This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
As we approach the end of our seventh year in the Premier League, are we actually any better than that first season in the division? According to Google our wage bill in that first season was £46m which has increased by 63% to £72m this time, the eighth highest in the league and more than Leicester, Burnley, Wolves, Newcastle and Burnley. Our wage bill is more than double Wolves and over 5x more than Sheff Utd according to this table... [Link] That season we finished 11th with 45 points, 33 goals scored, 48 goals conceded and a goal difference of -15. This year, after 33 matches, we have 42 points, 28 goals scored, 40 conceded and a GD of -12. With fixtures against Chelsea, Villa, United, Wolves and Spurs remaining we *might* beat that points total but I'd happily wager that our finishing position, goals scored, goals conceded and, as a result, goal difference will all be worse. Player for player if you look at our squad that season then not many of them would get into our current side. We'd definitely take 2013/14 Bolasie and I think most would agree that getting rid of Murray and Gayle were errors, that's probably it though. Our transfer model is extremely short-termist and basically seems to be paying as little as possible on transfer fees and recruiting 'experienced' players with the lure of high wages. This season, for example, we've brought in Cahill, McCarthy and Ayew for a combined £5/6m but they reportedly earn around £150,000 a week in wages combined (Cahil £75k, McCarthy £50k and Ayew £25k). Though Cahill and Ayew in particular have been good signings, it's such a short term approach. They have an average age over 30 and would have minimal sell on value even despite Ayew's heroics. As I said in the match thread yesterday, I'm certainly not saying I miss the days of Pardew and the seven goal thrillers that came with it but there has to be some sort of middle ground where we can show some sort of attacking intent in games whilst still staying relatively solid. We always hear about our huge catchment area in terms of young fans and players but which youngsters will have watched our recent games and thought Palace are the club for them? Indeed, what is the point of a shiny new academy if the only time we will give our youngsters a chance is when the manager has no other option? In my opinion we are at best standing still, if not slowly going backwards and, unless we make a huge effort to alter our philosophy this summer and inject some youth and ambition into our squad and playing style, I fear for us next year. Here is the Wiki page for that first season up in case you want to have a look... [Link] Edited by Canterbury Palace (05 Jul 2020 10.56am)
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
I don’t see much difference to be honest.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
I would like to see a central midfield set up that operated more like we did back then with two screening and one more advanced. Think we could do this with Reideweld playing alongside one of Mcarthur, Mcarthy, Luka, Kouyate in the two screening roles, with Reideweld utilising his passing ability from slightly deeper areas. Then play Meyer in the more advanced central role where he can play between the lines and link things together. I think in doing this it gives us better options across the pitch rather than just passing it to Wilf whether he is in space or marked by two players. I have liked what I have seen from Reideweld so far albeit he needs to get a bit fitter/ more minutes in his legs and the mixture of his passing ability with a decent work ethic to break things up make him a decent option. Originally posted by PatrickA
Interesting summary.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
We're still there, still competing. I agree that the team that went up was a good one and that the current team need a major freshening up. There are no teams that consistently, year after year, achieve their potential. We are a club with a championship infrastructure competing in the premier league. It will never be pretty until we put that right. I just wish the club would take a more long term view and invest in our future. I wish less of our fans were wanting and moaning for more short term spending. Yep, undeniable. However, so are Bournemouth, Burnley and Sheffield United, the latter two of whom look set for a better season than we've ever managed on a fraction of the wage bill. The first few seasons in the league you can understand a pragmatic approach, especially given that we started every season terribly and were desperately trying to play catch up. However, we've had Roy for a few seasons now and we still play like the underdog against every single side. There's just no hint of a developing philosophy other than uber-negative and, although I haven't been impressed with Wilf at all this season, I don't particularly blame him for wanting to go to a more progressive side. We should be doing better considering the money we pay players.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
As we approach the end of our seventh year in the Premier League, are we actually any better than that first season in the division? According to Google our wage bill in that first season was £46m which has increased by 63% to £72m this time, the eighth highest in the league and more than Leicester, Burnley, Wolves, Newcastle and Burnley. Our wage bill is more than double Wolves and over 5x more than Sheff Utd according to this table... [Link] That season we finished 11th with 45 points, 33 goals scored, 48 goals conceded and a goal difference of -15. This year, after 33 matches, we have 42 points, 28 goals scored, 40 conceded and a GD of -12. With fixtures against Chelsea, Villa, United, Wolves and Spurs remaining we *might* beat that points total but I'd happily wager that our finishing position, goals scored, goals conceded and, as a result, goal difference will all be worse. Player for player if you look at our squad that season then not many of them would get into our current side. We'd definitely take 2013/14 Bolasie and I think most would agree that getting rid of Murray and Gayle were errors, that's probably it though. Our transfer model is extremely short-termist and basically seems to be paying as little as possible on transfer fees and recruiting 'experienced' players with the lure of high wages. This season, for example, we've brought in Cahill, McCarthy and Ayew for a combined £5/6m but they reportedly earn around £150,000 a week in wages combined (Cahil £75k, McCarthy £50k and Ayew £25k). Though Cahill and Ayew in particular have been good signings, it's such a short term approach. They have an average age over 30 and would have minimal sell on value even despite Ayew's heroics. As I said in the match thread yesterday, I'm certainly not saying I miss the days of Pardew and the seven goal thrillers that came with it but there has to be some sort of middle ground where we can show some sort of attacking intent in games whilst still staying relatively solid. We always hear about our huge catchment area in terms of young fans and players but which youngsters will have watched our recent games and thought Palace are the club for them? Indeed, what is the point of a shiny new academy if the only time we will give our youngsters a chance is when the manager has no other option? In my opinion we are at best standing still, if not slowly going backwards and, unless we make a huge effort to alter our philosophy this summer and inject some youth and ambition into our squad and playing style, I fear for us next year. Here is the Wiki page for that first season up in case you want to have a look... [Link] Edited by Canterbury Palace (05 Jul 2020 10.56am) I think we are much better than when we were promoted. But each season will be much the same as the last - the race to the required number of points to stay up. Without a mega cash injection that's the reality. Questioning the Academy investment in the way you have suggests that you have totally missed the rationale behind it. Think about it - it's a project for the long term and Hodgson will be but a memory by the time that bears fruit. So you won't be able to blame him if the youngsters don't get a chance ! I do agree that the club is being run on a short term basis. Hopefully the investment in the Academy is a sign that things are changing - they need to.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I think we are much better than when we were promoted. But each season will be much the same as the last - the race to the required number of points to stay up. Without a mega cash injection that's the reality. Questioning the Academy investment in the way you have suggests that you have totally missed the rationale behind it. Think about it - it's a project for the long term and Hodgson will be but a memory by the time that bears fruit. So you won't be able to blame him if the youngsters don't get a chance ! I do agree that the club is being run on a short term basis. Hopefully the investment in the Academy is a sign that things are changing - they need to.
In terms of the cash injection, as I mentioned we are comfortably outspending clubs who are significantly outperforming us when it comes to wages so it's not like we're not investing anything, I just don't think we're investing it particularly well. That's a fair point about the academy, I hadn't considered it like that. I suppose we will see our true intent with the post-Roy appointment, whether it is someone youth orientated or not.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Nubes
I really don’t understand the constant pessimistic view towards the upcoming season, regarding relegation. We have been in the league for a number of seasons and what I think people want to actually happen is the club get relegated just for them to say ‘I told you so’ People actually wishing the Championship on us, no thanks, been there done that, appreciate that we are in the Prem and not scratching around playing teams that don’t provide any real appetite to leave your home for. Can’t people see, Big Sam, hugely experienced, Pulis was hugely experienced, Roy Hugely experienced, not getting relegated!!!! Yes the football can be brain numbing my boring, but look at our points in relation to Norwich, Bournemouth and villa and for all the Angst on here we are not worrying about relegation. I just think a lot of people are not happy unless they are moaning and hoping we get relegated do they can points score. We are a better team now - as the players we have now are established top level performers in comparison to the players who came up from the championship!
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
I totally agree with you Canterbury and thank you for your original post to.. Very informative and must have taken some research and effort so fair play.. Like you I'm of the opinion that surely no fan secretly wants us relegated??.. However in this day an age who knows how bizarre some people think!! It's interesting recent threads/comments etc.. The majority of my mates are Chelsea fans and when I've raised concerns about RH and how we play they can't get there heads round it and the stock answer is 'better the devil you know' and Hodgson does a job for us... Obviously I can't get them to come and watch what us Palace fans watch week in week out!! Are we better than our 1st season??.. Individual player wise without a doubt but I like you have serious concerns at where our club is heading and the football (or lack of) we are playing. How much more can a 72 year old offer us??.. His total disregard of any player (bar wilf) who has some flair to his game is very concerning for me.
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!! |
|
|
Which of our flair players are being disregarded? Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
I totally agree with you Canterbury and thank you for your original post to.. Very informative and must have taken some research and effort so fair play.. Like you I'm of the opinion that surely no fan secretly wants us relegated??.. However in this day an age who knows how bizarre some people think!! It's interesting recent threads/comments etc.. The majority of my mates are Chelsea fans and when I've raised concerns about RH and how we play they can't get there heads round it and the stock answer is 'better the devil you know' and Hodgson does a job for us... Obviously I can't get them to come and watch what us Palace fans watch week in week out!! Are we better than our 1st season??.. Individual player wise without a doubt but I like you have serious concerns at where our club is heading and the football (or lack of) we are playing. How much more can a 72 year old offer us??.. His total disregard of any player (bar wilf) who has some flair to his game is very concerning for me.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
In terms of the cash injection, as I mentioned we are comfortably outspending clubs who are significantly outperforming us when it comes to wages so it's not like we're not investing anything, I just don't think we're investing it particularly well. That's a fair point about the academy, I hadn't considered it like that. I suppose we will see our true intent with the post-Roy appointment, whether it is someone youth orientated or not. Well when we got promoted, we had Ian Holloway as our manager. Just stop and think about that one for a moment ! Add in the players that we were able to attract to the club at that time - a multitude of mediocrity. Since then we have signed a far higher calibre of player.So yes, we are better than when we were promoted. People will always find something to moan about. But I have been supporting Palace since 1967 and I am celebrating the fact that we have retained our Premier League status for 8 consecutive years. For a club of our size I see that as a real achievement. It's very easy to point fingers at the way the club is being run and of course mistakes have been made, but I think overall Steve Parish has done a great job. There are some challenges ahead in terms of the short term managerial situation and a squad in need of refreshing, but I believe these issues have been recognised and will be addressed.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Well when we got promoted, we had Ian Holloway as our manager. Just stop and think about that one for a moment ! Add in the players that we were able to attract to the club at that time - a multitude of mediocrity. Since then we have signed a far higher calibre of player.So yes, we are better than when we were promoted. People will always find something to moan about. But I have been supporting Palace since 1967 and I am celebrating the fact that we have retained our Premier League status for 8 consecutive years. For a club of our size I see that as a real achievement. It's very easy to point fingers at the way the club is being run and of course mistakes have been made, but I think overall Steve Parish has done a great job. There are some challenges ahead in terms of the short term managerial situation and a squad in need of refreshing, but I believe these issues have been recognised and will be addressed. With you to the last line NEILLO on squad refreshment. To have allowed it to have reached this point is mismanagement. You want a fistful of academy players with genuine potential plying their trade on loan or in development and the club attracting players of the right vintage and quality who will not just use us as a negotiating ploy to get into West Ham. I suppose we will see how the club proposes to address this from the end of this month.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.