This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| W12 20 Jan 19 8.12am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But surely anyone can apply to Oxford or Cambridge providing they have the grades. The problem with the wider issue of equal opportunities is that it doesn't work both ways. For example. A man from pakistan can come here and open a business in which he employs his family. That means no local people can apply for the jobs. How is that fair in a country where larger employers have to conform to an equal opportunities policy? In this case, why should someone with better grades be overlooked so Oxford can accept some poor kids? It’s easy. The answer is to provide better opportunities for everyone and not to try and level the playing field after the fact. Kids from privaledged backgrounds do well at least partly because private schools have a higher focus on individualism, discipline and traditional values. That would be a good place to start in state schools.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
it's a Pandora's box regardless. somebody who grows up in extreme poverty with a dire education yet matches the achievements of somebody whose education costs hundreds of thousands of pounds... In my view this is hyperbolic language that doesn't accurately reflect the British state school system nor the average economic experience of working class children in the UK. Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
meritocratically speaking, I'm just rooting for the pauper out of these two people and thinking 'I hope he gets his place at Oxbridge'.
What you are supporting is tokenism. Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
let's be realistic rather than idealistic for one second...hand on heartwho's likely to be more intelligent of the two, given their opportunities? who has achieved more? we both know the answer. So what....I don't hate someone because of their class.....what I hate is cronyism and other anti meritocratic practices. I recognise your objections and I hold some of them however I will never deny the brighter child an education because of class.....that's pure dumbing down for ideological purposes. I've seen what affirmative action has and is doing in America and it isn't good nor helpful. Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
there's this ex public schoolboy at my work. idiot. genuine idiot. no initiative. yet he's got his nice degree and somehow is climbing the greasy pole and building a nice life for himself to repeat the life he grew up into. there's another lad, east London geezer type. but smart and quick witted. proactive. talented. but not an operator in a large corporation... In a meritocratic world, the posh boy gets overtaken. I'm not convinced it'll play out that way. partly that's down to their upbringing. There will always be families with more wealth than others, just as there will differences between people with innate intelligence as with any other ability. I think you are in danger here of romanticizing the working class and of demonising the middle and higher. Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
meritocracy surely needs to reward genuine achievement. Western society already does this better than any other society in the history of humanity. I think you are guilty here of drawing extreme caricatures of situations to justify a policy that in reality is more unjust. You don't correct the problems with the class system by implementing your own systems of injustice. Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
there's some crossover between equity and meritocracy. No there isn't, they are near opposites.....Explain what you mean by this.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
It’s easy. The answer is to provide better opportunities for everyone and not to try and level the playing field after the fact. Kids from privaledged backgrounds do well at least partly because private schools have a higher focus on individualism, discipline and traditional values. That would be a good place to start in state schools. I would agree that this is part of the solution.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I agree that assessing people solely on merit is always what should be done. However affirmative action can sometimes help to achieve that. Why? Because when making the assessment you need to not only consider what someone has already achieved but what they could have achieved if there was a level playing field of opportunity for everyone up to the point of the assessment. So finding hidden bright nuggets within areas of deprivation who can then benefit from an Oxbridge opportunity is ultimately to all our benefit. There is nothing remotely "left wing" involved. It's just common sense and good practice.
Having been a secondary school teacher I know all about 'hidden nuggets'. In reality they don't stay hidden very long and indeed most of them become successful. In this country the reasons bright people don't achieve has very little to do with the level of education they receive. It's far more centred on their family life and other external influences. That's the reality.....success has far less to do with pure talent than many people realise. The state can't fix those problems. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jan 2019 11.19am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
It’s easy. The answer is to provide better opportunities for everyone and not to try and level the playing field after the fact. Kids from privaledged backgrounds do well at least partly because private schools have a higher focus on individualism, discipline and traditional values. That would be a good place to start in state schools. Privilege is not the fault of the individual concerned. Even if we had equal education, we would still have those that failed because of lower ability. Do we then blame some other factor for their failure? There are always winners and losers however you massage the system. That is life. There is also the inevitable tendancy for those of means to seek advantage by any and all means possible. That is how we get to where we are now and always will. In short. Equality is impossible. People are at the top and bottom of society for a reason.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
In this country the reasons bright people don't achieve has very little to do with the level of education they receive. It's far more centred on their family life and other external influences. That's the reality.....success has far less to do with pure talent than many people realise. The state can't fix those problems. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jan 2019 11.19am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I utterly disagree with you.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Sterling... Merit: Equity: Crossover: it's fair to get what you deserve. A person who rises up from nothing deserves more in my book than somebody born to great privilege who 'makes par' in their educational attainment. and please desist from accusations of hyperbole or I'll just not bother and you can claim your debating victory. I already said I was using extremes to make a point and I just can't be arsed with needly remarks like that.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by OllieMaidstoneEagle
