You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Excitement or the premier league.
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Excitement or the premier league.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Casual Flag Orpington 21 Dec 19 7.30pm

Are you more interested in being entertained/excited or not being relegated ?
This isn’t a moan, just been thinking it for a while.
Sometimes I think it would be a relief to be relegated and watch a team that tries to win matches and score goals rather than playing 8 defenders at home games to teams like Watford.
We need something between Pardew (with his 4-5 defeats) and Roy with 3 defensive midfielders in home games.
For a while now I’ve been going to Palace out of habit, rather than really looking forward to it.
As others have said if we get relegated without the ground being improved, what would have been the point? To create a load of 20 year old millionaires?
I’d like the main stand to be re developed as soon as possible, that way we will never end up being moved to Godstone/Purley or somewhere like that.
If I owned the club and was all about the money and staying up, I’d keep Roy until he goes to a nursing home, but other clubs have changed ‘safe’ managers , like Brighton and Millwall and the new boss has completely livened up , pretty much the same players and changed the way they play.
I understand after FDB why Parrish would be reluctant, but as a fan I’d like to celebrate a few goals and watch players that don’t look scared to pass the ball forwards. The biggest buzz I get at Selhurst at the moment is the 5-10 minutes when Meyer comes on.
Can’t knock the manager as his job is to keep us up, but is anyone looking at who is coming in next?
Just seems sometimes that we are looking at the short term money rather than a long term plan.
As I said at the start not a moan, just wondering if our most successful period in our history, is also one of the most boring?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 7.53pm

Originally posted by Casual

Are you more interested in being entertained/excited or not being relegated ?
This isn’t a moan, just been thinking it for a while.
Sometimes I think it would be a relief to be relegated and watch a team that tries to win matches and score goals rather than playing 8 defenders at home games to teams like Watford.
We need something between Pardew (with his 4-5 defeats) and Roy with 3 defensive midfielders in home games.
For a while now I’ve been going to Palace out of habit, rather than really looking forward to it.
As others have said if we get relegated without the ground being improved, what would have been the point? To create a load of 20 year old millionaires?
I’d like the main stand to be re developed as soon as possible, that way we will never end up being moved to Godstone/Purley or somewhere like that.
If I owned the club and was all about the money and staying up, I’d keep Roy until he goes to a nursing home, but other clubs have changed ‘safe’ managers , like Brighton and Millwall and the new boss has completely livened up , pretty much the same players and changed the way they play.
I understand after FDB why Parrish would be reluctant, but as a fan I’d like to celebrate a few goals and watch players that don’t look scared to pass the ball forwards. The biggest buzz I get at Selhurst at the moment is the 5-10 minutes when Meyer comes on.
Can’t knock the manager as his job is to keep us up, but is anyone looking at who is coming in next?
Just seems sometimes that we are looking at the short term money rather than a long term plan.
As I said at the start not a moan, just wondering if our most successful period in our history, is also one of the most boring?

WTF ..this is not league one!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 21 Dec 19 7.55pm

Originally posted by Casual

Are you more interested in being entertained/excited or not being relegated ?
This isn’t a moan, just been thinking it for a while.
Sometimes I think it would be a relief to be relegated and watch a team that tries to win matches and score goals rather than playing 8 defenders at home games to teams like Watford.
We need something between Pardew (with his 4-5 defeats) and Roy with 3 defensive midfielders in home games.
For a while now I’ve been going to Palace out of habit, rather than really looking forward to it.
As others have said if we get relegated without the ground being improved, what would have been the point? To create a load of 20 year old millionaires?
I’d like the main stand to be re developed as soon as possible, that way we will never end up being moved to Godstone/Purley or somewhere like that.
If I owned the club and was all about the money and staying up, I’d keep Roy until he goes to a nursing home, but other clubs have changed ‘safe’ managers , like Brighton and Millwall and the new boss has completely livened up , pretty much the same players and changed the way they play.
I understand after FDB why Parrish would be reluctant, but as a fan I’d like to celebrate a few goals and watch players that don’t look scared to pass the ball forwards. The biggest buzz I get at Selhurst at the moment is the 5-10 minutes when Meyer comes on.
Can’t knock the manager as his job is to keep us up, but is anyone looking at who is coming in next?
Just seems sometimes that we are looking at the short term money rather than a long term plan.
As I said at the start not a moan, just wondering if our most successful period in our history, is also one of the most boring?

That's the big question but all the time we're in the Premier League a lot of the kids are supporting us rather than Chelsea or Arsenal. Also I put up with the sh!t if it means giving it to the plastics once in a while. The wins against Chelsea, City, Arsenal and United are priceless.

One thing for sure is there's no next level without stupid money.


 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 8.03pm

Why is everyone saying we are boring to watch, frustrating we are yes, but boring just because we miss too many opportunities is daft, last season we dominated so many teams and just somehow failed to bang the ball in, Hodgson would look exciting as hell with a simple fit Glen Murray, it's as silly as that.

Results over performances and fans go nuts.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Dec 19 8.07pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

That's the big question but all the time we're in the Premier League a lot of the kids are supporting us rather than Chelsea or Arsenal. Also I put up with the sh!t if it means giving it to the plastics once in a while. The wins against Chelsea, City, Arsenal and United are priceless.

One thing for sure is there's no next level without stupid money.


..Benteke was part our next level, that's Hodgsons fault as well no doubt lol

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 21 Dec 19 9.22pm

now we are an established PL club i would rather we just stayed up & competed around mid-table than did the same in the championship and went into administration within 5 years.

i hold no ill feelings towards pardew as he did a good job for us, his undoing was the plan to play a better brand of football when what he was doing worked just fine.

i hold no ill feelings towards hodgson as he is doing an amazing job for us, i cant slate his subs or his dislike of change as he is (once again) doing an amazing job and takes us forward season on season...i hope he stays another 5 years.

i used to say i would rather be in the championship as its more competitive but f*** it, i would rather have a club to support that didnt have to sell its ground back to its rich owner to avoid a points deduction.

preston currently have the lowest wage budget in the chanpionship at an average of £8000 a week, thats f***ed up & un-sustainable without PL money.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Dec 19 9.26pm

The Premier League could be exciting again if we sorted out our squad. We've got ourselves into a real mess with an ageing squad on big wages, and no exciting young prospects coming through. We need to play Roy's style at the moment, and if we get through and begin to recruit properly (yeah, I'm not optimistic either), we could potentially have an exciting project to watch develop. As things stand though, it's pretty dire.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 21 Dec 19 9.43pm

Originally posted by Bangell

The Premier League could be exciting again if we sorted out our squad. We've got ourselves into a real mess with an ageing squad on big wages, and no exciting young prospects coming through. We need to play Roy's style at the moment, and if we get through and begin to recruit properly (yeah, I'm not optimistic either), we could potentially have an exciting project to watch develop. As things stand though, it's pretty dire.

today we had woods daly & perrick (sp) on the bench, personally i would be happier if we signed nobody in january and brought thru those 3 players, and mitchell to see if they were good enough, we wont get relegated either way but we could save ourselves a fortune in transfer fees, and the idea long term is to invest in the academy to produce 1st team players, well we already have an academy and we dont use it.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


EddieMac Flag 21 Dec 19 11.44pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Why is everyone saying we are boring to watch, frustrating we are yes, but boring just because we miss too many opportunities is daft, last season we dominated so many teams and just somehow failed to bang the ball in, Hodgson would look exciting as hell with a simple fit Glen Murray, it's as silly as that.

Results over performances and fans go nuts.

I agree with you completely. I don’t think we are boring in the slightest. We have a way of playing and it is certainly not 11 men behind the ball and hoof it forward. People seem to have their blinkers on because it is is Roy in charge but we play nice stuff I am a big fan of a decent defence and enjoy watching defenders do their job well which we do.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 22 Dec 19 7.21am

think it only feels boring this year, as we have 'no teeth' up front.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 22 Dec 19 9.01am

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

think it only feels boring this year, as we have 'no teeth' up front.

Souarez on loan in January then?

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Dec 19 9.27am

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

think it only feels boring this year, as we have 'no teeth' up front.

Yeah you are probably right. For me the most exciting times have always been when we have a proper goal scoring striker , that can get a goal from nothing. Wright, Bright, Armstrong, Jansen,AJ, Murray.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Dec 19 9.33am

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

think it only feels boring this year, as we have 'no teeth' up front.

I believe we do have teeth up front - yes, not as good as top 6 / 8 teams but how we play with a defensive midfield doesn’t allow us to attack. Our forwards also play in a defensive way supporting the midfield - we don’t use creativity in midfield which slows our attacking down and allows teams to easily defend against us. Meyer and Camarasa don’t get a look in as that would disturb the set up which has got us above the bottom 3. Yesterday was a good example of all Palace matches I watch with plenty of passing the ball back or sideways and making sure the defence doesn’t get broken down. Only once did I think we would score and McCarthur fell over :-(

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Dec 19 9.47am

Originally posted by palace chick

I believe we do have teeth up front - yes, not as good as top 6 / 8 teams but how we play with a defensive midfield doesn’t allow us to attack. Our forwards also play in a defensive way supporting the midfield - we don’t use creativity in midfield which slows our attacking down and allows teams to easily defend against us. Meyer and Camarasa don’t get a look in as that would disturb the set up which has got us above the bottom 3. Yesterday was a good example of all Palace matches I watch with plenty of passing the ball back or sideways and making sure the defence doesn’t get broken down. Only once did I think we would score and McCarthur fell over :-(


We will never score many goals when we are playing 8 defensively out of 11. Not sure our back 4 is as good as we think, but they have 3 others playing just in front of them helping them out.
It’s a tough one as it keeps us up each year, but the goals are on the low side.
Earlier someone said that none of the 3 in the middle have scored a goal this season (apart from penalties) there can’t be another team in the league with stats like that.
I know football has changed, but our previous decent teams have been decent at the back but always nicked a few goals from midfielders, Gray, Thomas, Hughes etc.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 22 Dec 19 10.06am

Originally posted by Casual


We will never score many goals when we are playing 8 defensively out of 11. Not sure our back 4 is as good as we think, but they have 3 others playing just in front of them helping them out.
It’s a tough one as it keeps us up each year, but the goals are on the low side.
Earlier someone said that none of the 3 in the middle have scored a goal this season (apart from penalties) there can’t be another team in the league with stats like that.
I know football has changed, but our previous decent teams have been decent at the back but always nicked a few goals from midfielders, Gray, Thomas, Hughes etc.

