You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Under or over-performing?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Under or over-performing?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 15 Apr 19 4.15pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Agree with most of this.

However, where we get those points from I really don't care. Obviously be nice to get more at home, but if the first priority is to stay in the Premier League then those 39 points should achieve that.

As a season ticket holder who infrequently travels away, it would be nice to see a few more wins at home. However it would also be nice if they could save the away wins up for when I do go

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 15 Apr 19 4.30pm

Originally posted by Bearcage

Yep, wage bill is probably the most reliable indicator of likely league position

Can be skewed by frees and loans surely?

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 15 Apr 19 5.42pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Paul Merson on sky has consistently said palace are the most underachieving team in the premiership, with a equal to anyone outside the top 6, I agree with this.

I emphatically don't agree!
On paper we have good players - in practice we have no cohesion, teamwork, ball holding skills or intelligence. I guess some manager would be able to sort this out but Roy Hodgson has proved he can't.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 15 Apr 19 6.17pm

Originally posted by Uphill

I emphatically don't agree!
On paper we have good players - in practice we have no cohesion, teamwork, ball holding skills or intelligence. I guess some manager would be able to sort this out but Roy Hodgson has proved he can't.

Hear hear ... I agree with most of the above but also believe some of our players are not as fit as they should be. They just do not work hard enough and that was very clear yesterday.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 15 Apr 19 7.23pm

The title of this thread should actually be under performing and over paid!

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 15 Apr 19 9.04pm

I think we are under-performing and it needs a couple of changes to reverse this.

1. A centre forward that can play the lone striker role

Benteke and Batshuayi don't seem to be able to do this, whilst Wickham appears to be struggling to recover fitness.


2. A dominant creative midfielder.

I thought Meyer would be the answer, but he won't dominate games.

However, these types of players cost ££££

 

dg1937 Flag 15 Apr 19 9.28pm

When I started the thread I had in mind how our performance in terms of league position compared with our relative financial clout (or lack of it). Probably 'punching above our weight?' might have been a better title.

I used attendance as a proxy for 'financial clout' and clearly it isn't a very good proxy. Someone pointed out that TV money is very unevenly distributed and also there's the question of sponsorship, money from stadium naming rights etc, etc.

I think Palace are well down the 'financial clout' table and I suspect we are truly 'punching above our weight'. The disparity in resources was crystal clear against Man City, as was pointed out on the match thread I think, any one of their players, including those on the bench, would be guaranteed starters for us and none of our players would make it into their team. That has very little it seems to me to do with Guardiola being a better manager than Roy and everything to do with the financial muscle City have.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Apr 19 6.50am

Originally posted by dg1937

When I started the thread I had in mind how our performance in terms of league position compared with our relative financial clout (or lack of it). Probably 'punching above our weight?' might have been a better title.

I used attendance as a proxy for 'financial clout' and clearly it isn't a very good proxy. Someone pointed out that TV money is very unevenly distributed and also there's the question of sponsorship, money from stadium naming rights etc, etc.

I think Palace are well down the 'financial clout' table
and I suspect we are truly 'punching above our weight'. The disparity in resources was crystal clear against Man City, as was pointed out on the match thread I think, any one of their players, including those on the bench, would be guaranteed starters for us and none of our players would make it into their team. That has very little it seems to me to do with Guardiola being a better manager than Roy and everything to do with the financial muscle City have.


And yet we've got the 9th highest wage bill?

 

Master Coin Flag 16 Apr 19 9.32am

The issue we have is that we’ve repeatedly failed in the transfer market. Most clubs hit on a couple of players occasionally which they can sell for a profit. We’ve not sold anybody outside of Bolasie for ages. Exclusively signing and not propping up the balance sheet with the odd big player sale is not sustainable.

It’s the main reason I’m accepting we’ll sell AWB. As good as he is, he’s a right back and they aren’t the most pivotal position on the pitch. As much as I love AWB if I had the choice of AWB and no signings or starting Ward at RB and reinvesting say £60m on a new central midfielder and striker I’d take the latter.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 16 Apr 19 9.47am

I agree. If Utd or anyone come in with an offer 50 mil + then we will sell. I would take 50 mil plus Fosu-Mensah for AWB. The only trouble is I have no confidence in our talent spotting ability to not waste it.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 16 Apr 19 10.58am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Thing is, we chop and change, which is expensive.