They've been "Offered" places but what are the chances of them actually "Getting" places.As a born and bred south-east-working-class-Londoner I'm very lucky to have had 3 of my kids graduate from Uni and even more lucky that they're all in employment in jobs that they studied for,graphic design,fine art and illustration. Ollie's Dad,Ash. They are probably going to be working on Sting's new album cover.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
he asked me to justify the crossover between equity and merit. so I did.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Sterling... Merit: Equity: Crossover: it's fair to get what you deserve. A person who rises up from nothing deserves more in my book than somebody born to great privilege who 'makes par' in their educational attainment. and please desist from accusations of hyperbole or I'll just not bother and you can claim your debating victory. I already said I was using extremes to make a point and I just can't be arsed with needly remarks like that. As a cynic or perhaps a realist, I would suggest that when students like these are selected for a hand up it is purely to promote the idea that anyone can succeed in our society. Tokenisms just tell us that the idea of equal opportunity is a fantasy that the ruling class wish to sell us so we all feel happy and content like the happy shoppers we are.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Sterling... Merit: Equity: Crossover: it's fair to get what you deserve. A person who rises up from nothing deserves more in my book than somebody born to great privilege who 'makes par' in their educational attainment. and please desist from accusations of hyperbole or I'll just not bother and you can claim your debating victory. I already said I was using extremes to make a point and I just can't be arsed with needly remarks like that. The crossover here is entirely your own. You attach value judgements to class and I don't think that should have a place in how meritocratic systems operate. I certainly share some concerns over working class access to systems designed by the middle and higher classes but I'm critical of these methods. To use a footballing example, essentially it doesn't matter whether the footballer in your first eleven comes from a middle class background or a working class background....what matters is that they merit their place in the team as the best available to you. If you start to introduce value judgements away from sheer merit you cannot also claim to advocate meritocracy in the same way I do....as yours is an advocacy of meritocracy with strings attached. As for the use of extremes in your examples....I criticised that because extreme examples are surly not a rational way to judge whether a policy is sensible or not. The fact that you said you would use them isn't an exclusion from commentary on that.....however I assure you, I'm not really looking for debating victories here or even trying to alter your view....but rather just exploring the topic in my usual direct way.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Earlier this year I was up in Oxford with one of my kids who was interested in one of the courses on offer. Firstly I get why people rave about it. The colleges are incredible and if you could design your own version of heaven, then I suspect mine would look a lot like many of those admittedly with an Adriatic beach nearby. An absolutely incredible place but I can also see the danger in why it produces an elite out of touch with the grimmer realities of UK life. We attended a talk on admissions. The lady stressed that Oxford was desperate to attract more state school kids. But they had to apply. That was the point. My kid's school were useless when it came to offering advice to my child. She still might apply as she is predicted to get the grades but the reality is that many state schools are to blame for not preparing the kids in advance as Oxbridge entry differs from all the rest. That is why the Private schools keep their stranglehold on Oxbridge because they prepare their pupils in advance and support them. Well done to these kids but more than that, well done to their school for creating an environment in which they have the cajones to go for it. That is the crucial element here. Good post.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Earlier this year I was up in Oxford with one of my kids who was interested in one of the courses on offer. Firstly I get why people rave about it. The colleges are incredible and if you could design your own version of heaven, then I suspect mine would look a lot like many of those admittedly with an Adriatic beach nearby. An absolutely incredible place but I can also see the danger in why it produces an elite out of touch with the grimmer realities of UK life. We attended a talk on admissions. The lady stressed that Oxford was desperate to attract more state school kids. But they had to apply. That was the point. My kid's school were useless when it came to offering advice to my child. She still might apply as she is predicted to get the grades but the reality is that many state schools are to blame for not preparing the kids in advance as Oxbridge entry differs from all the rest. That is why the Private schools keep their stranglehold on Oxbridge because they prepare their pupils in advance and support them. Well done to these kids but more than that, well done to their school for creating an environment in which they have the cajones to go for it. That is the crucial element here. Not sure I understand, your child passed the Oxford entrance test, or your visit was part of a process and they haven't sat yet?
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
Not sure I understand, your child passed the Oxford entrance test, or your visit was part of a process and they haven't sat yet? It was an open day. She was interested in starting off the process to sit the entrance test but recieved such mixed messages from her school that it put her off. She still has 5 offers from Russel Group Universities so no harm done but the message from Oxford was that they were desperate for more state sector kids to come there, and were willing to take a tolerant view of less than steller GCSE results (my kid got straight A's and A* so no issue there) when viewed against an average for the school. If my kid gets straight A's at A levels then she might defer Uni for a year and apply to Oxford but they will be despite her schoo, not because of it. But the kids had to apply and their schools needed to support them. That is the bigger issue. We made a huge mistake in encouraging our child to stay on at her schools 6th form and will not be doing so with our second but Oxford could not have been more honest about desperately wanting to attract kids from the state sector. Edited by Matov (21 Jan 2019 3.05pm)
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.