My favourite Palace player. If we had anybody in the midfield with his attacking presence now we would be far more effective in front of goal. Fondly remember a game at White Hart Lane where everybody was expecting Gazza to shine but Geoff stole the show. A creator and brilliant captain who would push the team forward. With Bright and Wright in a formidable attack was the real link to them.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Dec 19 10.33am

It also doesn’t help the way we play that chances don’t come anymore from set play. Our dead ball deliveries from Luka are so poor these days?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Dec 19 10.45am

For me the big reason why we have lacked attacking spark this season in many games is that Ward, and now Kelly, are not great at getting forward and Townsend has either been out of form or unfit for much of the season. Last year AWB and PvA got forward and supported Wilf and Andros and all that was missing was a goal scorer; Batshuayi came in and Bobs your uncle we climbed the table with verve and vigour. I lay the blame for this season's performances not at Roy's door but at the club for failing to sign neither a replacement for AWB or Batshuayi. We also clearly needed a back up winger, which has blown up in our faces again.

Having three holding midfielders can actually work if it allows the fullbacks to push on and the wingers to have more freedom, but at the current time our squad deficiencies are showing through. Meyer came on yesterday and once again showed his main weakness as Shelvey held him off like he was a small boy. For all his fans I just don't see how he fits in with the way we play other than as an impact sub? I thought McCarthy added some bite and with a few more games under his belt will be a strong asset.

Some games have been awful to watch this year and just when we seem to be finding our feet again and playing slightly more attacking football this has usually tied in with Andros starting. PvA coming back yesterday made a big difference as when he was out we really were impotent.

For me, if we have to endure this in the short-term then so be it, but the club can't go into next season and expect Roy to work miracles again. I just hope we do something in January to at least ensure we have the players to keep us up this year.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Dec 19 11.08am

I do agree to an extent with the original poster but for a club like Palace we really are achieving what we are capable of. To go to the next level playing free flowing football would cost 100’s of millions. Clearly the model for us is to emulate Leicester. That is easier said than done. But if we had a Jamie Vardy we would be challenging the top 6 even with our current squad. If we had scored another 10 goals this season we would most likely have another 10 points and be in a CL spot. Fine margins indeed.
The one thing I would love is for us to win something. An FA cup triumph would be fantastic. Trouble is with our injuries I suspect the u23,s will get a run out v Derby.
We all know that relegation would be a disaster for us financially. If we were to go this season or next apart from some decent memories there is nothing tangible to show from our extended stay in the top flight. That has to be a huge disappointment.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Dec 19 11.37am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I do agree to an extent with the original poster but for a club like Palace we really are achieving what we are capable of. To go to the next level playing free flowing football would cost 100’s of millions. Clearly the model for us is to emulate Leicester. That is easier said than done. But if we had a Jamie Vardy we would be challenging the top 6 even with our current squad. If we had scored another 10 goals this season we would most likely have another 10 points and be in a CL spot. Fine margins indeed.
The one thing I would love is for us to win something. An FA cup triumph would be fantastic. Trouble is with our injuries I suspect the u23,s will get a run out v Derby.
We all know that relegation would be a disaster for us financially. If we were to go this season or next apart from some decent memories there is nothing tangible to show from our extended stay in the top flight. That has to be a huge disappointment.

I agree, a cup final appearance and dare I say a win will live with us forever. Eventually we will be back in the lower division and having nothing to show for these seasons in the prem will be a missed opportunity. Especially for us old geezers as the time to see an FA cup final win gets less and less :-(

 

cpj Flag Kent 22 Dec 19 12.19pm

I suspect a lot go to watch matches to get some relief from the tedium of their working lives, to let off steam by having a good shout /sing and hopefully to get excited by seeing your team produce attacking football and score some goals. Under Roy that just does not happen. With the 3 midfielders he uses he is effectively playing with 7 defenders. Nothing ever changes, regardless of the opposition of the state of the game. The same subs are nearly always made (like for like) and the same predictable set-pieces are used. We have scored just 4 times in the first half of our 18 games this season and two of those were penalties. 12 of our games have been 0-0 at half-time. Sorry, but under Roy it's just so boring to watch. The annoying thing is that when he does let the players attack (normnally the last 15 mins) we actually play some decent football.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Excitement or the premier league.