We get in Holloway, we go up. He signs players, how he came about them is a whole different story.

Pulis comes in, does a remarkable job - he too signs players, Dann, Ledley and Henenrsey and the job is done we have a respectable finish.

He then wants to implement his team - Campbell, Kelly.

Then he's gone - Warnock comes in, very different manager. He brings in players like Zaha, Fryers and McArthur.

Then we get Pardew and a whole different breed of player comes in. The likes of Cabaye, Wickham, Mutch, Souare, McCarthy, followed by Tomkins, Townsend, Mandana, Remy.

Then Fat Sam - PVA, Luca, Sakho, Schlupp.

So already, it's a mix and match. How many of these players were veiwed as potential first teamers and paid so, but gone AWOL.

Suffice to say, this summer should be the result of a long hard scouting period where players are sold, moved on, replaced.
Roy stamps his mark on the squad and has 2 years to work on it.
changing a manager now is just going to add to that depressing list.

Chopping and changing styles cost money but that hasn’t happened at Palace, if you were to group every premier league manager along a line from organised and defensive to free flowing and creative then Warnock, Alladyce and Pulis would all be up one end along Dyche and Mourinho. Hodgson would be probably not be too far along . With Pardew we still had an effective counter attacking team until he tried to turn us into a more possession based attacking team and the defence fell apart.
Most of the players you list are still with us and would be first teamers or seen as god squad players, Hennessey, Dann , Kelly, Zaha, McArthur, Wickham, Townsend, Tomkins, Schlupp, PVA, Luka, Sakho. Not sure what has happened to Wickham since his return but looks like he is in Hodgson's plans. Ledley was solid but upgrade by Cabaye and moved on, Campbell went the same way, Soure had his horrific injury but has been upgraded anyway.
Fryers,I’ll add Sorloth and Riedweld to this, were a gamble on youth that didn’t pay off. McCarthy had a terrible started and was shot for confidence and sold on by Pardew , Mandana never settled and moved neither of which was not due to change in manager preference. Cabaye performed consistently and was chosen under several managers and he moved on for a big pay off.
You point makes sense for Mutch and Chung-Yong ,in that Pardew wanted to change us from a counter attacking team to a possession based team. Both were attacking more creative players brought by Pardew that never really worked for us and Alladyce was never going to play them. My fear would be Max Myer might go the same way, someone we want to break down organised defences but can’t quite work out how to fit him in.
Finally Benteke, he looked like he was an upgrade on the big number 9 from Cameron Jerome, Campbell, Wickham to the ultimate big lad up front Benteke. First year he did well but then his confidence went he still does most things you want from a number 9 except the important one score. You could argue that with Zaha and Townsend being encouraged to come inside it has meant less balls into the box but he been consistently picked by successive manager and if starts scoring again he will be picked.
The reason we have not kicked on over the last few years is we haven’t had a fit or decent forward, Wickham has only just returned Benteke has lacked confidence and been out regularly and Sorloth wasn’t up to it. If we had taken our chances against Cardiff, Newcastle and Brighton at home we would be challenging for Europe ,small margins at the end of the day.

Edited by Ketteridge (16 Apr 2019 11.02am)

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

dg1937 Flag 16 Apr 19 11.50am

Originally posted by spartakev2


And yet we've got the 9th highest wage bill?

My feeling is that that's where the problem lies. We offered Benteke and Sakho (and Wilf) massive pay packets that we are struggling to afford Hence 9th highest wage bill compared to bottom half financial clout.

I do agree with a lot of what Ketteridge just said. Our squad has steadily got better and with better finishing we would be several places higher up the table. It is, as he says, 'small margins'.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Apr 19 12.56pm

Originally posted by dg1937

My feeling is that that's where the problem lies. We offered Benteke and Sakho (and Wilf) massive pay packets that we are struggling to afford Hence 9th highest wage bill compared to bottom half financial clout.

