You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dortmund after Wilf


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Jacey Flag 24 Jan 19 1.16pm

Originally posted by jimruss

I kind of agree with you, I feel like maybe we're holding him back a little, I'd like to see him play in a good team surrounded by decent players, forget the Man Utd debacle, that was the wrong time and as it turned out the wrong manager who didn't use him. I'd love him to stay but I don't begrudge him a decent move.

However I don't trust us to reinvest the money wisely.

Probably a good time to sell to the highest bidder(Dortmund or Spurs) and invest the bulk of the proceeds into strengthening the squad.
Wilf deserves the opportunity to compete at the highest level,rather than fighting to save us against relegation year after year and zero chance of ever winning silverware!!

 

Terry Ven Flag 24 Jan 19 1.28pm

i dunno...is he as good as we think he is? I mean maybe he just looks good coz we have so many other bang average players. how come their hasnt been a queue of clubs wanting to buy him??

 

premier fan Flag BR4 24 Jan 19 1.29pm

Sometimes you go to a football match and hope to see something special now and then. Zaha is the player that can produce this for us on a regular basis.

For me its not just about the team and results, its also about these moments of ecstatic enjoyment. Yes, of course , I want us to stay up and there needs to be a balance.

However, I fear losing Zaha would be like losing a limb going forward.

The only reason he should go is if he himself really wants to and the price is right.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 24 Jan 19 1.29pm

If wants to go I rather he goes to Dortmund than to a rival premier league club.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 24 Jan 19 2.03pm

He has to go to a bigger club with more quality around him to truly reach his full potential.

If things carry on for him this season the way they have so far, getting north of 50m quid is fair enough.

It should be done over the summer, and be sorted early so that the players can come to terms with it, and so that the money can be used to bring in a winger etc.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

new_in_Wait Flag Lewisham 24 Jan 19 2.08pm

I'm not against Zaha leaving if it's good for him and a good deal for the club. However, I'm worried we'll do a good job at immediate post-Zaha life.
I'm thinking a lot of the first instalment will go towards balancing the books (Sakho, Benteke) and paying United's sell on fee (if any). We'll have to get another goalie to replace Speroni+Wayne (in case the latter is let go for disciplinary reasons) and getting a couple of modest players on high wages (i.e. a Matt Ritchie and Andy Carroll combo). Or imagine there's an automatic transfer fee for Ayew triggered if he hits a certain number of games...
We would be starting next season with Schlupp and Wickham still very close to first-team football and that depresses me.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 24 Jan 19 3.06pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He has to go to a bigger club with more quality around him to truly reach his full potential.

If things carry on for him this season the way they have so far, getting north of 50m quid is fair enough.

It should be done over the summer, and be sorted early so that the players can come to terms with it, and so that the money can be used to bring in a winger etc.

No we need to bring in a winger first, otherwise we will get striped up on the price once people know we have the Zaha money.
Bournemouth done it the right way, signed a replacement for Callum Wilson before they sell him. That way they will get top money for Wilson and won’t pay over the odds on a replacement.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 24 Jan 19 3.18pm

Originally posted by jimruss

I kind of agree with you, I feel like maybe we're holding him back a little, I'd like to see him play in a good team surrounded by decent players, forget the Man Utd debacle, that was the wrong time and as it turned out the wrong manager who didn't use him. I'd love him to stay but I don't begrudge him a decent move.

However I don't trust us to reinvest the money wisely.

Agreed but at the end of this season. Without Zaha, I struggle to see how Palace would stay up = current position is far too precarious to dispense of the services of our best player. Also Club shouldn't settle for anything less than £70m for Zaha.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Jan 19 3.43pm

It would be a disaster for the club if Zaha is sold.

He is the best player we have ever had in terms of skill and our Premier League status would probably disappear along with any idea that that Palace have an ounce of ambition.
I'd rather the owners buggered off and sold the club to someone who actually wants to achieve something.

The yearly spin around the plug hole is only going to end one way and I suspect that all concerned are more interested in lining their pockets than success.

Anyone fed up with mediocrity?

Goodbye Wilf and goodbye to my last hopes of seeing us become a proper club in my lifetime.
Football is about players. Sell the good ones and you have nothing left except a few thousand fans who would turn up to watch a dog turd if it had a red and blue shirt on.

Awaits some twit to tell me to go and support City after supporting Palace since I was four. That's fifty years by the way.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Jan 2019 3.50pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Jan 19 4.00pm

Easy Hrolf. Usually when we get these rumours talking about bidding wars for our best players etc., the club either states that there has been no approach, or they publicly advise said clubs to do one. And the players don't want to leave.

I know, that's the club line on it. Funny thing, the players actually stay.

