You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The James McCarthy thread


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
mattteo Flag 18 Jan 20 10.01pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

But we just drew at Man City and are 9th, Brighton are playing a more expansive game, where are they?
I would like us to play a more attacking entertaining style but what we are doing is working at the moment

It worked for WBA, Stoke or Burnley "at the moment". But then..?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Jan 20 10.25pm

Originally posted by mattteo

It worked for WBA, Stoke or Burnley "at the moment". But then..?

Basically, Stoke and West Brom did the same thing. They wanted a better display of football, like many on here, including you, and sacked the manager..... Tony Pulis

Not sure why Burnley are so sh!te, but they can fcuk off anyway! Nobody likes them

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 18 Jan 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I know how Roy plays and that he uses 3 central midfielders. I just don't think it's a good way to play. I'm writing this as we drew 2-2 away at Man City, so I'm going into the lion's den, but in the long term, I think it's horrible to be the team with least goals scored in the Premier League. It may very well get us relegated in a relatively short period, just as WBA got relegated after they had finished 7th the previous year with the best defense. Stoke never recovered and started scoring after the Tony Pulis period either. Burnley had the best defense in the PL 1-2 years ago and now they're almost down.

Youngsters need to be taught that they have to score 3-4 times in a match. If they become accustomed to defending a lot and having just 2 chances per game....they will never recover scoring form. The more chances you make in a game, the better your players will become with time. The more goals the attacking players score, the higher their price goes. So, even in case of less points, you still get to be more financially stable, cause you sell at a higher price.

Edited by mattteo (18 Jan 2020 9.27pm)

Whilst I sort of get where you are coming from I agree that we could do with a more attack minded and creative midfielder and most on here would agree with you. I do not think we are a Stoke, WBA or Burnley we are a Palace . McCarthy cost very little and is able to contribute as well as anyone in our midfield and as such is a great squad player in our set up. Your desire for a different midfielder should not label McCarthy as not worthy of being in our squad as it is. What you are really indicatingI think , forgive me if I am wrong, is that you would prefer us to be playing in a different style with different players but as we are not please don’t judge McCarthy in a system we do not play.
McCarthy fits our system COYP

 

mattteo Flag 18 Jan 20 10.46pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3502625]

Basically, Stoke and West Brom did the same thing. They wanted a better display of football, like many on here, including you, and sacked the manager..... Tony Pulis

Not sure why Burnley are so sh!te, but they can fcuk off anyway! Nobody likes them

From my point of view, it was Tony Pulis that got Stoke and WBA relegated, not that they replaced Tony Pulis. He was last when he got fired from WBA, so if they got relegated after that, it's on him too. And Stoke never really recovered after he was forcing his players to be so defensive. Sure, Mark Hughes had some years, but he was not really an improvement as manager.

Pulis went to Middlesbrough too and, even though they were one of the most powerful teams in the Championship on paper and were trying to get a promotion, they had the worst goal tally from the Top 8, failed to gain that promotion and eventually sacked Pulis after a series of bad results too. Now they will have to wait years for a new manager to fix what Pulis did.

Chelsea is a good example of how defensive tactics damage a team but how you can come out of it. Conte gave them a title but 3 bad years after that. Basically, they let the "young blood" and talented players roam free and play attacking football, so now we have Mount, Abraham, Pulisic, Hudson Odoi, Batshuayi, Barkley, Loftus Cheek (when he's not injured) instead of Giroud, Bakayoko, Matic, Pedro, Moses.

 

mattteo Flag 18 Jan 20 10.49pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

McCarthy cost very little and is able to contribute as well as anyone in our midfield and as such is a great squad player in our set up. Your desire for a different midfielder should not label McCarthy as not worthy of being in our squad as it is.

I'm not against McCarthy himself and I think that if he plays like this, then he really proves himself. I'm just saying I wouldn't keep all 3 of Kouyate, McCarthy and Luka in a 25 men squad.

Hard to chose though. Kouyate has probably been the best. McCarthy has been good for his price. Luka has been captain (penalties don't count). But he is 28 already and maybe if a 20 million offer would come, it would be good to let him go, cause it will not happen after 30.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 18 Jan 20 10.56pm

I haven’t rated him that much.... until today.

Watch a replay, he covered DeBreyne all game, plus attacking during the breaks. His best game as a palace player by far.

Just watch off the ball, he was never more then 3 yards off DeBreyne.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Jan 20 10.57pm

Originally posted by mattteo

From my point of view, it was Tony Pulis that got Stoke and WBA relegated, not that they replaced Tony Pulis. He was last when he got fired from WBA, so if they got relegated after that, it's on him too. And Stoke never really recovered after he was forcing his players to be so defensive. Sure, Mark Hughes had some years, but he was not really an improvement as manager.

Pulis went to Middlesbrough too and, even though they were one of the most powerful teams in the Championship on paper and were trying to get a promotion, they had the worst goal tally from the Top 8, failed to gain that promotion and eventually sacked Pulis after a series of bad results too. Now they will have to wait years for a new manager to fix what Pulis did.

Chelsea is a good example of how defensive tactics damage a team but how you can come out of it. Conte gave them a title but 3 bad years after that. Basically, they let the "young blood" and talented players roam free and play attacking football, so now we have Mount, Abraham, Pulisic, Hudson Odoi, Batshuayi, Barkley, Loftus Cheek (when he's not injured) instead of Giroud, Bakayoko, Matic, Pedro, Moses.

We are different. We survived Pulis. We don't have Chelsea's finances or acadamy.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

The Dolphin Flag 19 Jan 20 7.10am

I think that our injuries of late have forced the way we have played on us.
McCarthy will be better as we get stronger now he is fit.
With Tosun now able to be a focal point he will blossom.
The way he won the ball an set Wilf off yesterday was brilliant!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jan 20 9.53am

Originally posted by mattteo

From my point of view, it was Tony Pulis that got Stoke and WBA relegated, not that they replaced Tony Pulis. He was last when he got fired from WBA, so if they got relegated after that, it's on him too. And Stoke never really recovered after he was forcing his players to be so defensive. Sure, Mark Hughes had some years, but he was not really an improvement as manager.

Pulis went to Middlesbrough too and, even though they were one of the most powerful teams in the Championship on paper and were trying to get a promotion, they had the worst goal tally from the Top 8, failed to gain that promotion and eventually sacked Pulis after a series of bad results too. Now they will have to wait years for a new manager to fix what Pulis did.

Chelsea is a good example of how defensive tactics damage a team but how you can come out of it. Conte gave them a title but 3 bad years after that. Basically, they let the "young blood" and talented players roam free and play attacking football, so now we have Mount, Abraham, Pulisic, Hudson Odoi, Batshuayi, Barkley, Loftus Cheek (when he's not injured) instead of Giroud, Bakayoko, Matic, Pedro, Moses.

When Pulis left WBA after 12 games they were in 17th place, so not in the relegation zone.
They had lost 4 games on the bounce when he was sacked and this followed on from the previous season when they lost 9 of their last 12 games.

In terms of Middlesbrough, they did suffer a dip of 6 consecutive defeats which took them out of the top 6 but they won 4 of their last 5 games and finished in 7th place.Pulis's contract was not extended so one can assume that the expectations of the club were not realised.

Edited by Willo (19 Jan 2020 10.02am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 20 10.27am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I think that our injuries of late have forced the way we have played on us.
McCarthy will be better as we get stronger now he is fit.
With Tosun now able to be a focal point he will blossom.
The way he won the ball an set Wilf off yesterday was brilliant!

I agree, I think he is only just reaching full match fitness and the best is yet to come. He is a very good player and it is really a toss up as to who should start as the 3 out of 4; Milivojevic, Kouyate, McCarthy, McArthur? My current preference is to leave Luka out.

 

Kant Flag exeter 19 Jan 20 12.56pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Good to see his dead ball delivery. Hopefully he can keep that on full time. Finally we score from a corner

This could give us a useful alternative option. Our free kicks and corners have been so dire for ages. He also seemed to have a good relationship with Tosun, also ex Everton, that could be a positive.

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Jan 20 3.03pm

I think there are many who judge players way too soon and expect them to play at their maximum after a couple of games.

McCarthy will be an asset next season after his run outs this season and a full pre season behind him, I expect all will be raving about his energy, tenacity and commitment.

Why do people not take a balanced view after games, players will have good performances and so-so performances maybe the next game but people post he was great this game then after the next game he was crap and fully get emotional about it!

We have the second best points tally at this stage in the prem and defensively we tend to be sound. McCarthy will be the cog that protects / screens the back 4 with aplomb next season.

Look at his qualities and compliment these as he is working his way back to his natural game and that will take this season for him to get into stride and pattern.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 19 Jan 20 3.37pm

Originally posted by Nubes

I think there are many who judge players way too soon and expect them to play at their maximum after a couple of games.

McCarthy will be an asset next season after his run outs this season and a full pre season behind him, I expect all will be raving about his energy, tenacity and commitment.

Why do people not take a balanced view after games, players will have good performances and so-so performances maybe the next game but people post he was great this game then after the next game he was crap and fully get emotional about it!

We have the second best points tally at this stage in the prem and defensively we tend to be sound. McCarthy will be the cog that protects / screens the back 4 with aplomb next season.

Look at his qualities and compliment these as he is working his way back to his natural game and that will take this season for him to get into stride and pattern.

I agree - I was holding out for him but what concerned me was not his going in hard, he seemed to be doing it cos he was a fraction off the pace so had to make up for lack of anticipation, and anticipation is not directly connected to fitness levels, and some simple passes were going astray but he was wonderful yesterday, just when you give up you get pleasantly surprised - young prospects yes, but these are the types of signing we need to make, not marguee but bargain basement, like the Ayew signing - quality at great value.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Feb 20 10.31am

I have to say we are really starting to see the best from McCarthy now. Strong in the tackle, has a good engine and his dead ball delivery is certainly no worse than Luka's! I thought he had another good game on Saturday and is proving to be another shrewd piece of business.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Feb 20 10.43am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I have to say we are really starting to see the best from McCarthy now. Strong in the tackle, has a good engine and his dead ball delivery is certainly no worse than Luka's! I thought he had another good game on Saturday and is proving to be another shrewd piece of business.

He’s getting better with more games. It might have helped him and us getting in the team without a full season ahead of him.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 20 10.44am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I have to say we are really starting to see the best from McCarthy now. Strong in the tackle, has a good engine and his dead ball delivery is certainly no worse than Luka's! I thought he had another good game on Saturday and is proving to be another shrewd piece of business.

He had a good game.
Mick McCarthy was at the game on Saturday so might have attended to cast an eye over his namesake.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 24 Feb 20 8.55pm

He was previously very well thought of at Everton. 2 full seasons and we have a huge bargain on our hands.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

EddieMac Flag 25 Feb 20 7.43am

He could turn out to be an absolute bargain. Injury has hampered his career big time but he is a top player and will only get better for us.

Our board gets crucified for lack of signings in critical positions, and rightly so but a lot of credit needs to be given for Cahill, McCarthy, Ayew, Tomkins, Kouyate. 5 regular first teasers who didn’t break the bank.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Feb 20 8.07am

Really growing in stature now. Just hopes he keeps his place. At long last probably through injury, squad rotation is starting to work. Just hope our manager tells the players to shoot a bit more.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Feb 20 8.30am

Originally posted by EddieMac

He could turn out to be an absolute bargain. Injury has hampered his career big time but he is a top player and will only get better for us.

Our board gets crucified for lack of signings in critical positions, and rightly so but a lot of credit needs to be given for Cahill, McCarthy, Ayew, Tomkins, Kouyate. 5 regular first teasers who didn’t break the bank.

And Guaita

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread