This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
VAR so far...
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 03 Sep 19 3.21pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
I have just one question on this topic.
If the boot was on the other foot (so to speak) and we were 0-1 down in added time and the same thing happened to Zaha, what would our feelings be? Exactly the same as how Villa feel now I'd suggest.
Many refs would have given a penalty. I just think the ref. froze and didn't wish to incur the wrath of the home crowd. I think maybe the VAR ref. also flunked it.
...
I could understand a free-kick being given for the Zaha touch to the back but never a penalty. The ref had a very good view.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
Chubskip 03 Sep 19 5.52pm |
|
|
Time to let it go. If it was us I dare say I would feel robbed, but moaning about this still three days after is ridiculous. In fact running up to the officials after the decision has been made or at the end of the game changes nothing. We should take a leaf from the Aussie cricket skipper who just said after Stokes was not given LBW that the decision is made. Time to move on
|
PALACE FOR EVER London 03 Sep 19 6.46pm |
|
|
For me the main reason that Jenas (a past footballer of course) got so annoyed/worked up was the suggestion that a dive took place.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!
[Link]
Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 04 Sep 19 9.40pm |
|
Originally posted by Curlyeagle 2
Palace popularity is poor and I thought Match of the Day was shocking! Not a word about the game or how Palace dominated for most just all about the penalty claim.
I also feel that the boy Grealish will make a rod for his own back. Although a talented player he is petulant and spends a large majority of the game on his arse! This in itself makes it very difficult for referees to decide if it’s a genuine foul or if he’s throwing himself to the floor. In my opinion they got it spot on re the penalty, minimal contact if any just Grealish throwing himself to the floor whilst running at pace.
..when not on the pitch in front of the mirror.
Edited by Tickled pink (04 Sep 2019 9.41pm)
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 04 Sep 19 9.54pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
I have just one question on this topic.
If the boot was on the other foot (so to speak) and we were 0-1 down in added time and the same thing happened to Zaha, what would our feelings be? Exactly the same as how Villa feel now I'd suggest.
Many refs would have given a penalty. I just think the ref. froze and didn't wish to incur the wrath of the home crowd. I think maybe the VAR ref. also flunked it.
I expect Grealish and Zaha will vie for the title of 'most fouled player' this season. Zaha has calmed down, Grealish has not but a few more bookings will do it, just like it has for Zaha.
If we had bought Grealish with the AWB money our prospects would be rosier. I doubt if we will still be in the top ten after 12 games as our two wins were 'ref-assisted' About time the wheel of fortune has changed many will say ...
No, the majority would all realise how lucky we were to have not been four nil down.
|
steven_t92 Orpington 05 Sep 19 7.00am |
|
|
The rose tinted goggles are being worn in this thread.
He passed the ball before clattering into cahill (which did happen). Didnt go down under the touch from zaha, it was the cahill contact that sent them both to the ground. In essence theres no "dive" before he plays the ball to lansbury, which if he was trying to win a penalty he wouldn't have played the ball like that.
It was a goal, referee got it wrong, var got it wrong and we got incredibly lucky!
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 06 Oct 19 10.43am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
I couldn’t see if there was anything posted on this, but we have had a few games to get used to the system and at the moment the decisions seem to have gone our way. You can bet your life we will be on the wrong end of one soon, but what’s everyone’s feeling, personally I don’t like it, the winner against West Ham took way to long to be decided?
I thought the goal looked on side and Jordon Ayew certainly did, that linesman was bang in line and flagged due to West Ham fan pressure behind him....
|
Bangell Oxford 06 Oct 19 10.56am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
Looks very precise when they're analysing the freeze-frames, but VAR has a margin of error that means decisions like the one yesterday, with centimetres in it, are pretty arbitrary. I'll happily take the goal, but going to VAR to overturn non-obvious errors doesn't lead to the correct decision, it's just adding another element of fortune for one team or the other.
