.03am

Originally posted by jackosperoni

I think that's right, Pete.

The Palace players seem to depend too much on Wilf, and Roy's tetchiness at the press conference on Friday seems to suggest that he feels that way too.

One bad tackle and heaven forfend Wilf could be out for the season
. Roy has to develop a plan B and a different mindset in the players. It would also help if he picked players like Meyer who can hold onto the ball and use it creatively.

The first half yesterday was defend deep and hit and hope.

Remember game against Huddersfield last season - what do you think their plan will be next game.....

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 02 Sep 18 11.10am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Remember game against Huddersfield last season - what do you think their plan will be next game.....

Well he might not be fit for the game anyway - a mixed blessing. I seem to recall they also had a go at him in the away game as well.

 

Spitfire Flag Biggin Hill 02 Sep 18 11.12am

In hindsight might it have have been better to rate Wilf as doubtful at the press conference.

The news at 2 o'clock deflated everyone the same way as Roy was at the press conference.

But giving everyone 24 hours to let the news sink in we may have got over the disappointment and had time to rally everyone into a more underdog / togetherness mentality.

As it was it seems everyone was deflated form the first kick.

 

george1212 Flag london 02 Sep 18 11.30am

Completely agreed - we need to begin to win without Wilf.

The problem is, you take out Wilf, and who do we have that can actually win us games, score, be a danger, create assists?

We literally are a one-man team.

I think we miss Cabaye much more then we realise.

It's time for Ayew to start, and then Bentecke to be dropped. I'm not sure Sorloth will ever come good - I've been watching Palace long enough to see a punt on a player workout, and Sorloth looks miles away right now. That said, never say never and I hope to be proved wrong.

What a disappointing start to the season after a convincing first game. A few more losses and we'll all be in panic mode. Roy needs to make some bold choices - drop Bentecke, and start Meyer/Kouyate/Ayew.

We need 1 other player who provides an outlet. Looking back, Bolassie used to fill that role. He would terrorise fullbacks and had that ability to get the crowd excted - even though he wasn't the same calibre as Wilf, but that gave us so much more going forward having both of them in the team.

I'm sorry but Townsend doesn't really cut the mustard. He's a good crosser of the ball, but most of the time he seems to be falling a bit short. Compare him to a Walcott type player who will score every other week. A Walcott/Richarlison level player is what we need. We don't have that. We rely on ONE player for everything and the team is bog-standard outside of that.

We just don't have enough talent. The three new players look like they do have talent + AWB. But the rest of the team look a bit slow and heavy on the touch to be honest.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 02 Sep 18 12.10pm

As somebody mentioned in the matchday thread at halftime without Wilf one possibility is to put AWB on the wing and Ward behind. He seems one of the only players willing/able to move forward. Meyer should of also started in the midfield as nothing was coming through there as well. The starting eleven looked like we were playing Liverpool not Southampton and consequently we conceded about 70% possession at the start and only looked lively in the final 20 mins or so due to late subs, another issue in the game. By the way WH prevented an avalanche, even Luka fancied one !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Johng Flag 02 Sep 18 12.47pm

Originally posted by portlandeagle4

With every miss, Benteke is digging himself a bigger and bigger hole of low confidence to get out of. Macca and AWB were solid, as was Hennessey, but Schlupp and Ayew didn't do enough. I think we should line up like this v Huddersfield

Hennessey
AWB Tomkins(if he's back) Sakho Souare
Meyer Kouyate Macca PVA
Zaha Townsend

This with the possible exception of Soare. Anybody know how he has been performing? Anything like his pre-accident form?

 

jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 02 Sep 18 1.09pm

I think AWB on the wing with Ward behind him is a very good idea. He started as a winger after all. It must be right too, as my wife made the suggestion at half-time yesterday!!!!

Don't forget too, that we played our first season back in the Prem without Wilf. I think some players need to step up to the plate, and make a name for themselves.

We need to find a bit of the spirit we had with Damo, Jedi and the like.

 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

The Dolphin Flag 02 Sep 18 3.19pm

Townsend and Schlupp should be consigned to the bench along with Benteke
Start Ayew, Kouyate and Meyer.
PVA is suffering having Schlupp playing badly in front of him and Luka needs some creative help.
Leave Wilf out oop north - we should still get a result.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 02 Sep 18 4.24pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Townsend and Schlupp should be consigned to the bench along with Benteke
Start Ayew, Kouyate and Meyer.
PVA is suffering having Schlupp playing badly in front of him and Luka needs some creative help.
Leave Wilf out oop north - we should still get a result.

Why do you want to leave Townsend out, he had one bad game playing his 3rd game in a week, you have to take into account that his game is all energy.

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 02 Sep 18 4.28pm

I thought Ayew was also pretty bad yesterday, so he's not the answer.

I don't think the Luksa / McArthur partnership is working either. Although they're both quite decent players, we need something else.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 02 Sep 18 4.37pm

Originally posted by Dixie Eagle

I thought Ayew was also pretty bad yesterday, so he's not the answer.

I don't think the Luksa / McArthur partnership is working either. Although they're both quite decent players, we need something else.

