You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and substitutes


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Oct 18 10.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Poor Hodgson went through thr wringer last season and performed a miracle in keeping us up.

What many saw as his strengths last season IE rigid tactical discipline and organisation is now seen as a weakness.

Reading a number of the posts, in many eyes he has gone from hero to zero.

There’s no denying Roy did a great job last season keeping us up but that was last season. Pardew did a great job at first but look what happened with him. Would you want him back?

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 22 Oct 18 6.23am

Originally posted by herefordeagle

Absolutely spot on. Whilst goalless I commented on our supporter group page that they were getting the better of us and that YET AGAIN there was no reaction from Hodgson. Everton make the changes which make all the difference and we go two down at which point Roy thinks it's the right time to make a change. Roy worked wonders last year but with the squad we have this season has been unacceptable and time and time again it has been down to a lack of freshening things up or changing the game plan before it's too late. Today was the final straw for me. With the squad that we have another manager could do much much better

Who is on the bench who could come on and make a difference?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Oct 18 6.30am

Originally posted by Petereagle

Who is on the bench who could come on and make a difference?

Kaikai for townsend and Reidewald for macarthur.bit more pace up front and a more defensive midfielder.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 22 Oct 18 7.01am

We never took our chances which is our biggest problem but when they brought on more attackers Roy should’ve responded by bringing on Kelly and Riedewald to see the game out. His dislike of changing the team has cost us many points at the end of games.

They say you can’t teach an old dog new tricks and that looks so true in Roy’s case !

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Oct 18 7.07am

Originally posted by baldeagle73

The subs aren't good enough and the first team isn't good enough

Roy has pretty much said the same in other words along the lines of 'our subs have to improve the first 11 of or there's no point in changing things'. I don't fully agree with that as regardless of who is better on paper things need changing for other reasons ie fitness, tactics etc

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 22 Oct 18 7.43am

Sorry but this thread Roy and substitutes would probably not have been raised if luka had put penalty away and Tompkins guilt edged header gone in .Lukas pen worse since bentekes.One up maybe become a tad more defensive and 3 points We miss and it's Roy's fault.Do feel some weeks needs to make changes but yesterday not one of them

 

YoDougie Flag London 22 Oct 18 8.49am

I don't agree at all that our substitutes aren't good enough to the extreme that there isn't even any point bringing them on.

We haven't seen KaiKai properly, so hard to make a judgement on him.

Reidewald has had some good games for Palace - notably the game against Man City last Christmas. He certainly is capable of playing if needed.

We had no striker on the pitch - surely Wickham was fit enough to play longer than 1 minute. Otherwise why was he on the bench yet if not?

Ayew has been starting recently so I don't believe Hodsgon now deems him not good enough to come off of the bench.

It's confusing the minimal substitutes used - especially when we are all crying out asking him to make them.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Oct 18 9.08am

Originally posted by n wales eagles

Sorry but this thread Roy and substitutes would probably not have been raised if luka had put penalty away and Tompkins guilt edged header gone in .Lukas pen worse since bentekes.One up maybe become a tad more defensive and 3 points We miss and it's Roy's fault.Do feel some weeks needs to make changes but yesterday not one of them

Not really as it's been raised plenty of times before on here and in non-internet conversations. Everton used subs and won the game.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 9.10am

Originally posted by n wales eagles

Sorry but this thread Roy and substitutes would probably not have been raised if luka had put penalty away and Tompkins guilt edged header gone in .Lukas pen worse since bentekes.One up maybe become a tad more defensive and 3 points We miss and it's Roy's fault.Do feel some weeks needs to make changes but yesterday not one of them

I understand your thinking on this matter and can appreciate why Hodgson never made earlier substitutions.

At the end of the day any substitutions would not have prevented Sakho ball-watching and allowing Calvert-Lewin a free header for that vital opening goal.

All Hodgson's tactical planning and work carried out in training was working to a 'T', we were heading for a draw which would have been a creditable result so clearly he never felt the need to make changes as the players on the field had carried out what was asked of them.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2018 9.11am)

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 22 Oct 18 10.01am

Though I'm certainly not one of those calling for Roy's head, I feel that criticism for him over his attitude to substitutions is entirely fair.

I can't have been the only one to make a joke about us conceding a late goal long before it happened, the script became grimly predictable once it was clear that no subs were forthcoming.

Whether or not you subscribe to the ludicrous assertion that we had no options on the bench, consider for a minute that we will inevitably have injuries this season and many of these players be need to play a part. Imagine the psychological and physical affect that the manager repeatedly showing that he has no faith in them must be doing.