Given this and the fact that the system takes so long and drains so much energy from the game and the stands, I'm sure there will be a re-think of how it's implemented next season.
|
Elpis In a pub 06 Oct 19 11.28am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
As the OP suggests the lino may have flagged due to home support pressure . In the same sort of way that you would never expect to get a pen at Old Trafford or Anfield VAR can only even out on the side of the not so big clubs (that's us ) and is why I support it . Not because of the technology but more that I don't trust the officials to make the right call under pressure .
|
EddieMac 06 Oct 19 12.08pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
VAR has been great. It is always a big reason why the league table is now looking a lot more even. The big boys are not getting all the decisions going their way. It will go for you and against you but I would happily wait 90 seconds for the correct outcome.
|
PALACE FOR EVER London 06 Oct 19 12.33pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
Officials have been advised if they are not sure if there is an offside let play go on and if there is a goal then put your flag up. I'm sure this was what happened yesterday.
I only saw this on TV and there is no way an official could say for certain if this was offside or not.I understand that when this is so they give there decision to the attacking side.
Personally I was against VAR and I still are.
There are still many decisions like fouls that VAR is being used for but in the end are being discussed whether the decision was right or wrong like Liverpool's penalty yesterday.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!
[Link]
Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?
|
PZ Eagle Penzance 06 Oct 19 12.35pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
On MoTD last night analysis seemed to suggest Mane dived for Pools winning penalty. No VAR decision which also suggests big clubs at home still will get away with the close calls.
Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.
|
PALACE FOR EVER London 06 Oct 19 1.22pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
On MoTD last night analysis seemed to suggest Mane dived for Pools winning penalty. No VAR decision which also suggests big clubs at home still will get away with the close calls.
The VAR officials probably got their decision correct as their wasn't a 'clear and obvious error' made by the ref.
With VAR we now have two things to talk about in if there were any mistakes or not but the ref's is the most important where fouls are discussed so as you say big clubs at home will still get away with close calls.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!
[Link]
Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?
|
palaceontheup 06 Oct 19 1.25pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
People act like such precious princesses over VAR, never happy. For years it's been..
That was miles onside We've been robbed of a perfectly good goal That will cost us points That could be why we're relegated It's unfair The referee supports the oppo team We never get decisions
VAR comes in and, when it's called on, give the correct and fair decision by analyzing each phase.
We don't want to wait we want it all instantaneous and NOW.
Grow up. As someone else says as long as it gives the correct result 90 seconds is nothing.
Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha
Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Oct 19 1.35pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
On MoTD last night analysis seemed to suggest Mane dived for Pools winning penalty. No VAR decision which also suggests big clubs at home still will get away with the close calls.
Mane felt the contact and went to ground. There was certainly sufficient contact to warrant a penalty and a foul would have been awarded if it was outside the box. Albrighton went down with his head in his hands which would suggest he knew it was a penalty.
|
braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 06 Oct 19 3.09pm |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
i have always been of the opinion that over the space of 38 games decisions even themselves out.
VAR will only help this happen.
you can pick all the holes in it you want...but i think on the whole its a good thing.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|
steeleye20 Croydon 06 Oct 19 5.26pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
This post has been merged from a topic called 'VAR so far...' by bexleydave
Mane felt the contact and went to ground. There was certainly sufficient contact to warrant a penalty and a foul would have been awarded if it was outside the box. Albrighton went down with his head in his hands which would suggest he knew it was a penalty.
No penalty, football cannot be free of contact.
The player clearly dived and should have been red-carded.
Just when I was getting happier with VAR.
The ref gave it under Anfield home team pressure, thought VAR would have seen the end of that.
Plenty of work to do.
|
matthau South Croydon 06 Oct 19 5.34pm |
|
|
I’m sorry but whoever thinks mane one was a penalty is deranged
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Oct 19 6.28pm |
|
|
I stand by my comments. Some have a different viewpoint but such is the nature of football debates. Nothing more for me to add.
|
becky over the moon 06 Oct 19 7.08pm |
|
|
Var so far...... on MOTD last night Alan Shearer decreed that Var got it right
What more could you ask for? -.-'
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers
|