Yea, Ayew doesn't look like the player we all hoped he would be,lets hope he can improve,

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Sep 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Yea, Ayew doesn't look like the player we all hoped he would be,lets hope he can improve,

FFS it's his first game since the end of last season. But ok let's write him off already.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 02 Sep 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by Dixie Eagle

I thought Ayew was also pretty bad yesterday, so he's not the answer.

I don't think the Luksa / McArthur partnership is working either. Although they're both quite decent players, we need something else.

I thought Ayew started quite well. He looks to have good control and is able to hold the ball. He did tail off later but come on, give him a chance before writing him off.

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Sep 18 8.28pm

I don't rate Townsend and never have.
He is one dimensional, predictable, rarely scores and like Puncheon before him pretends to be interested in tackling back but rarely does so.
I am not saying he hasn't had some good games for us - he has - but right now he is not good and that is not just Saturday's game - he was the same at Watford as well.
Lucky for him that he has Wan B behind him to clear up his constant mess.
To think that Roy used to pick him for England over Wilf and that is really now why Wilf is not an England player!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Sep 18 7.26am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I don't rate Townsend and never have.
He is one dimensional, predictable, rarely scores and like Puncheon before him pretends to be interested in tackling back but rarely does so.
I am not saying he hasn't had some good games for us - he has - but right now he is not good and that is not just Saturday's game - he was the same at Watford as well.
Lucky for him that he has Wan B behind him to clear up his constant mess.
To think that Roy used to pick him for England over Wilf and that is really now why Wilf is not an England player!

Seconded.

 

PatrickA Flag London 03 Sep 18 7.35am

I heard an interview with Townsend’s dad where he said that Andros had injuries which took the edge off his pace which resulted in him having to adapt his game.
It is evident that he often turns back on himself and doesn’t seem able to get away from defenders as when he first burst on the scene.
Nobody can question his work rate but is he effective?
His goals are few and far between and he averages about 2 or 3 crosses in a game.
The Southampton right back alone must have hit eight crosses on Saturday.
There is argument that playing the narrow 4-4-2 system which Roy favours either Mcarthur or Meyer could have more influence and effect the game more in the right side midfield position.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 03 Sep 18 7.55am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I heard an interview with Townsend’s dad where he said that Andros had injuries which took the edge off his pace which resulted in him having to adapt his game.
It is evident that he often turns back on himself and doesn’t seem able to get away from defenders as when he first burst on the scene.
Nobody can question his work rate but is he effective?
His goals are few and far between and he averages about 2 or 3 crosses in a game.
The Southampton right back alone must have hit eight crosses on Saturday.
There is argument that playing the narrow 4-4-2 system which Roy favours either Mcarthur or Meyer could have more influence and effect the game more in the right side midfield position.

The same could be said for the Liverpool & Watford games - if Schlupp is nowhere near the wing then any right back is gonna have a shed load of space to work with. I think him playing so narrow is curtailing PVA's game too as he's not really got any protection should he take off on one of his runs.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 03 Sep 18 9.34am

Having had a few days now to calm down, sit and think about the game, there are quite a few errors and observations I personally spotted on Saturday which I don't believe some have been mentioned.

1st Goal : Sakho does well to make sure his man doesn't win the ball in the 50/50 and has the trust that Kelly will be sweeping him. Kelly loses all focus and ball watches and allows the ball to bounce and come across him and Ings to get inside him and finish. Without Tomkins we look so fragile at the back and lack a real leader. Ings and Long should not be bullying Sakho and Kelly.

Goal Kicks : Southampton's strikers allowed Kelly to remain free and come to collect the ball short from Hennessey. When Kelly received the ball he was immediately closed down and is forced to go long as the midfielders are all marked tight. In doing so, Kelly is playing the ball 60 yards up to Benteke who flicks it on to their centre backs. We are not releasing any off pressure of the back 4 by playing this way and allowing our defence to push up as unit. If Hennessey goes long to Benteke, the back 4 start 20 yards higher and this pushes the midfield on. We either play short and stick to it and need good movement from forward players, or we go direct with Hennessey's kicking (which is a strong point of his)

Team Shape : 442 and the line to start the game with no Zaha is one I did agree with and place no blame with Roy starting the game, apart from perhaps Meyer for Schlupp and pushing McArthur wide. After the first half hour it became clear we had no foot in the game and were overrun in midfield throughout. The obvious half time sub was to bring Ayew off for Meyer and go 451 with full back pushing on to put crosses into Benteke. Not until about 75 mins did we really get right round the back of them and pick a cross, which is Benteke's strong point. Playing 2 very attacking full backs meant without Zaha our plan B should have been go wide and put crosses in the box. I can't help but think Southampton's 2 worst players were there centre backs, who had a reasonably comfortable day in the end. Roy got it wrong and failed to change it when every supporter in the ground could see it. Frustrating to see. I would back that his decision to remove Townsend for Kouyate paid off and going 352, although I was at first very angry with the sub of our only winger.

Benteke : I feel bad for the guy today, which is different to my opinion on Saturday at 5pm. He's getting in the right places and doing some of the right things but nothing will drop for him. His chance from 6 yards was almost criminal to miss but McCarthy made a good instinctive save and had he came out in a 'star' shape to save it would have gone in. I wouldn't really know what to do if I was Roy. Sorloth is so clearly not the answer. Zaha and Townsend upfront like last season is his best bet. This compliments playing out from the back. *See Sakho pass to Zaha for his goal against Chelsea last year.

One final point, to the middle aged bald bloke in Block V of the Arthur, stop shouting WOY! and find something positive to say. You and a few of the guys sitting with you shouted nothing but negativity and borderline racist comments throughout the game towards Ayew, Benteke and Schlupp. I'm new to the seat this season, but I'll be keeping an eye at future home games. So disappointing in 2018.

Huddersfield away cannot come quick enough...

Edited by HerneBayPalace (03 Sep 2018 9.34am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Sep 18 9.43am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I heard an interview with Townsend’s dad where he said that Andros had injuries which took the edge off his pace which resulted in him having to adapt his game.
It is evident that he often turns back on himself and doesn’t seem able to get away from defenders as when he first burst on the scene.
Nobody can question his work rate but is he effective?
His goals are few and far between and he averages about 2 or 3 crosses in a game.
The Southampton right back alone must have hit eight crosses on Saturday.
There is argument that playing the narrow 4-4-2 system which Roy favours either Mcarthur or Meyer could have more influence and effect the game more in the right side midfield position.

From my humble perspective, Townsend is not the player of a few years ago and the same can be said of Benteke.And these are two of our regulars in the side !

Regards,Townsend I recall the player of old who was pacy, positive,showed a real desire to get on the ball and put crosses in.A player who would cut in from the right on to his stronger left-foot and have shots at goal but also a player who could beat opponents on the outside and cross with his right foot.He was also not shy of shooting with his right foot from outside the box and generally was an attacking threat.Sadly he isn't the player of old and having to adapt his game as his father mentioned has reduced his overall effectiveness.

Edited by Willo (03 Sep 2018 9.45am)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 03 Sep 18 9.57am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

Having had a few days now to calm down, sit and think about the game, there are quite a few errors and observations I personally spotted on Saturday which I don't believe some have been mentioned.

1st Goal : Sakho does well to make sure his man doesn't win the ball in the 50/50 and has the trust that Kelly will be sweeping him. Kelly loses all focus and ball watches and allows the ball to bounce and come across him and Ings to get inside him and finish. Without Tomkins we look so fragile at the back and lack a real leader. Ings and Long should not be bullying Sakho and Kelly.

Goal Kicks : Southampton's strikers allowed Kelly to remain free and come to collect the ball short from Hennessey. When Kelly received the ball he was immediately closed down and is forced to go long as the midfielders are all marked tight. In doing so, Kelly is playing the ball 60 yards up to Benteke who flicks it on to their centre backs. We are not releasing any off pressure of the back 4 by playing this way and allowing our defence to push up as unit. If Hennessey goes long to Benteke, the back 4 start 20 yards higher and this pushes the midfield on. We either play short and stick to it and need good movement from forward players, or we go direct with Hennessey's kicking (which is a strong point of his)

Team Shape : 442 and the line to start the game with no Zaha is one I did agree with and place no blame with Roy starting the game, apart from perhaps Meyer for Schlupp and pushing McArthur wide. After the first half hour it became clear we had no foot in the game and were overrun in midfield throughout. The obvious half time sub was to bring Ayew off for Meyer and go 451 with full back pushing on to put crosses into Benteke. Not until about 75 mins did we really get right round the back of them and pick a cross, which is Benteke's strong point. Playing 2 very attacking full backs meant without Zaha our plan B should have been go wide and put crosses in the box. I can't help but think Southampton's 2 worst players were there centre backs, who had a reasonably comfortable day in the end. Roy got it wrong and failed to change it when every supporter in the ground could see it. Frustrating to see. I would back that his decision to remove Townsend for Kouyate paid off and going 352, although I was at first very angry with the sub of our only winger.

Benteke : I feel bad for the guy today, which is different to my opinion on Saturday at 5pm. He's getting in the right places and doing some of the right things but nothing will drop for him. His chance from 6 yards was almost criminal to miss but McCarthy made a good instinctive save and had he came out in a 'star' shape to save it would have gone in. I wouldn't really know what to do if I was Roy. Sorloth is so clearly not the answer. Zaha and Townsend upfront like last season is his best bet. This compliments playing out from the back. *See Sakho pass to Zaha for his goal against Chelsea last year.

One final point, to the middle aged bald bloke in Block V of the Arthur, stop shouting WOY! and find something positive to say. You and a few of the guys sitting with you shouted nothing but negativity and borderline racist comments throughout the game towards Ayew, Benteke and Schlupp. I'm new to the seat this season, but I'll be keeping an eye at future home games. So disappointing in 2018.

Huddersfield away cannot come quick enough...

Edited by HerneBayPalace (03 Sep 2018 9.34am)

Excellent post Sir.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game