You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Season review so far...
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Season review so far...


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
PatrickA Flag London 09 Dec 18 4.24am

I have been alarmed this season by the drop in quality of performance of both the team and individuals.
At the end of last season we looked an efficient compact team that defended and attacked as a unit.
We looked in control of games.
This season there has been a marked deterioration in performance of individuals and the team.
The only players who have played as well this season ( other than for the last two games) are Hennessy, AWB and Tomkins.
What has changed?
Yes we’ve lost Cabaye and RLC but could this have such a dramatic effect?
The only game where we’ve defended and attacked in a similar way to last season is Burnley at home which now looks to more representative of Burnley’s poor form.
We do not look any sort of threat going forward and don’t look likely to keep a clean sheet.
Roy only seems to be prepared to use around 15 of the squad and of these he obviously doesn’t trust Sorloth and Ayew.
The optimists(or dreamers) point to the return of Benteke and Wickham and this should help but there is no guarantee this will lead to a marked improvement.
I don’t see us bringing in more than one or two in January and don’t see Roy using a dramatically different approach.
The catalyst for change has to be quality new players, new manager, or a big step up in performance from the existing players.
At the moment the latter looks the most feasible option.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 09 Dec 18 1.35pm

We have scored 5 goals in the last three games and hit the wood work at least twice. So one could argue it is poor defending that has cost us not our inability to score.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 09 Dec 18 2.32pm

We just haven't got going this season. We seem to always be a team of half seasons. Even under Pards when we were flying around this time we nearly got relegated with a shocking second half. Obviously I'm hoping that this season is the same and we push on in Jan. Possibly our stay in this league might be a permanent squeeze to remain in it as teams around us progress, especially financially. Perhaps expectations are too high and the realism around us not being seen.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Dec 18 6.59pm

I think the season so far can pretty much be summed up with one word.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Dec 18 7.03pm

The season so far has been an incomplete team limping through to January. We've put in some good performances here and there but this is pretty much the points total you'd expect from a team without a striker and very thin creative options.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 7.25pm

We started the season having only spent £10 Mill in pre-season and in my estimation with a worse squad than last season.We had Benteke whose dearth of goals and general performances have been well documented and as such we have been lacking in the striking department.I am not at all surprised that we are in our current position - I wasn't expecting a great deal better !

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 7.52pm

Totally underachieved. Given where we finished last year - 11th, we should have kicked on with ambition and investment by the board to equal or better this position. Why we didn't buy a centre forward defies understanding and logic!

Losing against the 10 men of Brighton is despicable, no excuses whatsoever..... players should have had their pay docked for this.

West Ham defeat with us 1-0 up needs an explanation from the players as there is clearly a problem. Was the weather too cold??

Probably in truth its didums stuff but whatever the reason you as players need to deal with it as professionals who at the present are doing completely f*** all to address it. Just think of the many supporters who pay to travel and the gate money to watch you under perform while still pulling your incredible wages
You are seriously under performing!!!

SP get a grip and start spending some money to invest in this club as you should have done in the Summer. A '0' hygiene rating in the players canteen is disgraceful. Also, start paying your suppliers on time, many of whom are small local suppliers. You 'talk a good game' but just don't back it up!!


 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 8.08pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Totally underachieved. Given where we finished last year - 11th, we should have kicked on with ambition and investment by the board to equal or better this position. Why we didn't buy a centre forward defies understanding and logic!

Losing against the 10 men of Brighton is despicable, no excuses whatsoever..... players should have had their pay docked for this.

West Ham defeat with us 1-0 up needs an explanation from the players as there is clearly a problem. Was the weather too cold??

Probably in truth its didums stuff but whatever the reason you as players need to deal with it as professionals who at the present are doing completely f*** all to address it. Just think of the many supporters who pay to travel and the gate money to watch you under perform while still pulling your incredible wages
You are seriously under performing!!!

SP get a grip and start spending some money to invest in this club as you should have done in the Summer. A '0' hygiene rating in the players canteen is disgraceful. Also, start paying your suppliers on time, many of whom are small local suppliers. You 'talk a good game' but just don't back it up!!


The thinking might have been that we had Benteke who surely HAD to start scoring soon and get back to his best, Sorloth might have been expected to do better, Wickham was returning from injury,so the club just brought in Ayew on loan, a player who scored 11 goals for relegated Swansea last season.Having only spent £10 Mill on transfers it would appear that financial constraints played a part !
Turned out a lot different !!!!

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Dec 18 8.09pm

Pretty s***.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

sprites Flag Auckland 09 Dec 18 8.11pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Totally underachieved. Given where we finished last year - 11th, we should have kicked on with ambition and investment by the board to equal or better this position. Why we didn't buy a centre forward defies understanding and logic!

Losing against the 10 men of Brighton is despicable, no excuses whatsoever..... players should have had their pay docked for this.

West Ham defeat with us 1-0 up needs an explanation from the players as there is clearly a problem. Was the weather too cold??

Probably in truth its didums stuff but whatever the reason you as players need to deal with it as professionals who at the present are doing completely f*** all to address it. Just think of the many supporters who pay to travel and the gate money to watch you under perform while still pulling your incredible wages
You are seriously under performing!!!

SP get a grip and start spending some money to invest in this club as you should have done in the Summer. A '0' hygiene rating in the players canteen is disgraceful. Also, start paying your suppliers on time, many of whom are small local suppliers. You 'talk a good game' but just don't back it up!!



Because we already had three, perhaps? We then went on to loan J Ayew for extra depth.

Couldn't have foreseen Benteke getting injured. Couldn't have foreseen Wickham taking this long to come back.

Give the guys a break.

Edited by sprites (09 Dec 2018 8.11pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.15pm

No Willo it's yet another example of trying to get by on the cheap. We should have scouted and then gone for a proper centre forward but as our scouting is an absolute f****g joke I suppose it's YouTube!!

Sums us up.

 


Bring back Brolin

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Dec 18 8.16pm

Originally posted by sprites


Because we already had three, perhaps? We then went on to loan J Ayew for extra depth.

Couldn't have foreseen Benteke getting injured. Couldn't have foreseen Wickham taking this long to come back.

Give the guys a break.

Edited by sprites (09 Dec 2018 8.11pm)

Lol. Literally.

Benteke was abject for an entire season last year.

Wickham hasn’t been fit for 2 years and may never fully come back.

Sorloth is league one standard and couldn’t cut it in the Dutch top flight.

Are those the 3?

Ayew has turned out to be a poor, poor signing. He is also a number 10 or wide forward type, not a striker.

Not buying a center forward was a massive error, and it was obvious before the benefit of hindsight.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 8.20pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

No Willo it's yet another example of trying to get by on the cheap. We should have scouted and then gone for a proper centre forward but as our scouting is an absolute f****g joke I suppose it's YouTube!!

Sums us up.

In terms of transfer expenditure, in pre-season our spend was £10 Mill, the window before that it was around £11.5 Mill (Excluding the Sorloth add-ons) so the outlay in the 2 windows is 'peanuts' in PL terms.Perhaps this indicates financial constraints which preclude us from spending sizeable amounts.Maybe in January we will be shopping in Aldi and Lidl !

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2018 8.21pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.23pm

Originally posted by sprites


Because we already had three, perhaps? We then went on to loan J Ayew for extra depth.

Couldn't have foreseen Benteke getting injured. Couldn't have foreseen Wickham taking this long to come back.

Give the guys a break.

Edited by sprites (09 Dec 2018 8.11pm)

No I won't give the guys a break, if the board thought that Benteke who couldn't hit a barn door at 10 yards; Wickham who is a continuing sick note and Ayew who is a championship player at best could have been our solution then they need a massive re-think (last Summer!!)

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of transfer expenditure, in pre-season our spend was £10 Mill, the window before that it was around £11.5 Mill (Excluding the Sorloth add-ons) so the outlay in the 2 windows is 'peanuts' in PL terms.Perhaps this indicates financial constraints which preclude us from spending sizeable amounts.Maybe in January we will be shopping in Aldi and Lidl !

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2018 8.21pm)

Or the local Jumble Sale......

 


Bring back Brolin

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Dec 18 8.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of transfer expenditure, in pre-season our spend was £10 Mill, the window before that it was around £11.5 Mill (Excluding the Sorloth add-ons) so the outlay in the 2 windows is 'peanuts' in PL terms.Perhaps this indicates financial constraints which preclude us from spending sizeable amounts.Maybe in January we will be shopping in Aldi and Lidl !

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2018 8.21pm)

If we are constrained financially, we only have ourselves to blame.

Schlupp on 55k a week says it all.

We have WAY too many players earning tasty wages and not contributing. Parish made his bed now he has to lie in it. If we have issues then we need to sell. So sell some players and let’s sign some bodies with attacking intent.

We have barley sold a single player for a fee in cpfc2010’s entire tenure. We bring in players for big money on big wages and then they leave on a free transfer. Then we sign loan players and integrate them into our starting 11, start to rely on them then they walk as we have no chance of signing them.

Meanwhile we have a product of Ajax who was once touted as a hot prospect in Europe and our manager thinks Jason Puncheon should play ahead of him.

Bizarre and poor decisions all over the shop.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 8.38pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If we are constrained financially, we only have ourselves to blame.

Schlupp on 55k a week says it all.

We have WAY too many players earning tasty wages and not contributing. Parish made his bed now he has to lie in it. If we have issues then we need to sell. So sell some players and let’s sign some bodies with attacking intent.

We have barley sold a single player for a fee in cpfc2010’s entire tenure. We bring in players for big money on big wages and then they leave on a free transfer. Then we sign loan players and integrate them into our starting 11, start to rely on them then they walk as we have no chance of signing them.

Meanwhile we have a product of Ajax who was once touted as a hot prospect in Europe and our manager thinks Jason Puncheon should play ahead of him.

Bizarre and poor decisions all over the shop.

I take it you mean Riedewald.I don't know why he is not getting in the squad.Will have to pose the question.

There appears to be a great deal of disillusionment at the moment and I get the feeling that in general our supporters don't have much faith that we will buy well in the January window.

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2018 8.44pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 8.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

.

Edited by Willo (09 Dec 2018 8.47pm)

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 09 Dec 18 8.43pm

For me the review so far is that we have been playing some of the best football I have seen in all my 60 years of watching/ following the team. In previous years we may have got more or less points at this stage of the season but the way we have got them or not got them has been from better quality and more pleasing on the eye than in previous years. Who knows what will happen come the end of the season which is the only time it finally counts but so far the team has shown great entertainment and judging by previous seasons we have more chance of success than previously especially if all on here are correct that we can improve the team come January.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 09 Dec 18 8.47pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I think the season so far can pretty much be summed up with one word.

Brexit??

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Season review so far...