I do agree with a lot of what Ketteridge just said. Our squad has steadily got better and with better finishing we would be several places higher up the table. It is, as he says, 'small margins'.

TBF you could say this about most teams.....

 

andy p Flag Warrington cheshire 16 Apr 19 2.09pm

We have under performed,but not by a lot.I have us 8 or 9 points short of where we could,should be now

 


stuck up here with a load of northern monkeys!

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Apr 19 1.31am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Very good post, however, That bit in bold...
As has been stated on here, It is thought that RH has only 1 or 2 seasons left in him. Going by your logic, should he be the one to stop this Mix and Match culture?

What this has done, and we can include RH's purchases in that(Meyer, Kouyate, Guaita) is mean that we have a lot of players, which have come in on higher wages.

I fear that this window we are going to be clearing of the deadwood with no dramatic Spending, save for some urgent replacements should we sell any 1st teamers. RH will be here next season as a steadying influence, and to give us the best chance at survival. We will then look to reinvest in the squad - potentially with a new longer term manager.

i agree with you, thats why i feel 1 of 3 things will happen:
A, not spend in the summer, maybe sell one or two of dead wood and see out roy's contract treading water hoping for more of the same - complete overhaul next year.
B, Back Roy - fund it by the sale of an asset and give him a year extension to see him take us to mid table and not near the relegation scrap and in 2021 shake his hand and next project.
C, New manager this summer, get him to tread water for a year then invest - or sell an asset now and invest.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Apr 19 12.34pm

Don’t understand how a team that’s so dependent on one player can be underachieving. The squad is poor from an attacking perspective if you take Wilf out and IMO probably relegation fodder. Can’t think of a team so heavily reliant on one individual.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Apr 19 1.33pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Don’t understand how a team that’s so dependent on one player can be underachieving. The squad is poor from an attacking perspective if you take Wilf out and IMO probably relegation fodder. Can’t think of a team so heavily reliant on one individual.

You've answered your own question. It's precisely because the team is over reliant on Zaha that there is an imbalance in the tactical approach to the attacking side of our game. I recall years ago the Spuds had a similar problem when Ginola played for them, everything went through him and it became easy for the opposition to double up.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 19 Apr 19 1.45pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You've answered your own question. It's precisely because the team is over reliant on Zaha that there is an imbalance in the tactical approach to the attacking side of our game. I recall years ago the Spuds had a similar problem when Ginola played for them, everything went through him and it became easy for the opposition to double up.

But the team has to be so reliant on him because with absolutely no support from anywhere else on the pitch we have to rely on our most skilful player to make things happen on his own and that's not down to the team thats down to bad management.A player like him should not be running around like a mad man chasing defenders and lost causes and he shouldn't be expected to take on entire defences to make things happen week in week out.If we didn't set up so so defensive every week and get the midfield up a bit there's no way we would be so reliant on him because he'd be getting help and support instead of when he receives the ball not having any help within 30 yards of him.He is completely and utterly wasted in a Roy Hodgson set up.

Edited by joe_cpfc (19 Apr 2019 1.48pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Apr 19 1.54pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

But the team has to be so reliant on him because with absolutely no support from anywhere else on the pitch we have to rely on our most skilful player to make things happen on his own and that's not down to the team thats down to bad management.A player like him should not be running around like a mad man chasing defenders and lost causes and he shouldn't be expected to take on entire defences to make things happen week in week out.If we didn't set up so so defensive every week and get the midfield up a bit there's no way we would be so reliant on him because he'd be getting help and support instead of when he receives the ball not having any help within 30 yards of him.He is completely and utterly wasted in a Roy Hodgson set up.

Edited by joe_cpfc (19 Apr 2019 1.48pm)

I totally agree. Others should step up to the plate and share the load. Ultimately this would be down to the manager to get across.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Apr 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I totally agree. Others should step up to the plate and share the load. Ultimately this would be down to the manager to get across.

In all fairness Zaha is one of the most gifted footballers any of us have seen at Palace. I'm tempted to say he has serious Tekkers but I don't use that type of language. We can hardly expect the rest of the team to be as skillful.
I would like them all to have the best level of determination and grit. Sometimes we have not looked pumped up, to say the least.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Under or over-performing?