We'll have absolutely no right to criticise the likes of Riedewald etc when they do finally get a game and are miles from match sharpness.

The gameplan yesterday was correct and we were the better team for large swathes of the game but if it was so blindingly obvious to thousands of supporters what was going to happen and what we needed to do, it does concern me that the man in charge couldn't see it. It was a real missed opportunity and after our next four games, there is now a very strong chance we'll find ourselves in the bottom three.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Oct 18 10.14am

Originally posted by Willo

I understand your thinking on this matter and can appreciate why Hodgson never made earlier substitutions.

At the end of the day any substitutions would not have prevented Sakho ball-watching and allowing Calvert-Lewin a free header for that vital opening goal.

All Hodgson's tactical planning and work carried out in training was working to a 'T', we were heading for a draw which would have been a creditable result so clearly he never felt the need to make changes as the players on the field had carried out what was asked of them.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2018 9.11am)

Sakho ball watching might not have happened if their midfield had someone to chase like a pair of fresh legs.
No matter if they are not good enough
10mins to go and a point in the bag if two or even three subs.

 

herefordeagle Flag Hereford 22 Oct 18 10.21am

Many have mentioned that our bench didn't possess the quality that Everton had on theirs. Whilst this is true the above post has it spot on, it's not just about the quality it's about getting fresh legs on in place of players who have been running their arses off for the previous 60-70 minutes which can make a difference

 


"It's ok postman , he'll lick you to death" "That isn't really that comforting , I still end up dead !!"

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 18 10.22am

Originally posted by Willo

I understand your thinking on this matter and can appreciate why Hodgson never made earlier substitutions.

At the end of the day any substitutions would not have prevented Sakho ball-watching and allowing Calvert-Lewin a free header for that vital opening goal.

All Hodgson's tactical planning and work carried out in training was working to a 'T', we were heading for a draw which would have been a creditable result so clearly he never felt the need to make changes as the players on the field had carried out what was asked of them.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2018 9.11am)

Yes it’s this kind of analysis that stops me from pointing the finger at Roy, although he as well as the players needs to up his game and some games we should be seeing earlier subs, not never or until 10 minutes or less. We thought he wasn’t making subs to begin with last season because the bench was so bad but it turns out its because if those on the bench aren’t as good as those on the pitch then they don’t go on (he’s said this), which is how to game manage teenage Sunday football because at this level fitness, tactics and just a change up, asking or answering new questions to the opposition is a big factor with these fine margins.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 10.40am

Originally posted by herefordeagle

Many have mentioned that our bench didn't possess the quality that Everton had on theirs. Whilst this is true the above post has it spot on, it's not just about the quality it's about getting fresh legs on in place of players who have been running their arses off for the previous 60-70 minutes which can make a difference

I understand where you are coming and your argument is valid.

However if Hodgson had introduced fresh legs and we still went on to lose the game there might of been cries of woe saying that we were doing perfectly well with the starting 11 and heading for a creditable draw so why did Hodgson feel the need to change things ?

It seems with Hodgson he has a 'Plan A' which he has worked on with his players in great detail and unless there are injuries, he will stick with it unless we are behind or he is happy to take the point at an away game.His teams are all about shape,organisation and discipline and he doesn't appear to be one to take risks which could scupper a good result.Maybe a lack of options influences his thinking.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Oct 18 11.18am

Originally posted by Willo

I understand where you are coming and your argument is valid.

However if Hodgson had introduced fresh legs and we still went on to lose the game there might of been cries of woe saying that we were doing perfectly well with the starting 11 and heading for a creditable draw so why did Hodgson feel the need to change things ?

It seems with Hodgson he has a 'Plan A' which he has worked on with his players in great detail and unless there are injuries, he will stick with it unless we are behind or he is happy to take the point at an away game.His teams are all about shape,organisation and discipline and he doesn't appear to be one to take risks which could scupper a good result.Maybe a lack of options influences his thinking.

I really don't think you'd get this sentiment from many people. It's widely accepted that 90-minutes of football isn't a game of 11 players any more and hasn't been for some time.

You only have to look at what Everton did. They introduced players that on paper may not be better than what was already on the pitch but their freshness and the change of focus it gave their team produced two goals and a win. They had a plan B, or their Plan A consisted of more than 11 players.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 22 Oct 18 11.30am

My concern used to be we had a paper thin squad with little or no depth. This year that is not the case.

Roy appears to favour a consistent team. The shirt is yours to lose. Again fair enough, but that now seems almost to extend to on a match day we have 11 and the rest. A question almost of tactics. Here is my 11 and this is how I want them to play. This is v old fashioned. Modern sports will look at the bench and say this is my team of (say) 16 and this is how I will deploy them. You note in training that a player switched off around the hour mark so you pick a sub to drop in at that stage, houses a forward gets tired around 70 mind and have a trained up replacement on the bench.

We set up tactically with a first 11 and that seems to be it. We seem to only bring on subs if we have to and they seem to sometimes struggle to fit it.

An example. Was delighted to see Connor back on the bench. He looked fit and hungry in the Dulwich friendly, but even though we needed goals we left it too late (and the whole team seemed set up to play without a big man up front.) So tactically we focused on the 11 not 16.

Our inflexibility could be our undoing.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 11.31am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I really don't think you'd get this sentiment from many people. It's widely accepted that 90-minutes of football isn't a game of 11 players any more and hasn't been for some time.

You only have to look at what Everton did. They introduced players that on paper may not be better than what was already on the pitch but their freshness and the change of focus it gave their team produced two goals and a win. They had a plan B, or their Plan A consisted of more than 11 players.

To be able to introduce Calvert-Lewin,Tosun and Lookman from the bench just highlights the difference in the respective strengths of our squads.And being at home they were really looking to win this game hence turned to all their attacking options whereas I get the feeling we were happy to get a point.

Hodgson being the experienced manager that he is, knows only too well that football is more than just the starting 11, but maybe what he sees as a lack of alternatives affects his thinking in games.At Everton his plan was working, we were heading for a good draw and he clearly trusted in the starting 11 to see out the game as they carried out his instructions to the letter and gave 110% for the cause.I cannot read Hodgson's mind but maybe my assessment of his thinking is not far from the actualite.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Oct 18 11.57am

Originally posted by Willo

To be able to introduce Calvert-Lewin,Tosun and Lookman from the bench just highlights the difference in the respective strengths of our squads.And being at home they were really looking to win this game hence turned to all their attacking options whereas I get the feeling we were happy to get a point.

Hodgson being the experienced manager that he is, knows only too well that football is more than just the starting 11, but maybe what he sees as a lack of alternatives affects his thinking in games.At Everton his plan was working, we were heading for a good draw and he clearly trusted in the starting 11 to see out the game as they carried out his instructions to the letter and gave 110% for the cause.I cannot read Hodgson's mind but maybe my assessment of his thinking is not far from the actualite.

I think you're probably right about Roy's thinking and his methods, but games change massively in the last 10 minutes - we know that more than most. He would have known that Everton would likely change things to try and win the game. It's naive to think our starting 11 would be ale to cope with that. Regardless of how good they are - fresh legs against legs that have been running for 80-minutes isn't a good match-up.

Still, this seems to be Roy's way - he's not going to get 'experimental' at his age. Whether it's because he thinks it's the best approach (I don't) or belligerence around the squad not being good enough aimed at the owners, it's costing us points and will cost us in injuries/fatigue when players are run into the ground. We saw at the end of last season that some players were dead on their feet because they were knackered from too many minutes.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Oct 18 12.00pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

My concern used to be we had a paper thin squad with little or no depth. This year that is not the case.

Roy appears to favour a consistent team. The shirt is yours to lose. Again fair enough, but that now seems almost to extend to on a match day we have 11 and the rest. A question almost of tactics. Here is my 11 and this is how I want them to play. This is v old fashioned. Modern sports will look at the bench and say this is my team of (say) 16 and this is how I will deploy them. You note in training that a player switched off around the hour mark so you pick a sub to drop in at that stage, houses a forward gets tired around 70 mind and have a trained up replacement on the bench.

We set up tactically with a first 11 and that seems to be it. We seem to only bring on subs if we have to and they seem to sometimes struggle to fit it.

An example. Was delighted to see Connor back on the bench. He looked fit and hungry in the Dulwich friendly, but even though we needed goals we left it too late (and the whole team seemed set up to play without a big man up front.) So tactically we focused on the 11 not 16.

Our inflexibility could be our undoing.

I agree with everything that you've said there. No doubt Roy's management style has got him a lot of success over the years, but this is a big flaw in his approach in my eyes.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 Oct 18 12.14pm

Perhaps someone on here could explain the point of Ray Lewington??

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes