You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Policy
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Policy


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Oldeagle3 Flag 09 Dec 18 5.29pm

OK so Freedman is DoF whilst Parish signs the cheques and the contracts. What role does Roy have regarding transfers?

 

crvenaeagle Flag 09 Dec 18 5.31pm

He's spends his time as a moderator on here, closing down unnecessary threads.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Dec 18 5.31pm

I suspect 'policy' may be a bit of an exaggeration.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Oldeagle3 Flag 09 Dec 18 5.43pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

He's spends his time as a moderator on here, closing down unnecessary threads.

The reason for my question is to seek opinion as to whether or not Roy is culpable with regard to our paucity of quality in the team.

 

chateauferret Flag 09 Dec 18 5.47pm

He does the gags. Then the others go out and buy the players and put them in the dressing room. Then they look stupid when Hodgson explains that he was joking.

And the only scouts are the kids wearing woggles.

Edited by chateauferret (09 Dec 2018 5.48pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

crvenaeagle Flag 09 Dec 18 6.18pm

Originally posted by Oldeagle3

The reason for my question is to seek opinion as to whether or not Roy is culpable with regard to our paucity of quality in the team.

Actually this recently published article hits the nail on the head
[Link]

 

the.universal 09 Dec 18 6.44pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Actually this recently published article hits the nail on the head
[Link]

Not a big fan of this article:
There are lots of reasons to criticise our transfer policy, but Rakip is not one of them. Never signed as a first team player.
Negative article that seems to be writing our season off already. Plenty of games left.
Mentions the new main stand in the same breath as being relegated. Our investors need some return on their monies.
Contradictory: mentions us ‘halfway there’ to doing a Sunderland then says we can consolidate top half Championship. Good to see all predictive bases covered!
Mentions food hygiene at the training ground. This is the sort of story that only comes up if a club is not doing well. It was closed for one day back in August, no big deal.

 


Vive le Roy!

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.03pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Actually this recently published article hits the nail on the head
[Link]

A brilliant article absolutely spot on and please add how we treat suppliers and subcontractors.

We are a Premier club with a National League attitude to administration and planning!

 


Bring back Brolin

Maine Eagle Flag USA 09 Dec 18 8.12pm

We don’t have a transfer policy.

We lurch from one window to the next and generally fail to address all of our needs, especially in terms of goal scoring.

Much akin to how we lurch from one relegation scrap to another with intermittent periods of late season purple patches.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

crvenaeagle Flag 09 Dec 18 8.13pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Not a big fan of this article:
There are lots of reasons to criticise our transfer policy, but Rakip is not one of them. Never signed as a first team player.
Negative article that seems to be writing our season off already. Plenty of games left.
Mentions the new main stand in the same breath as being relegated. Our investors need some return on their monies.
Contradictory: mentions us ‘halfway there’ to doing a Sunderland then says we can consolidate top half Championship. Good to see all predictive bases covered!
Mentions food hygiene at the training ground. This is the sort of story that only comes up if a club is not doing well. It was closed for one day back in August, no big deal.

Rakip is not one of them? I'm surprised you think so. I would have said the complete opposite, for me it absolutely highlights the bizarre goings on at the club within their transfers system, and is an emblem of failure within it. You can essentially sum up our transfer issues with him and/or Jach - unnecessary, added nothing and wasted time and funds, and just all out weird.

 

the.universal 09 Dec 18 8.36pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Rakip is not one of them? I'm surprised you think so. I would have said the complete opposite, for me it absolutely highlights the bizarre goings on at the club within their transfers system, and is an emblem of failure within it. You can essentially sum up our transfer issues with him and/or Jach - unnecessary, added nothing and wasted time and funds, and just all out weird.

Rakip was not signed as a first team player. Parish has gone on record to say that. He was signed to bulk out the first team squad for training, anything that we got from him above that was a bonus. A cheap option that was easy to get over the line.

Don’t get me wrong, our transfer policy has been shyte. But Rakip doesn’t fit with that. £16m for Sorloth on the other hand...

 


Vive le Roy!

crvenaeagle Flag 09 Dec 18 8.41pm

Parish using his years of experience of schmoozing with nice sounding phrases there by the looks of it.
Sorloth and Ayew weren't signed as first teamers either.

 

davehuggins Flag 09 Dec 18 8.45pm

I believe we just don't have a long-term plan and we lurch from one window to another. Trouble is we can't keep a manager long enough to have one. If we could have hung onto Sam this may have been different, Sam has the experience on what is needed to progress a smaller club like us. All IMO

 

the.universal 09 Dec 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Parish using his years of experience of schmoozing with nice sounding phrases there by the looks of it.
Sorloth and Ayew weren't signed as first teamers either .

Any source for that? Or just your opinion?

 


Vive le Roy!

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Dec 18 8.53pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Any source for that? Or just your opinion?

IMO I think that both were signed as first team players again on the cheap but were they Roy's choices or someone else?...... This also extends to Meyer and Guita.

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 8.59pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

IMO I think that both were signed as first team players again on the cheap but were they Roy's choices or someone else?...... This also extends to Meyer and Guita.

When one is unable to lavish significant sums on transfers then of course this limits what one can spend.

 

the.universal 09 Dec 18 9.03pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

IMO I think that both were signed as first team players again on the cheap but were they Roy's choices or someone else?...... This also extends to Meyer and Guita.

With a DoF structure, I think it’s unlikely Roy would have final yay or nay. So I don’t think it’s right to pin the blame on any one person. But we do seem to have an issue with buying players that don’t fit into our system/philosophy.

Keeping a manager for more than 18 months would be a good start.

 


Vive le Roy!

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 09 Dec 18 9.04pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

I believe we just don't have a long-term plan and we lurch from one window to another. Trouble is we can't keep a manager long enough to have one. If we could have hung onto Sam this may have been different, Sam has the experience on what is needed to progress a smaller club like us. All IMO


Our transfer policy is the same as the other bottom 12 clubs (probably excluding West Ham now they have a bigger budget with their 60k seater stadium) we buy to survive. Look at Fulham, they have spent 100+ million. Huddersfield, 60 million....Southampton blew all the VVD money and are 3 points worse off than us. United have spent 400+ million and are going backwards. Every club will look at their transfer policy and think they could do better. We have brought some good players over the past 5 years, but we have also brought players with little to no impact. That’s the problem when you go through so many managers. They all want their players and other players get disregarded.

I agree, we don’t have a long term plan and perhaps we need to persist with manager through thick and thin to try and get some stability. Big Sam has experience in keeping teams up, but has zero experience on pushing clubs on which I believe is our aim.

I think if Roy is our manager, he should have more of a say (if he has none already).

 

the.universal 09 Dec 18 9.04pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

IMO I think that both were signed as first team players again on the cheap but were they Roy's choices or someone else?...... This also extends to Meyer and Guita.

Sorloth was not cheap: £15m

 


Vive le Roy!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 18 9.07pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Sorloth was not cheap: £15m

My understanding is that the deal was £9 Mill rising to £16.5 Mill with all the add-ons.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Policy