This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
I totally disagree with the whole 'we were s*** for years so stop complaining' mentality. It's very possible to remember where we've been yet still hold high ambitions for where we're going. We have been told on numerous occasions by Steve Parish that we are a club with a huge catchment area in terms of fans and players, I remember the phrase 'frightening potential' being used. So if even the chairman recognises that this isn't our ceiling, why do we as fans persist with a mentality of being happy about where we are with no ambition to progress further? Sheffield United have proved that it is possible to play decent football and be successful on a much smaller budget than we have if you have a manager with the right philosophy. There's no way that they are a bigger club than us. Neither are Burnley. Fans are rightfully questioning Roy's refusal to try anything other than his tried and trusted first XI and his negative tactics, despite our woeful run of form and the fact that there is nothing to play for. If he won't experiment with youth and fringe players now then he never will. Ultimately football is meant to be fun and, with the exception of the United game when we were unlucky, there has been nothing fun about watching Palace recently. Edited by Canterbury Palace (18 Jul 2020 3.13pm) Sheff UTD are a one season wonder and will be in a relegation battle next year mark my words
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
I totally disagree with the whole 'we were s*** for years so stop complaining' mentality. It's very possible to remember where we've been yet still hold high ambitions for where we're going. We have been told on numerous occasions by Steve Parish that we are a club with a huge catchment area in terms of fans and players, I remember the phrase 'frightening potential' being used. So if even the chairman recognises that this isn't our ceiling, why do we as fans persist with a mentality of being happy about where we are with no ambition to progress further? Sheffield United have proved that it is possible to play decent football and be successful on a much smaller budget than we have if you have a manager with the right philosophy. There's no way that they are a bigger club than us. Neither are Burnley. Fans are rightfully questioning Roy's refusal to try anything other than his tried and trusted first XI and his negative tactics, despite our woeful run of form and the fact that there is nothing to play for. If he won't experiment with youth and fringe players now then he never will. Ultimately football is meant to be fun and, with the exception of the United game when we were unlucky, there has been nothing fun about watching Palace recently. Edited by Canterbury Palace (18 Jul 2020 3.13pm)
I deliberately said money AND status because money alone doesn't necessarily do the job (Fulham and Villa have found that out and West Ham faltered badly despite the millions given to Pellegrini. As for Sheff Utd their nett spend last summer was OVER 60 million, so I don't know why you think they have a smaller budget than us. Many of us oldies are thankful for what we have - the best ever run in the top flight plus a recent major cup final appearance (only the second in our history). We acknowledge that if a billionaire came in and bankrolled us a la Citeh, Chelsea, Man U etc. we might well hit the big time, but that's unlikely because we are not a fashionable team. The billionaires will look at the likes of Newcastle, Leeds, Everton, Villa etc. etc. before they will look at us. Edited by doombear (18 Jul 2020 3.52pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
If he won't experiment with youth and fringe players now then he never will. Ultimately football is meant to be fun and, with the exception of the United game when we were unlucky, there has been nothing fun about watching Palace recently. Edited by Canterbury Palace (18 Jul 2020 3.13pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Sheff UTD are a one season wonder and will be in a relegation battle next year mark my words
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
I agree, they'll buy a couple of players - not big names but decent players, and be mid table, top half. We will be having to pull off another escape and dealing with poor transfer windows and injuries, not The Blades.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
I deliberately said money AND status because money alone doesn't necessarily do the job (Fulham and Villa have found that out and West Ham faltered badly despite the millions given to Pellegrini. As for Sheff Utd their nett spend last summer was OVER 60 million, so I don't know why you think they have a smaller budget than us. Many of us oldies are thankful for what we have - the best ever run in the top flight plus a recent major cup final appearance (only the second in our history). We acknowledge that if a billionaire came in and bankrolled us a la Citeh, Chelsea, Man U etc. we might well hit the big time, but that's unlikely because we are not a fashionable team. The billionaires will look at the likes of Newcastle, Leeds, Everton, Villa etc. etc. before they will look at us. Edited by doombear (18 Jul 2020 3.52pm)
I actually think the top six are increasingly broachable. There is so much money in the league now that even traditionally unfashionable clubs can recruit top class players, even if just as a stepping stone. Liverpool and City are currently in a class of their own but clubs like Arsenal and Spurs are falling back into the pack. Sheffield United spent 60m last summer but we also spent heavily in our first couple of seasons and our wage bill is miles higher. Even if they qualify for the Europa League I doubt they'll spend that much again this year.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
He wouldn't have played Wan-Bissaka unless his hand was forced, you don't know unless you give them a chance which we have an opportunity to do at the moment but won't. I thought Mitchell, for example, looked fantastic when he came on the other night. I'd love to see him given a chance as I've had doubts about PVA for a long time. We have Riedewald who won player of the month when given a chance but was then dropped. Meyer who could be a solution to our dire lack of creativity but is a perennial bench warmer. We had Sorloth who was given 830 minutes to prove himself before being sent to Turkey where he has shown himself to be very good after all. We have and have had options but Roy doesn't want to use them. It's almost like Mourinho-esque stubborn-ness to prove a point.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
I do agree. Wholeheartedly. Some people appear to have a very tenuous grip on reality with expectation levels bordering on insanity. I agree with both of you but I suppose I have to admit to being impatient for some progress. I do not have any intention upon slagging anyone off. There are too many reasons and too many scapegoats to find but...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
He wouldn't have played Wan-Bissaka unless his hand was forced, you don't know unless you give them a chance which we have an opportunity to do at the moment but won't. I thought Mitchell, for example, looked fantastic when he came on the other night. I'd love to see him given a chance as I've had doubts about PVA for a long time. We have Riedewald who won player of the month when given a chance but was then dropped. Meyer who could be a solution to our dire lack of creativity but is a perennial bench warmer. We had Sorloth who was given 830 minutes to prove himself before being sent to Turkey where he has shown himself to be very good after all. We have and have had options but Roy doesn't want to use them. It's almost like Mourinho-esque stubborn-ness to prove a point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
I agree with both of you but I suppose I have to admit to being impatient for some progress. I do not have any intention upon slagging anyone off. There are too many reasons and too many scapegoats to find but... That sums it up. The question for the Roy, knockers is , in the circumstances why get rid of the safe hands, whilst everything else is not going to change in a hurry?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
He wouldn't have played Wan-Bissaka unless his hand was forced, you don't know unless you give them a chance which we have an opportunity to do at the moment but won't. I thought Mitchell, for example, looked fantastic when he came on the other night. I'd love to see him given a chance as I've had doubts about PVA for a long time. We have Riedewald who won player of the month when given a chance but was then dropped. Meyer who could be a solution to our dire lack of creativity but is a perennial bench warmer. We had Sorloth who was given 830 minutes to prove himself before being sent to Turkey where he has shown himself to be very good after all. We have and have had options but Roy doesn't want to use them. It's almost like Mourinho-esque stubborn-ness to prove a point.
As for Roy and his stubbornness, I, too get frustrated with his selections at times BUT for most of this season his system worked for us to achieve the no.1 priority - safety. Much of our recent form results from a number of factors including injuries to our first choice central defenders, frequency of games with a limited and aged squad and lack of real options on the bench, not to mention some poor individual and team performances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
As for Roy and his stubbornness, I, too get frustrated with his selections at times BUT for most of this season his system worked for us to achieve the no.1 priority - safety. Much of our recent form results from a number of factors including injuries to our first choice central defenders, frequency of games with a limited and aged squad and lack of real options on the bench, not to mention some poor individual and team performances. Re meyer and Roy's plan A.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
No club, after 7/8 season's in the prem, with like the 10th highest wage bill in Europe, be happy just to survive. That mentality is ridiculous. No supporter, in their right mind should be happy with the club to continue making transfer mistakes, racking up debt, selling youth off to reduce the bills. No supporter would enjoy tactics where the same players are getting fatigue, making mistakes - youth being ignored and the squad not being rotated, even when nothing to play for. Supporters, naturally, should worry that their squad is the oldest in the league with no real infrastructure in place, albeit youth academy or a scouting network to replace, let alone cash. Also, supporters, naturally should be wondering why there is no money to invest - as above. So whilst many of us where there, alongside you that May - we were watching youth players Morrison, Mullins, Thomson, Carlisle, Evans. With work horse/Fan favs Riihilahti, Freedman and Austin. We saw a team playing for the badge... playing for the fans.. MASSIVE DIFFERENCE Vaibow, first of all , our transfers have not been bad , think back , Chamakh, puncheon, Gayle , mcarthur, Kelly Ledley, Cahill,Sakho, Benteke (first season) Ayew , Guaita, Schlupp , milivojevic , van aanholt, are we going back to when CPFC2010 took over??? Then include Ward JedinAk and all the others that got us promoted , all for small fees apart from benteke and sakho , they are not transfer mistakes !!! In my opinion these have kept us up and got us up !!! People forget, a few bad results and that’s it,...... manager out , we are cr@p etc etc , it’s boring now , support the team, the club, and next year , just like this year and the last we will be safe and we will pull of a surprise (Roy masterclass) and everyone will be happy again , Also , going back to your quote of no team in the prem should be worried about surviving is absolute ludicrous , as I’ve said before , there is only 6 teams in that division who don’t have to worry , the rest will always look over their shoulder , the ones that don’t worry are Liverpool , Man City , Man Utd , Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham , and apart from that everyone else will always have an eye out ,
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder |
|
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
No club, after 7/8 season's in the prem, with like the 10th highest wage bill in Europe, be happy just to survive. That mentality is ridiculous. No supporter, in their right mind should be happy with the club to continue making transfer mistakes, racking up debt, selling youth off to reduce the bills. No supporter would enjoy tactics where the same players are getting fatigue, making mistakes - youth being ignored and the squad not being rotated, even when nothing to play for. Supporters, naturally, should worry that their squad is the oldest in the league with no real infrastructure in place, albeit youth academy or a scouting network to replace, let alone cash. Also, supporters, naturally should be wondering why there is no money to invest - as above. So whilst many of us where there, alongside you that May - we were watching youth players Morrison, Mullins, Thomson, Carlisle, Evans. With work horse/Fan favs Riihilahti, Freedman and Austin. We saw a team playing for the badge... playing for the fans.. MASSIVE DIFFERENCE Completely agree with you. There's been no progress, our playing style is awful and, worst of all, in recent weeks no passion. The age of the squad is a massive concern and as it goes up yet another year we'll just get slower and more injury prine. Serious investment needed which obviously won't come.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
Agree with all of this but would add that both Riedewald and Meyer look slower than the 30 yr old players so many want them to replace.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Vaibow, first of all , our transfers have not been bad , think back , Chamakh, puncheon, Gayle , mcarthur, Kelly Ledley, Cahill,Sakho, Benteke (first season) Ayew , Guaita, Schlupp , milivojevic , van aanholt, are we going back to when CPFC2010 took over??? Then include Ward JedinAk and all the others that got us promoted , all for small fees apart from benteke and sakho , they are not transfer mistakes !!! In my opinion these have kept us up and got us up !!! People forget, a few bad results and that’s it,...... manager out , we are cr@p etc etc , it’s boring now , support the team, the club, and next year , just like this year and the last we will be safe and we will pull of a surprise (Roy masterclass) and everyone will be happy again , Also , going back to your quote of no team in the prem should be worried about surviving is absolute ludicrous , as I’ve said before , there is only 6 teams in that division who don’t have to worry , the rest will always look over their shoulder , the ones that don’t worry are Liverpool , Man City , Man Utd , Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham , and apart from that everyone else will always have an eye out ,
"Vaibow, first of all , our transfers have not been bad" Never said they all were. "'no team in the prem should be worried about surviving' is absolute ludicrous" Show me where I said that.... maybe you misread and misinterpreted this: "No club, after 7/8 season's in the prem, with like the 10th highest wage bill in Europe, be happy just to survive." Read my message again and tell me I am wrong.... then we can discuss.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
"Vaibow, first of all , our transfers have not been bad" Never said they all were. "'no team in the prem should be worried about surviving' is absolute ludicrous" Show me where I said that.... maybe you misread and misinterpreted this: "No club, after 7/8 season's in the prem, with like the 10th highest wage bill in Europe, be happy just to survive." Read my message again and tell me I am wrong.... then we can discuss. Sorry , I had had a beer and yes it’s seems I got carried away with a. Few things however , I still stand by the fact that every team outside the top 6 should always breathe a sigh of relief for staying in the league, some teams will have more ambition than others, say Everton as they have a bigger budget and are a bigger club. Until we have huge investment I will be happy to just survive.
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.