BTW we are the same age.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 24 Jan 19 4.21pm

Originally posted by Casual

No we need to bring in a winger first, otherwise we will get striped up on the price once people know we have the Zaha money.
Bournemouth done it the right way, signed a replacement for Callum Wilson before they sell him. That way they will get top money for Wilson and won’t pay over the odds on a replacement.

That would be what we would do if the people running the club made smart moves....

Also FFP could be a factor there, see my previous comment on who is to blame on that one.

We will sell Zaha then spend ages messing around and maybe finally sign a replacement at 11pm on deadline day, or....if his brother/agent wants a bung then Zaha wont be replaced that window.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Jan 19 4.30pm

I'd just like remind folk about what happened when we sold Ian Wright - and on the relative cheap - we were relegated the season after...

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 24 Jan 19 4.59pm

Would be gutted to see him go...
The only silver lining would be that we wouldn't need to see him playing against us in another Premier League teams kit

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Jan 19 5.00pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Easy Hrolf. Usually when we get these rumours talking about bidding wars for our best players etc., the club either states that there has been no approach, or they publicly advise said clubs to do one. And the players don't want to leave.

I know, that's the club line on it. Funny thing, the players actually stay.

BTW we are the same age.


I always think a bit of overreaction is required when I see Zaha and sell in the same sentence.
What really irritates me is when some of our own fans say they don't mind.

Wow, some of them must dream of wet cold nights in the Championship.

 

est1905 Flag 24 Jan 19 5.38pm

Originally posted by Aray


But even if he doesn’t score enough he’s making most of our better chances. I don’t think we can replace him effectively or efficiently.

Well of course not. Players like Wilf are irreplaceable. Clubs like Palace can only dream about having a player of his quality for as long as we have. He is loyal and he is a Palace fan. Very unique.
Its almost the same as Le Tiss at the Saints except this is an era where loyalty in football is as rare as rocking horse manure.
Eventually he will leave. Better to get the best money for him while his value is at its peak. If we can buy a decent winger to fill the position (Demerai Gray?) who would cost a third of what we'll get for Wilf and spend the rest on a quality striker and a creative midfielder (If Roy is never going to use Meyer in that role)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Jan 19 6.06pm

Originally posted by est1905

Well of course not. Players like Wilf are irreplaceable. Clubs like Palace can only dream about having a player of his quality for as long as we have. He is loyal and he is a Palace fan. Very unique.
Its almost the same as Le Tiss at the Saints except this is an era where loyalty in football is as rare as rocking horse manure.
Eventually he will leave. Better to get the best money for him while his value is at its peak. If we can buy a decent winger to fill the position (Demerai Gray?) who would cost a third of what we'll get for Wilf and spend the rest on a quality striker and a creative midfielder (If Roy is never going to use Meyer in that role)

Did Le Tissier leave Southampton? Nope.
We need to keep Wilf. His monetary value is nothing compared to his presence in the team and staying in the Prem.

 

LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 24 Jan 19 6.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It would be a disaster for the club if Zaha is sold.

He is the best player we have ever had in terms of skill and our Premier League status would probably disappear along with any idea that that Palace have an ounce of ambition.
I'd rather the owners buggered off and sold the club to someone who actually wants to achieve something.

The yearly spin around the plug hole is only going to end one way and I suspect that all concerned are more interested in lining their pockets than success.

Anyone fed up with mediocrity?

Goodbye Wilf and goodbye to my last hopes of seeing us become a proper club in my lifetime.
Football is about players. Sell the good ones and you have nothing left except a few thousand fans who would turn up to watch a dog turd if it had a red and blue shirt on.

Awaits some twit to tell me to go and support City after supporting Palace since I was four. That's fifty years by the way.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Jan 2019 3.50pm)

im pretty much in agreement with this. fair enough, if he wants to go, i wouldnt begrudge him that, tho.
but i honestly dont think we're going forward as a club. still in relegation dog fights, still always linked with the same average players, that agents flog about to the same few clubs...us, fulham, west ham, newcastle, everton etc. we're getting left behind by the likes of brighton and bournemouth. and as someone else said earlier, if we got 50 mill or more, i couldnt trust the club to spend it wisely tbh.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 24 Jan 19 6.28pm

How many players have gone to the Bundesliga after being established in the PL for a club ? Quite a few talented youngsters over there agreed. Robben perhaps ? Obviously Champs League might be a pull. Think more likely that Wilf will step up to a big PL club in the future for quite a bit more, the Arse being my favourite like Wrighty.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Jan 19 6.56pm

If Wilf does go, then the club will just stick Schlupp on the left and Towhsend on the right Schlupp is one of Roy's faves after all.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Jan 19 7.13pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Did Le Tissier leave Southampton? Nope.
We need to keep Wilf. His monetary value is nothing compared to his presence in the team and staying in the Prem.

Correct.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf