You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Vincente Guaita - best keeper in the Prem?
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Vincente Guaita - best keeper in the Prem?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
pssguy Flag 11 Mar 20 8.38am

Originally posted by pssguy

I disagree. There is no way he would have made the howlers Ederson and Lloris have coughed up in the last few days. de Gea is well past his best, Kepa out of favour and Pickford a bit of a joke.
I think we have the best goals allowed to expected goals against in the league and a lot of that is down to him

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Mar 20 8.43am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

wonder how Nige would do in today's prem. vg's kicking is a weakness but it's levels better than Nige's (as I remember it, anyway). (yes Nige was a great keeper and a Palace hero)

I don’t like to compare players from different eras because the football styles change. Goalkeepers are now svelte figures, and being protected by refs has helped that happen. Many keepers including Nigel Martyn. Nigel used to treat his wife to pasty and chips at a local chippy on Saturday nights after he returned from away games. True! The glamour! And that was probably his second meal and possibly chippy meal of the night.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Mar 20 8.49am

Originally posted by pssguy

I disagree. There is no way hew would have made the howlers Ederson and Lloris have coughed up in the last few days. de Gea is well past his best, Kepa out of favour and Pickford a bit of a joke.
I think we have the best goals allowed to expected goals against in the league and a lot of that is down to him

Every goalkeeper makes a costly mistake, even Guaita who as we all know was responsible for a howler against Sheff Utd.

He has been excellent for us this season and worthy of plaudits but alas I don't place him higher in the 'Totem Pole' than the likes of Alisson,Ederson, De Gea, Pope etc.We all have our opinions about players and of course there are a divergence of views!

Edited by Willo (11 Mar 2020 8.49am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Mar 20 8.57am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t like to compare players from different eras because the football styles change. Goalkeepers are now svelte figures, and being protected by refs has helped that happen. Many keepers including Nigel Martyn. Nigel used to treat his wife to pasty and chips at a local chippy on Saturday nights after he returned from away games. True! The glamour! And that was probably his second meal and possibly chippy meal of the night.

I have met Nigel and Amanda on quite a few occasions.
Genuinely lovely people with no airs and graces.They are the very quintessence of respectability.They are now resident in the Harrogate area.

 

cpj Flag Kent 11 Mar 20 10.18am

Originally posted by Casual

Would probably be in the relegation zone if flapper was in goal this season.
Guaita is quality. Levels and levels and levels above Hennessy.

No need for nasty comments from the WH-haters! You call WH 'flapper' yet VG is the one who has trouble catching the ball from crosses preferring to punch at any opportunity, and I certainly cannot remember WH ever dropping a corner into his own goal. Both are decent keepers who make the odd mistake as all keepers do. The trouble with this board is that people either think certain of our players are the best in the world or the worst when the truth is neither.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 10.20am

Originally posted by pssguy

I disagree. There is no way hew would have made the howlers Ederson and Lloris have coughed up in the last few days. de Gea is well past his best, Kepa out of favour and Pickford a bit of a joke.
I think we have the best goals allowed to expected goals against in the league and a lot of that is down to him


Hes gone all taffy on us

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 10.21am

Originally posted by cpj

No need for nasty comments from the WH-haters! You call WH 'flapper' yet VG is the one who has trouble catching the ball from crosses preferring to punch at any opportunity, and I certainly cannot remember WH ever dropping a corner into his own goal. Both are decent keepers who make the odd mistake as all keepers do. The trouble with this board is that people either think certain of our players are the best in the world or the worst when the truth is neither.

Picked it out of the corner a few times though.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Mar 20 10.37am

For my part, I think we should be grateful that we have the Wales GK as our no 2.
BUT back to Guaita, I'll repeat an earlier comment that I believe that THIS SEASON he is amongst the best in the Prem. Some of the Big Teams' stars have been slipping off their perches as has England's so-called no 1 (who, of course, kindly let Benteke score a goal).
The proof re Guaita's status should come this summer when we see, who, if any, makes a bid for him.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 11 Mar 20 10.41am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Mrs Hennessey,

Please make sure Wayne has three shredded wheat so he doesn’t get knocked off course to jump 3 inches to catch those high balls.

Yours
All at CPFC

Wayne Hennessey pffffft don’t make us laugh.

Not up to your usual standard of humour , like Marco Silva is a great manager and is just unlucky all his teams in the prem turned to rubbish , and every Palace win is just lucky . Very disappointing.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Mar 20 10.45am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Not up to your usual standard of humour , like Marco Silva is a great manager and is just unlucky all his teams in the prem turned to rubbish , and every Palace win is just lucky . Very disappointing.

So you’re in the Wayney gang then?

 


COYP

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 11 Mar 20 12.40pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So you’re in the Wayney gang then?

No , I am in the Palace gang .

Proud of my club and what it has achieved , and not bleating about being lucky just because it doesn't fit
in with what I think it should be doing and hoping it does badly so it looks like I am right.

Try it , it's great being a Palace fan when we are in the best spell in the clubs history.

That goes to all the other whingers too.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Mar 20 1.33pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Picked it out of the corner a few times though.

Name a keeper, that hasn’t.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 11 Mar 20 1.36pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

No , I am in the Palace gang .

Proud of my club and what it has achieved , and not bleating about being lucky just because it doesn't fit
in with what I think it should be doing and hoping it does badly so it looks like I am right.

Try it , it's great being a Palace fan when we are in the best spell in the clubs history.

That goes to all the other whingers too.

Top post MKCPFC.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 11 Mar 20 1.50pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

No , I am in the Palace gang .

Proud of my club and what it has achieved , and not bleating about being lucky just because it doesn't fit
in with what I think it should be doing and hoping it does badly so it looks like I am right.

Try it , it's great being a Palace fan when we are in the best spell in the clubs history.

That goes to all the other whingers too.

Could not agree more MK you can count me in the Palace gang as well.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Mar 20 1.59pm

I see long distance supporters find it easier to watch. I understand why Roy is manager, but I can also see how we’ve got here so the coming years are key rather than celebrating the club’s greatest ever period when it could all amount to less than when we started.

I’ve invested time and money for years so have no warped agenda. D rather the right people got it right to begin with rather than winging it and passing the issues onto others who don’t have the experience either. Hope that clears up the confusion.

Anyway, Hennessey isn’t fit to coach or train Guaita if it came to it.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 7.25pm

Originally posted by Painter

Name a keeper, that hasn’t.

My mrs.
She keeps me.
Not financially but in other ways

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 12 Mar 20 12.19am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I see long distance supporters find it easier to watch. I understand why Roy is manager, but I can also see how we’ve got here so the coming years are key rather than celebrating the club’s greatest ever period when it could all amount to less than when we started.

I’ve invested time and money for years so have no warped agenda. D rather the right people got it right to begin with rather than winging it and passing the issues onto others who don’t have the experience either. Hope that clears up the confusion.

Anyway, Hennessey isn’t fit to coach or train Guaita if it came to it.

Sorry to break the bad news, but you have wasted a lot of time and money supporting the wrong club.

You are wasting even more time posting this sort of twaddle.

Just proves how badly you want the club to fail to say you were right.
Just remember how long you have been wrong for if it goes how you want it.

 

whatton Flag Stirling 19 Mar 20 12.06am

 


RGW

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 19 Mar 20 11.07pm

Guaita is a brilliant shot stopper, his presence fills our defenders with confidence and he seems an awfully nice and down to earth guy. Would not swap him for any goalie in the world - just so happy he signed for us.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 22 Mar 20 4.46pm

Yes he is and currently the stats support this.

 


Bring back Brolin

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Vincente Guaita - best keeper in the Prem?